Fair Tax Essay

2316 words - 10 pages

PA 8720 - “Fair Tax” Policy Analysis

John Maynard Keynes stated that “the avoidance of taxes is the only intellectual pursuit that carries any reward,” (Waters, 2011). In Missouri, while seeking to avoid an income tax, advocates for the “Fair Tax” have seemingly presented a proposal that is the antithesis of the pursuit Keynes deems worthy. They are proposing a constitutional amendment that would impose a sales tax that no Missourian could avoid. The “Fair Tax” would cost everyone, no matter their income level and even have its greatest impact on the most vulnerable among us. Even as a tax of this type would expand the tax base, the repercussions to the taxpayers, the state budget, and the state economy would present hurdles too high to conquer.
Missourians are facing a tough fiscal environment. They are enduring a slow economic recovery and attempting to overcome a nearly six percent rate of unemployment (DLIR, 2013). If a “Fair Tax” is implemented during this time of fiscal uncertainty, Missouri will be at risk of losing up to $1.5 billion in revenue while increasing its operating costs by $12.8 million (Schweich, 2011). It will also leave Missourians at risk of a reduction in personal funds available for expenditures and could cause a loss in state services.
According to a report released by the Missouri Budget Project ("Four new “mega," 2011), Missouri could suffer a $2.5 billion shortfall if the constitutional amendment were to pass. Totaling roughly one-third of the state’s general revenue, funding to governmental departments and the critical services they provide would be slashed significantly. The report suggests that funding could be cut by the following: $868 million for public schools, $465.5 million for social services and Medicaid, and $291 million for higher education. Departments that support public safety and prisons could lose up to $272 million, and programs for seniors stand to lose $263 million.
A study funded by Missourians Against Higher Taxes found that in order to compensate for the shortfall solely through a sales tax, it would need to be at the rate of twelve percent (Garrison, 2011). The initiative petition however, caps the state sales tax at seven percent ("Constitutional amendment to," 2012); leaving no mechanism for recovering such a substantial loss in revenue. James Moody, a former budget director, called the proposal “fiscally untenable,” stating that it would “either bankrupt the state, or in the alternative, bankrupt the poor and working lower and middle income classes.” (Moody, 2011).
This dilemma is furthered when exemptions are taken into account. Just as Irene Rubin noted in The Politics of Public Budgeting (2010), “as the burden on a group increases, the demand for exceptions for that group is likely to increase.” Moody applies this notion to the “Fair Tax” when stating that “the simple math is that exemptions from taxation lower the taxable base,” and that “the more tax exemptions assumed, the lower...

Find Another Essay On Fair Tax

Flat Tax System Essay

2264 words - 9 pages : true flat rate income tax, Marginal, and flat taxes with limited deductions. True flat tax is a simple tax rate with no deductions or exceptions. Marginal flat tax is a flat tax with deductions allowed. Flat tax with limited deductions allows deductions on certain items including charitable deductions and home mortgage interest. Here we’ll look at the true flat tax rate and the positive influence that comes with it. Flat tax will make taxes fair

The main differences between Tax Audit and Tax Investigation in Malaysia.

1152 words - 5 pages the taxpayer is selected for field audit, the taxpayer is usually given between 2 to 4 weeks notice to prepare some documents ready for audit. Otherwise, the taxpayer can extend the notice through written request. The purpose of tax audit is to determine a true and fair view of the business records. The audit officer is responsible to ensure that the reported amount is correct and the amount of tax that paid is correct accordance with tax laws and

Flat Tax

2183 words - 9 pages : true flat rate income tax, Marginal, and flat taxes with limited deductions. True flat tax is a simple tax rate with no deductions or exceptions. Marginal flat tax is a flat tax with deductions allowed. Flat tax with limited deductions allows deductions on certain items including charitable deductions and home mortgage interest. Here we’ll look at the true flat tax rate and the positive influence that comes with it. Flat tax will make taxes fair

Comparing and Contrasting United States and International Tax Systems

1040 words - 4 pages citizens. A marginal tax system, which the United States uses, places taxpayers into brackets by income. The percentage of income taxed raises in each bracket.The way a government taxes its people is often definitive of the way that government operates. Many people feel very strongly that one system or another is the ethical or fair way to collect taxes. Each system certainly presents fairness in at least some way. At the same time, every tax

Professional Challenges in Computing

2073 words - 8 pages According to the Wired.com - Google and Amazon have been blamed of hiding their UK-based activities to no paying fair tax. Chairwoman of the public accounts committee, MP Margaret Hodges on 16 may 2013 said to google: ‘You do do eveil’ when it comes to tax. Google has hidden their UK actions and not paying actual amount in tax. Google has purposely manipulate the realism of their business and handover the false evidence detailing Google UK

tax system

695 words - 3 pages INTRODUCTION As the supreme ruler of my own country, I need to raise $60,000 in taxes from three households. It is necessary to design a fair and effective tax system to raise money based on their family and income conditions. Next, I will explain the criteria and key design elements of the tax system in my country. Last, I will compare the designed tax system with the U.S. tax system. System Criteria The tax system in our country is based on

Tax as a Means of Control and Stimulator of the Economy in the Uk. Is it a Good Idea to Fluctuate the Tax Rates for Stabilizing the Economy? Is Tax Necessary for a Country’s Growth? Is Green Tax ...

9199 words - 37 pages . For this reason some people find tax to be fair and others object it as unfair.This paper carries a research regarding the equity or fairness of tax and its controlling power and stimulating effect on the economy. The research focuses on certain aspects of UK taxation and clearly illustrates how tax could ideally be used by the government as a tool for control. The paper analyses other's findings on fairness of tax, effects of green tax, tax

The Variable Rate Income Tax: Flat Tax

2192 words - 9 pages income tax, the middle and lower class Americans will continue to pay more than their fair share in taxes and the upper class will continue to pay well below their fair share. This will create a bigger gap between the classes. This is such an important issue to me because I come from a middle class American family that would like to pay less in taxes, and I believe in equality for all. The underlying problem of this issue is that Congress

Progressive Taxation System vs. Flat Taxation System

1076 words - 5 pages than one with a low income (“Progressive Taxation System”). This taxation system was created to collect a greater proportion of tax revenue from wealthy people reflecting the “ability-to-pay” principle. Regardless of which tax system a society or country chooses, the government benefits from it. It is to be said that both taxation systems could be considered fair in their own way, with both having their advantages (Nunes). Progressive taxation

The United States Should Not Impose a Flat Tax

1569 words - 7 pages /first-we-must-adopt-a-flat-tax-then-need-to-return-to-the-gold-standard/>. Mcgrath, Jane. "HowStuffWorks "Flat Tax vs. FairTax"" Howstuffworks.com. How Stuff Works, n.d. Web. 19 May 2014. . "THE NEW FLAT TAX: Encourages Growth and Job Creation." Heritage.org. The Heritage Foundation, 19 Jan. 2012. Web. 19 May 2014.

A Flattened Income Tax

2874 words - 11 pages producers (Merino 145). The flat tax is fairer for the general population than the current tax system. A flat tax would change many different aspects of the tax system in order to make it fair for all citizens. Businesses are changed the most with the flat tax system (Cobb 3). First, businesses are granted deductions only in costs paid to other taxpayers (Cobb 3). In addition, employers are no longer able to make tax-deductable payments on

Similar Essays

Fair Tax Essay

802 words - 3 pages Federal Income Tax Vs. The Fair Tax PlanThere is a plan being passed around the United States Congress called the Fair Tax plan. It is a plan that would help the United States government a great deal. The federal government taxes on our earnings. The IRS takes approximately fifteen to thirty-nine percent out of every registered person's paycheck (fairtax.org). This kind of taxing started in 1913. Before this our country taxed its people on

Fair Tax For Americans Essay

1233 words - 5 pages Fair Tax PAGE 2 Fair Tax for AmericansRussell DeSalvoCOMM105Instructor: Geraldine SmithJanuary 10, 2008Fair Tax for AmericansOur tax system today is one reason American citizens are finding it so hard to get ahead. The Fair Tax system would help all groups of Americans from rich to poor and make yearly household income non-essential at the end of the year when the time comes to calculate income tax. The current income tax system punishes

Encouraging Economic Growth With The Fair Tax Act

1805 words - 7 pages real tax reform. Proposals such as the Flat Tax, the Fair Tax, and the Value Added Tax where hotly debated during the 2008 political campaign cycle. Now they seem all but forgotten. Any drastic tax reform might be preferable to the status quo, but the Fair Tax is by far the most promising. The Fair Tax Act, a proposal to replace all existing federal taxes with a national sales tax, would spur the economic growth which we so desperately need. The

Taxation System In Bhutan. Good Or Bad?

1693 words - 7 pages achieve current state of Taxation System. The taxation generates huge revenue for the country which finds use in state’s expenditures or depositing in the Consolidated Fund. 2. Taxation system of Bhutan The preambles of tax acts of Bhutan focus to promote social justice, general welfare and the adoption of a tax system that is fair, uniform, equitable, efficient, and just, thereby securing equal distribution of wealth, financial sustainability