Fascist Italy And Nazi Germany As Totalitarian Atates

1810 words - 7 pages

Fascist Italy and Nazi Germany as Totalitarian Atates
A totalitarian state refers to a country in which the central
government exercises total control over all aspects of people's life.
Main features include an infallible leader, one-party rule, strict
party discipline, elitism, planned economy, an official doctrine,
absolute obedience of individuals to the State, nationalism and
usually an expansionist foreign policy. Up to these criteria, both
Fascist Italy (1922-43) and Nazi Germany (1933-45) could be deemed
totalitarian states to a large extent.

Chaotic situation, irrationality and national humiliation often lead
to totalitarianism. Both the Fascist and Nazi regimes owed their rise
to the people's disillusionment with the Paris Peace Settlement and
postwar difficulties. Though being a victorious power in World War
One, Italy could not get all she wanted on the Paris Peace Conference.
Especially Fiume was given to Yugoslavia, Italy's rival in Adriatic.
As the major defeated power, Germany was punished heavily by the
Treaty of Versailles. She was to pay a huge indemnity, cede
traditional territories, lose all overseas possessions, accept almost
total disarmament and the "war-guilt" clause, etc. Both Italy and
Germany had unsuccessful democratic experiment. The coalition party
governments in both countries had been incompetent in restoring
national pride and getting rid of massive unemployment and
hyper-inflation. Thus, a strong leader and efficient one-party rule
were accepted in both Italy and Germany. However, Hitler came to power
constitutionally while Mussolini staged a coup d'etat, i.e. the March
on Rome.

One-party rule is a totalitarian feature. In Italy it was the Fascists
while in Germany the Nazis. They claimed to represent all the people
and regarded themselves as the elite. The Fascists and Nazis shared
only 5% and 4% of the Italian and German populations respectively.
Strict party discipline was stressed. As party members spread among
different classes, they were able to control people at large.

In a totalitarian state all powers are vested in an infallible leader.
In Fascist Italy Mussolini was the Duce, while in Nazi Germany Hitler
was the Führer. The regimes were organized in a hierarchy and headed
by these all-powerful leaders. Both Mussolini and Hitler were the
personification of the State. By comparison, however, Hitler was more
powerful as he was the supreme head of the State. After the death of
President Hindenburg in 1934, Hitler merged Presidency and
Chancellorship, and inherited the position of Commander-in-Chief.
Above Mussolini, on the contrary, there was King Victor Emmanuel III.
He could dismiss Mussolini; he did so in 1943.

Totalitarian regimes usually employ terror as a means of mass control.

Find Another Essay On Fascist Italy and Nazi Germany as Totalitarian Atates

The Common Factors that Led to the Establishment of Totalitarian Regimes in Italy and Germany in the Inter-War Period

1358 words - 5 pages individuals to the State, etc. During the period 1919-39 there saw the rise of totalitarian regimes in some European countries. The most important ones in Western Europe were Nazi Germany and Fascist Italy. Their respective rise to power shared many similarities but there were some differences. The leaders of Fascist Italy and Nazi Germany were Benito Mussolini and Adolf Hitler respectively. The aftermath of the First

Topic:Mussolini and Fascist Italy Essay

868 words - 3 pages " Mussolini successfully established a totalitarian dictatorship in Italy."Q: How far do you agree with this statement about Italian politics in 1924-39?My answer:In the twentieth century, both Communist and Fascist states had been defined as being 'Totalitarian'. During the 1930's this was usually to distinguish the parties clearly from democracies, like Britain and France, and then once the Second World War had ended, to distinguish the Soviet

Mussolini and Fascist Italy.

1185 words - 5 pages Q)In what ways did violence and intimidation contribute to the success of Fascism in the years 1919-25? Answer: Violence and intimidation were most certainly used within the Fascist regime during 1919-25 in many different ways, for example propaganda was used as a form of intimidation, persuading the Italian people to join Fascism, Mussolini doing this by emphasising all the problems that the country was faced with after the First World War

Opic: Mussolini and Fascist Italy

997 words - 4 pages Q: 'TO WHAT EXTENT DID MUSSOLINI SUCCEED IN CAPTURING THE HEARTS AND MINDS OF THE YOUNG PEOPLE IN ITALY 1924-39?'My answer:During the years 1924-9, Mussolini had worked hard to indoctrinate the young Italians with different Fascist principles. Although, from trying to achieve a new generation of people who would follow and be committed to Mussolini as 'Il Duce', with the regimes aggressive foreign policies, Mussolini had only achieved this to a

Adolf Hitler and Nazi Germany

1610 words - 6 pages . During the interwar period, and leading up to the outbreak of WWII, Hitler presented himself as the strong, self-confident politician that Germany needed to lead the country back to its prior greatness. With a huge following both nationally and internationally, many bought into the image that Hitler presented. However, many still wondered who the real Adolf Hitler was. They wondered if they were dealing with the Hitler of Mein Kampf, lulling his

Nazi Germany and its Children

1369 words - 5 pages The way of living for Jewish Children changed for the worse when the Holocaust struck Eastern Europe. The steadily rising Socialist Workers' Party (Nazis) that started in the early nineteen thirties would eventually lead to genocide. The Nazis believed that Jews were corrupting society, and that they had plans to take over the world in the near future. Hitler, the Fuhrer of the Nazi Party, had a long range plan called 'The Final Solution

Were the Third Reich and Italy totalitarian states?

1864 words - 7 pages which defeats the definition of a totalitarian state.Furthermore, unlike Hitler in Germany, the Church still retained "considerable influence in certain sectors"(Clark), for example in education. In Germany as I have already noted all education was controlled by the Nazis, all teachers were Nazis and everything in School was Nazi orientated. The same cannot be said about Fascist Italy.Finally Clark claims that fascism had "little influence" in

Analyzing the unification of Italy and Germany

1932 words - 8 pages like the United Nations. The Congress of Vienna created boundaries between France, Netherlands, Saxony of Germany, several Italian states, as well as other states and it established many spheres of influence. These boundaries were established to prevent further violent outbreaks, and to keep a balance of power between these states and territories. The rest of Europe did not want another rise of a single empire, like the one of Napoleon and France

Structuralist and Intentionalist approaches to Nazi Germany

2544 words - 10 pages Historians are often divided into categories in regard to dealing with Nazi Germany foreign policy and its relation to Hitler: 'intentionalist', and 'structuralist'. The intentionalist interpretation focuses on Hitler's own steerage of Nazi foreign policy in accordance with a clear, concise 'programme' planned long in advance. The 'structuralist' approach puts forth the idea that Hitler seized opportunities as they came, radicalizing the

Youth and resistance in Nazi Germany

1176 words - 5 pages Cindy LuYear 9 Mandatory History Assessment Task 2Youth and resistance in Nazi GermanyThe Nazi methods of control on German youth were extremely successful, as there was a great use of propaganda towards them, which included the education system, Hitler Youth, and the control over Germany youth culture. Nevertheless, there were still youths who were against the Nazi party and were brave enough to make a stand, which lead to resistance groups

Autonomy and Responsibility in Nazi Germany

1530 words - 6 pages Autonomy and Responsibility in Nazi Germany Throughout history, the struggle of people finding their rights in society has played a major role, especially in the Nazi ideology. During this struggle, societies tried to determine who had rights, what a person owed to society and the duties of an individual. Nazis believed in the Volk, which meant people in the sense of a race, not individuals. Nazis saw the Volk as the major component

Similar Essays

The Rise And Fall Nazi Germany And Fascist Italy

1163 words - 5 pages ) are similar in many ways. In Italy, as violence rampantly swept the country and was about to enter into civil war, King Victor Emmanuel III asked Mussolini to become Prime Minister and establish order throughout the nation. Within the next few years, by eliminating all other political parties, Mussolini concentrated power to form a fascist totalitarian government. In Germany, with political strife rampant and widespread belief among the citizens

Nazi Germany As A Totalitarian State

2216 words - 9 pages Nazi Germany as a Totalitarian State Goebbels once said "the aim of the Nationalist Socialist Revolution must be a totalitarian state, which will permeate all aspects of public life" In reality to put this into practise was a lot more difficult. From the outside, people assume that the Nazis had brainwashed every German citizen during their reign. By booking more closely, through Germanys archives we can see a

Nazi Germany: A Totalitarian State? Essay

2358 words - 9 pages parties where they listened to English and American music. This group opposed Hitler by dancing to American dances like 'jitter bug' to banned jazz music. They accepted Jews at their clubs. As you can see this was not much effective opposition and did not affect Hitler much. The attitudes of Germans began to change in the early 1940's and Hitler was planned to be assassinated but he survived. There were anti - Nazi church leaders reappearing, symbols pulled down from buildings and people stopped wearing the Swastika. In conclusion I think Hitler had complete control and Germany was a totalitarian state.

Finding Fascism: Fascism Defined In The Context Of Mussolini’s Italy And Nazi Germany

1510 words - 7 pages leaders. Eventually, the fascist Grand Council threw Mussolini out of power; however, the coup was only temporary as German Nazi soldiers rescued Mussolini out of prison and reestablished him as the ruler of Italy with Nazi ‘protection’. With the fascist party on the decline, theologian Giovanni Gentile asserted the last form of the Italian fascist theory that served as the fourth phase of Italian fascism. In this new theory the state is once again