This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Factory Farms And Animal Cruelty Essay

3652 words - 15 pages

Factory Farms and Animal Cruelty

Imagine that Christ meant these words literally. Imagine that accepting Christ as your personal savior required lunching with him. Of course, if Christ were coming over today for lunch, you would probably dust, vacuum, adjust the pictures on the walls, pick your best outfit, comb your hair, jot down a few questions about heaven. But what would the two of you eat? Would you serve Christ fried chicken? How would you feel about setting a plate of steaming, sizzling pork chops in front of your savior? A few hard-boiled eggs wouldn't hurt, right? Maybe a glass of milk to wash it all down?

For many Christians, faith has little to do with what's in the fridge. Lunch with Christ would raise issues far more problematic than choice of food. However, I propose that if the above-mentioned foods came from modern factory farms, Christ would not eat or drink them. I will argue that Christians are obligated to be morally concerned about animals, and that this obligation brings Christians into moral conflict with modern factory farms. Furthermore, I will argue that Catholic Social Teaching (hereafter "CST") should emphasize a theocentric basis for such obligation and conflict.

Rethinking Aquinas: Why Animals Matter

Some Christians think the words "animal rights" smack of wacky liberalism or of sentimentality. Such thinking presupposes that animals are not proper objects of moral concern. After all, in Genesis God commanded Adam to rule over creation. God gave Noah "everything that lives and moves" for food (Gen. 1:28). Therefore, according to this way of thinking, animals exist exclusively as means to human ends.

This position, which I call the Utility Thesis, does agree with some traditional Catholic theology. Expanding upon Augustine, St. Thomas Aquinas claimed that "according to the Divine ordinance the life of animals and plants is preserved not for themselves but for man [italics mine]. Hence, as Augustine says […]'by a most just ordinance of the Creator, both their life and their death are subject to our use'" ("Summa"). In other words, animals have utility value only.

Aquinas denied that animals are proper objects of moral concern for at least two reasons: (1) God made animals exclusively for human use; we ride, wear, work, and eat animals, and "there is no sin in using a thing for the purpose for which it is" ("Summa"). (2) Animals cannot reason. Since only rational beings are proper objects of moral concern, how one treats animals is morally valuable only insofar as such treatment affects rational beings. For example, one should not torture animals only because doing so may subtly influence one to torture humans, too. Points (1) and (2) are central to the Utility Thesis.

Although Catholic theology is indebted to Aquinas, I think there are good reasons to reconsider the Utility Thesis and points (1) and (2).

(1') If God made animals solely for human use, then God would care most about...

Find Another Essay On Factory Farms and Animal Cruelty

Animal Cruelty and Abandonment Essay

785 words - 4 pages . The main reason why animals die is because of abandonment. They are given horrible living conditions and treated poorly. There are two kinds of animal cruelty, active cruelty and passive cruelty. Both types are inherent cruelty to companion animals, animals for research, industrial factory farmed animal cruelty, animals used for sport and ritual, hoarding, animals killed for their fur, skins and body parts and mass market puppy mill production

Animal Abuse and Cruelty Essay

1891 words - 8 pages Animal cruelty can be either deliberate abuse or simply the failure to take care of an animal. Harm is defined as the reduction of the capacity to have and fulfil desires. These words pay a high price when it comes to animal abuse. This abuse is committed by many types of people that if they feel they can abuse an animal their concept of the word beast is strayed. This word beast has been formulated and reformulated countless amounts of times

Greyhound Racing and Animal Cruelty

1840 words - 8 pages Research Background and Topic The American Society for the Prevention of Animal of Cruelty defines animal cruelty as “acts of violence or neglect perpetrated against animals…” (ASPCA, 2013). Cruelty can range anywhere from physical abuse, mental abuse, overuse, lack of socialization to neglecting to feed, water or shelter an animal properly and humanely. Many of those who commit animal cruelty have to conscious conception that they are truly

Animal Cruelty and Youth Violence

2242 words - 9 pages There are over seventy million cats and fifty-five million dogs in the United States, yet the number of reported cases of neglect, or abuse is severely lacking (Davidson 1). Animal abuse is an ongoing dilemma in this country; recent studies have indicated child animal cruelty offenders often go on to pursue disturbing acts of criminal behavior. This nation simply does not have standardized legislation across the nation as a preventative

A Brief History of Animal Abuse and Cruelty

1478 words - 6 pages other animals. Some of the most common places where animal abuse occur are, in no particular order: fur farms, dog fights, laboratories, races (both Greyhound and horse), slaughterhouses, and puppy mills. Some less thought of forms of animal abuse are crush videos, traditional Chinese medicine, the cat/dog meat trade in Asia, the ivory trade, trophy hunting, and even shock collars. Abandonment is the leading form of animal cruelty. (See illustration

Causes of Animal Cruelty and How to Stop Them

1950 words - 8 pages currently a growing problem in today’s society because of psychological disorders, overpopulation, and money and it should be stopped. Animal cruelty is a term that is not clearly defined as it deals with many different ways . Two types of animal cruelty are active and passive animal cruelty. Active animal cruelty is defined by Gaps, the Georgia animal protective services to be, “ implies malicious intent, where a person has

Domestic Violence VS Animal Cruelty and Child Abuse

1975 words - 8 pages only country to have a federal law that regulates the treatment of animals in research, exhibition, transport, and by dealers known as the Animal Welfare Acts of 1966 which has been amended throughout the years. Some states do not seem to take animal cruelty as seriously though. According to the Humane Society, a good felony anti-cruelty law should protect all animals, apply to first-time offenders, carry large fines and prison time, with no

The Connectio Between Animal Cruelty And Human Violence

1434 words - 6 pages      Animal cruelty encompasses a range of different behaviors harmful to animals, from neglect to malicious, brutal killings. Studies show that animal cruelty may lead to more serious forms of crime, like heavy drug use, violent outbursts, and most common, cold blooded murder. Many studies in psychology, sociology, and criminology during the last twenty-five years have demonstrated that violent offenders frequently have childhood and

The Cruelty of Animal Research, Testing, and Experimentation

1391 words - 6 pages The Cruelty of Animal Testing and the Need for Alternative Methods In his book Inhumane Society: The American Way of Exploiting Animals, Dr. Michael W. Fox estimates that twenty-five to thirty-five million animals are used in the United States each year for laboratory testing and research (58). Research involving tests done on animals is unnecessary and cruel. More humane methods of research need to be employed. Fox states that animal

Honors Research paper on animal cruelty with sources cited. Looks at types of animal cruelty and how to fix it

2311 words - 9 pages A well known leader, Mahatma Ghandi once said, "The greatness of a nation and it's moral progress can be judged by the way it's animals are treated." (qtd in ASPCA) According to that quote we still have a long way to go yet before becoming a great nation. Not only does the United States have a problem with animal cruelty but countries around the world are struggling with it too. Not only is animal cruelty committed in circuses, puppy mills and

Ancient Rome's Animal Cruelty for their entertainment in the Amphitheatre and to maintain Political Status Quo

1815 words - 7 pages shown in their mosaics including gladiator V gladiator, gladiator V animal (pic 2) and animal V animal, were a common feature. Less common, but not infrequent was the release of wild beasts from the pits into the arena where hundreds of criminals had earlier been positioned. These spectacles all deeming to be very entertaining to spectators.Throughout the history of the Republic, there was a difference between the gladiatorial contests and other

Similar Essays

Factory Farming And Animal Cruelty Essay

599 words - 2 pages Factory Farming and Animal Cruelty Animal rights are practically non-existent in many different ways today. Factory farming is probably the worst thing they can do to the poor helpless animals. Factory farming effects chickens, cows, pigs, and many other animals that are used for food, milk and eggs. One of the biggest organizations against factory farming is called Compassion Over Killing (COK). They go to great lengths to protest and inform

Animal Cruelty On Farms Essay

1037 words - 4 pages It is so easy to become complacent in our sheltered world and to turn the other cheek to the violence and misery that our every life decision can perpetrate, and that the majority of the country (mostly unknowingly) buys into. The fact is that if the horrors of the meat industry were common knowledge, the business would decrease, and drastically at that. So, to keep the knowledge from becoming widespread, meat and animal factory farms are

The Consequences Of Factory Farms And Animal Product Production

1702 words - 7 pages In American society today, animal consumption has become a primary source of food in everyday, family life. It is common to have meat on the table two to three meals a day, but the problem with this is the demand for meat and dairy products has increased greatly, creating a need for faster production. Factory farms, also known as confined animal feeding operations (CAFOS,) have been the solution created by the food industry to meet the demands

Animal Cruelty And Treatment Essay

2481 words - 10 pages . The way they make a profit is by altering or “enhancing” the animals to make them produce more of a certain commodity than in natural processes ("PETA People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals."). Animals in these factory farms are highly susceptible to diseases and illnesses caused from lack of fresh air and close, compact living spaces. In these conditions, it immensely increases mental, emotional, and physical stress on the animal