Same Sex Marriage: A Critical Analysis Of Some Common Conservative Arguments

1940 words - 8 pages

The issue of same-sex marriage has quite polarized society. There are those who are in favour of total equality of right for homosexuals, and there are those who are completely against the presence of homosexuality in our society. Very rarely does one find middle ground. It may seem difficult to find a stance on this issue that is not rife with hypocrisy and doublespeak. Having researched the conservative arguments against gay marriage , it has become apparent that all of the non-religious arguments against same-sex marriage can be dismissed as false, unreasonable, or irrelevant. The religious arguments pose a different challenge since they are not based on anything strictly rational, and therefore they shall not be dealt with here.Some critics of same-sex marriage argue that it is unnatural. That homosexuality is merely a human social defect and that attraction to the same-sex is a learned behavior. According to them, animal societies are free of these social deviants and are inherently better. However they fail to recognize many recorded instances of homosexual behavior among animals . Many species of animals have displayed acts of anal sex, same-sex kissing and same-sex long-term pair bonding. Some people explain this away by claiming that animal homosexuality only arises when there is a shortage of the opposite sex. However this is not the case, and sometimes even the opposite is true. Of course, even if this were true, claiming that since something does not happen in nature it must be bad for humans is ridiculous. After all, animals do not participate in religious ceremonies, they do not practice medicine or build nuclear weapons to protect their precious bodily fluids from the commies, projects which many opponents of same-sex marriage are likely in favour of.Another argument against same-sex marriage is that the purpose of marriage is procreation. This may seem a reasonable argument at first, but then one realizes how full of holes it is. Traditional couples who are infertile or who chose not to have children are still allowed to get married. Women who have gone through menopause are still allowed to marry. If the purpose of marriage were procreation, all of these marriages would have to be dissolved. Elderly married couples would have their marriages dissolved as soon as the woman went through menopause, or if the man got a vasectomy. Also, just because a couple cannot procreate itself, it does not follow that they cannot raise a child. Adoption does exist, as does artificial insemination. Furthermore, with over six billion people on the planet (and growing), one may seriously challenge the view that we need an institution promoting rampant birthing .Homosexuals (bisexuals and male homosexuals primarily) are generally seen as more promiscuous and deviant than heterosexuals, for instance, the public perception of bathhouses. This leads directly to the view that they should be prevented from getting married. Wait, no it doesn't! If...

Find Another Essay On Same Sex Marriage: A Critical Analysis of Some Common Conservative Arguments

Legalizing Same-Sex Marriage Essay

1293 words - 5 pages opposite sex marriage therefore claims as such “do not appear credible” (2012, p.1.). Another argument against legalization of same-sex marriage concerns the threat against the religious right to discriminate (NeJaime, 2012). Some religious based organizations are heralding their right to religious freedom as a mechanism to obstruct same-sex marriage legalization. It is this writer’s opinion that their argument is not relative to federal or state

Same Sex Marriage Essay

1260 words - 6 pages be addressed later. All in all, this paper has made me realize how much critical analysis goes into public policy issues of our nation today. Many people think that all politicians are just hypocritical bureaucrats only looking out for their own interests. After doing my research on same-sex marriage policies, I have begun to respect what our lawmakers do for us today and appreciate what they do to make America what it truly is. Works Cited

Same Sex Marriage

1246 words - 5 pages . “The Williams Institute estimates that same-sex marriage will bring $42 million in economic activity to Minnesota.”(Sanburn). Having a growth in the economy due to same-sex marriage will lead to a lot of positive outcomes. Although opposing to gay marriage is common for people to do, some may view it from a negative aspect to a positive one. Legalizing gay marriage would weaken the tradition of what marriage is truly about which is between man

Same Sex Marriage

1832 words - 7 pages . Although marriage is an important part of many religions, it would be incorrect to call marriage a religious institution, or to say that it has not changed dramatically over the course of history. The last common argument against same-sex marriage is a bona fide logical fallacy. “Slippery slope arguments falsely assume that one thing must lead to another. They begin by suggesting that if we do one thing then that will lead to another, and before

Same-sex Marriage

1738 words - 7 pages “I'm not for gay marriage, but I'm not for discriminating against people” (Eskridge 1425). During the late twentieth century, activities involving homosexual relations increased. Lately, it is common to encounter a person who is attracted to a person of the same gender. The marriage between couples of the opposite sex became one of the most controversial conflicts that the United States, and the entire world, has to deal with. There are cases

Same-Sex Marriage

1364 words - 5 pages writer La Shawn Barber, "on what ground can we deny the same to three people? Or 10? Or close relatives? Or adults and children?" Same-sex marriage is not like any of the possible degradations of marriage that are assumed would occur upon its allowance. Polygamy, for instance, would allow a marriage between more than two people, leading to possible maltreatment of children, or favoring the children of one spouse over those of another, leading to

Same-Sex Marriage

1456 words - 6 pages not be able to marry. Discriminations against them are based on hate and homophobia. Homosexuality is not a choice. It comes natural and some people have different orientations than others. Morally speaking, not allowing same-sex couples to get married is wrong. It strips couples of marriage privileges because of sexual preference. Love is love, no matter what shape, size, color, or preference. Since being gay is becoming more common, why should

same sex marriage

3364 words - 13 pages marriage would increase the amount of stable homes for children who would have been left in foster care. However, some argue that same-sex households are not the best environments to raise children because children need both a mother and a father. Girls that are raised without a father are more likely to engage in early sexual activity and have a higher chance in obtaining teen pregnancy ("Should Gay Marriage Be Legal?"). However, studies show that

Same Sex Marriage

2041 words - 8 pages Same-sex marriage has continuously been contradicted throughout our nation and so the arguments never seem to cease. Some argue the legality of same-sex marriage while others suggest that it compromises the sacredness of marriage. Various religious groups and their supporters in the U.S. tend to either support same-sex marriage or greatly oppose it, depending on their viewpoints and beliefs. Thus, the constant, bitter arguments between these

Same-Sex Marriage

1117 words - 4 pages straight community argues against same-sex marriages citing it is immoral, children will be harmed, it is an untried social experiment, and that marriage is a special ?right? of heterosexual couples. Their arguments are not substantiated. The subject of same-sex marriage is often to unspeakable for straights. Their embarrassed to admit the real reasons they are against legalizing it include not being comfortable with gays, offending their

Same sex marriage

735 words - 3 pages more stigmatizing than the word "gay".[4] Some publications that oppose same-sex marriage put the word marriage in scare quotes when referring to it. One notable publication that practices this is The Washington Times. Cliff Kincaid, a writer for the conservative American media watchdog group Accuracy in Media, agrees with this method, arguing that "marriage" is a word that same-sex couples merely want to apply to themselves, but have no legal

Similar Essays

Legalization Of Same Sex Marriage Essay

1376 words - 6 pages to marry, no matter what his/her gender is. The society is processing, people’s concepts, like the definition of marriage, should follow the progress as well. Next, if same-sex marriage is legalized, some people would concern about children’s problems. Statistics Canada shows that in 2006, 41.4% of married couples had children, which means a large part of couples didn’t have children (http://statcan.gc.ca). Lee (2012) from CBC

Legalization Of Same Sex Marriage Essay

2510 words - 10 pages citizenship with all rights afforded by law. By not allowing same sex marriage it is a denial of a basic civil right and justification of denial is discrimination on many levels. It is my belief that religion should play no part whatsoever in this debate over marriage as it is purely a civil matter. It is interesting to note here that some Christian based Religious groups exerting their influence today still want to deny same-sex couples the very freedom

The Perspective Of A Heterosexual Teenager On Same Sex Marriage

1462 words - 6 pages Church.After hearing such a profound homily, some parishioners enthusiastically agreed with him and others deeply pondered about the issue. Among the enthusiastic supporters of the Bishops' letter, I was one of them, who became one hundred ten percent in opposition to homosexual marriage. I refute same sex marriage for three significant reasons. Firstly, I believe that homosexuals were never created for each other. Secondly, undesirable consequences

Same Sex Marriage Essay

600 words - 2 pages Kendrick AndersonANTHRO 202Cultural Anthropology30-April-2013Same Sex MarriageMarriage is an institution between one man and one woman. Same-sex relations wouldpresent many changes in the meaning of marriage. Marriage is a historic, culturalinstitution, and same-sex will confuse society generation. The amendment protect marriagefrom over-ruling by either state legislatures or the courts orders. Same-sex marriage can affectchildren in a way of