This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

False Memories In The Courtroom Essay

2292 words - 9 pages

Imagine spending twenty-four years in prison for a crime you did not commit. Furthermore, imagine that conviction is based on witness testimony and no valid forensic evidence. This is the case for Texas resident Steven Phillips and countless others whose unfortunate circumstances stem from the fallacious nature of human memory. Phillips was wrongly convicted in 1982 based on a few of the many inadequacies of human memory (“Know the Cases”). Unfortunately, this is an all-too-common occurrence due to the high malleability of episodic memory.

In episodic memory, sequences and events are encoded; it is how we remember (or misremember) our lives. It is much more subject to erosion, interference, or suggestion than simple factual memory is. There are many psychological phenomena that interfere with the accuracy of memory, which can cause problems if an altered memory is needed. Specifically in the court of law, accurate memory is immensely important. The fact is, many eyewitnesses do not correctly remember details of the incident in question, and it happens as a result of many different processes.

Why should you care? Well, for one thing, no one wants to be wrongly accused or convicted of a crime he did not commit. As Constitutional-law abiders, we rely on the right to fair trial and the right to have an unbiased jury make judgments on evidence and testimony. It is in all of our best interests, then, to raise awareness of the fallibility of human memory so that if we are ever placed in a situation like Steven Phillips’s, we are not punished due to the mistakes of another. Still not convinced? Look at the other side. Again, as citizens under the Constitution, we must all serve as jurors at some point in our lives. How would you feel if you helped convict a man based on an eyewitness testimony, and twenty-four years down the road you find out that new DNA evidence exonerated him? It is safe to say no one wants that kind of guilt on his conscience. For these reasons it is pertinent to examine memory, its fallibility, and its role in the courtroom.

Before diving into specific problems in memory, it is imperative to understand the basics of memory, which goes through three steps: First, encoding is the process in which the information is initially recorded within neural networks. The next step is storage, in which the encoded information is stored for future use. This leads to retrieval, the final stage, in which information is recalled when necessary (Feldman 209). While the steps sound simple, memory cannot be relied upon like a video recording of an event. “Research has overwhelmingly shown that, contrary to what most people believe, human beings are neither unbiased observers nor veridical recorders” (Haber and Haber 1059), and problems arising in any three of the steps mentioned may result in memory mutation that may have serious implications if called upon in the courtroom.

There are...

Find Another Essay On False Memories in the Courtroom

Memories in Katherine Anne Porter's The Jilting of Granny Weatherall

1540 words - 6 pages In Katherine Anne Porter's "The Jilting of Granny Weatherall" an old woman's light is slowly fading out and memories from her past are phasing in and out of her head as she lives out her final moments. The times she was "jilted" are pouring out of her memories, releasing themselves and allowing her the peaceful death she so desires. She has good memories: memories of her children, memories of her husband, and memories of her silly father: "Her

Phoniness, The True Face And The False Face in "Cather in the Rye" by Salinger

635 words - 3 pages his life, Holden struggled to find the meaningof life, and his survival, they easily depressed Holden demands theircompany, even though he calls them 'phonies.' Holden is really a decentand mature teenager, but he only hides behind the false front to obtainthe approval. In the meantime, he tries to find the meaning of hisexistence. There's Holden's false front, a rude and without standardteen, but what's behind it are important. A decent

The Importance of Huzun to Orhan Pamuk in Istanbul: Memories and the City

1615 words - 7 pages Istanbul problems unlike any other which was integral for Huzun as it brought them closer, because only an ‘Istanbullu’ could understand the problems of another ‘Istanbullu’. The people could neither relate to the people of the east, nor the people of west, the city of Istanbul was its own isolated community. A major origin of Huzun for Orhan Pamuk in Istanbul Memories and the City was the cultural clash that had engulfed the entire city. Slowly, as

The False Reality of the American Dream in the Great Gatsby

1352 words - 5 pages Graham Whittaker / Brandon Joice Mrs. Turnbull ENG3U1-3 Wednesday, April 09. 2014 The False Reality of the American Dream in the Great Gatsby The Great Gatsby by F. Scott Fitzgerald is a novel that has a large focus on the ideas of the American Dream and social class in the 1920s. In the novel, the people of West Egg and East Egg are people of the upper who have earned money either through inheritance or working hard and have had many

Memories of childhood in "Looking For Dad", "My Grandmother" and "The Sick Equation"

1591 words - 6 pages Memories from our childhoods are often remembered for the rest of our lives. They can range from small things like playing in the park or a birthday party to important milestones such as a first kiss or the first day of school. Now matter how small or insignificant these events seemed at the time, they will be treasured for ever and looked back on as some of the best times of your life. The memories are normally reminders of good times and the

12 Angry Men: Conflict in the Courtroom

791 words - 4 pages The jurors had several conflicts in disagreeing with each other and it didn't help that they would shout over one another. The very first conflict is when juror 8 voted not guilty against the 11 guilty votes. The other 11 jurors don't seem to want to hear this man out; they don't want to hear why he has voted not guilty. Some of these men, jurors 3 and 7, just want to get this case over with so they can get on with their lives. They don't think

Exploring the relevance of bosphorus as a cultural link between the east and west in Istanbul: Memories and The City

1722 words - 7 pages Istanbul to the exclusive of the rest of the world. River is an important factor for the development of the city. River is the easiest way to provide water in huge amount at any time. Bosphorus was the river which was very deep and wide so the chances of it drying up were very less. In the memoir pamuk wrote many things about Bosphorus and culture. The style of writing is melancholic that means pamuk tells the readers about his feelings and memories. My

"The Great Gatsby" By: F. Scott Fitzgerald The tragic result of the American Dream in it's false reality

746 words - 3 pages The Great Gatsby, a novel by F. Scott Fitzgerald, Has a central theme, the American Dream and it's tragic result of those who attempt to capture its false reality. For Jay Gatsby, the dream becomes real through wealth and power, and he maintains that all this glory will result in happiness. To get this bliss Jay chooses to use the drive of love to justify the illegal ways of reaching "the American Dream". Many of the 19th century

False Qualities of Life. Speaks of novelist Brian Moore, and Dimmesdale in Nathaniel Hawthorne's "The Scarlet Letter"

1373 words - 5 pages Irish novelist Brian Moore observed, 'There comes a point in many people's lives when they can no longer play the role they have chosen for themselves' (Bookshelf 95). From Hollywood movie stars to professional athletes, people have and will continue to lead false lives, under the public spotlight, concealing their personal travails. In literature, the preceding statement has held true numerous times, in works such as Nathaniel Hawthorne's The

False Picture of Marriage in The Dead by James Joyce and Odour of Chrysanthemums by D.H. Lawrence

1207 words - 5 pages impression of the other. Modern literature demonstrates that a marriage built upon illusion will falter when exposed to reality. In order to understand the effects of illusion on marriages in modern literature, we will explore two pieces: The Dead by James Joyce and Odour of Chrysanthemums by D.H. Lawrence. Both stories have central characters who have created, and lived with, a false picture of their spouse and their marriage. Firstly, I will

Courage in "To Kill a Mockingbird" by Harper Lee; this focuses on true and false courage and the natural characteristics of courageous people

794 words - 3 pages To Kill a Mockingbird demonstrates courage by certain characters' willingness to defend and sustain their own perspective. Also, true courage involves boldness and strength to resist other opinions, disregarding the pressure of others and their morals. False courage would include hypocrisy. Throughout the novel, Atticus and Mrs. Dubose are courageous in their acts, while Aunt Alexandra and the other hypocrites like Miss Gates, possess false

Similar Essays

The Therapeutic Implications Of False Memories

1893 words - 8 pages This paper discusses the current state of research into false memories and memory manipulation as well the therapeutic applications of this research. The paper describes studies that demonstrate the susceptibility of memory to change and influence to establish the viability of memory manipulation. Current and proposed applications of memory modification are described through the chronicling of research in the area. The ethical concerns of such

Cameras In The Courtroom Essay

1414 words - 6 pages Cameras in the Courtroom This fall, Zacarias Moussaoui is scheduled to go to trial for his participation in the airplane bombing of the World Trade Center in New York City. Along with the media frenzy that accompanies a trial of this magnitude, a separate battle is being waged between Courtroom Television Network LLC (Court-TV) and the U.S. Government over the right of the former to televise trial proceedings. The Government of the

Cameras In The Courtroom Essay

2610 words - 10 pages Cameras in the Courtroom Throughout history there have always been issues concerning judicial courts and proceedings: issues that include everything from the new democracy of Athens, Greece, to the controversial verdict in the Casey Anthony trial as well as the Trayvon Martin trial. One of the more recent and ever changing issues revolves around cameras being allowed and used inside courtrooms. It was stated in the Handbook of Court

False Pride In The Necklace Essay

510 words - 2 pages Loisel's, who were poor, to replace such an expensive item. Instead, as always, Mme Loisel tried to maintain this false pride. The Loisel's had a hard time giving up only 400 francs for dress she had worn at the ball. They didn't go out and buy a necklace in the first place because they couldn't afford it, so I don't see any justification in going out to buy a replacement necklace for the lost one.When they discovered that the new necklace was going