This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Federal Court Ruling And The Pledge Of Allegiance.

657 words - 3 pages

Federal Court Rulings.A Federal Appeals Court ruled two to one that reciting the Pledge of Allegiance is unconstitutional in public schools because of the phrase "one nation under God." In the article regarding the use of the phrase "under God" there are three main issues addressed. One is the question of whether or not the phrase violates The Establishments Clause of the United States Constitution in regards to the separation of church and state. Second, is the question of whether or not the use of the phrase permits religious discrimination. The third issue here is whether the phrase is an attempt by the state, or government, to impose a theological doctrine, or specific religious content, on an individual. It was one of the most closely watched church-state cases in the Court's history: a legal challenge to include the phrase "under God" in public school recitations of the Pledge of Allegiance.A surprising number of Americans felt that the judges had a good point, that the reference to God in the pledge was an inappropriate endorsement of religion. Zirkel (2003) states, atheists and agnostics are offended by an unnecessary reference to God in a patriotic pledge. However, the Supreme Court has ruled in the past that ceremonial references to God in public places and institutions do not represent an establishment of religion. The Court has never blinked, for example, at the use of a Bible in a courtroom, where one swears to tell the truth "So help me God".The United States' government regularly acknowledges the existence of a "Creator" or "God" as an illustration of its cultural and political philosophy. A motto for the United States "In God We Trust" was written in 1863 and is inscribed on the nation's currency. Additionally, The Declaration of Independence adopted by the US Congress in 1776, states "...that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable rights...." Currently, the US government employs a Roman Catholic Chaplain to lead the US House of Representatives regularly...

Find Another Essay On Federal Court Ruling and the Pledge of Allegiance.

Remove God from the Pledge of Allegiance

2335 words - 9 pages ” should be removed from the pledge for purposes of creating equality in different beliefs and allowing each American their right laid out in the constitution. These are the original words to the Pledge of Allegiance. "I pledge allegiance to my flag and the republic for which it stands, one nation indivisible, with liberty and justice for all." The key word for Bellamy was "indivisible," which recalled the Civil War and the triumph of federal

contraversial Pledge of Allegiance Essay

1282 words - 5 pages district U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals. Two years later three judges issued their opinions on the case. With a two-to-one decision in his favor, Newdow won the appeal. "[T]his week [3 February 2002] [Federal Courts] bann[ed] the Pledge of Allegiance from public schools in California and eight other western states...rul[ing] it was unconstitutional because it includes the words 'under God'" ("Court Bans Pledge in Schools: Decision Stirs Swift

The Debate Over God in the Pledge of Allegiance

1834 words - 7 pages "I pledge allegiance, to the flag, of the United States of America, and to the Republic, for which it stands, one nation, under Congress, the Supreme Court, the Declaration of Independence, our founding fathers, and the President, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all." Francis Bellamy wrote the Pledge of Allegiance in 1892 (Baer). He did this in the memory of the 400th anniversary of Columbus discovering America ("The Pledge"). In

Recent controversial topic of the pledge of allegiance

698 words - 3 pages What is Constitutional?The Constitution. A document that was written over two hundred years ago two outline the ideals and principals of a nation. During the past few years parts of the constitution itself have come under fire, and other things in our nation, such as prayer in schools, and even our own Pledge of Allegiance, have been topics of debate and even lawsuits.In the late 1950's a Supreme Court decision forever changed the course of our

The Solemn Oath: Understanding the Pledge of Allegiance

1137 words - 5 pages Have you ever thought about what it truly means to be a patriotic American? Does a patriotic American simply support his country no matter what the cause; or does this patriot passionately reprimand his country’s injustices, no matter how small or big? Consider the Pledge of Allegiance. This oath of loyalty binds us as Americans and should unite us. The keyword being unite, for the essay I’ll respond to thinks otherwise. Indeed, Gwen Wilde is

“Under God” Should Be Removed From The Pledge Of Allegiance

1013 words - 4 pages conservatives who insist that no one is forced to say it” (Cline). In the fall of 2013, “an atheist family and the American Humanist Association” (Al-Khatib) brought a supreme court case against the pledge of allegiance in Massachusetts. Their case had to do with discrimination and “linking belief in God with patriotism” (Al-Khatib). Their efforts are among the latest of many attempts to get religion out of the pledge. They did not win the case

God Should Remain in the Pledge of Allegiance

1169 words - 5 pages God Should Remain in the Pledge of Allegiance One of the most controversial issues, if “Under God” should remain in the pledge, and if children should be required to say it, went to court a few weeks ago. The argument was brought to court by Michael Newdow, the father to the girl on whose behalf the lawsuit was brought forward. Newdow argued in court and on many different public speaking occasions that knowing his child is being led to say

Kids Must Do More Than Recite the Pledge of Allegiance

777 words - 3 pages pledge goes against the sense of individual liberty and freedom that is as the very heart of what our Republic stands for. James Perry, author of the essay titled, “What I Expect My Child to Learn from Not Saying the Pledge of Allegiance,” states, “recitation of the Pledge of Allegiance doesn’t support American ideals. Instead, it gives away our liberty, minimizing that for which the founding fathers fought.” Children do not learn patriotism by

The Words UNDER GOD Should Be Removed from the Pledge of Allegiance

1276 words - 5 pages Government, not a Christian Nation and ? In the 2008 the United States Census Bureau, Self-Described Religious Identification of Adult Population, The Christian faith proved to be the more dominating religion out of all religions. So it would seem the words “Under God” would be beneficial for the majority, the Pledge of Allegiance allures and supports the loyalty of the majority of citizens. The nonbelievers of religion have had the right to not

Pledge of Allegiance: A Perfect Symbol of Hypocrisy

2077 words - 8 pages Every morning over 75 million students around the nation recite the Pledge of Allegiance verbatim (Digest of Education Statistics). If one walks up to one of these students and asks them about the meaning and the origin of this pledge, what would they say? Nothing. However, even though more than a million students recite these words every day, not more than half probably know the true meaning behind these words. One cannot deny the fact that

An article citing the reasons the line "under god" should be removed from the pledge of allegiance

571 words - 2 pages ...One Nation, Uh, Indivisible...Two words in the Pledge of Allegiance - "under god" - have sparked a firestorm from the schools of California to the halls of the Supreme Court, which will decide next June about the legality of the phrase. In a diverse country with a great variety of religious faiths running the gamut from devoted believers to atheists, issues of government and religion are a touchy subject. However, it is clear that the phrase

Similar Essays

The Pledge Of Allegiance Essay

1158 words - 5 pages public school classrooms began with West Virginia State Board of Education v. Barnette, 319 U.S 624 (1943) when Jehovah’s Witnesses took several cases to courts forcing the Supreme Court to make a ruling (Pledge, 2013). The Supreme court ruled, “We think in the actions of the local authorities in compelling the salute and pledge transcends constitution limitations on their power and invades the sphere of intellect and spirit which it is the purpose of

The Pledge Of Allegiance Essay

1843 words - 7 pages these cases include Holden v. Board of Education, Elizabeth in 1966, Goetz v. Ansell in 1973, and Holloman ex rel. Holloman v. Hardland in 1994. Other court cases involving the Pledge of Allegiance focus more on the inclusion of the words “under God” in the Pledge itself. In the case of Sherman v. Community Consolidated School District 21 of Wheeling Township in 1992 and 1993, the Court reasoned that “the words ‘under God’ constituted a secular

History And Analysis Of The United States Pledge Of Allegiance

923 words - 4 pages the United States”. On June 14, 1954 the words “Under God” added and officially cleared until present days. Works Cited 93907224/?no-ist. Accessed on March 23, 2014. Accessed on March 24, 2014. L. Deppner, Teresa.UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT. Available at SOUTHERN

Should Students Recite The Pledge Of Allegiance?

1013 words - 4 pages -court-9th-circuit-allegiance-in-public-schools?_s=PM:LAW>."Top 10 Pros and Cons - Under God in the Pledge -" Under God Web. 27 Sept. 2010. <>."Debate: "Under God" in the American Pledge of Allegiance - Debatepedia." Welcome to Debatepedia! - Debatepedia, Debatepedia the Wikipedia of Debates. Web. 27 Sept. 2010. <