This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Federal Welfare Reform Essay

1517 words - 6 pages

Federal Welfare Reform: A Critical Perspective

Abstract:
This project will examine “welfare reform,” which was signified by the signing of the Personal
Responsibility and Work Opportunity Act (PRWOA) in 1996. PRWOA replaced the original welfare
act of 1935, titled Aid to Dependent Children (later changed to Aid to Families with Dependent
Children), with the program Temporary Assistance to needy Families (TANF). Under PRWOA, TANF
was instated as a system of block grants allocated to states to implement their own forms of
assistance and replaced programs like the cash-assistance program, Aid to Families with Dependent
Children, and the Job Opportunities and Basic Skills Training. The most influential change of this
legislation among others has been the implementation of required work hours and strict time limits
to how long families may receive aid, implying that people can simply will their way out of poverty
provided they work hard enough. While the significant fall of TANF cash assistance caseloads
within the program’s first five years has been celebrated as proof of reform’s success, the new era
of welfare can only be considered a success if America views the transformation of the welfare
poor to the working poor an achievement.

Review of the Literature:
In conducting my research, it was interesting to find dramatically divergent perspectives on the
topic of welfare reform, especially considering that each perspective gave the impression that their
argument was based on quantitative facts. The sources I consulted that were affiliated with the
federal government, such as statistics and fact sheets from the Administration for Children and
Families (ACF) as well as the Whitehouse website, were the most optimistic about welfare reform.
The objective information provided by these sources is valuable in that it outlines many
specifications of welfare reform such as the details of work requirements, time limits, funding, and
penalties. Yet, by focusing exclusively on the decline in TANF caseloads, welfare reform is
portrayed as a wild success that has allowed families to “move from dependence on welfare to
greater independence through work” (U.S. Department of Health). These sources talk extensively
about “empowerment,” “protection,” and “independence” as related directly to work, welfare reform,
and its reauthorization. They emphasize a “national” interest in spending cuts which they assume to
be exclusive from the interests of the nation’s poor.
The other sources I consulted that were unaffiliated with the government either contradicted
or conflicted with the analysis of welfare reform’s success in one way or another. Instead of
focusing on the decline in TANF caseloads, these sources looked critically and holistically at welfare
reform as a policy and its effect on individuals and families. Instead of ending the analysis with the
removal of recipients from the welfare roles, Fremstad, Melendez, and Goldberg...

Find Another Essay On Federal Welfare Reform

Current US Welfare Reform Essay

919 words - 4 pages reform, the beneficiaries’ work effort with difficulties to employment increased making the economy of U.S to drop to 14 percent in 2002. Moreover, some of the beneficiaries who leave welfare were getting income that is below the federal poverty level. Some of them could not access the labor market as well as the welfare system. The current US welfare reform comes with time limit that on benefit together with the work activity requirement (Weil

Off Welfare, On to College Essay

626 words - 3 pages training and education.Research shows that 85 percent of women on welfare who go to college and graduate get off and stay off welfare. The more years of education they have, the better the outlook is for their future. By the year 2000, the vast majority of new jobs in the United States will require a postsecondary education.The welfare reform law states that in order to keep welfare benefits, people on welfare have to work 20 hours a week. The federal

Welfare to Work Programs

1045 words - 4 pages opportunity to improve their life. References (No Author) 1996 Personal Responsibility &Work Opportunity Reconciliation Act Retrieved April 2, 2011, from http://www.sourcewatch.org Dolgoff, R. & Feldstein. (2009). Understanding social welfare: A search for social justice. Boston, MA: Pearson Education Inc. Stryker, R., & Wald, P. (2009). Redefining Compassion to Reform Welfare: How Supporters of 1990s US Federal Welfare Reform Aimed for the Moral High Ground. Social Politics, 16(4), 519. Retrieved April 2, 2011, from Research Library. (Document ID: 1921506111).

The United States Welfare Programs

1081 words - 5 pages effective strategy, for the purpose of weeding out those who abuse Social programs, particularly the cash assistance, food stamps, housing assistance and Medicaid. Welfare is defined as a process or social effort intended to promote the basic physical and material well being of people in need. (Webster) Welfare or social programs in the United States is way that the federal or the local government provides supports for those who are less

The social welfare state

3767 words - 15 pages reform a success. (Murray, 1999) He cited a near fifty percent drop in welfare rolls since he took office as evidence of welfare reform's success. (Murray, 1999)Yes, welfare rolls have plummeted. That much was insured by welfare reform, but how have former recipients fared off welfare? According to the Children's Defense Fund, there was a 26% increase in the number of children living in extreme poverty, or half the federal poverty line, between

The Welfare Reform Debate

1171 words - 5 pages assistance, and imposing a work requirement on able-bodied recipients.Presently, welfare is an entitlement under which funds flow to all eligible recipients on the basis of need. The federal government pays from 50-80% of the costs, depending on the state. New proposals are being thrown around that would give a fixed amount to each state, that would no longer vary with the number of families needing assistance. Nearly all recent reform proposals assume

Politics and Poverty

1227 words - 5 pages Fraser, Caneel. A History of U.S. Federal Welfare Policy. Dec.2002<http://www.niu.edu/pub_ad/p326/hist2.htm> "Hispanic Radio Address on the Economy." Democratic National Committee. Raul Grijalva. 26 Oct. 2002. http://www.democrats.org/news/200210300002.html "Senate Republicans Back President's Welfare Reform Plan." United States Senate Republican Policy Committee. 18 June 2002. 8 Dec. 2002 <http://www.senate.gov/~rpc/releases/1999

Welfare in The United States

679 words - 3 pages benefiting without having to work. Others just simply felt it was not the federal government's responsibility to provide a Welfare system. As the system grew over the years so did the opposition to it. Criticism of the system reached an all time high during the 1980's and 1990's. In 1992, then presidential candidate, Bill Clinton promised welfare reform as part of his political platform and in 1996, The Personal Responsibility and Work Opportunity

This is an essay on welfare and research with statistics

1143 words - 5 pages welfare reform bills Congress has been considering have causedsome fear, both in the eyes of welfare recipients and advocates of the system.However, the reforms being considered are beneficial. There really is no reasonfor concern. The welfare bills do not mean that the Federal Government isgiving up the anti-poverty fight. Washington will still continue to spend over $20billion per year on aid to the poor. The difference, however, will be that

Welfare Reform: Promoting Independence and Self-Reliance

1985 words - 8 pages , said, " Now I'm starting to roll. I'm going to get my own apartment, I'm putting money in the bank, and I'm fixing on getting a car" (Naughton 106). Through the help of training programs like that in Grand Rapids, Michigan, most people that are leaving welfare are finding and keeping stable, full-time employment. Three years after the enactment of federal welfare reform, between sixty-one and eighty-seven percent of adults leaving public

Welfare Reform

1034 words - 4 pages and to change the downfall sure to come, the government needs to reform the accessibility and ownership of welfare because it defiles the reason why it was formed, it is creating a dependent nation, and effects taxpayers and people who really need government assistance. The federal government welfare programs in the United States were made to assist the unemployed or underemployed. The poor were the benefactors of the many government welfare

Similar Essays

The Welfare Reform Law Of 1996. This Is An "Explaining A Concept" Essay

566 words - 2 pages bill that was signed by President Clinton. The new law was expected to save $55 billion in welfare over six years. It also established a limit of five years for welfare payments to any family. The new law also required most adults to work within two years or loose benefits. In addition, welfare would now be administered by the states, which would receive block grants from the federal government. This was called welfare reform, the attempt to

Review Of The Book "Ending Welfare As We Know It"

849 words - 3 pages welfare strategies, including denial of additional benefits for children born or conceived while a mother received AFDC, work requirements, and time limits on receipt of cash benefits. The speed of change at the state level accelerated after the 1996 federal welfare reform legislation gave states better flexibility to design their programs. Until 1996, there was a situation of overwhelming public rejection of existing AFDC program. Candidate

Welfare Reform Essay

627 words - 3 pages is subject to the states approval.Casse says that there is something that distinguishes the current reform from all others. "[I]t has forced both federal and state governments to take seriously the idea that welfare policy can deter, or encourage, behavior". (231) This statement shows how reform is beginning to effect people in ways that the welfare policy might help them to choose to get off of the system for themselves. This would be a

Analysis Of The Welfare Reform In The Us

971 words - 4 pages the State. Welfare Reform The 1996 federal welfare reform law devolved to states unprecedented control over welfare policy while requiring a dramatic overhaul of their welfare rules and services. In August 1996, the Personal Responsibility and Work Opportunity Reconciliation Act reformed the nation's welfare laws. It created a new system of block grants to the States for Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (TANF) changing the nature and