Explain Hume's Claim: 'reason Is The Slave Of The Passions'. Is Hume Right About This? Does Hume's View About Reason And Passion Imply That Every Action Is Ultimately Performed For Selfish Reasons?

2000 words - 8 pages

Unlike many of his predecessors, David Hume held that moral distinctions are not made by reason but instead are controlled by one’s passions, claiming that “reason is the slave of the passions”. In this essay, I will first assess Hume’s view of moral psychology by explaining this statement and comparing the theory to those that preceded his, then go on to show that he is correct in his understanding and finally explain how his view implies that every action is ultimately performed for selfish reasons, providing examples.Before we may begin to analyse Hume’s view, we must first create a reference point by understanding the previous view held by classical philosophers such as Plato and Aristotle, presented through texts such as Plato’s This Republic. In this, Plato claimed that one must act accordingly to either reason or passion, where reason was a stable, logical force whereas the passions were said to be inconstant, involuntary, blind and bestial. The best moral agent presented by Plato is one who acts only according to reasons and never allows his passions to overcome reason.Here in Plato’s model, reason cannot act as its own motivation in order to perform an action. It exists only as device with which one my employ to come to a decision, but on solely in its own presence. For example, reason is unable to tell you to ‘go to the library’. However, it may be used to say ‘the best way to achieve your goal of obtaining a book would be going to the library’; hence, making this is a good decision.’ Reason allows one to achieve their incentive but not to set this incentive, and for this reason, one needs passions to motivate actions.Hume presents that all reason can be either demonstrative or probable, where demonstrative reason is reason which discovers relationships between concepts, existing independently of experience. This is the kind of reason used when solving mathematical equations and similar rational problems, gives facts only based on the existence of other, corresponding facts.Probable Reasoning is reasoning based on experiences which find causal relationships between ideas. In decisions, it is able to find the best means to a desired end, but cannot in itself motivate this means in the absence of a desired end. From this, we can see that reason can in no way challenge the will of the passions, nor develop motivations of its own. We can hence see that reason must serve only as a slave of the passions, as it hasn’t the ability to occupy any other office but to serve the passions.Reason, Hume maintains, can at most inform us of the tendencies of actions. It can recommend means for attaining a given end, but it can't recommend ultimate ends. Reason can provide no motive to action, for reason alone is insufficient to produce moral blame or approbation. We need sentiment to give a preference to the useful tendencies of actions.But this does not however mean that reason is to be...

Find Another Essay On Explain Hume's claim: 'reason is the slave of the passions'. Is Hume right about this? Does Hume's view about reason and passion imply that every action is ultimately performed for selfish reasons?

"All of the other Ways of Knowing are controlled by language." What does this statement mean and do you think it is a fair representation between perception, emotion, reason and language?

1323 words - 5 pages " the other ways of knowing.I don't think that this statement is a fair representation between perception, emotion, reason and language. In my opinion language does not control emotions since any form of language is triggered by emotions. Emotion is defined as a moving of the mind or soul; excitement of feelings, whether pleasing or painful; disturbance or agitation of mind caused by a specific exciting cause and manifested by some sensible effect

Faith, Reason, Belief and Action Essay

2001 words - 8 pages that, while its significance has been diminished in the past two millennia, continues to be at the core of the Catholic tradition. To become a true representation of what St. Peter’s original church called for, a balance must be achieved, holding the values of belief, action, faith and reason as equal and necessary measures of the manifestation of Jesus’ message. When the early church is considered, both the theology behind the founding members

Reason for Returning to School This essay describes the reasons why working adults, like myself, decided to go back to college and obtain a degree.

723 words - 3 pages that by getting a degree, they can achieve this goal. All of them pertain to me. Especially in today's current economy, I strongly feel that there is a great advantage to having a degree versus to not having one when it comes to searching for a job.More and more each year, I see new programs for education that are designed for working adults. If there were no real demand for these programs, they would not exist. But that demand is real. There is a

Reason for Returning to School This essay describes the reasons why working adults, like myself, decided to go back to college and obtain a degree.

718 words - 3 pages that by getting a degree, they can achieve this goal. All of them pertain to me. Especially to today's current economy, I strongly feel that there is a great advantage to having a degree versus to not having one when it comes to searching for a job.More and more each year, I see new programs for education that are designed for working adults. If there were no real demand for these programs, I believe they would not exist. But that demand is real

Reason and Passion in Charlotte Bronte's Jane Eyre

875 words - 4 pages in resurrection!" (Bronte, 17) Jane's passions are uncontrolled because she is not using reason. We see the dangers of nature and passion tempered by reason in the scene in which Rochester almost marries. Jane must get over her overwhelming passion for Mr. Rochester or Jane runs the risk of losing herself. In this case, passion nearly gains a victory over reason. Jane nearly loses her own personality in her overwhelming love. "Feeling

An Age of Reason, An Age of Passion

1128 words - 5 pages -Honor6 Fragonard (1732-1804), the outstanding masters of three generations of Rococo painting in France” (Stewart et al., 156). When it comes to Fragonard and his paintings, I have to mention that he is one of my favorite painters. Paintings like “The Swing” (1766), “A Young Girl Reading” (1776), “The Study” (1769), “The Lover Crowned” (1771-73), “The Meeting” (1771-73) and so many more hold a special magic for me. Every time I look at his

The Reason Behind Women's New Right to Vote in 1918

751 words - 3 pages The Reason Behind Women's New Right to Vote in 1918 In 1918 all men got the vote at 21 and all women got the vote at 30. However, women had to be householders or married to a householder. It is often said that women were given the vote because of the war. The war did change the situation in many ways. The obvious effect was that the women's role in the war was greatly appreciated - other than the usual criticism

'The most important reason why there was little opposition in Germany towards the Nazi regime was its use of propaganda' Explain how far you agree with this statement?

3809 words - 15 pages German people that they were a problem so they would see that he is doing the right thing. He always stirred up any thing that a social outcast did to make it look worse than it was and he blamed all of Germany's problems on them. This was easy for him as he controlled the propaganda, all he had to do was aim it at making the outcasts look bad and that was enough to brainwash the Germans. He then told the public that to complete his desirable

What was the reason the U.S Dropped the Atomic Bomb on Hiroshima And Nagasaki? Find out some of the reasons why this happen and how it got started. DBQ

563 words - 2 pages three most important reasons to use the atomic bomb were; End War Quickly, Save Lives, and last but not least Revenge. Was dropping the bomb the right choice? We'll never know. All that is knowing is that the atomic bomb ended the war quickly.World War II ended quickly with the use of the atomic bomb. What's it necessary? According to Mr. Byrnes the bomb wasn't necessary to end the war. In a interview Mr. Byrnes told Mr. Szilards that the

Of Mice and Men, John Steinbeck : How does the killing of candy's dog relate to the killing of Lennie? What were the similarities between them? What was the reason for killing?

1789 words - 7 pages killed the dog for selfish reasons, while George killed Lennie out of mercy. This was how the killing of the dog relates to the killing of Lennie.The society wished both Lennie and the dog dead as soon as they were no longer useful to it. The dog was smelly and old, therefore it became unwanted by the society. Carlson said "God awmighty, that dog stinks. Get him outta here, Candy! I don't know nothing that stinks as bad as an old dog. You gotta get

Paley vs. Hume This is a inductive argument about the origin and nature of God, religion, and the universe.

1025 words - 4 pages about from the clashing of the divine intelligence of God.From these arguments, he then concludes that the universe was designed. This gives a somewhat convincing view that God was the sole designer and creator of the universe. However, in "Dialogues Concerning Natural Religion," David Hume easily finds fault within the argument that Paley puts forth. Hume examines both sides of the argument and allows the reader to draw their own conclusions. Hume

Similar Essays

How Accurate Is The Claim That The Effects Of Wwi Were The Most Important Reason For The Rise Of Totalitarian Governments In Italy During The Period To 1939?

1164 words - 5 pages The rise of totalitarian governments in Italy became a decisive issue in the history of Italian politics. Many historians believe that the effects of the First World War were the most important reason for the rise of these fascists. However the war simply accelerated the necessity for a new and reformed government. Many factors existed before the war and the First World War simply highlighted the necessity for change. In addition, without the

Affirmative Action.Talks About How Affirmative Action Is The Reason For More Diverse Student Bodies, While At The Same Time, It Might Be The Cause For More Black Failure Rates In Colleges.

1700 words - 7 pages feel that because he belongs to this or that race he will be advanced regardless of his own merits or efforts"(81). These writers feel affirmative action is a "well-meant folly" that can only encourage harmful outcomes because it does not teach blacks to believe in hard work and ability; rather, it rewards them for being black(81). If black students go to a university where their scores are lower than that of the white students, they may not excel

"There Is Every Reason To Believe That Resources Can Be Developed Sustainably". To What Extent Do You Agree With This Statement?

758 words - 3 pages kinds of aquatic plant life. Despite some methods in the MEDW being so controversial, sustainable farming does allow MEDC's to grow enough food for their populations, even when it is naturally near impossible to grow some types of crop.Sustainable development in the LEDW appears to be far harder to achieve than it is in the MEDW. One reason for this, and possibly the main one from which all the other contributing factors stem from, is corruption. In

David Hume On Sentiments And Reason

1549 words - 6 pages In Appendix I., Concerning Moral Sentiment, David Hume looks to find a place in morality for reason, and sentiment. Through, five principles he ultimately concludes that reason has no place within the concept of morality, but rather is something that can only assist sentiment in matters concerning morality. And while reason can be true or false, those truths or falsities apply to facts, not to morality. He then argues morals are the direct