This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Examining Contending Views On Human Nature: Mancius Vs. Xunzi

2039 words - 8 pages

Examining Contending Views on Human Nature: Mancius vs. Xunzi

Throughout human intellectual history, mankind has debated the question: “are humans good by nature?” Do humans do good out of only self-centered motivations, or is there an internal built-in sense of morality? Today, we face this problem more than ever. For example, if a lawyer argues a killer’s intentions for committing heinous crimes originate from the fact that he has a tendency towards naturally incompetency, or if outside influences turned a naturally well-to-do individual into a ill-willed murderer. Mencius and Xunzi are among the most notable Confucian scholars, yet their differing views on this philosophical conundrum set them apart. Mencius maintained an optimistic stance on humans, while Xunzi believed that humans were ill-willed by nature and in need of rigorous moral education and reform. Both scholars had a large impact on the interpretations of Confucian doctrines and the strive for moral cultivation throughout Chinese history. This makes their unique stances on human nature especially relevant when examining Chinese as well as human civilization as a whole. In this paper, I will argue that although contemporary philosophers in today’s society would most readily agree with much of Mencius’ moral philosophy, Xunzi has a more realistic perspective on contemporary societal ideologies. In order to accurately purvey my argument I will use the primary sources; Mencius: a new translation arranged and annotated for the general reader; and Xunzi: a translation and study of the complete works translated and arranged respectively by W. A. C. H. Dobson and John Knoblock. I will also use a number of historical and contemporary secondary sources to assist and further my argument.
This paper consists of a concise linear argument on the positioning of Mencius and Xunzi’s views on human nature in relation to modern society and common contemporary notions of human morality. The first section will deal with the similarities between the two philosophers beliefs and methodologies, and their interpretations in the modern day. Then, the essay will individually analyze first Mencius, then Xunzi’s fundamental stance on human nature using the primary sources mentioned above. Subsequently, I will reiterate the primary stance of my thesis and support it using the primary and second sources that I have acknowledged in the body of my paper. Finally, I will conclude by examining these two competing beliefs in light of modern interpretations of human nature.
It is necessary to observe that Xunzi and Mencius both acknowledged that humans in general have both good and bad emotions as well sentiments of selfishness and selflessness. Furthermore, their belief system is built on the fact that humans’ internal battle to cultivate good sentiments and purge the bad ones is influenced by nature and external environments, and that by performing rituals one can achieve moral enlightenment and inherent...

Find Another Essay On Examining Contending Views on Human Nature: Mancius vs. Xunzi

Analysis on Human Nature

1565 words - 7 pages Human Nature By Erich Dominguez My goal in this paper is to provide an analysis on human nature, from two different philosophical positions, Darwinism and Marxism. First, I will give an explanation of both Charles Darwin and Karl Marx’s individual views on human nature. Secondly, I will provide an objection to these views and explain how a defendant would respond to their positions. Furthermore, these positions will be evaluated to determine

Human Development: Nature vs. Nurture Essay

1643 words - 7 pages affect human development. Naturally, the nature versus nurture debate relates to many controversies such as intelligence, gender identities, violent behaviors, and sexual orientation. There are countless studies on whether intelligence is an inherited trait or if it is influenced by environmental factors. A study was conducted with adopted children and non-adopted children to see if a conclusion can be made based on the influence of hereditary and

Different Viewpoints on Human Nature

739 words - 3 pages full of sexual allusions and darker views on human nature and man himself. This wasn't exactly a new concept, it was just brought about in a different and unusual way. Candide is different from the other works in the fact that it was written as a story about a baron's son, which Voltaire uses as a third party media to get his views across. Both Machiavelli and Pope were straightforward in their works. Another difference between Voltaire and the

Thrasymachus' Perspective on Human Nature

1340 words - 5 pages Thrasymachus' Perspective on Human Nature Thrasymachus' perspective of human nature is that we all seek to maximize power, profit and possessions. He gives the argument that morality is not an objective truth but rather a creation of the stronger (ruling) party to serve its own advantage. Therefore definitions of "just" and "unjust", "right" and "wrong", "moral" and "immoral" are all dependent upon the decree of the ruling party

On Evil and Human Nature

858 words - 3 pages When prompted about the true nature of the human race, a great majority assumes “survival” instead of “good”. What this assumption leads to is a study of weather the human race is in fact “good” as people would like to think. In fact the one think that has allowed our race to survive is praying on the weaker, so are we morally “evil” by allowing our nature to dominate over us? If so is this nature a true evil? Many philosophers have studies

Marx’s Views on Religion vs. My Own

551 words - 2 pages Marx’s Views on Religion vs. My Own Karl Marx wrote that religion was, “an opiate of the people.” Although those words were not published in The German Ideology, they best describe his various views on religion. Marx wrote that there was a social relationship between the upper class or bourgeoisie and religion. The upper class that owned the means of production used religion as a tool to keep the working class or proletariat, oppressed and

Scientific vs. Religious Views On Cloning

1514 words - 6 pages Scientific vs. Religious Views on CloningFor many years man has driven himself to make new discoveries to better the life for mankind. We call these people scientists; they try to make new discoveries and take a scientific look at something and better it. Unfortunately, everyone does not always appreciate their discoveries or views and improvements on something. Sometimes the scientist himself or herself learns what he or she has done is not

Locke vs. Marx: Views on Property Rights

1832 words - 7 pages essay will examine the views of both Locke and Marx on the subject of private property and will render insight on whose principles appear more credible. Locke is best known for his philosophical ideals regarding the rights of humankind- all individuals have the right to life, liberty, and property. The state of nature has a law of nature to govern it, which obliges every one: and reason, which is that law, teaches all mankind, who will but

Comparing Coleridge and Wordsworth's Views on People's Relationship to Nature

2817 words - 11 pages Comparing Coleridge and Wordsworth's Views on People's Relationship to Nature Although Wordsworth and Coleridge are both romantic poets, they describe nature in different ways. Coleridge underlines the tragic, supernatural and sublime aspect of nature, while Wordsworth uses anecdotes of everyday life and underlines the serene aspect of nature. In order to imply a connection between nature and the human mind, Wordsworth uses the

Henry D. Thoreau's views on nature, society, and man

1520 words - 6 pages Thoreau Views on Nature, Society, and ManHenry David Thoreau's life began on July 12, 1817 in Concord, Massachusetts. At a young age he began to show an interest in writing. In 1833, at the age of sixteen, Thoreau was accepted to Harvard University. Although his parents could not afford the cost of tuition, his family offered to help with the funds, and in August he entered Harvard. In 1837 he graduated and applied for a teaching position at a

Carl Rogers and George Kelly's Views on Nature and Development

3665 words - 15 pages Carl Rogers and George Kelly's Views on Nature and Development Many consider the science of psychology an attempt to create a comprehensive theory of personality and therefore be able to explain why people are alike in some ways and different in others (Jourard, 1974). In so doing, varying schools of thought have evolved. Carl Rogers and George Kelly

Similar Essays

Human Nature And Its Views On Religion

478 words - 2 pages It is human nature to question all that pertains to life and our surroundings. We speculate and attempt to answer anything that extends beyond our grasp. This is most common in ancient Greek times where the belief of gods and goddess ruled the minds of all. In today's modern era, religion is looked upon more as guidance rather than a way of life. In the first paragraph, the type of religious faith that is present is one where faith is present

Soul, Body, And Augustine's And Machiavelli's Views On Human Nature

2412 words - 10 pages Soul, Body, and Augustine's and Machiavelli's Views on Human NatureMachiavelli insists that he sees men as they really are rather than we might wish men to be (XV, p. 62). Augustine also depicts how men actually live in the City of God. How are Augustine's and Machiavelli's understandings of human nature similar to and different from each other? How does these differences affect their political philosophy? Augustine and Machiavelli are similar

The Title Of The Paper Is Human Nature: Comparing Christianity To Islam. The Question Was Aimed At Comparing The Work Of A Prevalent Figure From Each Religion In Regard To Understanding The Varying...

1750 words - 7 pages Untitled In comparing the views concerning human nature expressed within the writings of Paul, a first century Christian biblical writer, alongside those of Ayatullah Mutahhari, a twentieth century Islamic philosopher, we are confronted with two very different aspects of human nature. On the one hand, both writers claim that human nature is founded in the supernatural, mainly God; however, they both explain the importance of this

Nature Vs. Nurture And The Impacts On Human Intelligence

2276 words - 9 pages education. A higher emphasis is placed on that individual's educational future. This act in itself alters the environmental influence on the individual's intelligence. From the examples used in this paper we can see an argument for environmental influences taking shape as the majority defining factor of an individual's intelligence level. I conclude that while both nature and nurture have varying influences on human development, it is the