This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

False Picture Of Marriage In The Dead By James Joyce And Odour Of Chrysanthemums By D.H. Lawrence

1207 words - 5 pages

Illusion versus Reality: Marriage in Modern Literature
Modern literature is known for questioning society and its various conventions. One question that these works often ask is, “What is real?” Some modern authors explore this question by placing their characters within self-constructed illusions that are later shattered by the introduction of reality. Marriages are frequently at the center of this theme, with one spouse crafting an illusory impression of the other. Modern literature demonstrates that a marriage built upon illusion will falter when exposed to reality.
In order to understand the effects of illusion on marriages in modern literature, we will explore two pieces: The Dead by James Joyce and Odour of Chrysanthemums by D.H. Lawrence. Both stories have central characters who have created, and lived with, a false picture of their spouse and their marriage. Firstly, I will discuss Elizabeth Bates’ negative, villainizing view of her husband in Odour of Chrysanthemums. Secondly, I will provide a contrast to that negative illusion with Joyce’s character Gabriel Conroy, who has painted a positive, idealized picture of his wife and their affection for one another.
Elizabeth Bates is an unhappy woman, particularly with regards to her husband’s drinking habits. She bitterly thinks to herself, “…he had probably gone past his home, slunk past his own door, to drink before he came in, while his dinner spoiled and wasted in waiting” (Lawrence 2247). While her husband has been brought home drunk before (2249), she has no evidence of that being the case on this particular day. This assumption is at the heart of Elizabeth’s illusion. Instead of being worried for her husband’s safety, she chooses to believe that he has no regard for his wife waiting at home. However, Elizabeth has not always been so resentful of her husband and their marriage.
Lawrence intimates that Elizabeth was once happy with her husband, particularly through the representation of chrysanthemums. When Elizabeth comes upon a patch of pink chrysanthemums, she becomes “suddenly pitiful” and picks the flowers, holds them to her face, and tucks them into her apron (2246). Later, we learn that her husband gave Elizabeth chrysanthemums on special occasions (2249). Unfortunately, Elizabeth’s bitterness toward her husband taints the joy she associated with the flowers. She later calls the flowers “nonsense,” removes them from her apron, and turns away—just as she has turned away from her husband.
While Elizabeth’s illusion has eroded most of the positive feelings she held for her husband, there is some spark of that former affection still left. When she believes her husband will be coming home ill, her thoughts briefly turn to a hopeful imagining: “[P]erhaps she’d be able to get him away from the drink and his hateful ways…The tears offered to come to her eyes at the picture…” (2253). Unfortunately, Elizabeth’s illusion of her husband as nothing more than a selfish drunkard clouds her...

Find Another Essay On False Picture of Marriage in The Dead by James Joyce and Odour of Chrysanthemums by D.H. Lawrence

The Upper Class of Society in The Dead by James Joyce

1706 words - 7 pages The Upper Class of Society in The Dead by James Joyce The novella "The Dead" by James Joyce tells the tale of early twentieth century upper class society in the Irish city of Dublin. The story tells of the characters' entrapment, and the tragic lives they lead, hiding behind the conventions of their society. Joyce uses the symbolism to draw a parallel between the natural way in which the snow covers the land and the way in which the

Comparison and Contrast "You Touched Me" D.H. Lawrence and "The Boarding House" from James Joyce

1153 words - 5 pages gradually alters, most people comply with it either for self mentality pursuit or public reputation. In the early twentieth century, public took the ethicality and morality very seriously, and this arose contradictions with human's free will and instinct for self benefit. "You Touched Me" from D.H. Lawrence and "The Boarding House" from James Joyce each tells a story that ends with one controversial marriage in the conservative Europe. By comparing

James Joyce "The Dead"

5257 words - 21 pages Thesis: In James Joyce's pluralistic short story, "The Dead", Gabriel Conroy is dragged westward by the same nets as Stephen Deadalus (those of family, religion and politics), and at the end of the story he is not reborn but rather accepts the transition to the world of shadows.Joyce thought the present as the only legitimate frame of mind. The stream of consciousness writing style is the vehicle he invented to convey the importance of the

James Joyce The Dead - Effect From Beyond the Grave

750 words - 3 pages It is known that many times people have their greatest effect on the living after they have passed away. In the story The Dead, by James Joyce, it is clearly seen that Michael Furey, has his greatest effect on Gretta from beyond the grave. Death shows man's greatest flaw and when people have a close brush with it, they are forced to come to the reality that they, too, will someday die. The realization that death is approaching yields decisions

Analysis of "the piano" by D.H. Lawrence

702 words - 3 pages Analysis of "Piano"The speaker in "Piano" by D. H. Lawrence is proud to be a full grown man, yet he loves remembering his happy childhood; his nostalgic attitude causes him to feel guilty as if he had betrayed his present state of being. Through effective imagery, Lawrence is able (to describe an image) to help the reader understand the speaker's nostalgic attitude. The diction and tone used in this poem reveal the speaker's struggle as his

Review of Snake by D.H. Lawrence

2342 words - 9 pages Review of Snake by D.H. Lawrence Vocabualry: *Carob-tree: a red flowered tree originally in the Mediterranean area. * pitcher : tall, round container with an open top and large handle. * flickered: moved * mused : think about * bowel: bottom of earth * perversity: offensive * log: tree trunk * clatter: v. loud sound of hard things hitting * convulsed : violent movement * writhed

Women Roles in "The Story of an Hour" by Kate Chopin and "Eveline" by James Joyce

1389 words - 6 pages The Story of an Hour by Kate Chopin and Eveline by James Joyce are the two short stories that will be analyzed using feminist criticism in this essay. Both short stories share a lot in common about what the role of women’s was perceived within the time they were written. In the story The Story of an Hour Mrs. Louise Mallard was told that her husband’s had died from a tragic accident in a railroad and when she finally became at peace with her

The Traditional British Character as Made New by D.H. Lawrence in "Daughters of the Vicar"

1697 words - 7 pages figures with no personality flaws, of immeasurable virtue and revered by all and sundry, yet D.H. Lawrence's characters do not meet this criterion whatsoever.In the short story, "Daughters of the Vicar," Lawrence presents us with what appears to be a traditional English character - the vicar - a religious figure that is both supported by and yet remains above the community at large. Traditionally a vicar is an educated man, often a second or third

Odour of Chrysanthemums: observations

564 words - 2 pages Odour of Chrysanthemums: observations ‘‘Odour of Chrysanthemums’’ was written between the end of the Victorian period in 1901, and the beginning of World War I in 1914. It was a time when England was still a powerful international force, and the head of a huge empire that extended from India to Nigeria, which demonstrated England’s political power and also provided a vast market for its manufactured goods. During the nineteenth century

The Conflict of Intercultural Values in Stories by William Faulkner and James Joyce

2190 words - 9 pages Southern life to Joyce’s in that traditional values and modern values clash as times change in early 20th century Dublin. In conclusion, this literary study has analyzed the intercultural conflict of traditionalist and modern values that are found within “ A Rose for Emily” by William Faulkner and “The Dead” by James Joyce. Faulkner and Joyce use family as a foundation for comparing Emily and Gabriel’s struggle to adapt to the modernist values

Comparison of "Thistles" by Ted Hughes and "Mountain Lion" by D.H Lawrence

1446 words - 6 pages successful in showing how man is linked to, and a part of, nature. The tone of "Thistles" is more reflective and a statement of 'what is', "Mountain Lion", by D.H Lawrence, however, has a distinctive negative mood as the poet shows the link of man to nature as domineering and destructive to the latter party. Although the simplistic and often negative diction of "Mountain lion" plays an effective part in conveying the theme of the piece, in

Similar Essays

The Method Of Characterisation In D.H. Lawrence, "Odour Of Chrysanthemums" (Norton Anthology, 2316 2330)

1359 words - 5 pages The characters in this story can be studied in their relationship to one another. It is in the attitudes of Elisabeth, Walter, Walter's mother and the children that their thoughts on each other become clear. The most important symbol in this story, the chrysanthemums, also refers to the bond between the two main characters, Elisabeth and her husband Walter.This story is rather predicable because of the indication to the chrysanthemums in the

The Withered Arm By Thomas Hardy And Odour Of Chrysanthemums By Dh Lawrence

3149 words - 13 pages Farmer Lodge, it was her unwanted son that was hung. Gertrude and Farmer Lodge both die also. D.H. Lawrence wrote “Odour of Chrysanthemums” which is about a lonely woman named Elizabeth Bates. In this story Elisabeth feels trapped in her marriage as her husband, Walter Bates is always out either working down the mines or drinking whilst she is left looking after their two young children. One day when Walter does not return home, she

D.H. Lawrence's Use Of Language In Odour Of Chrysanthemums

699 words - 3 pages Write a study of the opening of D.H. Lawrence’s short story Odour of Chrysanthemums. Comment in detail on the way in which Lawrence’s use of language creates a particular atmosphere and raises certain expectations. The opening of ‘Odour of Chrysanthemums’ tells us about the domination of industry over nature. It presents nature at its worst and the dominance of technology, symbolized by the engine. The focus of the story is on the

"The Dead" By James Joyce Essay

1298 words - 5 pages into that other world, in full glory of some passion, than fade and wither dismally with age" (Broadview 116), it is too late for these Markans' party attendees, for everyone is already dead.Works CitedAnspaugh, Kelly. ""Three mortal hour/i~s": female Gothic in Joyce's "The Dead." - James Joyce". Studies in Short Fiction. Wntr 1994. 02 Apr. 2007. Joyce, James. "The Dead." Broadview Anthology of Short Fiction. Ed. Julia Gaunce and Suzette Mayr. Toronto, ON: Broadview Press, 2004. 89-116.Mepham, John. "Stream of Consciousness." The Literary Encyclopedia. 17 Oct. 2003. The Literary Dictionary Company. 2 April 2007.