Explain What Is Meant By Verification And Falsification, In The Context Of Religious Language? Evaluate Their Criticisms Of Religious Language.

1844 words - 7 pages

The basic question behind religious language debate is ‘what can be said about God?’ The religious language debate is not concerned with whether or not God exists, or what God is like or why there is evil in the world. It is solely concerned with working out whether or not religious language means anything. Within the debate, old tradition of religious believers argue that you can speak and write about God, because God is a reality. Nevertheless Logical Positivists claim that statements about God have no meaning because they don’t relate to anything that is real? In the debate about religious language, there are two types of language, cognitive and non-cognitive. Cognitive language conveys facts i.e. things that we can know. Non-cognitive language, predictably, conveys information that is not factual; emotions, feelings and metaphysical claims.In the 1920's in Vienna a group of philosophers, known as the Vienna Circle, proposed a theory to do with logic and language. Influenced by the ideas of Wittgenstein, the group proposed a way in which it could be decided what it was meaningful to say, and what was pure nonsense. This view also became known as Logical Positivism. They concluded words had to be justified either through empirical evidence or through logic following empirical evidence. Therefore to verify any word, one had to establish its worth. For example the word “table” is easy to verify because we can see and touch the table. “Two plus two equals four” is a logical and therefore a meaningful statement, if we do not try to specify what two is. “God is Love”, is meaningless because we can find no verification of “God” nor “Love”. Beliefs are not based upon any thing verifiable as philosophers had tried to create logical ontological, cosmological and teleological arguments for the existence of God, but all have failed to convince the logical positivists.A. J. Ayer in “Language, Truth and Logic”, sets out the distinction between "strong" and "weak" verification. "A proposition is said to be verifiable, in the strong sense of the term, if, and only if, “its truth could be conclusively established by experience”. It is this sense of verifiable that causes the problem of verification with negative existential claims and positive universal claims. However, the weak sense of verification states that a proposition is "verifiable. if it is possible for experience to render it probable". Ayer stated there were two types of statement that are meaningful: Analytic propositions; these are statements that contain all the information within the statement that we need to verify it i.e. 2+2=4 and Synthetic propositions; these are statements that can be confirmed through the use of the senses by recourse to empirical evidence i.e. it’s raining outside.After establishing these distinction, Ayer goes on to claim that "no proposition, other than a tautology, can possibly...

Find Another Essay On Explain what is meant by verification and falsification, in the context of religious language? Evaluate their criticisms of religious language.

Critically Evaluate Cupitt's Cultural-linguistic Approach to Religious Language

1708 words - 7 pages Religion without doctrine, religion without creed, religion without belief in another, spiritual world we live in - that is what Cupitt is striving for since he denies the literal truth of virtually all the elements of religious creed: the afterlife, heaven and hell and the resurrection of Jesus Christ." are comments made by Julian Baggini after an interview with Cupitt. Cupitt is seen as "a man who wants to dispense with all religion's claim

Assessing the View that Religious Language is Meaningless

2910 words - 12 pages argument, followed by its complete rejection by Wittgenstein, and then I will go on to falsification and its criticisms. The first argument for the idea that religious language is meaningless is logical positivism, a branch of philosophy that sprouted the idea of the verification principle. This idea first came about in the early work of Ludvig Wittgenstein, who put forward a picture theory of language. This is a simple

Discussion of the Importance of the Social and Cultural Context Where Child Language Acquisition is Concerned

3568 words - 14 pages Discussion of the Importance of the Social and Cultural Context Where Child Language Acquisition is Concerned Beginning with Elene Lieven’s review of the importance of the environment for language learning, discuss the importance of the social and cultural context where child language acquisition is concerned. Environment According to Elena Lieven, the roles played by brothers and sisters, and other children and

Discuss the importance of context in understanding language play.

1582 words - 6 pages context. In other words, it can invoke context and provide context for other talk. Dialogic can be altered by words or utterances, which have gone before. Also, words used can be connected and associated with their previous use in other contexts.In demonstrating the affect of context within language play I am going to explain and define its importance depending on the type of discourse. The areas that I will be looking at closely include general

Cultures and Their Religious Beliefs: The Power of Myth by Joseph Cambell

2406 words - 10 pages a person’s religious faith can reveal their ultimate purpose. Knowing their views of religion will help me to further understand the individual on a deeper level. My personal story also is impacted by their perspective. Having someone explain their religious faith is eye opening, and makes me see things in a different light. As I grew up Christian I understand their values, but Buddhism is very dissimilar to me. I can see many great aspects to

The Historical Context of The Bhagavad Gita and Its Relation to Indian Religious Doctrines

2519 words - 10 pages The Historical Context of The Bhagavad Gita and Its Relation to Indian Religious Doctrines The Bhagavad Gita is perhaps the most famous, and definitely the most widely-read, ethical text of ancient India. As an episode in India's great epic, the Mahabharata, The Bhagavad Gita now ranks as one of the three principal texts that define and capture the essence of Hinduism; the other two being the Upanishads and the Brahma Sutras. Though this work

Show how through an analysis of the content, language and style Eliot's "Preludes" is a reflection of its context

1040 words - 4 pages questions the very core of the ideas and contextual reflections that are conveyed in the text. Having argued about the state of the world, and how modernism has overridden Romanticism and the Victorians and become dull, Eliot finishes off by saying there is nothing he can do, there is nothing anyone can do but laugh at the state of the world.In conclusion, it can be seen through Eliot's use of language and imagery that "Preludes" is greatly

Language in a Cultural Context

1237 words - 5 pages There are many languages that people can use at their disposal, and English is certainly one of the most important languages of them all. The story By Any Other Name by Santha Rau shows just how vital the English language is. The story revolves around an Indian girl and her sister and showcases just how crucial English is in the education system and displays its vast positives such as developing a form of communication between others and a

Explain the emergence of Left and Right Realist Criminologies and evaluate their strengths and weaknesses.

2424 words - 10 pages goals, leading to strain theory. He suggests that frustration is most likely to be experienced by those at the lower end of the social ladder such as the unemployed, people who are disabled and the oppressed ethnic minorities. According to strain theory, some people in these vulnerable groups, as a result of frustration and failure to achieve success, may resort to crime in order to achieve their aims. (McLaughlin et al, 2004)Right realists hold a

Use of Language in How the Garcia Girls Lost Their Accents by Julia Alvarez

3230 words - 13 pages Use of Language in How the Garcia Girls Lost Their Accents by Julia Alvarez In her novel How the Garcia Girls Lost Their Accents, Dominican author Julia Alvarez demonstrates how words can become strange and lose their meaning. African American writer Toni Morrison in her novel Sula demonstrates how words can wound in acts of accidental verbal violence when something is overheard by mistake. In each instance, one sees how the writer

how culture of students affects in learning their language

1956 words - 8 pages participated in the survey.Our questions were:Do you believe that the culture of a person has any effect on their language? Would you please explain how?How culture affects the writing skills of a student? What about the speaking skills?Do you think social status, educational, and economic backgrounds have any role to play in learning a language? Please give examples.Procedure: After framing the questions, we decided to make an appointment with the

Similar Essays

Ludwig Wittgenstein: The Nature Of Religious Language

1014 words - 4 pages non-believer may be able to understand religious language and decide if it holds any meaning for them. It is also argued that if anything, non-believers may be able to understand religious language better than a believer, as they can be more objective about it. It seems that Wittgenstein was mistaken as seeing religious language only being intelligible in the context of religious belief. Many religious statements entail a truth which is not dependent upon context, but statements such as 'Jesus died to bring salvation' are though of as true for everyone.

"Religious Language Is Meaningless" , Discuss

2927 words - 12 pages exists". However now science and technology have developed, we know such a statement not to be meaningless.Ayer published a second edition of his book "language, truth and logic" in which he responded to many of the criticisms he faced after the publication of his first book. He began by changing the definition of principle verification to "A statement which is held to be meaningful if and only if it is either analytic or empirically verifiable

Does The Via Negative Solve The Problem Of Religious Language?

715 words - 3 pages 'Does the Via Negativa solve the problem of religious language?' Assess this view.When using human language in a religious context we come across many problems, including that of anthropomorphising God, and using words of our limited experience to attempt to define a Transcendent and ineffable being. Many scholars have assessed whether the Via Negativa has solved this issue, and whether or not it should be an attempt used by Christians, as we

An Investigation Into The Meaningfulness Of Religious Language

2644 words - 11 pages range of our vocal interactions.There is a great deal of what might be termed 'religious vocabulary' in our language; much of it also used in a variety of normal contexts. This is necessitated by the fact that, in order to state that there is a God and to make other religious claims, theists use words in general use such as personal, creator, free and good, terms which we first learn to use from seeing them applied to everyday objects and