Experimentation Critique Essay

1448 words - 6 pages

Experimentation Critique PAGE \* MERGEFORMAT 1
Running head: Experimentation CritiqueExperimentation CritiqueExperimentation Critique"Pleasure derived by children from cognitive challenge and mastery" describes a research by Susan Hater. In this article, two studies illustrate a positive linear connection involving pleasure and choice of level of difficulty. Suggestion is made that people receive the most pleasure in solving the most challenging task and that children who were given the most difficult problem rated their performance negatively because of the increase in time and struggle. She suggests that the relationship between pleasure and challenge is not linear, but curvilinear. Susan Harter forecasts that in the absence of grades, children will actively seek out optimally challenged problems. These problems are relatively difficult for children but when properly solved, also produce the most pleasure. She also suggests that in the presence of grades, children would choose to solve less challenging problems because of their desire to do well and get a good grade.Harter's experiment involved a total of 40 sixth graders, 20 girls and 20 boys, all from the same school. The boys and girls were evenly assigned to the two conditions, "game" or "grade". In the first phase, all the children were exposed to assignments of four varying difficulties. They were given 120 seconds to make a word using all of the provided letters. In the second phase, the students chose which assignments they wanted to do. The "game" group was informed that it was a game, whereas the "grade" group was told they were going to be evaluated using a letter grade. The independent variable was grades: whether they received them or not. There were several dependent variables: difficulty choice, smiling, and children's reasons for choosing the assignments they chose. The experimenters measured solution time and smiling. Participants also rated assignment difficulty and their own competence levels. Harter found that assignment difficulty is inversely related to children's subjective level of competence. She also found that there was a clear connection between smiling and assignment difficulty for the first three levels of difficulty, and that smiling dropped significantly in the most challenging level. Harter also found that children in the "game" group chose more challenging assignments and that these children also smiled significantly more. There was also significantly more smiling when the children solved the more challenging problems. The children in the "game" group also verbally expressed that had they been in the "grade" group, they would have chosen easier assignments. The children in the "grade" group would have chosen more challenging assignments had they been in the "game" group. These results support Harter's hypotheses that children would choose to solve easier problems in the presence of grades, suggesting that extrinsic rewards lower their desire to be challenged....

Find Another Essay On Experimentation Critique

Robert Smithson & Richard Serra Essay

1028 words - 4 pages the socioeconomic classes. Personal expression became acceptable and art practice exploded to include multiple fields of activity that Rosalind Krauss likens to “an extraordinary practice in elasticity”. Interest in ecology, performance, process, alternative materials, a loosening of social mores and experimentation with altered states of reality contributed to the rise of what is now known amply as Postmodernism. Civil rights, the anti-war

Rationalism, Empiricism, Dialectic materialism Essay

815 words - 3 pages , your brain is translating these sensations into certain conclusions and you cannot just conclude it with calling it "knowledge".The critiques of dialectical materialism is the process of cognition. Cognition is not something static, but a process of movement towards objective, complete and comprehensive truth. The first critique of dialectical materialism is sensationalism. Sensations are the result of the interaction of two material systems: the

Role of the Victorian Society in the French lieutenant's woman by John Fowles

757 words - 3 pages this way, he attempts to critique those values that Victorians most heralded.Until today, the Victorian Age was seen to be a Golden Age where Reason and Rationality were proclaimed asdogma and faith. People were beginning to question the claims that religion made about the existence of Godand the beginning of man. Anything that could not be proven through experimentation and science wasimmediately treated with suspicion. With Charles Darwin's The

Critique of Milgram

897 words - 4 pages who was under experimentation. With Milgram?s experiment, he concludes that the people react based on the situation and the entire situation is different.I don?t agree with Milgram?s experiment, because the people force to continue somehow on the experiment that they refuse to do. Meilgram?s experiment can be dangerous because whenever the one person give the wrong answer then the stranger will receive steadily increasing electrical shocks

Comparison of the Social Exchange Theory and the Symbolic Interaction Theory

2133 words - 9 pages The theory I originally chose to critique was the Social Exchange and Rational Choice framework from our class book. I chose this theory because when we talked about it in class it made a lot of sense to me. Its propositions and foundations are very applicable to many situations, and I felt like I had a good grasp of its concepts and structure. However, in doing research for this paper, I discovered that contrary to what our book led me to

Analyze Lyotard's reworking of the Kantian Sublime.

2559 words - 10 pages According to Kant in The Critique of Judgement (1790) 'the sublime moves, whilst the beautiful charms.' Kant's theory of the sublime relates strongly to that of the sublime in nature, however Kant doesn't see that it is the object in nature, which is purely sublime, but rather our minds superiority to reason over the 'unpresentable' in nature. Lyotard whilst developing and reworking this Kantian model, stipulates rather that the sublime is not

The Learning Organization

1653 words - 7 pages : The Challenges to Sustaining Momentum in Learning Organizations (1999) and his latest Schools That Learn in the year 2000 (Smith, 2001). Critique: The article begins with Senge stating that he believes that in today’s organizations there are five new component technologies that provide a different dimension that can build to learning organizations. As stated by author Michael Marquardt: Four main forces have brought us quickly to this global

Jean Piaget

1527 words - 6 pages stage. It was during this time period when Piaget observed the childhood development of object permanence. Object permanence is the concept which states that when a give object passes behind another it still exists. Children under age eight monthes do no seem to possess this concept. Piget proved this through extensive experimentation with his second child, Laurent. Piaget would roll a ball back and forth in front of Laurent. Then he would roll

Wide Sargasso Sea: A Cultural Commentary

2089 words - 9 pages impossible; without mobility cultural boundaries cannot be established. It is through acts of “improvisation, experimentation, and exchange that cultural boundaries are established” (228). Literature attempts to examine these improvisations (Greenblatt 229). However, as Greenblatt explains, that it not to say that culture influences literature and not the other way around. He states, “They [literary works] do not merely passively reflect

Social Critique versus Sadism in Horror Films

1702 words - 7 pages emergence of this character for a major improvement in the way women are presented in horror. Still, this transition to slasher films resulted in “ambivalent gender messages” (Prince) due to an increase in sexualized terror. These horror films generally feature a sadistic male killer and a helpless female victim. These two archetypal characters became essential to the genre’s experimentation with point of view. In her book, Men, Women, and Chain

Dorothea Orem's Self Care Nursing Theory Analysis

1813 words - 7 pages theory (McEwen & Wills, 2011). “Critical reflection of a theory determines how well the theory serves its purpose” (McEwen & Wills, 2011, p.95). Therefore, a critical reflection will be applied to the SCDNT. The purpose of this paper is to analyze and critique the SCDNT using the WAT method of theory analysis. Theory Description Origins of the Theory The origins of the SCDNT began when Dorothea was asked to write the nursing curriculum for the

Similar Essays

Adaptive Management Essay

865 words - 3 pages , adaptive management is learning by doing, and it is proactive in that it does not postpone management actions until complete data or information is gathered; essentially, it is experimentation that affects social arrangements and individual lives.Adaptive management has been defined in various ways since its development in the late 1960s. Its most effective form-"active" adaptive management-employs management programs designed to experimentally

Human Resources Paper

1052 words - 4 pages Week 3 Experimentation Critique (Res/320) Student Name: Directions: Find a research report that uses experimentation. The source must be the UOPX Library. Complete each section below after carefully reviewing the syllabus instructions and the Week 3 chapter readings. You are welcome to pick a report that will help you with your team project or something you are interested in personally. Deductions will be made if the sources are not

The Avant Garde Die First Essay

2618 words - 10 pages The Avant-Garde Die First In the 19th century, under the suffocating weight of a centuries long tradition in academic art, artists began to break free. Tired of meaningless imitation and decoration, the avant-garde artists pushed for drastic revolutions in aesthetic and social taste. This experimentation rapidly grew less and less controlled, and new technique and new style, which shocked and enraged the critics and public

Dogmatism Vs Criticality Essay

1694 words - 7 pages considered critical, but I will critique Popper by arguing that scientists have often displayed dogmatic attitudes and present a brief argument for a healthier relationship between science and religion. Imre Lakatos, another twentieth century philosopher, talks about the paradigm shifts in science that occur slowly because of scientists’ tendency to hold on to certain theories even when evidence suggests an alternative hypothesis must be tested