Fat Head By Tom Naughton And Super Size Me By Morgan Spurlock

961 words - 4 pages

As the rising epidemic of obesity has attracted considerable media attention, so has the promotion for maintaining healthy wellbeing. Tom Naughton’s documentary, Fat Head, is a stellar model of this media attention. It examines the exact cause of weight gain, and the reliability of the Government’s nutritional guidelines. The contention of Fat Head is that the U.S Government and Morgan Spurlock (the creator of Super Size Me) present misleading information. However, Naughton’s bias becomes apparent through the careful selection of film techniques, and the silencing of certain characters, who may express opposing viewpoints. The ideal audience of this documentary, parents and concerned parties such as medical professionals, are invited to agree that the U.S Government and Spurlock are deceptive.

The negative representation of Spurlock is revealed in many instances in Fat Head. Firstly, Naughton mirrors Spurlock’s 30-day fast food binge, which he uses as a means of demonstrating the faults in Super Size Me. Another error the director analyses is Spurlock’s daily consumption of more than 5000 calories. By displaying the calculations on the side on screen as Naughton’s criticises the errors, the director accentuates the fact that none of the meal combinations that Spurlock could consume contain 5000 calories. He also manages to construct Spurlock as sinful, dishonest person, which is symbolised by the red background. While Naughton explains his calculations, the lyric ‘Something here doesn’t seem to add up’ is played in the background. This song works together perfectly with Naughton’s commentary of Spurlock’s errors, since it further emphasises the director’s biased argument, that is, Spurlock is a prevaricator. This ensemble of visual and auditory cinematic techniques conveys the shocking reality of Super Size Me to the audience, and, at the same time, creates a negative mood.

The refuting of Spurlock’s criticism of McDonald’s is also shown in the scene, where Naughton requests for Spurlock’s food log. In this segment, where there is on screen text accounting the number of hanged up calls, the audience is positioned to believe that Naughton has been refused repetitively by the representatives of Super Size Me. From this, viewers are given the impression that Spurlock is a liar, as Spurlock is unwilling to provide Naughton the food log. While Spurlock is mentioned, but he himself is not given the opportunity to put forward his point of view. Nowhere in this scene do viewers hear Spurlock’s refusal, or the actual conversation between the agents of Super Size Me and Naughton. It is clear from this scene that Fat Head is one sided.

Another instance in Fat Head that effectively portrays Spurlock negatively is through the director’s body language while criticising Super Size Me. Much of the time, Naughton has his hands on his hips with his eyebrows synclined. This gesture connotes anger. Viewers perceive through Naughton’s aggression that the...

Find Another Essay On Fat Head by Tom Naughton and Super Size Me by Morgan Spurlock

Super size me Essay

1256 words - 5 pages McDonald’s is killing Americans, at least that is what Morgan Spurlock believes. In his documentary Super Size Me he embarks on a quest to not only describe and use himself as an example of the growing obesity trend, but to offer the viewers with base-line nutritional knowledge that will allow them to draw their own informed conclusions. Spurlock's primary intention is to prove through self-experimentation that eating solely McDonald's food is

Super Size Me Essay

2280 words - 10 pages SUPER SIZE ME I. Summarize the documentary “Super Size Me”. “Super Size Me” is a documentary directed by and starting Morgan Spurlock. Spurlock embarks in a 30 day challenge in which he will only eat food from McDonalds. The purpose of this experiment is to prove that this food is extremely unhealthy and can cause serious damage to the body. Plus, how these fast food companies persuade and encourage poor nutrition for its own revenue. II

The Super-Size Me Documentary

1319 words - 6 pages eat McDonalds for every meal. He also took the challenge in response to a lawsuit against McDonalds by a family whose children became obese by the contents of its meals. Directed and starring Morgan Spurlock, who is married to a vegan chef and a healthy man for his age, Super-Size Me is a film that followed Spurlock for 31 days as he follows certain rules set by a series of physicians. He was only allowed to meals off the McDonalds menu including

Super Size Me: An Analysis

955 words - 4 pages The documentary Super Size Me, produced by Morgan Spurlock, is a film which aims to frighten its viewers into adopting a more healthy lifestyle. Super Size Me uses techniques which attempt to shock the viewer- showing them the devastating effects that consuming nothing but fast food (in the case of the documentary, food purchased from McDonalds) for 30 days has upon the physical and mental health of the previously healthy Morgan Spurlock, as

Obesity in the U.S: Super Size Me

1020 words - 4 pages negative effects are present with the daily eating of fast foods. What were two themes discussed in the documentary Super Size Me? In the documentary film Super Size Me directed by Morgan Spurlock, there were many themes discussed about on the topic obesity. Two themes were obesity increasing and children being targeted as they are an easy topic. The frequent photos and interviews of obese adults and children suggest that America definitely has an

Naked Lunch: Comparisons of Documentaries Super Size Me and Forks Over Knives

1816 words - 8 pages Spurlock’s different approaches saying, “Morgan Spurlock, a born salesman, covers similar ground in Super Size Me but figures out how to entertain by putting himself through a unique, McDonald’s-driven fast-food challenge.” Again, this could be more a case of knowing their audience and the filmmaker knowing their intended market. Bill Nichols “we experience a distinct form of fascination for the opportunity to witness the lives of others when they seem

Oppinion paper on the film/ documentary "Super-Size Me"

690 words - 3 pages The movie "Supersize Me" portrayed some astonishing results on the individual performing his "experiment." It gave some definite ideas as to why the United States is currently the "fattest" country in the world. However, when one takes into account this mans dietary habits and exercise habits before beginning the experiment, and realizes that all this fattening food and lack of exercise was completely out of character for him, it seems obvious

Morgan, Morgan by Janette Turner Hospital

1762 words - 7 pages This paper will explore the short story “Morgan, Morgan” by Janette Turner Hospital in a poststructuralist way using both New Historicism and Deconstruction. First, we will explore the tenants of New Historicism and apply it to the story, and then we will explore the tenants of Deconstruction and apply it to the story. The ideals of New Historicism were first outlined by Michel Foucault and later developed by Stephen Greenblatt. Foucault did

Slavery and Freedom: The American Paradox by Edmund Morgan

2220 words - 9 pages Elizabeth II. The letters patents, granted by the Queenes Majestie to M. Walter Ralegh, now Knight, for the discovering and planting of new lands and Countries, to continue the space of 6 yeeres and no more. Virginia: University of Virginia (etext). Online Morgan, Edmund. “The Labor Problem at Jamestown”. The American Historical Review. Online Morgan, Edmund. "Slavery and Freedom: The American Paradox." JSTOR. http://www.jstor.org/stable/info

Inner journeys and "My Place" by Sally Morgan

651 words - 3 pages of their aboriginality, their spiritual identity as aborigines and their self esteem/ self worth.Gladys faced many challenges and obstacles in her life. At Parkerville children's home Gladys resented the colour of her skin. "I wanted to be white; I even hoped a white family would adopt me..." Gladys' fear of authority and her aboriginality stemmed from her mother Daisy. Upon confessing her nationality, an old lady exclaimed "Oh you poor thing

Arcadia by Tom Stoppard

1328 words - 5 pages Arcadia by Tom Stoppard Some critics have suggested that the dazzling intellectual display in Stoppard’s plays comes at the expense of genuine emotional engagement. We are amused, intrigued, even educated but we do not feel any real sympathy for his characters. How far do you find this true of Arcadia? The first thing we notice about this play is its intellectual brilliance. The characters are amusing and we are interested in how they

Similar Essays

Super Size Me, By Morgan Spurlock

1260 words - 5 pages many instances of evidence to help support his argument. He includes his own personal experience, the experience from other individuals, and expert testimonies. By including all of this, Spurlock was able to justify his reasoning towards criticizing the fast food restaurants for their role in the obesity epidemic. The techniques used by Morgan Spurlock is very effective in detailing the causes and effects of obesity in order to make people more aware of the situation. Works Cited Super Size Me. Dir. Morgan Spurlock. Perf. Morgan Spurlock. Sony Pictures, 2005. DVD.

"Super Size Me" By Morgan Spurlock

646 words - 3 pages Key Performers: Morgan Spurlock, Daryl M. Isaacs M.D., Bridget Bennett, RD., Healthy Chef Alex (Morgan's Wife)Did you like this movie? Why/why not?Although "Super Size Me" was a very disturbing movie, I enjoyed it. Morgan Spurlock did a great job of showing that fast food might taste good, but we need to be careful about how and when we eat it. I also enjoyed it because the music to the movie was catchy and it sticks in your head.In what way did

Morgan Spurlock?S Super Size Me Essay

1399 words - 6 pages Morgan Spurlock's Super Size Me After watching Morgan Spurlock's Super Size Me it became even clearer to me that there is an obesity crisis in this country. While this was not news to me; I was surprised by Dr. Satcher, the former U.S. Surgeon General, stating that 'left unabated obesity will surpass smoking as the number one preventable cause of death in this country.' Morgan Spurlock focused his attention on McDonalds in his documentary

"Super Size Verses Fat Head: How Fast Food Effects Our Lives

1007 words - 5 pages the reason Spurlock, decided to take on his 30 day diet of “McDonalds” food eating it (meals) three times a day, to show the probability he would gain a lot of weight and prove a significant point to “the citizens of United States of America.” A comedian named Tom Naughton, who had made a reply documentary to the film “Super-Size Me.” called “Fat head,” it debuted in 2009. His angle was to show that there was no way that Spurlock, could have