How Did Economists Get It So Wrong?

1970 words - 8 pages

Shortly after the financial crisis in 2008, many economists had to rethink their approach to the market. Everyone knew we had a panic because the stock market and the housing market collapsed. American economy was reaching to the bottom. Many people considered it as a second worst recession after the great the Great Depression. But what was the cause? Who were responsible for the crisis? What can we learn from this turmoil? In the recent New York Times Sunday magazine article, Nobel Prize winner Paul Krugman offered his explanation for the causes and insight toward fixing the economy.
In the article, Krugman addresses several problems underlying the recent state of the economy. He traces the cause for our recession all the way back to academia. The problem is rather subtle. He argues that faulty thinking about the market is the primary reason that has led to the 2008 and 2009 recession. The crisis has evoked the two schools of macroeconomics thought for long have stayed dormant: the “freshwater” and the “saltwater” economist. Both have their own ideology in resolving the crisis.
As Krugman put it “freshwater economists are, essentially, neoclassical purists.” They assume that people are rational and markets work. They do recognize the use of Keynesian theory but just do not trust the government interference. Therefore, they usually prefer monetary policy over fiscal policy. On the other hand, Krugman says that “saltwater economists are pragmatists.” Their approach is to do apply any methods that can keep the economy running smoothly whether it’s a fiscal or monetary policy. They usually favor Keynesian theory.
Freshwater economists base their practices on the perfect market. They trust that the market system will not ever fail, but as we all know the financial market did fail in 2008. The government had to step in to bail out the system. Freshwater economists rely on the models that they have used for a long time to predict the markets’ performance. They want the markets to operate on their own. They think that government intervention will make it worse.
Consider an economy in the long run and the effects of fiscal policy. When the government alters its spending, they will directly affect the economy’s performance. Freshwater economists usually don’t buy into the notion of government purchases. When the government increases their purchase by a certain amount, it will increase the demand for goods and services. According to the equation of supply and demand for the economy’s output, disposable income and consumption are unchanged. Total output is constrained by the factors of production. An increase in government spending must be balanced out by other variable. In this scenario, it is investment. It must decrease with an equal amount. Investment decreases because interest rate rises (Mankiw, pg. 69). Most economists would agree that government purchases would lead to a reduction in national saving and hence raising the interest rate.

Find Another Essay On How did economists get it so wrong?

How did Alexander the Great manage to conquer so much territory in so quickly?

4043 words - 16 pages Ancient HistoryIn this essay, I questioned how it was that Alexander the Great managed to be so successful in his conquest of Persia and Greece, and if this success made him the greatest military leader of all time. I looked at the advantages that Alexander inherited, as well as those that he provided to his men. Some have claimed that the general actually contributed very little to his cause, merely riding on the coattails of others and taking

This is How I did It

1496 words - 6 pages care about my grades though and I think that had something to do with why I care so much about my rank, now that I am a senior. Throughout the years I have worked hard to get good grades. My mother was always nagging me when they weren’t at her standards. During my schooling I have taken the highest level classes that were offered here. It was during my junior year that I really started to worry about what class rank I was. Since it was

Manifest Destiny - How did it ffect Americans ?

580 words - 2 pages or political lines.However, this expansion was not a defined movement, and although it effected most people, was not supported by all Americans. Whig party leaders strongly opposed territorial growth, and even expansionist Democrats argued about how much new land should be acquired. Many supporters of this idea of Manifest Destiny believed in strong, even aggressive moves to gain more land, even if this risked going to war with other nations

Why did it take so long for the Vietnamese Veterans to be recognized in Australia?

661 words - 3 pages Australian people widely did not at the time. They believed it was a mistake and that it was humiliating because a poor nation defeated the world's greatest super powers. Although Australians were not involved with napalm bombing and torture of the Vietnamese, they were their allies so really they felt Australians were just as guilt as the Americans.The Domino Theory turned out to be wrong, which was one of the main motives in first sending troops

Why did it take so long for the nations of Europe to defeat Napoleon I?

772 words - 3 pages . Despite these defeats, Napoleon was still a very powerful man, and did not show any more signs of weakening; he still held a firm grip on his conquered lands and single-handedly governed the states and led the army.In January 1814 France was being attacked on all it's frontiers, but the allies made it clear that they were fighting to defeat Napoleon, not France. Napoleon was basically being attacked because in 1813 he had refused to sign the treaty


691 words - 3 pages relocation from their land. Although some people think the Indian Removal Act was justifiable because Indians were not taking advantage of the land, well they are wrong, Indians thought nature as a god or something related to religion; It was sacred for them. In the constitution is written congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press

Unlawful Justice; It is about the death penalty and how it is wrong

978 words - 4 pages that two out of three kids sent to death row are children of color. Also, almost 90% of people put to death for committing a crime were convicted of murdering whites but, about half of all homicide victims in the U.S. are colored. It is so bad in Maryland that if you kill a white person you are seven times more likely to get the death sentence than if you murder a colored person. About 90 % of the people that the U.S. Government prosecutors tried

‘How did a European War turn into a World War so easily?’

838 words - 4 pages and provided much reason to go to war against Serbia. This was extremely unjustified, as it was merely a man from a group of six Serbian assassins and not Serbia as a nation who planned the assassination. However, both of these countries had alliances with other countries, which both came into play soon after this event. Austria’s allies, who are known as the Triple Alliance, consisted of Germany and Italy, while Serbia did not have any instant

Animal Farm/WWII Propaganda: How did it Work?

768 words - 4 pages Freedom is a very valuable thing, sometimes taken for granted. Some people desire freedom for the right reasons, and some people desire it for their own self-seeking reasons. Every country has their own rules, government, and leaders. Of course, the leadership in Russia during WWII was very harsh and malevolent compared to our government now. George Orwell used symbolism in his American classic Animal Farm to demonstrate how communism affected

Creationism vs. Evolution: How did it really happen?

1232 words - 5 pages Creationism vs. Evolution: How did it really happen? Ever since 1859 and the publication of On the Origin of Species by Charles Darwin1, his first publication of his observations, much debate has come about concerning the issue of how life on earth came to be. Both the Creationists and Evolutionists believe in the "Big Bang" theory of creation of life; however, the mechanism for the development of new life provides the conflict

Roman Architecture: How did it come to existence?

1481 words - 6 pages Roman Architecture. Although this doesn’t usually come to peoples minds very often Roman Architecture hides many things behind it. The Etruscans started living in Rome in 700 B.C. There they created art and many architectural buildings. At that time the Romans had no true art. They copied Etruscan art and yet did not want them living in Rome. As a result the Romans exterminated almost all the Etruscan from Rome. After wards the Romans were

Similar Essays

Why Did It Take So Much Longer For Women To Get The Vote?

904 words - 4 pages . There, they see a ‘main gate [which] said “HMP Maze”. Herpes, Mastitis, Piles.’ The author’s use of rule of 3 gives a negative description of the prison. Fergus’ acrostic for the maze by using ‘Herpes, Mastitis, Piles’ reinforces the characters view of the prison and how they look down on it. The ‘HMP Maze’ is known to be a prison with such a bad name because even ‘the Nazis had wanted to bomb the place out of existence…’ This emphasizes how

Autism: How Did My Child Get It?

1242 words - 5 pages from Autism. The author reveals that there may be many factors of how children are contracting this disorder. Many children are being diagnosed with autism, and in fact they are more often misdiagnosed. This is due to the fact that there are many mental disorders that have symptoms are very similar to autism, so therefore they are getting the wrong treatment for the illness. Autism is most difficult mental condition for doctor to diagnose a child

West Nile Virus: What Is It And How Did It Get Here?

2322 words - 9 pages explore the origin of West Nile virus. I will address protection techniques for both humans and equines along with information that I have gathered on the cause of West Nile virus in the United States.West Nile Virus: What is it and how did it get here?During my research on the West Nile Virus, I was surprised at some of the interesting facts and opinions that I came across. This paper will address human and equine statistics along with some

Historical Investigation: How Did The Bluestones Get To Stonehenge?

1885 words - 8 pages : if they were in Wales, how did they come to Salisbury? The earliest recorded theory dates back to around 1139AD, when Geoffrey of Monmouth wrote:"If you are desirous," said Merlin, "to honour the burying place of these men with an everlasting monument, send for the Giant's Dance, which is in Killaraus, a mountain in Ireland. For there is a structure of stones there, which none of this age could raise, without a profound knowledge of the