Explanation, Understanding, And Subjectivity Essay

3302 words - 13 pages

Explanation, Understanding, and Subjectivity

ABSTRACT: Many theorists of explanation from Hempel onward have worked with the explicit or implicit assumption that considerations of the subjective sense of understanding should be kept out of the formulation of a proper theory of explanation. They claim that genuine understanding of an event comes only from being in an appropriate cognitive relation to the true explanation of that event. I argue that considerations of the subjective sense of understanding cannot be completely removed from the process of formulating and justifying an acceptable theory of explanation. Although understanding is neither a necessary nor sufficient condition for an explanation, understanding is necessary as an initial guide to the nature of explanation. The widespread method of providing counterexamples for criticizing theories of explanation presupposes that there is a neutral method of identifying at least some clear cases of explanation and some clear cases of non-explanations. I argue that the only plausible method to fill this role relies essentially on the subjective sense of understanding. Objective validation of judgments about explanatoriness comes only through a complex process of social correction of our initial intuitive judgments regarding explanation.

It is clear that understanding and explanation are related. It is unclear exactly how they are related. We speak both of explaining-why and understanding-why some event occurred. Explanations typically produce understanding in those who consider them, and the sense of increased understanding typically comes from consideration of an explanation. Consideration of an explanation can, however, fail to produce in someone an increased level of understanding of the explanandum. Further, the subjective sense of gaining increased understanding of an event can come from an account that is not the explanation of that event. Hence, we cannot say that anyone's sense of understanding is either necessary or sufficient for an account to be an explanation. However, I shall argue, we cannot completely avoid all reference to understanding in a correct theory of explanation. This situation presents a pressing problem for philosophical studies of the nature of explanation, for many theorists relegate the sense of understanding to a strictly derivative position by claiming that the subjective sense of understanding of an event comes, under appropriate (articulable) conditions, from consideration of a potential explanation, and that genuine understanding comes, under appropriate conditions, from consideration of the true explanation. (See, for example, Hempel 1948, 256-257.) According to such philosophers we should rely on a proper theory of explanation to delineate potential explanations from non-explanatory accounts and a delineation of understanding will follow. I shall argue that this is not a workable option.

One can also express the issue at hand in terms of the...

Find Another Essay On Explanation, Understanding, and Subjectivity

Reading Response Essay

659 words - 3 pages another person’s options for agency are limited by another. I would think that all agency is a positive thing for a movement such as the feminist movement. Evans & Williams “Subjectivity”: Subjectivity is also an important concept for gender studies as it refers to both the process and relationships that an individual forms with society and discourses they were born into. Like agency, subjectivity is also a part of our foundation and building blocks of

Has molecular data replaced morphological data in phylogeny reconstruction

1974 words - 8 pages mentioned that very few characters are often used. Morphological homology poses a far greater problem, exacerbated by the fact that our understanding of morphological evolution is poor and thus satisfactory models cannot be applied. The incorrect conceptualisation of character provides one explanation for the inaccuracy of the anthrophyte hypothesis (Crane, 1985).Related to the arguments posed above is the concept of character coding whereby the

Reconsidering Harcourt in Wycherley’s The Country Wife

5992 words - 24 pages in Harcourt as a wit who contributes substantially to our understanding of the society of the wits,[5] what it means to be a wit and what the society of the wits requires (wit as an identity), and what attitudes and behaviors wits exhibit, what I will be calling wit subjectivity. Harcourt has frequently been overlooked and subjected to Horner-centric understandings of wit (those that derive primarily from Horner) that conflate a certain kind of

An Indepth Look at Subjectivity and Panopticism

1327 words - 5 pages left with no choice but to act in a manner to which he believes the watcher wants him to act. (Giroux & Nealon) A classic example of subjectivity can be found in an episode of Chuck Jones’ Looney Tunes called “Duck Amuck.” In said cartoon short, Daffy Duck (a regular throughout the show) is held subject to the upper hand of the mischievous Bugs Bunny and his antics as the “illustrator” for the short. Bugs Bunny is perhaps the most well known

The Bigger Problem Describes black subjectivity in the urban north through two texts

1784 words - 7 pages What does Richard Wright's depiction of Bigger Thomas suggest about his conceptualization of black subjectivity in the urban North, and to what extent does it depart from the "the New Negro" in Alaine Locke's text?The Bigger ProblemAlain Locke's essay "The New Negro" explains how the condition of black people during the Harlem Renaissance is evolving to a New Negro who is independent. Locke tells us that the Old Negro was a stereotype not a

Definition of Impartial

832 words - 3 pages Title Subjectivity, impartiality and Ethics Subjectivity, impartiality and Ethics While it is debated as to whether or not we can obtain pure impartiality, I'd like to attempt to submit a definition of what I mean by "impartial". I could use the dictionary, but words often take on a personal meaning. Ironic, really, that I'm offering a subjective definition of impartial. A thing can be said to be impartial if it fits, consistently, within

An Existentialist Meaning of Life

3640 words - 15 pages own subjectivity. Therefore the earlier explanation that includes, one must attempt to actively experience the world around them asserting their own freedom, with the responsibility to assert the freedom of others as well, must be footnoted with, in a manner that makes them happy. The Teleological goal of technology and the question of God: Technology is a huge aspect of our everyday lives. It is impossible to imagine our lives without

Social Science

1648 words - 7 pages science research, to test the researchers’ hypothesis. However, interpretive approach prefers to use qualitative research method, and believes that the research should focus on the situation which individual is involved in. The critical approach attempts to improve social condition based on general theory. Because critical approach concentrates more on the changing of social condition instead of understanding the root of conflicts and its resolution

Little Red Cap by Carrol Anna Duffy

1204 words - 5 pages text than individual biographical influence, and rejection of either can lead total confusion of a text’s purpose. New Criticism’s rejection of subjectivity is justified through its focus on the “complexity of a text” that is produced through paradox, ambiguity, tension, and irony (Tyson 138). When recognizing the importance of irony in Duffy’s “Little Red Cap”, New Criticism appears to be an accurate lens to assess the text with, but instead the

Understanding Consciousness

634 words - 3 pages that have been proposed, by which most are understood by means of aspects of the material world. The direct observation of consciousness seeks answers to questions such as what its characteristics and functions are. Does it exist only when we are awake? Are all living organisms a part of this phenomena? Does it require something to be conscious of? Etc. The subjectivity of the idea of consciousness leaves the door open to multiple answers for

Understanding Consciousness

634 words - 3 pages that have been proposed, by which most are understood by means of aspects of the material world. The direct observation of consciousness seeks answers to questions such as what its characteristics and functions are. Does it exist only when we are awake? Are all living organisms a part of this phenomena? Does it require something to be conscious of? Etc. The subjectivity of the idea of consciousness leaves the door open to multiple answers for

Similar Essays

Eudora Welty's The Golden Apples Essay

688 words - 3 pages Other Subjectivity in Eudora Welty's The Golden Apples The language, meaning, and otherworldliness of Eudora Welty's The Golden Apples, like the golden apples in Yeats' Song of the Wandering Aengus, invite yet often defy grasping. Gratefully, Lowry Pei has offered an informed and lucid perception of this collection, enabling readers to gain that much more ground towards achieving a valuable understanding of the stories, individually and

Postmodernism Disrobed: Jean Baudrillard V.S. Stanley Fish

1263 words - 5 pages my brain, but not learned much. Baudrillard and Fish both wrote articles exploring the lack of interrelation between subjectivity and objectivity. I disagree with both of them, but I found Fish's writing more convincing, because Fish engaged himself with his readers more.In "The Map Precedes the Territory", Baudrillard portrays the postmodern world as a "hyperreal"( Baudrillard 80) society, where "the map precedes the territory,"(80) meaning that

Heidegger's Reading Of Descartes' Dualism Essay

4301 words - 17 pages own cognitive images even if I may not know the worldly thing because I have the idea of the worldly thing in my cogito, and therefore cogito with its contents is beyond doubt. According to Descartes, "res cogitans" also means "cogitat se cogitare". (3) The "ego" as subject has its predicates in a cognizing way; so I know about the predicates I have, i.e., I know myself. Heidegger thinks that Descartes' understanding of subjectivity is

Discussion Of Theoretical Perspectives In Danby, S. (1996). Constituting Social Membership: Two Readings Of Talk In An Early Childhood Classroom. Language And Education, 10(2&3), 151 170

1654 words - 7 pages of reconstructing or resisting contradictory subject positions and practices (Weedon, 1997).The feminist post-structuralist approach theorizes the idea of subjectivity in gender construction, as children position themselves in different discursive practices. In post-structuralist terms, subjectivity refers to "the conscious and unconscious thoughts and emotions of the individual, her sense of self and her ways of understanding her relations to the