This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Fall Term Essay 2

1466 words - 6 pages

1Fall Term Essay Question Two:"Do you think that the EDS pilot Barton did to Marilyn what he ought to have done - given the situation? Do you think that Narveson is able to morally justify his position with regard to what becomes of Marilyn using the principle of utility? What changes does Narveson make to Godwin's story "Cold Equations" to help convince you of the merits of his ethical position? Are they successful? What changes to Godwin's story would you make before you could reasonably argue that Marilyn's life should in fact be spared by the EDS pilot? Justify"Seanna ThompsonStudent ID: 5159298PHIL 1F90Seminar 20Turnitin Paper ID: 365445620The story, "The Cold Equations", written by Tom Godwin may cause one to question and examine the idea of human rights along with the exceptions that may follow. "The Cold Equations" takes place in a futuristic setting where an EDS pilot referred to as Barton is travelling through the galaxy. This mission is an attempt to bring life saving medical supplies to six ill men on time who will otherwise die a painful death. During this trip Barton becomes aware of another body on board the ship and upon further investigation he discovers it is a young teenage girl by the name of Marilyn. She was hiding in the supply closet in hopes of reaching her older brother who is on Woden; the same planet as the ill men. Unfortunately, the ship they are on only has enough fuel to carry just the weight of itself and the pilot to Woden and land safely. Therefore, it is law that any stowaway in an Emergency Dispatch Ship must be jettisoned in order to avoid compromising a mission. Any difference in weight such as an extra body will cause the ship to burn too much fuel and eventually crash and kill both the pilot and Marilyn. Usually this law applies to stowaways with bad intentions or illegal purposes but since this one is an innocent girl, human and moral rights are brought into question. Should the law still be applied despite the girl's ignorance and innocence in order to help the greater good? Jan Narveson discusses this in a commentary about Godwin's story as well as multiple variations of what could have happened. Given the situation the pilot did the right thing, as there were no other options for him. This decision was morally just despite attempts at changing the story; however, in order to spare the girl the pilot would need to sacrifice himself.Laws are often considered to be black and white as there are right and wrong options in every day decisions that are made based on this. However, there are grey areas, which are highlighted in this story. Once Marilyn is discovered two options become clear to Barton: he can either proceed as he is expected and sacrifice the girl, or he can keep her inside the ship where they will both meet their deaths, perhaps within a few hours or days. Barton eventually helps Marilyn to see that her sacrifice truly is the right thing to do and she allows herself to be jettisoned from the...

Find Another Essay On Fall Term Essay 2

Saggag Essay

556 words - 2 pages - 24k - Cached - Similar pages Welcome to My Term! Need a free paper? We have ...... here ironing, 1427. I Stand Here Ironing Literary interpretation, 1090. ... Iago's Plague, 1687. Ibsen, 656. Ibsens' A Dolls House, 634. ... 776. In the Skin of A Lion Essay, 1124. - 14k - Cached - Similar pages theatre studies ... Theatre

Financial Analysis of Matalan and House of Fraser

2501 words - 10 pages . It is at this point that I would like to mention about the share price and broker sentiments it is to be noted at this point that the share price of house of fraser have been more or less consistent and that of Matalan have been a rise and fall. it is also to be noted that 9 of the brokers out of 13 for house of Fraser suggest the shareholders to buy more shares and only 2 suggest to sell. In the case of Matalan out of 16 brokers only 3 say

A Reflection about Eve and Adam

602 words - 2 pages rather than a demand by Adam. She extracts Genesis 2:18, in which God concludes that Adam needs a “helper fit for him.” The focus being on the phrase “helper” (“ezer” in Hebrew). Trible points out that the term “ezer” is a relational one expressing a beneficial connection and not one of inferiority. While the animals conceived by God can be seen to be in a beneficial connection with Adam, they are of inferior rank and this inferiority is


917 words - 4 pages . Many people think that riding a horse is quite hard, when in ... 2 pages 31 Feb/2005 0.0 WriteWork About Privacy Terms of Use Twitter Contact Short-cuts Help Browse Essays Top 10 Lists Book Notes Sitemap Research Book Reports Compare & Contrast Essays Essay Examples Persuasive Essays Term Papers Research Paper Topics WRITING GUIDES How to write a book report How to write a research paper How to write an essay ©

learner journal

784 words - 3 pages Learner Journal 1This week, we have learnt arguments and discussion. Before the university studies, I have done essay regarding argument e.g. 2-sided argumentative essay. But all the argumentative words I use is very narrow range and sometimes makes the essay becomes repetitive and no academic. After attending the lesson about arguments and discussion, my essay is now more planned and organized with a wider range of words. This also helped me a


1201 words - 5 pages Formalism In this essay I will show that whilst formalism is an attractive view it does not provide us with an adequate account of mathematics. I will begin with a brief outline of the basic position before going on to discuss it. Finally, I will discuss Hilbert’s programme. In brief, formalism is the view that mathematics is the study of formal systems. This however does not tell the whole story and formalism can be divided into term

A Critical Essay on Edgar Allan Poe’s The Fall of the House of Usher (1839)

1255 words - 5 pages The twenty first century author Alexandra Iftodi Zamfir (1986- ) argues that “architecture and settings are more important in Gothic fiction than in any other type of literature…all architectural elements are closely connected with Gothic protagonists and the plot.” (Zamfir. 2011: 15). This critical essay will first consider and analyse this statement and investigate the style, language and form of the American author Edgar Allan Poe’s (1809


1079 words - 4 pages How To Write A History EssayStart listing the main causes for long term and short termP1 Short Term/GoodP2 Long Term/BadP3 Comparison of the two points (i.e. Pro's Con's)And then conclude, either choosing a side or stating the significant long term causeTips For Extra MarksWrite ReferencesThe Vital First ParagraphEvery part of an essay is important, but the first paragraph is vital. This is the first chance you have to impress - or depress - an

Politics & The English Language-By George Orwell

530 words - 2 pages Dylan BaurMrs. PassarellaAP LangJanuary 27 2014Politics and the English Language: Questions on Rhetoric and Style1: Orwell's thesis is somewhat stated, but also implied. His thesis is that any effect can become a cause, such that something that starts as an aid for a different ailment may eventually become detrimental.2: Orwell's analogy of the cause and effect of alcohol abuse to the demise of lanuage in paragraph two is very effective. It


4431 words - 18 pages EssaysEssay ExamplesPersuasive EssaysTerm PapersResearch Paper TopicsWRITING GUIDES
How to write a book reportHow to write a research paperHow to write an essay© w contribute with an essayWe only accept essays with at least 2 pages of text (500+ words) and with a bibliographyEssay titleInclude the title, as well as any questions your teacher specified to you when you got this assignment. If this is a book report, include its

The notion of capital

588 words - 2 pages : 567Top 100 Essay Sites-Top 50 Essay SitesTop 25 Essay SitesQuick Links: 1. 3. Free-Essays-Free-Essays.com4. Essays.cc5. Free-TermPapers.com6. WowEssays.com7. 9. Free-ResearchPapers.com10. Free-TermPapers.comCan`t find essay here? Order custom written term paper. We offer highquality and quick writing for only $12.95 per page!

Similar Essays

Wilfred Owen – Term 2 Essay

2033 words - 9 pages Wilfred Owen – Term 2 Essay ‘Owen struggled with religion throughout his life’. How are these struggles shown in the two poems that we have studied? In Wilfred Owen’s poem, ‘The Unreturning’, the audience is concerned with Owen’s perspective of the nature of death. Catholicism was a faith that Owen struggled to have faith in; his philosophy in ‘life after death’ was part of his life long plea to find truth in religion. ‘Maundy Thursday’ uses

Things Fall Apart Thesis Statements And Essay Topics

602 words - 2 pages works or find ways Okonkwo has good intentions but because of his flaws (pride, anger, etc) cannot see a positive resolution to his troubles. For more assistance with this topic, check out this article on the tragic nature of Okonkwo compared to another tragic character from literature, Oedipus. Thesis Statement / Essay Topic #2: The Importance of Customs and Traditions in "Things Fall Apart" Throughout "Things Fall Apart by Chinua Achebe, the

Gatsby Essay

2354 words - 9 pages Locke's 1690 An Essay Concerning Human Understanding .An essay has been defined in a variety of ways. One definition is a "prose composition with a focused subject of discussion" or a "long, systematic discourse".[1] It is difficult to define the genre into which essays fall. Aldous Huxley, a leading essayist, gives guidance on the subject.[2] He notes that "the essay is a literary device for saying almost everything about almost anything", and

Creative Essays Creative Essays Offers A Large Amount Of Free

516 words - 2 pages . 6 9 10 000 Free Term Papers 100% Free Term Papers & Easy To use Search Engine 5 10 EssayCity - Free Essays Why Pay why you can Get it Free, over 50000 essays 4 11 TheProcess.Tv Essay Zone Top Site Directory With Essays, Reports & More! 2 12 Ryan's Free Essays and Termpapers 10000+ Free Essays and Termpapers, Custom Writings, Free Easy Search Options 2 13 UPDATABASE.COM - United Paper Database (5,000+ papers) Why search 173 different