Fight Club: A Better Movie Than Pulp Fiction

831 words - 3 pages

Mike Brennan

Per. 1 English

05 / 19 / 2005

Debate Composition

Is Fight Club a Better Movie than Pulp Fiction?

PRO

There are many ways to declare one thing better than another. Be it through the message sent, the money made, or the critic's reviews, we have made that distinction between the two movies, Pulp Fiction, and Fight Club. Fight Club comes out as the overall winner in many categories that we use to define greatness. My intent was to prove this through a multitude of arguments, primarily through the themes, issues, stimulation, and quality of acting in both movies.

Fight Club contains better themes than Pulp Fiction. For example, with the theme of honor. It is not so much on the surface as it is a theme you discover as the story moves along. This is much more complex than the themes of Pulp Fiction, which are visible for the most part. The same can be said of the theme of freedom. The plot gets you thinking one way, and by the end after all the twists and turns, you realize that the story was a lot deeper than you expected. Once again this trumps the plot and theme of Pulp Fiction, where a story is laid out for you and the themes are not hidden whatsoever. While the themes are more complex, Fight Club also finds a way to integrate more common issues and situations as well.

In Fight Club, the common man is used as the main character. One way he is shown to be Joe Everyman, so to speak, is through his anonymity. The fact that he is kept anonymous (named only Narrator) proves the point of the story that this could be any one of us; that a rebellion against Corporate America can be started by an average person. Pulp Fiction, on the other hand, deals with issues that basically only gangsters face, as you follow Jules and Vincent primarily through their one day adventure of murder and cover-ups. Basically every person can relate to the pressures of living under a nation run by Big Business, whereas the gang mentality can not be associated with the majority of us. In the transition from common man to rebellion leader, Edward Norton shows great versatility in his acting as well.

The quality of acting is much greater and the roles are harder to take on in Fight Club...

Find Another Essay On Fight Club: A Better Movie than Pulp Fiction

Essay on Fight Club the movie.

987 words - 4 pages Fight Club tells the story of an everyday man who wanders from the safety of his nine-to-five life into a no-man's-land of violence and social destruction. The protagonist, played by Edward Norton, is a white-collared American nobody who joins an underground boxing society and engages in bare fisted fighting in an attempt to recover his sense of manhood. How did he lose it...

Write about a movie/film and the significance behind it. I choose Fight Club by David Fincher

3246 words - 13 pages When does life have no purpose?David Fincher's Fight Club is a narrated movie that explains the journey of the narrator's mid-life crisis; the movie begins with the ending scene, a microscopic view of a gun inside of the narrator's mouth. All of the particles...

"Today's Entertainment: Social Commentary or Not?" Argumentative essay based on book Fight Club and movie Secret Window. 1st Draft, got a great criteria score. Includes works cited.

1334 words - 5 pages Social commentary is the act of imparting one's opinion on the nature of society to another person. This is usually used with the idea of bringing a change in society by means of informing the general populace of a given problem. Problems range in topic and relevance from racism, poverty, and child abuse, to greed, individual identity, and chasing The American Dream. W.H....

Not in Control of Our Own Destiny: The Movie "Stranger than Fiction"

1066 words - 4 pages Unwilling changes or turning points are often employed by authors to aid the characters in acquiring better attitudes towards life. In the film Stranger than Fiction written by Zach Helm, turning points are used this way through Harold Crick. Harold’s realization of being powerless to avoid his fateful death provides a turning point that induces Harold’s transformation into a more emotional and passionate individual who lives every minute of his...

The Setting in the Ambrose Bierce’s Story “An Occurrence at Owl Creek Bridge” is better than in the Movie

712 words - 3 pages Student's Last Name 1 Spurlock PAGE 1 Tracy SpurlockDr. S. ThompsonEnglish 130212 April 2010The Setting in the Ambrose Bierce's Story "An Occurrence at Owl Creek Bridge" is better than in the Movie.Ambrose Bierce's short story "An Occurrence at Owl Creek...

My Place by Sally Morgan in relation to the movie Fight Club by David Fincher, the painting Cathedral by Jackson Pollock and the poem Kith of Infinity by Somtow Sucharitkul

4076 words - 16 pages My Place by Sally Morgan (Fight Club, Cathedral and Kith of Infinity) Fight Club Fight Club is a movie directed by David Fincher and written by Chuck Palahniuk. It is a satire on the dehumanizing effects of consumer culture that forms the backbone of the American Dream as it tells the story of an unnamed man, a child of generation X, "a generation of men raised by women", who is on a journey to recover his sense of masculinity....

Fight Club: A Controversial Classic

1062 words - 4 pages The film Fight Club has generated controversy from the very moment it was released. Critics have both acclaimed and denounced this film. At the same time, it has been a fan favorite, ranking 14 on IMDB’s Top 250 Chart. On one hand, the film Fight Club lacks in its originality and unrealistic plot. On the other hand, it displays exceptional acting. Ultimately, Fight Club fails to deliver, leaving the audience disappointed. The story revolves...

Optimizing Chloroquine to Make a Better Drug to Fight Malaria

1302 words - 5 pages Optimizing Chloroquine to Make a Better Drug to Fight Malaria Abstract: Malaria has haunted man for centuries. Humanities experiments in drugs allowed for the discovery of chloroquine, perhaps the most successful cure against the parasitic infection. However, a new strain of malaria, plasmodium falciparum, has proven to be resistant against chloroquine and other cures we have for this virulent disease. Should man then cast aside this...

Absolute Monarchy May Be Better than a Democratic Government

654 words - 3 pages Nick Odabashian March 16, 2014 Absolute Monarchy Many people will question whether an absolute monarchy is better than a democratic form of government. Absolute monarchy is a much smarter idea due to the fact that it can provide the stability to a country or a nation that democracy in many situations is unable to provide. A big factor in the difference between a monarchy and a democracy includes how the successor comes into play. In a democracy,...

Telling The Truth Is Better Than Creating A Lie

1925 words - 8 pages The Crucible is a play written by Arthur Miller in the year 1953. The play is based on the actual historical event- the Salem Witch Trials of 1692- in which twenty people died due to hangings while seventeen died in prison. There are so many people can be blamed for the witch trials. One of those people would be John Proctor, because if he had not had that affair with Abigail before the witch-hunts, she would not have danced in the woods,...

Little man against the system film analysis-fight club&a clockwork orange

2154 words - 9 pages "You are not your job.You are not how much you have in the bank.You are not the contents of your wallet.You are not your fucking Khakis.You are not a beautiful and unique snowflake.You are the all-singing, all-dancing crap ofthe world."~Tyler~If this is the case, who we really are is the question that we should ask ourselves. Human beings are in a constant seeking. We are all seeking for...

Similar Essays

Fight Club: Movie Review

1040 words - 4 pages In a time when so few motion pictures leave an impact, Fight Club refuses to be ignored or dismissed. The experience lingers, demanding to be pondered and considered, and, unlike most of the modern-day thrillers, there is a great deal here to think about and argue over. Fight Club presents an overload of thought-provoking material that works on so many...

Review Of The Movie "Pulp Fiction" By Quentin Tarantino

1054 words - 4 pages A soft, moist, shapeless mass of matter. 2. A magazine or book containing lurid subject matter and being characteristically printed on rough, unfinished paper. This is the exotic, but extremely fitting and appropriate, opening to the 1994 film, Pulp Fiction. Directed by Quentin Tarantino, this film is unpredictable, surprising, and possibly offensive. It forces action and thrill-seeker cineastes to dispose of all predictions and prepositions....

Fight Club: Consumerism And Globalization A Look Into One Of The Main Themes Of The Movie, Fight Club.

527 words - 2 pages Fight Club: Consumerism and GlobalizationConsumerism and globalization have a huge influence on us and the characters in the film, "Fight Club." What the main character, "Jack," said, "You are not the car you drive" is very true. In the world we live in, we are all the same. We all wear brand name clothes and drive brand name cars. Our khakis and...

Film Analysis Of The Movie "Fight Club"

1155 words - 5 pages For years David Fincher has directed some of the most stylish and creative thrillers in American movies. His works include: Aliens 3, Seven, The Game and Fight Club. Each of these films has been not only pleasing and fun to watch but each has commented on society, making the viewers think outside the normal and analyze their world. Fight Club is no...