Fallacies In The Newspaper

1856 words - 7 pages

The effective use of rhetoric can spur people into action for worthy causes, bring about positive health changes, and even persuade one to finish a college education. In contrast, like most things in life, what can be used for good can also be used in a negative way to elicit emotions such as outrage, fear, and panic. This type of rhetoric often uses fallacious statements in an appeal to emotion which complicates the matter even more as the emotions are misdirected. Unfortunately, the daily newspapers are filled with numerous examples of fallacious statements. Within the past week, the following five examples appeared in the New York Times and USA Today. The examples included statements that demonstrated scapegoating, slippery slope, ad hominem, straw man, line-drawing, arguments from outrage, and arguments from envy.

The first example, in an article about the current condition of income and wealth in the United States, the author stated that the fact that Americans are earning less and worth less than four years ago was started by the “financial crisis and the sharp decline in the value of homes, the principal asset of Americans, followed by the sharp drop in the stock prices. The crisis led to stubbornly high unemployment that cut income for many Americans and made wage increases harder to obtain for those who did hold on to their jobs” (Norris, 2012). The drop in housing prices is used as a scapegoating technique for the general financial condition of Americans. Scapegoating is a technique that places blame on a specific group for a certain circumstance (Moore & Parker, 2012, p. 187). By placing blame on the housing industry, Norris attempts to demonstrate that the American public is largely experiencing financial woes due to the drop in housing prices.

While it is true that housing prices did decline sharply between 2006 and 2010, the article does not provide the full picture. By ignoring the years prior to 2006, the author limits the perspective of the reader. When one reviews the full ten year period from 2000 through 2010, the data shows that there was a substantial increase in housing prices from 2000 through 2006, with some states showing increases of up to 120% over that timeframe (Mulbrandon, 2012). Though there was a decrease over the next four years, the full ten year period resulted in moderate increases over that time period in every state except Michigan. In reality, what happened between 2000 and 2006 was that too many Americans got caught up in a buying frenzy, believing that housing prices would not go down, overextended their mortgage beyond what they could afford, and then suffered when the housing bubble burst. This brought many negative consequences as a result of consumers not using their own critical thinking skills.

The second article reviewed provided an example of a slippery slope argument combined with a scare tactic. The article title
was “Prescription drug overdoses plague New Mexico”...

Find Another Essay On Fallacies in the Newspaper

Health care using two basic models: Biosocial and biomedical. It uses marijuana as the main focus point in the discussion and has reference to some newspaper articles

1630 words - 7 pages There are two basic models that can be used to help outline health care. These models are biosocial and biomedical. I will examine and critique these two models through the use of mainstream newspaper articles. Many people have a wide range of opinions on this matter but the area I wish to examine is how the press represents health care issues in terms of these two models.The articles I have chosen for the biosocial model help portray what

Rhetorical and Fallacies in the Article “The Media Violence Myth” by Richard Rhodes

1410 words - 6 pages In 2000, Pulitzer-winning journalist Richard Rhodes published an article titled “The Media Violence Myth,” through the “American Booksellers Foundation for Free Expression,” a liberal establishment dedicated to the protection of the First Amendment right to free speech. Despite coming from a background plagued with violence and abuse, Rhodes has studied nuclear history and weapons use for over 20 years and has developed a unique opinion about

A newspaper-style article describing the end of the Boer war, ending in British victory.

706 words - 3 pages May 1902--The pent up tensions between British in Afrikaner states and the Afrikaners themselves had finally broken. The British gold prospectors moving in on Boer land, and the Boer's mistreatment of the British became too much for both sides and in 1899, the Boer's declared war. A little history of the relationship between these settlers is due.The British claimed the Cape of Good Hope in 1806. Called the "Great Trek", the Afrikaners settled

This essay is about the upcoming war against Iraq. In the essay, I analyze President George W. Bush's fallacies in explaining his urge for war.

1316 words - 5 pages Yesterday night, I was in a fierce dispute with my American friends about a war against Iraq. They advocated for the war as they pointed out some "good old reasons" about Iraq being a haven for Al-Quaeda as well as many other terrorist association or the Nuclear-Biological capacity of Hussein. Mostly, they support President Bush's "evil triangle" theory. Some even went as far as they stated that the notorious Chamberlain-Hitler scenario will

Cinema review in the form of newspaper article/essay, of Alfred Hitchcock's Rear Window, so personal opinion is included.

680 words - 3 pages regularly starts before the 8:30pm film. Despite Rear Window being only the Hitchcock film I had seen, after Marnie, I thought I knew what to expect.The first characters we are introduced to are the tenants living in the block of apartments of Greenwich Village. Though they remain nameless except for labels such as "Miss Torso" and "Miss Lonely-hearts", these are people we recognise as part of our own lives. Then, there is L.B Jeffries, played by

Fallacy Summary and Application Paper - UOP CSS/330 Required Paper

1124 words - 4 pages Fallacy Summary and Application PaperFallacies by definition are a false or mistaken idea's, or an often-plausible argument using false or invalid inference. There are two types of fallacies discussed in this paper. Logical fallacies of relevance are fallacies that occur because the premises are logically irrelevant to the conclusion. Logical fallacies of insufficient evidence are fallacies that occur because the premises, though logically

Fallacy Summary and Application

975 words - 4 pages "Logic is not everything. But it is something--something which can be taught, something which can be learned, something which can help us in some degree to think more sensibly about the dangerous world in which we live" (Fischer, 1970, p 306). This statement sums up why it is important to study the logical fallacies and why the fallacies are important to critical thinking and decision-making. Therefore, the following describes why knowing the

Fallacy Summary and Application MGT 350 - Critical Thinking: Strategies in Decision-Making July 16, 2005

1358 words - 5 pages Fallacy Summary and Application Paper Fallacy: defined by Merriam-Webster as "deceptive appearance" or "false or mistaken idea". Fallacies are everywhere in the media, workplace, and even the home. Fallacies contain relevance, premises, arguments, and factual errors. In business today, it is important to be able to identify fallacies or organizational profitability could be adversely affected. This paper will define three fallacies

Summary and Application

1237 words - 5 pages Fallacy is defined as "deceptive appearance" or "false or mistaken idea". Fallacies are everywhere in the media, workplace, and even the home. Fallacies contain relevance, premises, arguments, and factual errors. In business today, it is important to be able to identify fallacies or organizational profitability could be adversely affected. This paper will define three fallacies, explain their significance to critical thinking, discuss the

Fallacy Summary and Application

1084 words - 4 pages knowing how to identify them prevents us from falling victim to their deceit. To do so would cause our thinking to be unreasonable and inhibit good decision-making or problem solving skills. "The first step towards developing critical thinking is to learn and apply the rules of logic, in particular, to uncover the logical fallacies." (Linda B. Nilson, 1997) The logical fallacies defined in this paper fall into two categories: fallacies of

Doomsday: The Rebuttal

967 words - 4 pages The world has to end because it began. How the world will end has been the center of heated discussions. The topic of Doomsday has produced conferences, meetings, movies and books attempting to prophesy the end of age. With the emergence of Doomsday prophets have also emerged fallacies that preach propaganda to audiences of those seeking immunity from one sole apocalyptic day. One author in particular is Ronald Bailey. According to

Similar Essays

The Impact Of Logical Fallacies In Critical Thinking

740 words - 3 pages According to (Bassham 1), critical thinking is disciplined thinking governed by clear intellectual standards. The standards, as defined by (Bassham 1-2), are clarity, precision, accuracy, relevance, consistency, logical correctness, completeness, and fairness. In order to achieve a conclusion that encompasses all of the intellectual standards, the critical thinker must have the ability to identify and evaluate logical fallacies in arguments

Analysis Of A Story In The Newspaper

1824 words - 7 pages considerable amount of people rely on one of the traditional news media – newspaper. Facing the competition, the way news reported may change as newspapers ‘need to maintain large circulation figures to stay profitable’ (Bignell 1997:83). This directly affects how news is presented. To make news appeal to readers, information may under ‘design’ as mentioned by Thorne (2008), the function of newspapers in the 21st century is not only

Comparing The Length Of Words In A Broadsheet Newspaper And Tabloid Newspaper

1272 words - 5 pages Comparing the Length of Words in a Broadsheet Newspaper and Tabloid Newspaper I am now going to start my mathematics statistics coursework. The aim of this coursework is to compare the length of words in a broadsheet newspaper to the length of words in a tabloid newspaper. My first hypothesis is that in this investigation the broadsheet newspaper should contain longer words than the tabloid newspaper. I think this

The Image Of Persons With Disabilities As Portrayed In A Newspaper

3873 words - 15 pages The newspaper dailies, have the ability to link persons with disability to the world. Still, no research has been found specifically on persons with disabilities and their portrayal in the newspaper daily in India. Many studies have focused on the more general topic of disabilities in the news (Mick 1996; Power 2006; Haller, Dorries, and Rahn 2006). Person with disabilities are also part of the society. The newspaper dailies depict the persons