This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Finding Contentment In Mr. And Mrs. Elliot

1526 words - 6 pages

Finding Contentment in Mr. and Mrs. Elliot

 
     Ernest Hemingway's "Mr. and Mrs. Elliot" ultimately leaves us with a paradox. From its opening line, the story defines the marriage of Hubert and Cornelia as a marriage of failure: failure to conceive a child, failure to communicate, failure to have good sex. Indeed, the story's opening image seems the perfect metaphor for the marriage as a whole: "Mr. and Mrs. Elliot tried very hard to have a baby. They tried as often as Mrs. Elliot could stand it" (161). The Elliots' marriage is one of unfulfilled desires-of trying as much as one "can stand it", but never achieving success. Nevertheless the story's final line asserts, "they were all quite happy." How can we reconcile the failures of this marriage with contentment? One tactic might be to assert that Hemingway was being cute when he said they were all quite happy, and the reader is expected to infer that they were really quite unhappy. While I acknowledge that Hemingway had a penchant for understatements and paradox, I think the Elliots are in a very real sense content with the state their marriage ultimately finds itself in, despite their unfulfilled desires.

 

To find out why, we must first clarify who "they" are at the story's close. It isn't simply Hubert and Cornelia-it also includes Cornelia's girl friend from the tea shop in Boston. The presence of this friend has a noticeable effect on Mrs. Elliot from the moment of her arrival-Cornelia becomes "much brighter" and the two of them have "many good cries together" (163). This friend also takes to typing Mr. Elliot's poetry for him, as she is "very neat and efficient and seems to enjoy it" (164). Cornelia used to type his manuscripts, but she would make mistakes, which Hubert was "very severe about" (163). Her friend is simply much better at it.

 

It is interesting that Hemingway never gives the girl friend a name; perhaps we are meant to infer that Hubert himself (from whose perspective the story is more or less told) doesn't know the girl's name. Similarly, while the story notes that "Cornelia had taught him to call her Calutina" (162), the story itself never refers to her using that name. I think it's reasonable to believe that while Hubert may call her Calutina to please her, he still thinks of her as Cornelia. The sort of closeness that the use of a nickname implies does not really exist between them; in his mind, she is always Cornelia. The girl friend, in contrast, calls Cornelia "Honey", not because she was taught to do so but simply because she cares for her (163).

 

Hemingway also notes that the girls cry "together", whereas Cornelia always cries around Hubert but never with him. Indeed, often Cornelia is crying because of her husband. Nowhere is this more evident that in Dijon, where Hemingway writes, "She cried a good deal and they tried several times to have a baby before they left Dijon" (163). Hubert's and Cornelia's expectations about marriage...

Find Another Essay On Finding Contentment in Mr. and Mrs. Elliot

A Comparison of Mrs. Hale and Mr. Wright in Trifles, by Susan Glaspell

1342 words - 5 pages slightly different means. Susan Glaspell presents Mr. Wright and Mrs. Hale as having contrasting and comparable characteristics. While Mrs. Hale and Mr. Wright differ in terms of emotions, they are similar in their cleanliness and are well respected by others. Mr. Wright was a cruel, cold, and heartless man. He was also a very unsociable man. He abandoned his wife's contentment and paid very little attention to his wife's opinions. He even

The Elements of Fortune and Contentment Dissected in Great Expectations

828 words - 4 pages is not always perfect whether someone is rich or poor. In the novel, Great Expectations, Charles Dickens uses the element of fortune and social class to show the dynamic of how wealth doesn’t guarantee contentment. Joe Gargery, Pip's brother-in-law and a benevolent blacksmith , is very satisfied with his status as a member of the lower class. He believes that he’s “wrong out of the forge” (224) and well off working in what he senses is his

Comparing the Ways in Which Mrs. Casper, Mr. Sugden and Mr. Farthing Treat Billy in A Kestrel for a Knave by Barry Hines

1046 words - 4 pages Comparing the Ways in Which Mrs. Casper, Mr. Sugden and Mr. Farthing Treat Billy in A Kestrel for a Knave by Barry Hines I am going to compare how these three characters, Mrs. Casper, Mr.Sugden and Mr. Farthing treat Billy, a 14 year old boy, living up north in a rough school and he has quite a hard time. Mrs. Casper, who is Billy's mother, has no time for Billy "Oh stop pestering me! I'm late enough as it is!" She finds

Compare the ways that Mr Briggs and Mrs Kay are presented in 'Our Day Out'. With whom does Willy Russell intend us to sympathise?

1217 words - 5 pages Our Day out by Willie Russell is an energetic and humorous play, about a school trip to Conwy castle. The 'progress class', a class for illiterate children, are on a trip to Wales where the liberal Mrs Kay and the strict Mr Briggs have completely different ideas about the day should be organised.Mrs Kay and Mr Briggs have two distinct personalities that clash frequently throughout the play and Willie Russell presents both in an interesting and

Finding Truth in Math, Arts, and Ethics

1284 words - 5 pages arts. Overall, the approaches toward finding the truth within mathematics, the arts and ethics vary, but the final truth is intertwined. Works Cited Bernardin, Andrew. "Four Types of Truth." The Evolving Mind. N.p., 15 June 2008. Web. 25 Jan. 2010. . Lamb, Robert. "How are Fibonacci numbers expressed in nature?" HowStuffWorks. Discovery Communications, 24 June 2008. Web. 28 Jan. 2010. . Rowse, Darren. "Rule of Thirds." Digital Photography School. N.p., 2009. Web. 29 Jan. 2010. .

Finding clarity in Buddhism, Christianity, and Philosophy

3288 words - 13 pages Finding clarity in Buddhism, Christianity, and Philosophy There are many things in life that work to guide us to ultimate transcendence. Philosophy and Theology (specifically Buddhism and Christianity) each employ different concepts for allowing people passage to some harmonious place. Although each following is, in part, correct in their assumption of how to sustain a meaningful life, I find that the only religion that is relevant in

The Importance of Mrs. Hale and Mrs. Peters in Susan Glaspell's Trifles

1124 words - 4 pages the bird infuriated Mrs. Wright and caused her to exact revenge upon Mr. Wright. She thought it was only just that she kill John in the same fashion that he killed the bird, by strangulation. The evidence against Mrs. Wright mounts as the play proceeds, but the women stay "loyal to their sex" (130) and keep these clues from the men. Perhaps Mrs. Hale and Mrs. Peters begin feeling sorry for Mrs. Wright, or perhaps neither knows how to handle

Social Status in Mrs. Dalloway and Pride and Prejudice

1646 words - 7 pages are able to get invited to the parties and afford the right things, and more related to wealth. While in Pride and Prejudice social status is all about marriage and status over love. In Mrs. Dalloway, Clarissa was in love with Richard Dalloway and still is. Mr. Dalloway is very much in love with Mrs. Dalloway, as well as Peter was once very in love with Clarissa and may even still be. Love does not control their lives, but their lives are not only controlled by status either, unlike in Pride and Prejudice, where status is all that matters in life, and the rest will follow.

How the Police are Depicted in The Blue Lamp and Billy Elliot

3529 words - 14 pages though the habitants of the district are used to, and have become familiar with, the seemingly strong force surrounding the community. Billy ignores the police, and they do not see him as they plan another day controlling the picket line and the increasing number of miners encompassed in the violent resistance to the strike-breakers, including Tony and Mr. Elliot. Billy, much to the disgust of the father, is interested in

The Representation of Gender in the Films Bend it Like Beckham and Billy Elliot

2357 words - 9 pages The Representation of Gender in the Films Bend it Like Beckham and Billy Elliot The society we live in today is full of stereotypes. Each job, sport, item of clothing carries and many more carries a certain stereotype. When people go against and challenge these stereotypes they are seen as strange and unconventional and can end up stuck with these stereotypes for life. In both films Billy Elliot and Bend it like

Media Devices Used in Bend It like Beckham and Billy Elliot

1575 words - 6 pages Media Devices Used in Bend It like Beckham and Billy Elliot Narratives are constructed in many different ways; narrative editing, narrative music, cinematography and mis en scene. This assignment will take you through media devises and method used by the directors of "Bend it like Beckham" and "Billy Elliot" use to construct their narratives. The plots of both films are based on stereotypes and how the main characters

Similar Essays

All About Mr. And Mrs. Bennet

706 words - 3 pages silly and ignorant, Mrs. Bennet exclaims, “Mr. Bennet, how can you abuse your own children in such way? You take delight in vexing me. You have no compassion on my poor nerves.'' Bennet replies, ''You mistake me, my dear. I have a high respect for your nerves. They are my old friends. I have heard you mention them with consideration these twenty years at least”. He not only has a relationship with his wife, but he does not care about his daughters

Evaluating Mr And Mrs Bennet As Parents

954 words - 4 pages Evaluating Mr and Mrs Bennet as Parents In the 21st century, the definition of a 'good parent' remains clouded and vague. It is basically down to the judgement of the parent raising their children in a way that they view appropriate. The same goes for the 18th century and every other century before and beyond. Parenting styles can be

The Murder Of Mr. And Mrs. Borden

1403 words - 6 pages poisoned he was very unconvinced about this fact. Lizzie was the one who attempted to poison Mr. and Mrs. Borden (“Lizzie Borden”). During this time at the Borden House they had a maid that lived at their house. Their maid was an Irish immigrant. The maid’s name was Bridget Sullivan. Bridget started working at the Borden house in 1889. One day when Bridget, Lizzie and Emma were the only ones that were home there was a robbery at the Borden house

Essay On Mr. And Mrs. Bennet's Parenting In Pride And Prejudice

1494 words - 6 pages Analysis of Mr. and Mrs. Bennet's Parenting in Pride and Prejudice   The roles of Mr. and Mrs. Bennet in Jane Austen’s novel Pride and Prejudice are contrasted between a father who cares about what’s inside of people and a mother who only worries about vanity and appearance. Mr. and Mrs. Bennet’s parental guidance is unique to their personalities. Because of their two opposing personas, Mr. and Mrs. Bennet’s ideas of marriage are