This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

How Long Should Compassionate Care Continue In A Brain Dead Patient?

1027 words - 4 pages

How long should compassionate care continue in a case of a brain-dead patient? Does the definition of ‘death’ need to be reconsidered? Who should decide when treatment should stop on a loved one? All these questions were brought up in the recent case of Jahi McMath, a 13-year-old girl, who underwent surgery at Children’s Hospital Oakland, on December 9th.
The procedure was meant to cure her case of sleep apnea, by having a routine tonsillectomy as well as clear some tissue from her nose and throat. However, due to complications she went into cardiac arrest, and was placed on a ventilator. On December 12th, she was deemed “brain-dead” by several neurologist, and was to be removed from the ventilator. With her daughter’s heart still beating, the mother believes her daughter is still alive, and filed a lawsuit against the hospital, to keep her daughter on the ventilator. The court declared Jahi to be brain-dead, but gave the mother until January 5th to find a new long term care facility, because Children’s Hospital in Oakland refused to continue providing care, on the grounds that it is unethical to operate or provide care to someone who is deceased. The court allowed Jahi’s body to be released to her mother, after issuing a death certificate. The mother had arranged for an emergency team to transfer Jahi to an undisclosed hospital who has stated it will continue to provide care.
Certainly the definition of death needs to be addressed. There are currently two standard medical/legal definitions of death. The first being cardiopulmonary death, which is the irreversible loss of function in the heart and lungs. The second being brain-death, which is the irreversible cessation of all brain functions. This can be a difficult diagnosis for relatives and friends to understand and accept. The patients have a heartbeat and are breathing, and appear to just be sleeping peacefully. They even feel warm to the touch, but the stark reality is that this is only due to the machines, providing mechanical support breathing for the patient, and the medication given to maintain their blood pressure.
Nevertheless it is unethical for physicians to operate, or provide care to someone who is deceased. So in this regard the doctors of Children’s Hospital Oakland acted accordingly. Physicians have no obligation to offer treatments that do not benefit the patient. Futile interventions may give the patient’s family false hope, and expend finite medical resources. Christopher Dolan, the attorney for Jahi’s family, is challenging the law linking the end of life to brain death. He states “families – not hospitals, judges or governments – should decide when treatment stops on a loved one.” But I don’t think Mr. Dolan quite understands the full ramifications of what this would lead to. The deceased person would be taking up a hospital bed, medical equipment, not to mention the time of physicians and nurses. Time that should be used to provide care to those that it will actually...

Find Another Essay On How Long Should Compassionate Care Continue in a Brain-Dead Patient?

How Does Patient Centered Care Compare to Inattention to Patient´s Self Concept Effect Outcome in Disease Processes?

562 words - 3 pages case study, the doctor makes a remark that can take the self- confidence right out of the patient. This concept does not explain how to handle inappropriate conversations with our client’s made by professional health care providers. Evidence-based Approach The question that we would like to research is “In physicians, how does patient centered care, compared to inattention to patient’s self-concept effect the outcome in disease processes

Information System in an Integrated Multidisciplinary Health Care Team: A Strategy for improving Patient care

1021 words - 5 pages integrated IT (information technology) system.  To propose appropriate changes to the organisation. Research Questions. In order to achieve the mentioned objectives above and throw more light to the topic, attempted answers need to be given to the following questions. • What effect does integrated care plan have on a patient- centred IT system? • What are the current ways in which co-ordination of care delivery is achieved? • What IT system does the

A Multidisciplinary Approach to Patient Care

1968 words - 8 pages another UISQT standard, clarity, the nurse should ask and record more details on what S.P. means by only performing “very mild exercises at home” in order to understand what her level of fitness and functioning at home consists of especially since she is suffering from severe RA. It is also important to clarify how long S.P. has had RA. The nurse should also use depth to gather what S.P. knows about the medications she’s taking and if she has a

The U.S. War in the Middle East: A Fight for Honor and Survival - Why America Should Continue Fighting in Iraq

1173 words - 5 pages Eastern civilians, the leaders brainwash the civilians into hating America. In Palestine, the only path to independence, dignity, and progress is democracy (46). Some Americans feel that the civilians of the Middle East should be left alone to live a life of pain and suffering, but the U.S. government should not listen to such weak, uneducated chatter. Modernization is not westernization, and it is a long and arduous project that takes years to get

A Body’s Dignity of a Maternal Brain Dead Mother

1214 words - 5 pages . 2008). This quote just shows that our society still has a notion of respect for the dead and that it will stay like that. Now hat I have talked about the dignity of the deceased, I will now talk about brain death and how it is different from ordinary death. Brain death is an irreversible brain damage causing the end of independent respiration, regarded as indicative of death. This is a problem in todays society because the current medical

Patient and Family Centered Care in Nursing

746 words - 3 pages patient’s physical, emotional, and spiritual needs through their hospitalization. Treating the patient and family as one, can have improved outcomes, decrease hospital stays, increased patient satisfaction, and improved reimbursements for the hospital. Developing a relationship with not only the patient, but family as well, can pay off in the long run by providing better communication, better quality of care, and trust. The patient and family

Should Mass Media Continue to Promote a Thin Body?

1865 words - 7 pages up, and the age that girls and boys begin to develop low self-esteem has gone below twelve years old. These are the reasons why media should not be allowed to continue with the promotion of unrealistic beauty ideals. In the realm of social media and body image, there are three kinds of people. There are those that say they believe everyone is beautiful, the people who say they don’t care, and there are the people who point out every single flaw

Adapting to a Long Term Care Facility

1728 words - 7 pages The character Dorothy said in The Wonderful Wizard of Oz, “there is no place like home” (Baum, 1960, p. 45). Sadly, many of our elderly live in Long Term Care Facilities (LTCF). The transition from living in their own homes, to living in a LTCF, can be a traumatic experience. Poor adaptation to a LTCF may cause depression, malnutrition and significantly reduce the lifespan of the elder. Thus, it is imperative, that nurse’s recognize this

This paper is related to communication in a personal care home. it discusses staff-patients relationship, staff-staff, and patient-patient nonverbal and verbal cues

871 words - 3 pages I become a nurse.Patient And Patient CommunicationWe cannot forget that patients in a personal care home are human beings and want to be accepted. Patients want to be treated as people and want to be appreciated. Some patients don't get along with others and we have to respect that. I observed that some residents were annoyed of others and others got along quite well. I found that the residents at the facility were frustrated and angry when they

Given it's controverial nature, should The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn continue to be taught in schools? Write a persuasive letter to the school board

1225 words - 5 pages Huck Finn, and that the typical society of America is still as it was more than a hundred years ago? How does this book prove beneficial to African-Americans and Caucasians? Times have changed, and so has peoples' thinking. Today, people do not regard blacks as emotionless, inhumane, or by the perspectives of many characters in the novel. Other than providing a perspective of life before the Civil War in America, and provoking long-suppressed

Care Management Plan: A Newly Diagnosed Diabetic Patient

1018 words - 4 pages Type 2 diabetes mellitus is a growing disease in the United States. When developing a care management plan for new diabetic patient, several areas of education and resources should be considered. The purpose of this paper is to describe a hypothetical care plan for a newly diagnosed diabetic, including case management model used, initial and ongoing educational needs, and data collection and evaluation. Case Management Model Jane Doe has

Similar Essays

The Joint Commission: National Patient Safety Goals For Medicare Based Long Term Care

1723 words - 7 pages The Joint Commission: National Patient Safety Goals for Medicare Based Long Term Care The Joint Commission is a nonprofit organization that focuses on improving the Healthcare system. They do this by regulating and evaluating health care organizations, helping them improve and give a more effective and safe care (The Joint Commission, 2012). The National Patient safety goals are ways in which the joint commission strives to improve the way

A Literature Review On Patient Transport In Intensive Care Units

4856 words - 19 pages to use specifically constructed carts including standard intensive care unit ventilators in a selected group of patients. To further reduce the rate of inadvertent mishaps resulting from transportation, alternative diagnostic modalities or techniques and performing surgical procedures in the intensive care unit should be considered.Introduction:The safest place for the critically ill patient is stationary in the intensive care unit (ICU

Care Of A Vulnerable Patient Essay

2848 words - 11 pages system and memory has a tendency to deteriorate. Rita may also be feeling pressure from her daughter to make the decision to go into respite care making Rita feel she has become a burden to her family. The role of the nurse is a varied one with emphasis on patient centred care. Patient centred care puts the client in control of the treatment or at the very least gives them a say in what is being planned for them, giving the client a say in what

Programs And Activities Involved In A Long Day Care

848 words - 4 pages builds on individual strengths and recognizes potential.
 Target Group
Mostly the target group aged 0 to 5 years and 50 children per a day. They provide with good care, education and home-like environment programs for children and a huge range of childcare services to the community and also offers long day care. 
 How the organization is accessed
This organization can be accessed from anywhere, people can accessed through online research for