This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Feminism Taken To Extremes In A Streetcar Named Misogyny

4823 words - 19 pages

Feminism taken to Extremes in A Streetcar Named Misogyny

         
     As women's studies programs have proliferated throughout American universities, feminist "re-readings" of certain classic authors have provided us with the most nonsensical interpretations of these authors' texts. A case in point is that of Kathleen Margaret Lant's interpretation of Tennessee Williams' A Streetcar Named Desire in her essay entitled "A Streetcar Named Misogyny." Throughout the essay, she continually misreads Williams' intention, which of course causes her to misunderstand the play itself. Claiming that the play "has proved vexing to audiences, directors, actors, readers, and critics" (Lant 227), she fails to see that it is she herself who finds the play vexing, because it does not fit nicely into the warped feminist structure she would try to impose upon it.

 

Her first problem is with the heroine of the play, Blanche DuBois, who, she claims, is "ironically made guilty for her own victimization. No longer fully human, she is simply a metaphor of all that is vile about women. Blanche cannot, then, claim tragic stature or even our sympathy precisely because she is a victim of rape. And as she becomes responsible for her own victimization, Stanley is left to glory in his ascendancy. This aspect of Streetcar arises from the misogyny which colors the play…" (Lant 226).  Admittedly, Blanche does flirt with Stanley briefly at the beginning of the play—just as many women playfully flirt with their brothers-in-law. But as her relationship with Stanley deteriorates, she makes it quite obvious to him that she loathes the sight of him. Though the world in which Lant lives may be one in which a woman, playfully sprinkling her brother-in-law with perfume, justifies his subsequent rape of her, I daresay most of us do not live in such a world. Stanley's rape of Blanche is the action that sends him beyond the pale of civilized existence. That he gets away with murder hardly justifies his action; indeed, the audience's feelings of disgust with his character and his behavior are only heightened when he is left unpunished. 

 

Ironically, one of Lant's feminist mentors, Andrea Dworkin, whom she cites thrice in her essay, has written in her book Intercourse that "there is nothing in the text of the play, despite the way it is sometimes staged, to suggest that she [Blanche] wanted it [i.e. to be raped] all along. In fact, there is a pronounced and emotionally vivid history of her wanting its opposite—a sexuality of tenderness and sensitivity" (Dworkin 44).  Another of Lant's mentors, Susan Brownmiller, whom she cites twice in her paper, has written that "Tennessee Williams has always treated the rape theme with sensitivity. Stanley Kowalski's rape of Blanche DuBois in Streetcar Named Desire is also no glamorization, for Blanche, however damaged, represents fragility and aspiration while Stanley is symbolic of the darker forces of nihilism" (Brownmiller 337,...

Find Another Essay On Feminism Taken to Extremes in A Streetcar Named Misogyny

Gender Roles in A Streetcar Named Desire

2306 words - 9 pages as is too often the case, she is in complete control and dominates over them as Stanley dominates over Stella. Her masculinity and sexual power overwhelm her and turn her from a meek belle into an animal ready to pounce on the unwilling, where these targets for her are a dirty secret she can’t control her love for her sister is the salvation that she holds so tightly to. A Streetcar Named Desire is a hotbed in which gender roles run rampant

Stanley's Control in A Streetcar Named Desire

869 words - 3 pages Stanley's Control in A Streetcar Named Desire Remember what Huey Long said – Every Man is a King! - Explain how Stanley had his control, how he has had his kingship challenged and how he is trying to re-establish his control. “Remember what Huey Long said – “Every Man is a King!” Explain how Stanley had his control, how he has had his kingship challenged and how he is trying to re-establish his control. In the opening of “A

The Characters in A Streetcar Named Desire

2138 words - 9 pages A Streetcar Named Desire is a classic tragedy written by Tennessee Williams, which earned him the Pulitzer Prize as well as many other awards. This brilliant play explores many important themes and issues. The main recurring theme Williams explores to the readers is the conflict between fantasy and reality, honesty and lies. However, sexuality, violence, and social differences also shape the action of the plot, in which they contribute to the

A Streetcar Named Desire

1279 words - 6 pages Annotated Bibliography Henthorne, Susan. "A Streetcar Named Desire." Masterplots, Fourth Edition (2010): 1-4. Literary Reference Center. Web 2 Dec. 2013. William Portrays in this play the reality of people's lives. It has a frank presentation of sexual issues. It was not meant to foresee the autobiographical elements of his life, but to show the reality of people's everyday lives. Dramatic devices are often used in this play to

A Streetcar Named Desire

869 words - 3 pages A Streetcar Named Desire is widely considered as one of those classic movies that marked one period of time. This movie presents a sharp critique of the way the institutions and attitudes of postwar America placed restrictions on women's lives. Williams uses Blanche's and Stella's dependence on men to expose and critique the treatment of women during the transition from the old to the new South. The fact that the movie was made in black and

a streetcar named desire

1270 words - 6 pages A Streetcar Named Desire is a Pulitzer Prize-Winning play. The film was nominated for twelve nominations and was awarded four Oscars. It is a stage play with elements of tragedy. The play opened at the Ethel Barrymore Theater in New York City on December 3, 1947. The producer of the play Charles Feldman sold the production to the Warner Bros. The play was written by Tennessee Williams. Williams is considered the greatest Southern playwright and

A Streetcar Named Desire

742 words - 3 pages All relationships have their ups and down; the effects of these quarrels may lead to violence or love. William Tennessee's A Streetcar Named Desire is a story about two sisters Stella and Blanche DuBois. The older, Blanche, arrives in her sister and brother in law, Stanley Kowalski's, relationship. Blanche used to live in a house named Bell Reve, which she didn't have anywhere to go. The arrival of Blanche highlighted and traced the violence and

A Streetcar Named Desire - 1151 words

1151 words - 5 pages In A Streetcar Named Desire, Tennessee Williams focuses on Blanche's deception, paradoxically also identifying her as the most honest character in the play. He thus asks his audience to question whether true honesty is accepting harsh reality or recognizing the human need for magic, idealism, and lies to cope with life.Fantasy is a product of the imagination that one creates to escape the harsh realities of life. Blanche realizes her need to

A Streetcar Named Desire - 1160 words

1160 words - 5 pages Tennessee Williams vividly describes mid-twentieth century New Orleans, as he perceived it, through his play ?A Streetcar Named Desire?. His primary goal in the first scene seemed to be to portray the vast difference between the inhabitants of a city, New Orleans, and the more country-inclined folk, like the main character, Blanche Dubois. However in order to effectively do this, he was sure to set a striking scene.The stage directions in the

A Streetcar Named Desire - 1877 words

1877 words - 8 pages The drama A Streetcar Named Desire is one of Tennessee Williams most well-known plays. Blanche DuBois seeks refuge in her sister’s home after the loss of their ancestral home, the Belle Reve plantation. Her little sister, no more than a year younger than she, shares her home with her husband. During Blanche’s stay, she attempts to escape her past, start afresh, and attract a new suitor to settle down. However, she is tormented by her aggressive

A Streetcar Named Desire - 805 words

805 words - 3 pages to defeat Blanche by raping her. ?She could not escape the reality of her imprisonment in the small flat with Stanley and her dreams about Shep Huntleigh(a rich man from Blanche?s past) succumbs to physical reality after Stanley raped her? says Londre.(60) Stella is packing Blanche?s belongings while Blanche was bathing. Stella has said that she has made arrangements for her sister and Blanche has taken this mean that Shep was coming for her. But

Similar Essays

Beliefs Taken To The Extremes Essay

1811 words - 7 pages Beliefs Taken to the Extremes          Belief is a fundamental human trait. Belief in many things is what helps humans continue living their lives. Religious beliefs are one of the strongest forces of human emotion and often times those emotions can create dangerous situations. When people's religious beliefs are taken to extreme levels innocent people can be hurt. All throughout history there have been examples of just such incidents

Themes In A Streetcar Named Desire

891 words - 4 pages     The play A Streetcar Named Desire revolves around Blanche DuBois; therefore, the main theme of the drama concerns her directly. In Blanche is seen the tragedy of an individual caught between two worlds-the world of the past and the world of the present-unwilling to let go of the past and unable, because of her character, to come to any sort of terms with the present. The final result is her destruction. This process began long before her

Death In A Streetcar Named Desire

999 words - 4 pages Death in A Streetcar Named Desire Tennessee Williams uses the theme of death continually in the play ‘A Streetcar Named Desire’ through the use of dramatic imagery and literal references. The characters of Blanche and Mitch are used the most frequently to express Williams’ own obsession with death. Though neither of the characters actually obsesses about death, Blanche’s life has been smothered by the deaths of those she loves and the

Blanche Du Bois In A Streetcar Named Desire

1315 words - 5 pages While watching A Streetcar named Desire, the character of Blanche Dubois at first appeared to be a weak self-absorbed southern woman, when really what started coming from her character was a flawed personality. What is not known is whether this is something that runs in the family, or has only shown itself through Blanche. Since this was during a time when mental illness was not yet studied deeply, the way Blanche is treated while