Feminism And The Hard Boiled Genre: Breakdown In Sara Paretsky's Breakdown

2317 words - 9 pages

III. Readerly versus Writerly: Roland Barthes and the Hard-Boiled Genre
So to what extent does the hard-boiled genre lend itself to cultural and political appropriation? This question has continued to be posed since 1988 and contending responses have been suggested. On the one hand, it has been argued that crime fiction in general suffers from two features which render it inflexible and unsuitable in advancing political causes: conservatism, since the story needs a resolution whereby the status quo is restored, and masculinism, because the classic PIs are not only almost exclusively male but also misogynistic. On the other hand, given the success of authors such as Sara Paretsky and Sue Grafton, an equally strong case has been made in favor of the adaptability of this genre. I would like to assert (in agreement with Scaggs, Willett and Christianson) that new insight might be gained into this debate by drawing on the Barthesian contrast between the readerly and the writerly texts.
According to Barthes, there are two types of texts: the readerly (lisible) and the writerly (scriptible), each of which encourages a different kind of reading. The readerly text invites a passive reader who is inclined to accept the text’s meanings as already determined, “[p]lung[ing] him into a kind of idleness” and leaving him “with no more than the poor freedom either to accept or reject the text” (qtd. in Scaggs 74). This type of text typically reaffirms the ideology entrenched in it; further, it attempts to naturalize that ideology and make it seem commonsensical. Contrary to the readerly text, the writerly text aims “to make the reader no longer a consumer, but a producer of the text”. This kind of text encourages the reader to assume an active role in rewriting and revising the text in order to make sense of it. In other words, it invites the reader to participate in the construction of meaning.
Along this line of argument, the mystery novel, since its ultimate goal is narrative closure in solving the crime, falls into the category of the readerly text; however, it is less easy to give the hard-boiled novel the same label. Scaggs enumerates several reasons in favor of viewing the hard-boiled novel as a writerly text:
In the hard-boiled novel the private eye achieves only partial understanding or limited and temporary success. Furthermore, the characteristic first-person narrative of the hard-boiled novel is constructed around the divided, fragmented figure of the private eye, resulting in a multivalent text… (75)
The hard-boiled novel, therefore, can be considered writerly, “whose gaps and fissures encourage the reader to enter into the production of meaning.”
In a similar vein, Scott R. Christianson in his article, “A Heap of Broken Images: Hardboiled Detective Fiction and the Discourse(s) of Modernity”, likens the hard-boiled to the fragments of The Wasteland. He finds the “isolated modern hero sitting before a spectacle of modern chaos and trying to make sense...

Find Another Essay On Feminism and the Hard-Boiled Genre: Breakdown in Sara Paretsky's Breakdown

Community Breakdown and Crime Essay

9330 words - 37 pages findings lay an alternative to the traditional model of prosecutors as felony-case processors. But it is not hard to understand why the survey's findings failed to capture mainstream attention in prosecution as they did in policing. Much of prosecutors' work is shielded from public and professional scrutiny and tends not to arouse the same public concern as police abuses. A prosecutor's decision not to charge is far less visible to the public than a

The Breakdown of Ithaka Essay

699 words - 3 pages -217). They “eat their way” (1.220) through all of Odysseus’ food, and they are “not caring what they do” (2.59). The suitors disrespect Odysseus in this way, since none of them remember “how like a gentle father Odysseus ruled” (2.233-234). The most insolent suitor of them all is Antinoos, who refuses to “go anywhere else, until she takes an Akhaian to her liking” (2.128-129). All 108 of the suitors cause the breakdown of Ithakian society

The Massia Cultural Breakdown

1788 words - 7 pages culture has been around since the latter part of the first millennium (http://www.environmentalaction.net/kenya/kenya_policy_failure.html). They generally stay in the same area, unless they need to hunt the lion. Only when they are forced out by Westeners or animals will they abondon their homeplace. WORLD VIEW When looking at the World View it is important to remember it is timeless and must represent a fundamental set of assumptions, thoughts and

“Same Love” the Breakdown

1106 words - 5 pages If you watch the television or listen to the radio, then there is a good chance that you have been able to catch “Thrift Shop” by Macklemore. It is currently run on several radio stations and has over 100 million views on YouTube. I wouldn't say it is the best song out there, but it sure is catchy. Due to its “catchyness” I decided to check out other work by Macklemore. In doing this I discovered his song “Same Love” featuring Mary Lambert

Cinematic Styles in Sholay, women on the Verge of Nervous Breakdown, and Amores Perros

1399 words - 6 pages Sholay, Women on the verge of a Nervous Breakdown, and Amores Perros have very different cinematic styles; yet, are equally able to convey their messages effectively to their audience. These films span four decades (from the 1970s to 2000s), take place in very different countries; however, are all connected in that all three films are masterful works of cinematic genus and that globalization greatly affected each film. Sholay, a 1975

The Causes of Ophelia's Breakdown

837 words - 3 pages The Causes of Ophelia's Breakdown The play Hamlet is known for its eccentric plot and warped sense of reality as well as its fanatical characters. Hamlet himself created all the drama in the play with his pretend “madness” and his emotional outbursts, which lead to the destruction of almost all of the characters in the play. The most notable self destruction came from Ophelia, Hamlet’s object of affection. During the play, Ophelia had

The Physiological Breakdown of Hamlet

888 words - 4 pages The Physiological Breakdown of Hamlet      In Shakespeare's masterpiece Hamlet, the main character, Hamlet is overcome by a physiological breakdown. Hamlet was a sensitive man who was destroyed by a corrupt environment. Hamlet's dead father, the deeds of his uncle and mother, and the frequency of death caused the destruction of Hamlet.               First of all, the loss of any close family member is very traumatic. Hamlet is not

The Breakdown of a Manuscript and the Content

932 words - 4 pages The Breakdown of a Manuscript and the Content The introduction, located in the first paragraph of the manuscript, prepares the reader. It documents the main points covered and gives the reader insight into the rest of the paper. The synopsis of the article Management of Diabetes in the Dialysis Patient includes four crucial content areas, which are headings, abbreviations, crediting sources, and reference. Synopsis The supervision of dialysis

The History and Breakdown of the Glass Ceiling

2473 words - 10 pages The History and Breakdown of the Glass Ceiling The term the "glass ceiling" first came into use in 1986 when two Wall Street Journal reporters coined the phrase to describe the invisible barrier that blocks women from the top jobs in corporate America. (Glass Ceiling Commission,"Successful Initiatives "). Since then the metaphor has also been applied to the barriers of minorities. The Glass Ceiling Effect has been around for

The Breakdown of Lady Macbeth in William Shakespeare's Macbeth

1664 words - 7 pages The Breakdown of Lady Macbeth in William Shakespeare's Macbeth Throughout the play of Macbeth, Lady Macbeth goes through several drastic personality changes, which finally leads her to breakdown. In some ways I feel the breakdown and collapse of lady Macbeth is quite unexpected, but on the other end of the scale it could be seen to be inevitable. I will cover the points for and against, how the collapse could be seen to

Relationship of Breakdown in The Second Coming Poem

790 words - 4 pages The societal breakdown of the Ibo people can be harmonized to the poetry of Yeats during its collapse. The poem, “The second coming”, successfully describes the emotion felt by a person or persons during times of war, anarchy and even defeat. The African journey in this story and its untimely end are riddled with the very same emotion W.B Yeats expresses in his poetry. Both publications are a tale of pain expressed at different times, in

Similar Essays

How Does The Film Chinatown Endeavour To Alter The Hard Boiled Detective Genre, Give A Brief Discription

843 words - 3 pages The hard boiled detective subgenre has spawned many a film to have come out of Hollywood. Following a basic formula, the genre lives up to the expectations of the audience, while using the themes of crime and consequent justice. Unlike many hard boiled detective films of the noir persuasion, Chinatown isn't afraid to play with its constructed conventions. The story takes place in Los Angeles, California during the 1930's. The mood of the film is

The Breakdown And Restoration Of Order In Macbeth

1432 words - 6 pages The Breakdown and Restoration of Order in Macbeth     When Macbeth kills King Duncan in William Shakespeare's tragedy Macbeth, there is a breakdown of order throughout Scotland. This breakdown is evident through three main factors; within the person, mainly through Macbeth and Lady Macbeth, through the kingdom and through nature. From a completely ordered nation into the depths of chaos - Scotland collapsed from the lack of strong

The Breakdown Of Women In Combat Situations

1269 words - 5 pages Back in the Dark Ages, before feminism and egalitarianism enlightened us, conservatives used to claim that women just aren't suited for life in the military. Today, after a decade or so of applying enlightenment to the profession of arms, the Clinton administration is telling us that the military just isn't suited for women. However you phrase it, it comes out to the same thing.So perplexing have been the problems of sexually integrating the

The Breakdown Of Mental Health And Stability

1661 words - 7 pages The Breakdown of Mental Health and Stability Progress has always been an essential component in modern society. At times it is equivalent to success, learning, and overall growth. In the field of science, progress is measured by comparisons to what was known before, what is known now, and what can be known in the future. Therefore, one could say that much progress was made in the field of science in terms of understanding the functions