This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Fate In The German Epics And Modern America

2944 words - 12 pages

Fate is defined as “something that unavoidably befalls a person; that free will does not exist” (American Heritage Dictionary). Fate is one of the central themes in the three Germanic Epics: The Nibelungenlied, Njal’s Saga, and Beowulf. In all the stories, the characters believe everything that occurs is predetermined. Hagen believes that he is fated to die in The Nibelungenlied; Njal sees the future through his dream in Njal’s Saga; Beowulf defeats Grendel’s Mother because fate has decided that he should win in Beowulf. Evidently, almost all of the characters in Germanic epics have a fatalist view towards life. In contrast, America was founded on the notion that everyone has free will. From the Declaration of Independence to the Bill of Rights, people are ensured the right to create their own future. Currently, this idea still stands, since America is often labeled the “Land of the Free [Will]”. In a paper published by Dr. L. Robert Kohls, director of international programs at Washington and S.F. State University, he claims:
Americans do not believe in the power of fate. In the American context, to be “fatalistic” is to be superstitious, lazy, or unwilling to take initiative. Most Americans find it impossible to accept that there are some things that lie beyond the power of humans to achieve. Americans believe every single individual should have control over whatever in the environment might potentially affect him or her.

From Dr. Kohl’s extensive study of different cultures, he accurately describes the average American’s belief that they are in control of their future. Despite the contrast, Americans are much more inclined towards believing in fate than they appear. In reality, the Germanic idea of fate is integrated into all aspects of American culture, from movies to religious beliefs.
In the German epic The Nibelungelied, fate is portrayed as a powerful force that can even change the mindset of the most powerful men, such as Hagen. Initially, Hagen advocates the belief of free will. This can be seen through his actions, especially when he assumes leadership over King Gunther. Although, as king, Gunther is supposed to be the most powerful man in Burgundy, he defers most of this power to Hagen. Whenever a decision is needed, Hagen assumes the role of the leader and makes the choices because he believes in free will; he believes he has the power to determine his future. If Hagen believed in fate, he would be “lazy, or unwilling to take initiative to act”, as stated by Dr. Kohl. This is not the situation; the American value of free will is present in the mind of Hagen.
Yet, although Hagen takes the initiative to act, it may not mean that he necessarily believes in free will. In Njal’s Saga, for example, Gunnar is also very ambitious, yet he believes in fate. Gunnar says, “[d]eath will come to me when it will come… if that is my fate” (Chapter 67). However, the scene with the nixies in The Nibelungenlied proves...

Find Another Essay On Fate in the German Epics and Modern America

Poem and Music in the German Lied

787 words - 3 pages In his book Poem and Music in the German Lied, Jack Stein attempts to evaluate the fidelity of Schumann's music in Dichterliebe to the poems he appropriated from Heine's Lyrisches Intermezzo. Stein asserts that, although he certainly caught some of the nuance of Heine's work, Schumann often ignored the text's "caustic" and "ironic" components which results in a "sweetening and sentimentalizing of Heine's sharp, pointed verse." Stein progresses

Modern Doemstic Design and Traditional German Architecture

3014 words - 12 pages architecture (modernism) and was in a period of political change with the Weimar republic creating an enforcing the new constitution. So to see an architect still building traditional old style German house was for example like ‘building a caveman’s hut amongst modern brick buildings’. The contrast was very clear and fellow architects of his time the avant-gardes dismissed and pushed aside Tessenow’s architecture and ideology that all architecture in

Modern Wicca in America

3066 words - 12 pages Modern Wicca in America Abstract Wicca, an alternate and often preferred name for the religion of neo-Pagan witchcraft; a religion based, in part, on ancient northern European Pagan beliefs in a fertility Goddess and her consort, a horned God. Although the religion is a modern creation, some of its sources pre-date the Christian era by many centuries. Most Wiccans do not believe that their religion is a direct continuous descendent of

Fate in Antigone, Beowulf, and the World

1311 words - 6 pages entire life. In the end, the only thing that all men and women are fated to do is die, and even that is not determined until the day that it happens. In the two epics, Antigone and Beowulf, fate plays a major part in determining the events that happen to the two main roles of these stories, Antigone and Beowulf respectfully. They both go along with their actions, knowing that it is fate that has determined they must act in this manner, and that fate

Fate and Freewill in Oedipus the King

1149 words - 5 pages In the play Oedipus Rex, it shows many different forms of fate and freewill. Fate is a word that can be defined in many different ways. Fate can affect a person's life in many different ways. Oedipus's fate ruined his life and lead him to a horrible death. Antigone's life was also thrown out to the hand of fate. Neither one of them had any freewill in there lifetime, all of there lives were based upon the fate that the gods handed to them

Fate and The Supernatural in Macbeth

1049 words - 4 pages What will, and will not, happen in the future can never be known for certain, but what if the possibility was available? Believable or not, Shakespeare portrays the role of fate in Macbeth and the significance of the supernatural. In the play, Macbeth is given prophecies concerning his fate from the weird sisters, three witches who represent the supernatural throughout the play. Macbeth’s belief in the witches’ prophecies leads him to

Technology and Modern America

1113 words - 4 pages The microeconomic picture of the U.S. has changed immensely since1973, and the trends are proving to be consistently downward forthe nation's high school graduates and high school drop-outs. "Of allthe reasons given for the wage squeeze - international competition,technology, deregulation, the decline of unions and defense cuts -technology is probably the most critical. It has favored theeducated and the skilled," says M. B. Zuckerman, editor-in

Why the 1920s in America was considered the "modern era" and "modernism."

1063 words - 4 pages QUESTIONS FROM INSTRUCTOR:. Many historians cite the 1920s as the decade in which America entered the "modern era." Given the myriad labels attached to this decade, this essay focuses on the broader context of all those movements under the umbrella term "modernism."First, what is modernism and why did it apply to the 1920s (as opposed to earlier decades)? What ideologies or beliefs had changed by the 1920s that qualified this decade as "modern

Florida: History and Modern Attractions of the 27th State in America

1321 words - 5 pages . Florida has many universities with great academic programs and great students. With humble beginnings Florida has become the most popular state in America with its rich history and modern day beauty. Records show that life in Florida started with Juan Ponce de Leon in 1530. Between April 2nd and April 8th Ponce de Leon washed up on shore after a terrible ship wreck. In honor of Pasuda Florida Ponce de Leon named the area La Florida. The country

The Analysis and Comparison of the Themes of "Beowulf", "The Odyssey" and Other Related Epics

2553 words - 10 pages An epic is best described by the Merriam-Webster Dictionary as a long narrativepoem in elevated style recounting the deeds of a legendary or historical hero. Epics like"Beowulf" and "The Odyssey" are perfect examples of this definition; they are eachcentered on the deeds and triumphs of their heroes, Beowulf and Odysseus. All epics aresimilar in a way that they are made up of elements. One major element of the epic is itsthemes. In all epics

Anton And The German

1666 words - 7 pages Knipper September 4 Moscow At last a letter from you, dear Anton! I'm so glad you're in good health and working, I want you to be happy, not down, so you will come quickly. Oh, I feel troubled in my mind"¦ Your Olga The above excerpt was taken from a novel entitled Dear Writer, Dear Actress, The Love Letters of Anton Chekhov and Olga Knipper, by Jean Benedetti. The novel tells the love story between Chekhov and Knipper

Similar Essays

Destiny, Fate, Free Will And Free Choice In Oedipus The King Fate And The Modern World

985 words - 4 pages Oedipus Rex, Fate, and the Modern World      In the two thousand since “Oedipus Rex” was written, it has been analyzed and dissected innumerable times and in every possible way.  Usually the analysis has been within the context of the play itself or within the context of other Greek tragedies.  Perhaps it would be more relevant and interesting to evaluate the play within the context of the modern world.          In his play Sophocles

Corn In Ancient And Modern America

1604 words - 7 pages says there is insufficient evidence for such claims. Just as in ancient America when the native Americans used every part of corn to serve a useful purpose, nothing goes to waste from growing corn in modern times as well.BibliographyFoley, Jonothan. "It's Time to Rethink America's Corn System." Scientific American 5 March 2013. Web. 16 April 2014.n.p. "Corn.", n.d. Web, 16 April 2014."Native American Plants Legends: The Three Sisters" Unabridged. Native American Encyclopedia 28 Apr. 2014. <

The Importance Of Beowulf In Modern America

2485 words - 10 pages The Importance of Beowulf in Modern America By Jennifer Carley Modern culture and literature include many stories of great heroes and fictional adventures. Many people grow up reading about these great adventures and looking up to the heroes of the stories. Heroes are great roll models because they are portrayed as courageous and trustworthy individuals, two very admirable qualities. Despite numerous cultural and technological advancements, life

The Effects Of Technology In Modern America

1168 words - 5 pages It's a view of the techonlgy that has effected America He said it was well written but I needed to talk about the theme more.U.S. Wage TrendsThe microeconomic picture of the U.S. has changed immensely since 1973, and the trendsare proving to be consistently downward for the nation's high school graduates and highschool drop-outs. "Of all the reasons given for the wage squeeze - internationalcompetition, technology, deregulation, the decline of