Explain The Main Differences Between Common And Civil Legal Systems; Discuss The Feasibility Of The Convergence Between These Legal Systems.

1463 words - 6 pages


Obviously, definite and unified legislation all round the world is the dream of many people because it would make many aspects of life easier and certain. For example, the dissimilarity between law and legal proceedings of different states is one of the obvious barriers to and free trading and investing. However, every state has own legislation by the reason of diverse mentality, religion and historical heritage. All the state laws can be divided for convenience into three main legal systems of the world; which are civil law, common law and religious law. The main purpose of this work is to clarify the principal distinction between Common and Civil Legal Systems. Consequently, the knowledge of these distinctions will make it possible to discuss the feasibility of the convergence and unification of these legal systems.

According to Winterton (1975) legal system in the broad sense can be considered as juristic philosophy and methods shared by the number of states with broadly identical legal systems. There are two major legal systems to consider; the civil law and common law legal systems. Civil law is the oldest and the most widespread legal system in the world. According to Neubauer and Meinhold (2006) civil law is based on a code and the orderly collection of interdependent articles written in a laconic, detached manner. The civil law system is built on the Roman law of Justinian's Corpus Juris Civilis (Body of Civil Law). The Code Napoleon (1804) can be considered as an example of Civil Code in a modern state.

Roman law did not actually influence the common legal system of England. The term "common law" refers to the Norman Conquest of England in 1066 which paved the way to the establishment of common law throughout the realm. The main feature of common law system is the influence of judicial decision as the major source of law rather than legislative states. Law is relied mostly on customs and traditions and the reasonableness of the judges' decisions was the most important point. Common law legal system is primarily in use in the states which inherited English common law system such as the United Kingdom, most of the United States, Canada, India, New Zealand, and Australia etc.

Uzbekistan, along with other post-soviet countries is experiencing the transition from the socialist law to civil law. There are some peculiarities in the civil law system of Uzbekistan; the executive branch has much more authority in order to accelerate the process of conversion to free market and civil society. The resources of decrees of the president and the cabinet of ministers are widely used. The president also has the authority to appoint and dismiss the judges of regional, district, city and arbitration courts. In whole, Uzbekistan legal system is the part of the civil law system.

The source of law is probably the main distinguisher of a Legal System. The sources of law are legislation, codes, judicial...

Find Another Essay On Explain the main differences between Common and Civil Legal Systems; Discuss the feasibility of the convergence between these legal systems.

Exploring the Differences Between Liberal Democratic, Authoritarian and Totalitarian Political Systems

1742 words - 7 pages consider the differences between three political systems: ‘liberal democratic’, ‘authoritarian’ and ‘totalitarian’ the individual definitions must first be established then any similarities and differences evaluated and finally the practical consequences of these must be highlighted. Liberal democracy is a very popular political system in modern times. It has several defining attributes. Within a liberal democracy there

The Differences Between an Electronic Medical Record and Clinical Information Systems

687 words - 3 pages Discussion A Describe the difference between EMR and Clinical Information Systems (CIS). What are the advantages and disadvantages of CIS’s? EMR is an electronic record of patient health information that is created by each encounter in any healthcare setting (Menachemi & Collum, 2011). Information in the EMR includes patient progress notes, medications, problems, vital signs, immunizations, laboratory and radiology reports and past medical

Legal systems: Duty of Care and Negligence

1406 words - 6 pages Legal systems are critical to the functionality of any given society. In particular, issues of duty and responsibility are fundamental to address especially when one party causes harm or injury to another. In this respect, the concept of duty of care and its connection to negligence serve a key role in the society. Tort law provides for legal processes following acts of negligence that exhibit duty of care. The underlying liability in negligence

Understanding the Convergence of Media Systems and Political Communication in the U.S. and Western Europe

1429 words - 6 pages Understanding the Convergence of Media Systems and Political Communication in the U.S. and Western Europe A powerful trend is clearly underway in the direction of greater similarity in the way the public sphere is structured across the world. In their products, in their professional practices and cultures, in their systems of relationships with other political and social institutions, media systems across the world are

This essay will aim to explain the main differences between Marxian, Durkheimian, and Weberian approaches to social inequality.

1492 words - 6 pages essay will discuss the main differences between each of their approaches to social inequality.Social inequality did not exist in mans 'natural' state because of the common control of resources allegedly characterised by the ownership of land by the total community with individual rights in tools, cultivation and the distribution of products. Those who laboured owned the land they laboured on, the requisite tools, their own labour power and had

In this essay I will describe two sociological perspectives; I will also explain the similarities and differences between two of the main theories functionalism and Marxism.

882 words - 4 pages different people and institutions e.g. schools and the family, these values are passed on from generation to generation.Marxist theories are about class conflict rather than consensus. Similar to Functionalism Marx acknowledges the structural integration of societies institutions such as political, legal or religious groups, which he describes as the superstructure. Unlike functionalism however Marx argued that rather than having a harmonious

Explain how mortgage backed securities are issued. Present evidence of the main issuers of these securities and explain the main reasons they issue these bonds.

948 words - 4 pages Present evidence of the growth in the importance of non-government bond issues over the past five years (to2005). Explain how mortgage backed securities are issued. Present evidence of the main issuers of these securities and explain the main reasons they issue these bonds. Describe the main forms of bonds issued by (non-financial) companies (excluding hybrids) and on the basis of evidence of the amounts issued assess the size of this segment of

The Most Common Types of Systems Access Controls

703 words - 3 pages The most common types of systems access controls Access control requires unique user identification, emergency access procedure, automatic log-off, and encryption and decryption of data. In order to maintain confidentiality, integrity and availability of data, it is important to control access to the information system. Controls prevent unauthorized users from accessing the system and/or altering data. They also prevent authorized users from

Criminal and Civil Law in the English Legal System

1893 words - 8 pages One of the main differences between criminal cases and civil cases is that they are held in different courts, this is because there is a significant distinction between a civil wrong and a criminal wrong. Crimes are considered to be a type of wrongdoing, however civil wrongs tend to have only an impact on the parties involved in the case. For example: a breach of contract. Where as criminal wrongs tend to have an

Critically evaluate the main principles of legal positivism and natural law.

3538 words - 14 pages of its moral goodness or badness"Natural law maintains a link between justice and morality. The major property of legal positivism is that law and morality, 'is' and 'ought,' are clearly separated, the so-called "Separability Thesis". The keeping apart of 'is' and 'ought' has become a major controversy within the debate between Natural Lawyers and Positivists. It rejects the notion of a metaphysical basis for the law. It studies laws the way

Discuss the influence of global relations on the production and distribution of legal and illegal opiates.

1049 words - 5 pages to work on the issue of the production and distribution of opiates. As far back as the nineteenth century global relations played a key role in the legal and illegal distribution of opiates. With the emergence and dominance of the British Empire in this period free trade between countries became more common and China became a key supplier of the Britain’s new obsession, tea. Britain began to see financial disadvantages in its trading with China

Similar Essays

The Differences Between The Gaap And The Ifrs Accounting Systems

1239 words - 5 pages In the world of international finance there are two major accounting systems; GAAP, which stands for Generally Accepted Accounting Principles, and IFRS, which stands for International Financial Reporting Standards. The United States prefers GAAP while the European market, as well as many other countries, prefers IFRS. By 2015 the Securities Exchange Commission is anticipating a total transfer to IFRS in the United States. Though the differences

The Italian And English Legal Systems

1423 words - 6 pages an explanation for the above statement, it could be said that legal systems fall into two systems, the adversarial system and the inquisitorial system. Conversely, a hybrid between those two systems has formed yet another system which is identified as the mixed system. These derive from historical law and judicial practices which have been practiced for a considerable amount of time, which eventually improved and standardised. Debara.K in 2002

The Australian Legal System, Differences In Civil Law And Criminal Justice, How Can Both Systems Be Improved? Justify.

1097 words - 4 pages In Nsw, courts provide a resolution between individuals, corporations, government agencies etc... Courts are the place where the validity and application of law are determined and enforced. In courts there are two systems, Criminal justice and Civil law. Generally Criminal cases involves the person being persecuted by the police or Director of public persecutions for an offence against the law, while civil cases are disputes between people

Comparative Law Analysis Between Australian, Germany And China Legal Systems

4297 words - 17 pages behalf of B&CO. This concept will be discussed and explained further later.In the remaining part of this section, we will also discuss two further issues to understand Moe's legal position. The first of it is whether a valid legal contract was formed between the two parties.The other major issue arises when B&CO, through its new Managing Director (Bart), cancels an earlier assurance from the old Managing Director (Lisa), to rent premises