This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Exploring Why The Tsar Abdicated After The 1917 Revolution But Not After The 1905 Revolution

2839 words - 11 pages

Exploring Why the Tsar Abdicated after the 1917 Revolution but not after the 1905 Revolution


Before the 20th century Russia was still very much living in the
medieval age with a Medieval standard of living. Before the mid 19th
century, Russia’s peasants were subjects to a form of slavery and were
known as “Serfs”. This from of slavery was abolished in 1861and
peasants were aloud land for themselves – but at a price. The peasants
did not receive enough land to make a living and were given land in
strips, making it difficult to improve on the current inefficient
harvesting methods. Bad harvests often brought famine and the Russian
population wanted a more modern Russia. As Russia moved into the 20th
century a very high percentage of the Russian population were peasants
who wanted a change from the agricultural ways – into a new
industrialised nation. This was because the current system was too
harsh on the peasants who were not getting enough food or money to
support their families or themselves, with all the money going to
upper class landowners. Another rising problem was the steadily
increasing population, which meant less land for peasant families to
grow food. Because of this Russia had had a spurt of industrial growth
and factories were popping up in all major towns and cities. Many
young men from the peasant villages went off to the cities looking to
work at the new factories; expecting better pay and good working
conditions. However that was not the case as all it did for the
workers was give them equally bad money and a higher risk of getting
injured while working unprotected with dangerous machinery. This was
the start of peasant uprisings and Revolution with new political
parties forming against Tsarism.


The two wars are an important part for the causes of revolution, The
Russo-Japanese war (1904-5) and World War I (1914-17). They both show
Russia not living up to its expectations of a powerful giant that
could crush any opponent. The Tsar had a huge powerful army throughout
his reign and knowing his strength in numbers, he became
overconfident. The Russo-Jap war started because Russia wanted
possession of Port-Arthur due to its ice free conditions and seized it
by building the Trans-Siberian railway into the port. The Japanese
felt humiliated and easily crushed the Russian Navy at the port who
were totally unprepared for an attack from what they thought was a
second-class power. The Russians then sent their Baltic Fleet to crush
the Japanese but were defeated easily. This was a massive humiliation
for the Navy and for the Tsar. Word of this humiliation spread and
this convinced the Russian people they needed change. After the loss
against Japan he was shaken up so he relaxed control of the country.
This allowed various working groups to...

Find Another Essay On Exploring Why the Tsar Abdicated after the 1917 Revolution but not after the 1905 Revolution

The 1905 Russian Revolution Essay

968 words - 4 pages reign as an autocrat. However this revolution was an indication of the power of the people and it can be said that it was a dress rehearsal for the February and October revolutions of 1917.There are many reasons for the outbreak of the revolution in 1905, most of which are related to the events of the year itself. The agitation and unrest of the Russian people began to show itself when the war against Japan began in February of 1904. It was thought

The 1905 Revolution Essay

1102 words - 4 pages The 1905 revolution was the result of opposition to the Russo Japanese war (1904)As with any revolution they are never mono-causal, there are always many reasons for the revolt, strikes and demonstrations throughout the whole country. There were many different causes affecting many different people. This created a diverse nature of the revolt. Countless different areas and classes had different reasons for the revolt so it was not very uniformed

Why did the Revolution of 1905 occur?

1272 words - 5 pages , and though after the Fundamental Law the Czar merely a year later, which gave him the right to veto the existence of the Duma altogether, still proved to be one that planted the seeds of revolution and prepared the nation for the more thorough in 1917. The revolution was an inescapable accumulative force that came from a very diverse people, spread across a cross continental country, that had been denied just treatment for far too long. It showed and aspired future revolutionaries to point to it as an example of why violent revolution was the only way to completely alter a system of government.

Why did the Tsar abdicate in 1917?

1030 words - 4 pages Why did the Tsar abdicate in 1917?The title 'Tsar' means a male monarch or emperor. Russia had always had a Tsar for 300 years; Nicholas II was the last .There is a number of reasons that led Nicholas abdicating in 1917.One of the main reasons that led the Tsar abdicating was failures of Wars. In 1904 Russia planned what was meant to be a surprise attack on Japan so it can stretch its empire, but ended up loosing which meant the tsar was

Why was the Tsar overthrown in 1917?

619 words - 2 pages The Tsar abdicated in the year 1917. Three important problems which contributes to the over throw of the in the year 1917 are, first of all the Tsar made mistakes by taking personal charge of the army and the actions he took after he did. Secondly, World war one played a big part in his over throw and thirdly one of the Tsar's strengths was that he had support of the army so when the army abandoned him, he lost one of his strengths.In 1917 the

Causes of the 1905 Revolution

1411 words - 6 pages Causes of the 1905 Revolution In 1905 was a vast but backward country. Compared to Britain, Russia's industry were undeveloped, also its people were poor and uneducated. It was ruled by A Tsar who had complete power over the country. In Britain it is a totally a different story, most of the people were well off, not rich and not poor. Also the industry was the driving force of the country. The vast majority of the

Lenin And Problems After The October Revolution

689 words - 3 pages Russia. This prosperity was for many “ distasteful and often disquieting”. It meant a reversal to capitalist corruption, confusing those that had learned to accept the harsh terms implied by revolution. Yet, I cannot agree completely with Serge. Lenin knew how essential a transitional period was for a Russia in ruin. The NEP, though not entirely successful in solving all the problems that came after the October Revolution, did manage to bring a

Napoleon Bonaparte: Restoration After the Revolution

883 words - 4 pages qualities to their full potential. Napoleon was the hero of nineteenth-century France, restoring the country to its former glory after the violence, instability, and turmoil of the French Revolution. Napoleon was the classic underdog, originally viewed as a “second-class Frenchman” due to his Corsican origins, but rising to success based on his own hard work and determination. He demonstrated the most improbable capacity for resilience; although

Iran Before and After the Revolution

836 words - 4 pages Iran before and after Revolution: Textual - Visual Metaphors of Graffiti during Revolution Introduction During the prehistoric period , human was creating markings on the surfaces of the caves and , since the down of civilization , on the walls of ancient structures Although in certain cases motivations to produce such marks are covered by mystery , wall paintings , and engravings definitely serve as factual evidence of human's presence

The Russian Revolution of 1917

1213 words - 5 pages . At first it was difficult trying to establish independence in my mother's house, but after a while it seemed as if I had won the battle. Unbeknownst to me that battle would be short-lived and ultimately my mom won the war. Basically, I had constructed my own crazy revolution against my mother. You see a revolution is “a fundamental change in political organization; especially: the overthrow or renunciation of one government or ruler and the

Exploring the American Revolution

1242 words - 5 pages men had the right to vote, to enjoy the privileges of a free press and freedom of religion Student’s name by the middle of the XVIII century. In other words, the colonies developed separately from the metropolis, and settlers began not only to realize themselves as Americans, but also they began to resist the attempts to subdue them. Exploring the American Revolution, it can be noted that even nowadays there is no general

Similar Essays

Why Did The Revolution Fail To Topple The Tsar In 1905, But Succeed In 1917?

1670 words - 7 pages Why did the Revolution fail to topple the Tsar in 1905, but succeed in 1917?The Russian Revolution had a decisive impact on the history of the twentieth century. Its implications and influences went on to effect a huge area and last decades. True to the large impact that it had, it was a large event. It spanned years and included many various groups and individuals. When studying the Russian Revolution it is important to note that it came during

Tsar Nicholas 2nd's Survival Of The 1905 Revolution

1506 words - 6 pages Tsar Nicholas 2nd's Survival of The 1905 Revolution There are several factors that help our understanding of how the tsar and his regime endured the turmoil of the 1905 revolution. However, one thing is for sure, after the uprising and swift, brutal suppression of the revolutionaries on the 22nd of January 1905 outside the gates of the Winter Palace, the Nicholas 2nd and his administration received a drastic wake up

Cuban Literature After The Revolution Essay

3579 words - 14 pages , censored news and publicity, and no freedom of speech. Throughout the years Castro stayed in power, but due to health issues originating on July 31, 2006, he had to step down. After Castro returned, he took control of Cuba up until February 19, 2008. He then abdicated his place as dictator and handed down his position to his brother, Raul Castro. The experience that the Cubans had throughout the harsh revolution is portrayed in Carlos Eire’s

Women After The American Revolution Essay

2204 words - 9 pages The desire of the Founding Fathers to make America a successful republic played a significant part in changing the many roles that women found themselves in after the Revolution. The role of women as wives became more important as republican ideals established an emphasis on marriage. Society saw marriage as a miniature representation of a republic. Therefore, republican ideals like independence and the freedom from arbitrary power allowed women