This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Examining The Basic Principles Of The Belmont Report In Relevance To The Clinical Trial Involving Human Subject, Jesse Gelsinger. Sara Schultze Btc6

1284 words - 5 pages

In the United States, the basis for ethical protection for human research subjects in clinical research trials are outlined by the Belmont Report developed in the late 1970’s. This document, published by the Nation Commission for the Protection of Human Subjects of Biomedical and Behavioral Research, highlights three important basic principles that are to be considered when any clinical trial will involve human research subjects. They are; respect for persons, beneficence, and justice. (Chadwick & Gunn, 2004)
Over 20 years after the proclamation of these specific ethical guidelines, we are introduced to the University of Pennsylvania’s Institute for Human Gene Therapy’s study on a delivery mechanism for gene therapy that resulted in the death of an 18 year old research subject Jesse Gelsinger. Gelsinger suffered from partial OTC (ornithine transcarbamylase) deficiency caused by a defective single gene (Obasogie, 2009).
Upon first examination of the Jesse Gelsinger case, it may seem as if his death was merely an unforeseeable result after all protocol and considerations were distinctly followed. In the weeks proceeding his death, investigations into the study would find vital flaws with the clinical study design protocol and ethical judgment. The facts uncovered after Jesse Gelsinger’s death would raise questions into how our seemingly advanced regulatory structure could fail this patient.
We can cross examine each principle outlined within the Belmont Report to specific sequences of events to determine in which ways these principles were skewed or ignored, perhaps understanding the way in which the regulatory protocols can be incorrectly carried out or enforced, despite the fact the United States has set such protections in place.

Respect for Persons
The Belmont Report outlines the respect for persons to include protections for an individual’s right to know and understand the details of the clinical trial in which they are to become a subject. One aspect of this principle explains the importance in the protection of autonomy for individuals, to ensure they are not being subjected to research against their will. It also outlines provisions for individuals that are deemed ‘vulnerable populations’ to be recognized and given special considerations. Vulnerable populations generally include children, mentally incapacitated and prisoners that may not be capable of providing true consent due to cognitive abilities or personal freedoms. (Chadwick & Gunn pg.30).
In this aspect of the Respect for Persons principle, we know that Jesse Gelsinger was protected. As a legal adult, it was documented and reported by his family that he was excited about the prospective outcome of the gene therapy trial. He recognized that he would not benefit from the study, but looked forward to being able to help advance medical knowledge so that others like him, with debilitating or potentially fatal single gene deficiencies, could be saved in the...

Find Another Essay On Examining the Basic Principles of the Belmont Report in Relevance to the Clinical Trial Involving Human Subject, Jesse Gelsinger. Sara Schultze BTC6

The basic principles of alternative dispute resolution

4367 words - 17 pages AbstractThe basic principles of alternative dispute resolution (ADR) are reviewed and discussed in relation to actual business disputes that were resolved through ADR.Alternative Dispute ResolutionAfter a review of the usefulness and purpose of alternative dispute resolution (ADR), this paper examines represenative examples of business disputes that were resolved without recourse to court proceedings. The sample cases are examined by way of

Understanding The Basic Principles of Voodoo

1935 words - 8 pages understand the basic principles of Voodoo, it seems necessary to understand the very word itself. The original spelling was “Vodun,” which is Louisiana’s derivative of the French word for spirit. The word has many other spellings, all of which were created to capture the pronunciation of the Haitians. However, many of the various spellings can also be linked to American scholars who first studied the religion. It would appear that their goal was

Examining the Role of the Clinical Nurse Specialist in Diagnosing and Prescribing

2608 words - 10 pages the inclusion of Clinical Nurse Specialists (CNSs) amongst those APNs authorized to be able to furnish (California’s legal terminology for “ordering” medications) prescriptions (CA BRN, 2003). The only CA BRN policy affecting CNSs and signed into legislation as assembly bill (AB) 90 (Cunneen) in 1998, addresses the minimum educational requirement for the CNS being masters prepared with a minimum of 500 hours of practicum and the stipulation

Explain the relevance of Human Resource Planning in an industry?

1146 words - 5 pages IntroductionIn today's competitive business market, it is very important to remember how effective planning and development play an important role in the overall success of the organization. Planning is vital part of any department of the organization whether it is the operations department or the marketing dept if planning doesn't take place than objectives will not be achieved in an appropriate manner. Then why not Human Resource Planning

The Legacy of Jesse Jackson

2403 words - 10 pages , but her principles have outlasted the life of every delegate who voted to lock her out. Rosa Parks did not have the most votes, but she was morally right. Dr. King didn’t have the most votes about the Vietnam War, but he was morally right” (Jackson 1984). In considering the legacy that Reverend Jesse Jackson has created and continues to build today, this excerpt of his speech was remarkably foretelling. Similarly to Fanny Lou Hamer, Rosa

The subject of free will as shown in Kafka's "The Judgement", "A Report to the Academy", and "A Country Doctor"

687 words - 3 pages events are inevitable consequences of antecedent sufficient causes; often understood as denying the possibility of free will," a belief that is clearly shown in all of his works, including the three short stories of "The Judgement," "A Country Doctor," and "A Report to the Academy."

The Ongoing Trial of Human Trafficking

1674 words - 7 pages . However, both sides agree that prostitution is equal to slavery when children and young people are involved because of how hazardous the work is and the fact they cannot give legal consent for themselves. Children around the world are being taken at all ages, most are unaware they are even in danger until it’s too late. A report from the Inter-Departmental Ministerial Group on human trafficking in 2011 found that 234 out of 946 potential victims

Discusses these principles of natural order as first established in ancient Chinese philosophy, and how the style of poetry conforms to the basic ideals of the Daoists

1142 words - 5 pages in religion. God would not be referred to a creator, but more as the meaning or purpose in nature. Human beings, a Daoist would hold, are an integral part of nature. Daoism does not believe humans had domain over nature; rather it is human's responsibility to live in harmonious balance with nature.Daoist believed that nature should be the guiding model for human behavior. From nature we should find way to interact with each other."Be still like a

Role of Jesse Jackson In the Black Civil Rights Movement

943 words - 4 pages Jesse Jackson is a famous Civil Rights leader, often considered to be one of the greatest. He believes that African Americans should get more political power. He fought for that power by being the second black American to run for President (the first was Congresswomen Shirley Chisholm in 1972 but wasn't a factor in the election). He was the first African-American to be a contender in a presidential election. Throughout the Civil Rights

The Two Worlds of Venice and Belmont Depicted in Shakespear's The Merchant of Venice

1336 words - 5 pages The Two Worlds of Venice and Belmont Depicted in Shakespear's The Merchant of Venice In 'The Merchant of Venice,' Shakespeare explores two different yet similar worlds. The world of Venice and the world of Belmont. These two worlds have many differences and some similarities. For example, Venice is a completely different setting compared with Belmont. Also, the characters in Venice are different but also similar to the ones

Explain The Relevance Of Poverty to Nursing

2895 words - 12 pages To understand the relevance of poverty to nursing we first need to determine what poverty actually is, many sociologists have come up there own definitions of poverty. Townsend's (1979, 125-6) study of poverty in the Britain states that individuals"can be said to be living in poverty when they lack the resources to obtain the type of diet, participate in the activities and have living conditions and amenities which are customary , or at least

Similar Essays

Freedom And Privacy On The Internet Can Be Realised On Basic Principles Of Human Rights And Good Governance

933 words - 4 pages police state that knows a lot about its citizens. In his 2013 report on the state of freedom of opinion and expression the UN Special Rapporteur Frank La Rue raised concerns about the lack of judicial oversight, and the enormous capabilities of surveillance structures, in terms of access to private data. These concerns have implications for freedom of opinion and speech with these surveillance activities giving undue power to the state over

The Belmont Principles And Declaration Of Helsinki

715 words - 3 pages Revelations from the Tuskegee syphilis experiment forced the medical community to enact policies to prevent such a tragedy from repeating itself. Consequently, the Belmont Principles and Declaration of Helsinki were created in order to establish a universal code of ethics for research involving human subjects. Both the Belmont Principle and Declaration of Helsinki emphasize that the well-being of research subjects triumphs over any research

The Belmont Report

1715 words - 7 pages , including the Holocaust and the Tuskegee experiments, demonstrate instances where scientific research on human beings is clearly unethical and damaging. Due to horrific events such as these, the National Commission for the Protection of Human Subjects of Biomedical and Behavioral Research published the Ethical Principles and Guidelines for the Protection of Human Subjects of Research, or Belmont Report, in 1979. Based on numerous years of

The Role Of Post Marketing Surveillance In Clinical Trial

1241 words - 5 pages effects in a large number of people (1) (3). The aims of the post-marketing safety surveillances program are to examine and quantify new drug safety issues, to recognize risk factors of product marketing, and to control medication use patterns (3). If undesirable effects are noticed In this forth phase of trial, the drug might get withdrawn from the market. Figure: Methods of Suveillance Studies: There are four different types