Eyewitness Identification And Reliable Testimony Essay

2839 words - 11 pages

Eyewitness identification and testimony play a huge role in the criminal justice system today, but skepticism of eyewitnesses has been growing. Forensic evidence has been used to undermine the reliability of eyewitness testimony, and the leading cause of false convictions in the United States is due to misidentifications by eyewitnesses. The role of eyewitness testimony in producing false confessions and the factors that contribute to the unreliability of these eyewitness testimonies are sending innocent people to prison, and changes are being made in order to reform these faulty identification procedures.
Human memory is flexible and prone to suggestion. “Human memory, while remarkable in many ways, does not operate like a video camera” (Walker, 2013). In fact, human memory is quite the opposite of a video camera; it can be greatly influenced and even often distorted by interactions with its surroundings (Walker, 2013). Memory is separated into three different phases. The first phase is acquisition, which is when information is first entered into memory or the perception of an event (Samaha, 2011). The next phase is retention. Retention is the process of storing information during the period of time between the event and the recollection of a piece of information from that event (Samaha, 2011). The last stage is retrieval. Retrieval is recalling stored information about an event with the purpose of making an identification of a person in that event (Samaha, 2011).
There are many factors that can contribute to faulty eyewitness testimony, including own-race bias, focus on a weapon, stress, length of exposure to the stranger, eyewitness confidence, and events that occur after the incident, such as suggestive police procedures (Vallas, 2011). “Own-race bias, also known as the cross-race effect, refers to the fact that individuals have less difficulty identifying and remembering faces of their own race than those of a different, less familiar race” (Vallas, 2011). Research that has been performed on this factor shows that the chance of mistaken identification is 1.56 times greater in cases that involve different races than in cases involving same race identification (Vallas, 2011). This factor of own-race bias does not vary significantly among age groups. Other factors that affect eyewitness identification are violence, stress, and the focus on a weapon.
“Violence, stress, and the presence of a weapon at the time of a crime all may have detrimental effects on the ability of a witness to make an accurate identification” (Vallas, 2011). Stress distorts an eyewitness’s observations, and while it is understandable to focus on the weapon when faced with a situation in which the eyewitness is in danger, the focus on the weapon is not as important as the description of the perpetrator. Since it is not within the power of researchers studying the effects of violence and stress on witnesses to replicate the exact stress and violence of an actual crime,...

Find Another Essay On Eyewitness Identification and Reliable Testimony

Psychological research shows that eyewitness testimony is not always accurate, therefore it should not be used in the criminal justice system. Dis...

1394 words - 6 pages shown though that this form of line-up has reduced the mistaken identity of a person in a line-up where the suspect wasn't there, but was also showing a reduction in accurate identification in line-ups with the suspect present (Brewer and Wells, 2006). Works Cited Wells, G., & Olson, E. (2003). Eyewitness Testimony. Annual Review of Psychology, 54, 277-295. doi:10.1146/annurev.psych.54.101601.145028 Wright, A., & Alison, L. (2004). Questioning

The Reliability of Eyewitness Testimony, can you really remember what happened or is your judgement impaired over time.

794 words - 3 pages a long incubation time like that it wasn't really recognized until the 1970's. With plenty of unsolved crimes and not enough evidence eyewitness testimony was all that was needed. Now with psychologist holding scientific studies to see if it is really reliable the legal jurisdiction try to pay more attention to the specific details. Through many studies it has been shown how the accuracy of the reports given can be altered by the ethnicity of the

Eyewitness Testimony

1807 words - 8 pages less accurate when the perpetrator is of a different race. Therefore, studies show that it will be 56% more likely to be wrong than if it were same race identification. When in a stressful situation the perpetrator is seen for a short period of time causing the accuracy to decrease even further. (American Psychological Association) We must not forget that prejudices, and stereotypes can factor into the result of an eyewitness testimony. As well

The Unreliability of the Eyewitness

2207 words - 9 pages the credibility of the spectacle. Instead, it is the act of correctly recalling what was seen that can be a difficult task. In the case of James Bain and many others, it turns out that a pair of” lying eyes” cost them their freedom. When listening to the proceedings of a court case, a jury is often comforted by the thought of an eyewitness being present. The group considers the individual as reliable because the person was present to see all of

Eyewitness Error

1178 words - 5 pages is not only affected during an observed event, but there are instances where memory can be influenced after an event as well. There are also instances where memory can be affected retroactively due to personal experiences and biases. Incorrectly recalling the memories of one’s life is usually not detrimental, but the flawed nature of long-term and short-term memory functions becomes a serious matter in regards to criminal eyewitness testimony

The Innocence Commission

1832 words - 7 pages studies have affirmed that eyewitness identification is often inaccurate and that it can be made more accurate by implementing specific identification reforms (The Innocence Project, 2008).Forensic ScienceBecause forensic science results can mean the difference between life and death in many cases, fraud and other types of misconduct in the field are particularly troubling. False testimony, exaggerated statistics and laboratory fraud have led to

DNA Testing

1604 words - 6 pages trial phase of this case the prosecutor relied heavily on the victim’s eyewitness testimony, courtroom identification, and the twisted testimony of forensic expert, Fred Zain (Connors et al, 1996). These witnesses represent two of the primary reasons innocent people are convicted; misrepresentation by an eyewitness and improper use of scientific evidence (Innocence project, n.d.). Eyewitness testimony and courtroom identification can easily sway a

Faulty Eyewitness Testimony

2815 words - 11 pages even report can vary drastically, the quality of eyewitness testimony wasn't really recognized as an issue until the 1970's. With plenty of unsolved crimes and not enough evidence eyewitness testimony was all that was needed. Now with psychologists holding scientific studies to see if it is reliable; the legal jurisdictions try to pay more attention to the specific details. Through many studies it has been shown how the accuracy of the reports

The Unreliability of Eyewitness Testimony in Children

2963 words - 12 pages accurate eyewitness testimony has been the subject of increasing attention by social scientists and members of the legal profession (Davies, 1996). Cases relying on evidence provided by child witnesses, such as physical or sexual abuse cases have helped bring to the fore issues pertaining to the accuracy and reliability of such eyewitness reports (Ceci & Bruck, 1993). As a result there has been a related increase of scientific studies of children’s

Forensic Evidence Admissibility For or Against in the Bloodsworth v. State Case

2496 words - 10 pages feet tall, a stocky build, no facial hair and red hair. He resembled the sketch that witnesses say did not look like the person they saw. (Jain, 2001) Bloodsworth also had weak alibi and made incriminating statements to others. The boot print that was found at the scene was later determined to be two sizes bigger than Bloodsworth’s. (Jain, 2001) In this case they simply went on the evidence of eyewitness testimony that seemed to waver and at times

Testimonial Evidence in Major League Athletes

1186 words - 5 pages evidence, Mason et al. (2005) regards physical evidence as a more reliable source of information because testimonies are subjective to the witness or victim. Testimony relies on accurate recollection of all the events that transpired (Mason et al., 2005). Subjectivity also originates from biased or imprecise perception causing the facts to become distorted. In many cases an expert witness, having vast knowledge and qualifications on the subject, will

Similar Essays

False Memory And Eyewitness Testimony Essay

2096 words - 8 pages structural changes in paradigm of police and legal procedures. In her book, first published in 1979, (Loftus 1996 Edt) , which clearly indicates her concerns with American miscarriages of justice and the influence of recall of false memories in the juridical system. Reviewing her work (Weinstein 1981) , clearly agrees that; Loftus is able to clearly exhibit how unreliable eyewitness identification can be, and concurs with her reasoning that memories

Racial Bullying And Eyewitness Testimony Essay

1860 words - 7 pages themselves to achieve high. Problem 2: Eyewitness Testimony Due to numerous errors occurred in Eyewitness Testimony (EWT) from failures in Source Memory, Scotland Yard has asked to provide an overview of psychological theory for the type of memory under consideration and to (a) provide them with possible interventions for improving this type of memory and (b) outline how it might be able to measure the efficacy of this intervention

Judges And Jurists Have Great Faith In The Accuracy Of Eyewitness Testimony. Psychologists, However, Would Have Us Believe Eyewitnesses Have Little To Offer The Criminal Justice System. Discuss.

2488 words - 10 pages recall errors. Yet, if judges and juries are aware of the factors that can impede accuracy in the courtroom and appropriate measures are taken to reduce these, it will help insure that they hear the most reliable eyewitness testimony possible. It must be noted however, that even if the jury hear a completely honest and reliable testimony, they too are only human and therefore subject to the same memory deficiencies, and as Cohen (1990) points out, trials are often full of stories about arguments over misremembered witness evidence!

The Importance Of Eyewitness Testimony Essay

652 words - 3 pages in trials and their testimony is considered crucial in the identification and arrest of a suspect and the likelihood of a jury convicting a defendant. Eyewitness testimony needs to be reliable as it can have serious implications to the perceived guilt/innocence of a defendant. Bartlett’s study involved the Indian folk story ‘War of the Ghosts’. He wanted to investigate the effect of schema on participant’s recall of a story. Participants were