This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Why Is Diotima A Woman? Essay

807 words - 3 pages

Diotima, Socrates' great teacher from the Symposium, a work by Plato was one of the most influential women thinkers of all time, whether she was a real person or a literary fictional character. She related to Socrates the theory of love that he described to the partygoers at Agathon's banquet, a celebration of Agathon's victory at the competition of Dionysis in Athens and of Eros.
     Before we search for the idea of why Diotima is a woman, we should first discuss a little about her. We know that, if she were an actual person, she would have been born around 470 BCE and died around 410 BCE. She might have been a priestess from Mantinea. Now if she was a real priestess or poet is uncertain. There is archaeological evidence, plus the fact that no historians for hundreds of years ever challenged her existence, suggests Diotima was an historical person. Her authenticity was not disputed until the 15th century.
     We should also discuss about how women were generally treated in the days of the Symposium. We read in the beginning of the Symposium that Eryximachus wants to get rid of the women so that the men may “stick to conversation”. (Symposium 176.e3-177.a2) This invokes the idea that women are unable to have a meaningful conversation. This could be justified because ancient Greeks thought our (women) emotions get in the way. The ancient Greeks (men) had wives for the purpose of producing babies. They had boyfriends for the purpose of fun. The men felt the women should be subservient to the men and men were head of the family. For this reason women in ancient Greece seemed inferior socially. But the women were isolated in their homes and did not mix in the society of men. What the men thought may not have been that important to the women.
     We should now go on to why Diotima is a woman. Socrates consulted the Oracle at Delphi (Know thyself) so we know that it is possible that Socrates would consult a priestess. Still, knowing that doesn’t answer why Plato would select a woman to initiate Socrates into the mysteries of male, homoerotic desire.
     I have uncovered two plausible answers to this question. The first is obvious. Diotima is a woman because she is not a man. If Diotima had been portrayed as a man then Socrates would have been seen as having been initiated into the mysteries of erotic desire by an older and wiser male. This would have inevitably suggested to Plato’s...

Find Another Essay On Why is Diotima a woman?

Peaceful Woman Explains Why She Carries a Gun

1237 words - 5 pages In the article “Peaceful Woman Explains Why She Carries a Gun” Linda M. Hasselstrom, explains a series of events that prompt her to an important decision. It was a decision that changed her life. Hasselstrom is a respected writer who has written several books on based on personal, life experiences. In this particular article she gives examples of events that have occurred to her that forced her take a decision of carrying a gun. She explains

Alice Walkers a woman is not a potted plant

760 words - 3 pages Calloway, AyashaEng 102 - 010 Feb - 19 - 04Explication of Alice Walkers "a woman is not a potted plant"Walker writes this poem using a potted plant as metaphor describing a woman's role in the 20th century. The speaker in Walker's poem describes the great depression of women during this point in time, by unfolding the difference between a potted plant and a woman. The 20th century was a time in which women were expected to do as her man

This Is How You Turn A Girl Into A Woman

1160 words - 5 pages Stories have a beginning, middle, and an end. This is not your typical short story piece. Girl by Jamaica Kincaid is an expressive, one-page portrait of womanhood. This methodical monologue is narrated by a strict and caring mother. Kincaid writes a “how-to guide” on the transformation from a little girl into a woman, by means of exposing gender roles. Most sentences start with “This is how you...” which directly informs the reader of

Why is Ghana a LEDC?

567 words - 2 pages Why is Ghanaaledc?Ghana is located in the west of Africa. Levels of development are different in lots of countries. But in Ghana they are exceptionally low. There are many different reasons as to why Ghana is an LEDC. They are split up into 3 categories: Socio-economic, Historical and Environmental. In this essay I will explain which one is more important.Socio-economic reasons are the trade, the slave trade, the country having its resources

Why There Is A God

1938 words - 8 pages the most convincing reason as to why God could not exist was the reality and presence of evil in this world. For these three simple reasons alone many people in today's materialistic world dethrone God.Evolution by definition is the theory that all living things developed from a few simple forms of life through a series of physical changes. According to evolution, the first mammal developed from a type of reptile, and ultimately all forms are

How is a 21st century woman defined? I recently began

1841 words - 7 pages . It does not surprise me we have children who are rebelling and are out-of control. Don't get me wrong! I am NOT suggesting it is wrong for a woman to work and I am by no means blaming a mother for the rebellion of the child. I am simply stating an observation that runs the same with many other things in society. It just seems that this is another tiny aspect of the BIG picture that I deem reason as to why society is turning out the way it is

A Woman in the Presidency: Is America Ready?

4476 words - 18 pages , 2006, 1). Interestingly, a corresponding 15% increase in the public's response to the question "Is America ready for a woman President?" occurred just since 1996.So, why is there such a dramatic shift in opinion? Could the shift in opinion be related to the public's perception of what makes a great President? How do current presidential hopefuls stand up to these perceptions and what should they do to make themselves viable candidates in the eye

Marriage is a Sacred Union between Man and Woman

1161 words - 5 pages Marriage is Sacred Marriage has always been a sacred agreement between a man and a woman. This definition was written in the Bible and sanctified by God. Our country was founded on the principles of the Bible and therefore should not support an action, such as legalizing gay marriage, which goes against our founding beliefs. When it comes to the issue of gay marriage, Americans have many different views. Research

Euripides was accused by his contempories of being a woman hater. Why

1558 words - 6 pages play and fails to reflect upon the true reason why the female roles are characterised the way they are. Therefore the accusation of being a woman hater is valid. In the Medea, the Nurse shows sympathy to Medea by siding with her. The play opens with an apprehensive speech by the Nurse. One of sympathy, but betrayal done to Medea. She worries as to what Medea might do to herself. "But now her world has turned to enmity, and wounds her where

A Woman without a Husband Is Like a Fish without a Bicycle

1033 words - 5 pages as a woman who completely defies the standards of a woman and acts as though she is equal to men. Shakespeare portrays Beatrice as independent and outspoken to praise her features as ideal in a woman that would otherwise be shunned during his time. Shakespeare portrays Beatrice as an independent woman to show his critique on society’s views towards a woman. Instead of giving Hero advice to listen to her father, Beatrice advises Hero to protest

"The explanation of a work is always sought in the man or woman who produced it." (Roland Barthes) Why should we not look to authorial intention for meaning in literature?

1868 words - 7 pages chooses to comment on the text itself. With both authors it is commonly recognised that their situations were of great inspiration to them and this is reflected in their work. So why then should a critic choose todiscard all this seemingly relevant material? Robert Webster wrote, 'the more you knew about an author's life the more you were likely to understand their literature'10 . But with the arrival of formalism this normative was challenged

Similar Essays

One Is Born A Woman Essay

1976 words - 8 pages . Realizing as long as heterosexuality and patriarchal norms are what run society, she will never be able to completely make the transition into this culture. That is why she argues for the obliteration of any notion of sex, for as long as man and woman exist there will always naturally be categories and differences. "This can be accomplished only by the destruction of heterosexuality as a social system which is based on the oppression of women

“A Peaceful Woman Explains Why She Carries A Gun”

703 words - 3 pages In the article “A peaceful Woman Explains Why She Carriers a Gun,” the author Linda M. Hasselstrom has a credible argument for carrying a gun. Hasselstrom has a solid ethical appeal and her argument had logic based on her many dangerous personal experiences. Although her article is credible, she uses many fallacies to make it seem that if women have a gun they can protect themselves from men. Ms. Hasselstrom has ethical appeal because she used

A Peaceful Woman Explains Why She Carries A Gun

1165 words - 5 pages   A Peaceful Woman Explains Why she Carries a Gun    Linda M. Hasselstrom wrote the article “A Peaceful Woman Explains Why she Carries a Gun,” she has a credible argument for carrying a gun because she has experienced many dangerous sexual assaults. Hasselstrom is a journalist who has gun ownership. The audience of this article is the women who want to protect themselves. In the article, Hasselstrom describes many sexual assaults, and she shows

Is That A Woman In Your Attice

1761 words - 8 pages 1 One of the most startling scenes in Jane Eyre is when finally it is revealed that Mr. Rochester has been keeping his wife in his attic, in an attempt to keep her away from the eyes of society, and of course, his and Jane's. It is at once a tragic and horrifying scene as the woman comes into the view of the innocent love-struck heroine, who had no notion of Mr. Rochester's insane wife in the attic before the moment she is revealed. While