This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Fat And Happy Hillel Schwartz Critique

671 words - 3 pages

In “Fat and Happy?”, Hillel Schwartz is examining the arguments over obesity and the effectiveness of its treatments. Schwartz mortifyingly claims in his article, that a fat society would be a preferable culture to live in. He uses biased arguments and unsupported information to back his views against the overweight society. He does state some information that is defended by evidence but much of his statements require further confirmation. Schwartz sways his readers’ opinions over the causes of obesity and the efficiency of its cures using logical fallacies and personal attitudes.Schwartz claims that members of the society who are in good physical shape are the cause of unhappiness among obese people. He says that by labeling obese people as clowns, cannibals, and clodhoppers, they are causing more shame and humiliation than an obese individual would experience from being overweight alone. People that make comments such as, “To be fat is the end of life” (Schwartz 380), only make them more miserable. These are all accurate points that Schwartz makes but most would consider this apparent logic.One of the logical fallacies Schwartz uses is hasty generalization. Schwartz claims that overweight people are not able to excel in school and/or in their careers. The writer has no evidence that overweight people are unable to perform well in these areas but blindly accuses them as being unsuccessful. Schwartz also uses false analogy in his case when he affirms that minorities and obese people are similar. He argues those both minorities and obese people have difficulty being promoted in the workplace and being accepted to colleges. This is not a logical argument because minorities have been known to hold high positions in many occupations and there are countless scholarships sponsoring minority students to attend colleges nationwide.Another one of the author’s arguments states that obese patients’ have no other option other than burning their own body fat and in turn, being cannibalistic (Schwartz 386). This statement is...

Find Another Essay On Fat and Happy Hillel Schwartz Critique

Obesity and Self-Esteem Essay

925 words - 4 pages this condition go through can be gained. Works Cited Gawande, Atul. “The Man Who Couldn’t Stop Eating.” New Yorker 9 July 2010. Koplan, Jeffrey P., MD, MPH, and William H. Dietz, MD, PhD. “Caloric Imbalance and Public Health Policy.” Journal of the American Medical Association (2009). Schwartz, Hillel. “Fat and Happy?” Never Satisfied. Free Press, 2006. Seid, Roberta. ““Close to the Bone”: The Historical for Women’s Obsession with Slenderness.” The Program for the Study of Women and Men in Society. 2004.

The Issue of Obesity Essay

1844 words - 7 pages intake and a lack of proper exercise. They believe that we have become a society of over eaters and under exercisers. And the we should begin a nation wide approach to physical fitness. However Hillel Schwartz sees being overweight not in terms of an individuals lack of control, but more of a society that doesn?t understand nor care how a person might get that way. In the essay Fat and Happy we are told that the world would be a better place if

Do Options Effect a Person's Satisfaction?

599 words - 2 pages distinguished whether a person will be satisfied or earn the likelihood of becoming depressed when having multiple options. The maximizer (Schwartz, 2004) was described as someone who wants to make a concise decision, but cannot ever be certain, even after he or she has made the decision. The more options a maximizer had, the more chances they had of not being satisfied or happy with their decision. Our minds want to make rational decisions based

History of the Corpulent

5695 words - 23 pages , New York: William Morrow and Company, 1976.5. Caroline Hunt, Life of Ellen Richards, Boston: Boston, Whitcomb & Hunt, 19126. Hillel Schwartz, Never Satisfied, New York: Doubleday, 1986.7. Ibid.8. Ibid.9. Shepard B Clough, A Century of American Life Insurance:A History of the Mutual Life Insurance Company of New York 1843-1943,New York: Columbia University Press, 1946.10. Judith Anderson, William Howard Taft: An Intimate History, New York: W.W

Women, Beauty and Self-Esteem

5170 words - 21 pages , 2(1), 61-73. Rothblum, Esther D., Miller, Carol, & Gorbutt, Barbara. (1988). Stereotypes of obese female job applicants. International Journal of Eating Disorders, 7, 277-83. Saltzberg, Elayne A. (1990). Exercise participation and its correlates to body awareness and self-esteem. Unpublished master’s thesis, Connecticut College, New London, CT. Schwartz, Hillel. (1986). Never satisfied: A cultural history of diets, fantasies, and

Amazing Paper

1227 words - 5 pages , Martin, Bartolic, 2013). The main critique that is common in all of the articles being looked at is the lack of diversity among familial marriages such as homosexual couples. The disruption of a child’s overall physical and mental health is at risk following a divorce, which is why it is so important to explore the effects that a divorce has on children. Researchers study this topic in order to find out how and why children suffer from divorce and

The Oppression of Fat People in America

5835 words - 23 pages the other, and there is no word to describe people who fall in between these categories. Fat and thin have been arranged in a strict dichotomy in which thin women are "good, moral, beautiful, healthy, happy, and in control of their lives" whereas fat women are "bad ugly, disgusting, physically unfit, lazy, and lacking will power" (Meadow 168). In this system of description, it is difficult to describe oneself because "fat" or "thin" may not be

The Medical Construction of Obesity

1905 words - 8 pages defines obesity and the actual medical costs and future health risks the disease holds (ACSM, 2010). This is where medical professionals need to bridge the gap of medical and social construction. Medical Construction of Obesity: The American Medical Association defines overweight and obesity as abnormal or excessive fat accumulation that may impair health. To classify weight status the most commonly used parametric in adults is Body Mass Index

The USDA guidelines for school cafeteria food has reduce adolescent obesity in the United States - ESL 117 - Essay

1327 words - 6 pages United States Department of Agriculture has come up with new standards in 2012 setting upper limits on fats and sugar, supervising food’s nutrition content, and controlling food’s serving portion. These three resolutions have successfully lowered the obesity rates among adolescents in the United States. The 2012 USDA new nutrition standard has addressed the prevalence of obesity by regulating the amount of fat and sugar intake. In the United

Does Fat Come Back Elsewhere After Liposuction?

1193 words - 5 pages friend cautions you: The fat will come back, just not in the area that you have had liposuctioned. You mean … if I get my thighs liposuctioned and for the first time ever they are slim and trim and I am happy as hell … the fat will pop up elsewhere? This is certainly not your objective. Yes, you want slimmer thighs but you don’t want new fat appearing in places that were never fat before. Can this really happen? Yes, if you are not vigilante

The Road to Happiness Is a Lonely One

1562 words - 7 pages that make you happy will give you a head-start on the road to happiness, and put you in front of the people who are wallowing on the sidewalks of the road to happiness! In the article “The Myths of Happiness” by Barry Schwartz, he says: “Positive emotions are the best antidote to the vicious cycle of negative emotions” (3). These positive emotions can be the small things you look forward to. If you have nothing to look forward to, it will be even

Similar Essays

Hillel Schwartz's Story, 'fat And Happy.'

549 words - 2 pages "Obesity is Bliss"Hillel Schwartz, in his piece, "Fat and Happy?," asserts that society is responsible, rather than the actual weight of the people, for the unhappiness and depression of the obese. With this in mind, he depicts what the world would be like if everyone was fat, while fantasizing of a world in which obesity is embraced and celebrated. First, however, he must admit the difficult truth that obesity is unaccepted in our world

Critical Analyses Of Fat And Happy, In Defence Of Fat Acceptance By Mary R. Warley

777 words - 3 pages Fat and Happy, In Defense of fat acceptance is considered to be as a wake up call or a realization note for the fat people’s society. It’s not easy for a fat person to save his self from the society where fatness is a serious medical and socially unacceptable problem. Here the Mary R. Wary tells about the stereotypes of our society which fat people experience. But being a part of this society she believes that it is better to accept

Root Of Happiness: Synopsis Of Happy Like God And A Critique Of Positive Psychology

1353 words - 6 pages get the wrong answer. Scientists and economists believe they know what happiness is but have missed the true meaning of happiness. Maybe the mystery of happiness hasn’t been solved by any means of surveys, studies or experiments yet. They just had the experience rather than the meaning of true happiness. (Schoch 451-453) Critique. “Happy Like God” by Simon Critichley and “A Critique of Positive Psychology” by Richard Schoch both had firm beliefs of

Happiness Essay

1665 words - 7 pages throughout the following movie and articles. Obesity has many health risks and also causes a lot of emotional damage to an individual. Hillel Schwartz wrote the article "Fat and Happy." The emotional thoughts are negative throughout this article and put a negative face on obese people. Schwarz describes how "fat" people are made fun of and how "bad" it is to be "fat" through the eyes of a "skinny" person. In the article "Fat and Happy: In Defense of Fat