This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Federal Preemption Of Class Iii Medical Devices Receiving Premarket Approval

1743 words - 7 pages

Federal Preemption of Class III Medical Devices receiving premarket approval
Case in Review
Court rulings have held that the preemption clause included in the Medical devices act of 1976 protects class III medical devices which have been approved through the Food and Drug Administration’s (FDA) premarket approval process (PMA) from litigation. Injured parties have no means to seek relief from device manufacturers for injuries sustained due to the use of a class III medical device receiving PMA.
Overview of the FDA and Medical devices act of 1976:
Congress created the Food and Drug Administration in 1938 under a statute known as the Federal Food, Drug and Cosmetic Act. Under the 1938 act, the FDA could not prevent medical devices from entering the market but they could remove unsafe devices from the marketplace. The FDA believed that those same powers given to regulation of drugs should be extended to medical devices to ensure public safety. The Medical devices act of 1976 granted oversight and approval of medical devices to the FDA as a logical extension of duties already provided under previous legislation.
The act provided for three classes of medical devices, levels I, II and III. Devices classified under level III were given the most rigorous level of testing and review due to the fact that these devices could produce the greatest level of harm. Level III devices are the only class of devices that are subject to premarket approval which requires manufacturers to submit information related to the safety and effectiveness of their devices for FDA review and approval.
The Medical devices act of 1976 included a preemption clause over state law to ensure the federal statutes held supremacy over any state statutes or requirements. Section 360k of the MDA contains this specific preemption provision: “[N]o State or political subdivision of a State may establish or continue in effect with respect to a device intended for human use any requirement – (1) which is different from, or in addition to, any requirement applicable under this chapter to the device, and (2) which relates to the safety or effectiveness of the device or to any other matter included in a requirement applicable to the device under this chapter.”
Consumer: Consumers using these medical devices are at best in ill health at the time of receipt of a class III medical device and realistically near death. Due to the severity of their illness, their focus is on survival not on what medical device will be used. These consumers must rely upon their doctors, hospitals, their insurance company (if any), the FDA and medical device manufacturers to provide a safe and proven device to improve and extend their quality of life. By the nature of this relationship, these parties are in a fiduciary position to the patients and their families.
Consumers receiving a device that has undergone the premarket approval process are assured that the product has...

Find Another Essay On Federal Preemption of Class III Medical Devices Receiving Premarket Approval


3697 words - 15 pages million in punitive damages. The evidence is sealed by a court order.June 1988 Six years after the 1982 proposal, FDA classifies the implants into Class III. Premarket Approval Applications from silicone breast implant manufacturers are due by July 1991. The PMA's must prove affirmatively, with valid scientific data evaluated by the FDA, that their devices are safe and effective. After the PMA's are submitted by the manufacturers, the FDA has 180

Physical and Virtual Feedback Systems in Robotic Surgery

792 words - 4 pages and prototypes and must go through extensive testing and regulations in order to be used in an actual surgical environment. The Food and Drug Administration (FDA) classifies medical devices on the risk posed by the device. The classification systems can change based on scientific data results. A haptic feedback system would be a Class 3 device because it used in the body and has the potential for unreasonable risk of illness or injury (). For a

How the Federal Legislation Affect the Practice of Pharmacology

638 words - 3 pages For nearly seventy years federal legislation continues to impact the practice of pharmacology. The definition of pharmacy is the branch of medicine concerned with the uses and effects, and modes of action of drugs. The medical definition of pharmacology is the science of drugs including their origin, composition, and properties or reactions of drugs especially with their therapeutic value. In almost every case the legislation has had every

Company Report to Implement a Unique Device Identification

2851 words - 12 pages process will be mitigated. The progress of the project will be communicated to the Steering team and management team on scheduled report out. Criteria for Solution CareFusion team will invest resources on the risk based implementation of UDI as per the ruling requirements: • Class III medical devices for all the business units will be first to implement the ruling as these devices has to be compliant within 1 year of implementation of ruling that

Companies and Technology in the Medical Field

1051 words - 4 pages financial outlay of technology, operations, products and taking the medical product or service to market can be expensive. An example is the, the Medical Device User Fee and Modernization Act (MDUFMA), that was implemented on January 4, 2004, that elevated the fees for the Premarket Approval Applications (PMAs) and PMA supplements increase by over 34 pct. Original PMA costs increased from $154,457 to $206,931. As buyers for medical equipment

The Food and Drug Administration Program and Food Additives

1379 words - 6 pages . As the food industry has grown into a multi billion-dollar industry, the task of ensuring all ingredients are safe for consumption has become a bit more complicated. The law has been amended over the years in an attempt to address the thousands of new additives that have been developed. A result of attempting to streamline the process has been that companies are permitted to add certain types of ingredients to foods without premarket approval

Guidant - Harvard business study

1856 words - 7 pages Summary:In late 1994, five medical device companies, namely, Advanced Cardiovascular Systems, Inc., Devices for Vascular Intervention, Inc., Cardiac Rhythm management Business, Heart Rhythm Technologies, Inc., and Origin Medsystems, Inc., has been combined to form Guidant Corporation. Formerly a part of Eli Lilly and Company, these companies as a group were split off by Lilly to capitalize on common customers, markets, and competencies in three

Technology and Health Policy: Rapid Technology Diffusion and Policy

6269 words - 25 pages 1997 (Koenig, 1998). In contrast, the purchase and operation of high-cost medical devices are subject to central government approval in France. France also has an extensive list of devices that are subject to regulation for adoption. Although UK has no specific regulation on the adoption of high-cost medical devices, budget allocation in the health sector and the dominance of public hospitals help health care providers have little financial

The Relationship Between the Law and Your School

1318 words - 6 pages together as one nation we rely on preemption. The conflict preemption under the Supremacy Clause, any state law that conflicts with a federal law is preempted. In addition, even in the absence of a direct conflict between state and federal law, a conflict exists if the state law is an obstacle to the accomplishment and execution of the full purposes and objectives of Congress (The White House, 2013). Evolution of the Legal System and the Repercussions


2576 words - 10 pages intersect in several areas. One significant area is that of copyright preemption of state contract law. For a combination of reasons, we can expect to se considerable emphasis in litigation on the preemption doctrine in the future.Copyright owners have a variety of rights under the copyright act, including the rights of reproduction, and the rights of public distribution, performance, and display. For convenience, let the term "copying" serve as a

Regulatory Issues for Opening a Laboratory

1521 words - 6 pages centrifugation or complex mixing; require operator evaluation of sample; or produce results that must be communicated to a state or local health department. A test system is cleared or approved by the FDA through the premarket notification or premarket approved process for in-vitro diagnostic use. CLIA regulation recognizes that clinical laboratories can run three types of test systems with reference to FDA-clearance or approval: 1) test systems run by

Similar Essays

House Energy And Commerce Committee, Subcommittee On Health: Examining Federal Regulations Of Mobile Medical Apps And Other Health Software

624 words - 3 pages their intent to regulate mobile medical apps as medical devices but with discretion, only regulating certain subsets of apps. However, there is still a pressing need for increased transparency and safety in this area to ensure that patients remain safe and these tools are effective. Current bipartisan legislation entitled the Sensible Oversight for Technology which Advances Regulatory Efficiency (SOFTWARE) Act of 2013 moves to provide the FDA with a

Stem Cell Clearly Describes The Benefits Of Stem Cell Research To Modern Medical Research And Advancement Done For A High School Anatomy/Physiology Class 5 Pages

1709 words - 7 pages regulating stem cell research in Israel and embryo destruction for stem cell research is allowed. Scientists announced this month that they succeeded for the first time in growing heart cells from human embryonic stem cells. The heart cells can beat spontaneously, according to a report published in the Journal of Clinical Investigation. In 1999, a law was passed prohibiting cloning humans for five years. AUSTRALIA: In June 2001 Australian federal

Paper For My Health Class Assessing The Use Of Medical Marijuana. I Received An A On This Paper. My Sources Are Listed At The End

1425 words - 6 pages Medical Uses Of MarijuanaMarijuana, a drug we see as completely shunned by society. Although it may receive a bad reputation because of media coverage, it has its benefits as well as downfalls. Science will never be proven, but people should be aware of what science is discovering about medicinal marijuana. It is best to be informed about what marijuana is, what conditions it treats, it's history, and the scientific evidence that may shine new

Law302 Foodand Drug Administration Essay

2948 words - 12 pages intended for use in the United States (U.S.) are required to register annually with the FDA." My company registers with the FDA for the following year during the fourth quarter of the present year. For the year 2013, my company was charged a $2575.00 registration fee.Listing the company's medical devices according to categories listed in the federal regulations. Medical devices are classified as either class 1, class 2, or class 3 devices. Class 1