Finding The Nation: The Issues With Modern Immigration Policies In The United States

1661 words - 7 pages

In the dawn of the 21st century the typical impression an American can hold when the word ‘immigration’ is brought up may include a lot of controversey. Immigration in the late 18th century was essentially a norm for the newfound American society. With Congress introducing bills like Arizona’s SB 1070 it is quite apparent that immigration is now one of America’s biggest discussions in U.S. Politics. Two interpretationa of the topic at hand can be illustrated by examining Jacob Hornberger’s essay “Keep the Borders Open” and Peter Brimlow’s essay “A Nation of Immigrants”. Jacob Hornberger makes it clear in his opinion that the main cause of an immigration problem is the establishment of laws restricting immigration; which he believes that the founders of the United States would not condone restrictions on immigrants. In comparison, Peter Brimelow takes a definitive approach by addressing America’s lack of homogeneity, which Brimelow feels is an essential characteristic of a nation. In both essays each author takes an indirect stance on the topic of immigration. Hornberger implies that people should be allowed to do and live freely. Brimelow argues that America is not so much a nation, but a ‘polity’ and the only way for the United States to become a nation is to restrict immigration and begin a process that would lead to unity and homogeneity.
Jacob Hornberger
Jacob Hornberger urges the reader to look at a time in American history not only before immigration restriction, but also government interference in its citizen’s lives. By this the author means Social Services, Welfare, and other programs. He states that “[T]he bedrock principle underlying American society was that people should be free to live their lives any way they chose.” and goes on to relate this to the concept of ‘freedom’ that Americas founding fathers intended on (Miller 525). The author feels as though the government is playing too big of a role in the American people’s lives leading to the utter failure of what this country was meant to be. In the 20th century immigration restrictions began to arise giving birth to even more negative consequences as described by Hornberger. At one point, America, on the world stage this country could be seen as a land of “freedom” in which a person could seek opportunity and escape the harsh restriction of a parent country. Hornberger then reveals the “voyage of the damned” along with other events in the 20th century when the United States put restrictions on persons allowed entry during time of strife or tyranny in parent countries. At this point, this idea of a worldly safe zone has now completely diminished.
In this argument Hornberger takes the more deductive approach of addressing his opinions or solutions to many of the concerns that have led the American people to question whether immigration laws should be more strictly enforced or relaxed. The three concerns mentioned that stood out amongst others are: immigrant abuse of...

Find Another Essay On Finding the Nation: The Issues with Modern Immigration Policies in the United States

United States Policies toward the Sioux Indian Nation.

1260 words - 5 pages per acre to the Lakota or as Black Elk states "the Black Hills would be just like melting snow held in our hands, because the Wasichus would take that country anyway" (Neihardt 81). After making the offer Crook held individual meetings with almost every tribe leader and that simply the United States had taken advantage of the weakened Lakota Nation once again.These policies and actions are perfect examples of how this nation of proud people was

Gun Policies in the United States

720 words - 3 pages “Our big concern is to make sure that guns get into the hands of only those who know how to use them. Guns don’t kill people. People kill people.” -NRA slogan. Many citizens believe in this quote but many do not. Some say guns should be out overall; although, this would change the independence of the United States. The largest issue is mass murders with high powered artillery. American's say that guns are killing people and if we had no guns we

Immigration Policy in the United States

2012 words - 8 pages            We are now in the 21st century and like the beginning of the 20th century the United States finds itself in the throes of a period of mass immigration. More then one million immigrants enter the Unites States, both legally and illegally every single year. Many argue that this new wave of mass immigration may help sustain the success that our nation is having in regard to the way of living that many American have come accustomed to

Illegal Immigration In The United States

1221 words - 5 pages U.S. Illegal immigration is a major threat to the country’s homeland security policies however some states are threatened by it more than others. Therefore, the immigration problem facing Florida and the rest of this Nation exposes pressing issues of border control, security issues, and economic stability. The country’s state borders are a passageway into the Nation. The insufficiency of security causes the country to become defenseless to

History of Immigration in the United States

1958 words - 8 pages Throughout the history of the United States immigration has become apart of our country’s fabric which, began centuries ago. Only to become a hot topic in the US in recent years with its primary focus being illegal immigrants. Illegal immigration is when people enter a country without government permission. As of 2008 the Center for Immigration Studies estimated that there are 11 million illegal immigrants in the US which is down from 2007‘s

Immigration in the United States of America

1118 words - 4 pages the book of Current Issues the United States has always benefited from the hard work and cultural diversity that new comers bring to the country which considers itself "a nation of immigrants." (Farrell, Tiffany 2006.) Nonetheless, the terrorist attack of September 11, 2001 committed by nineteen foreign-born men was the evidence of the fact that more attention should be paid to immigrants and more quotas should be introduced. In order to improve

Illegal Immigration in the United States

1143 words - 5 pages Illegal Immigration The people of the United States are now showing higher dissatisfaction rates with the present US government, than that which was ever shown in the past; of course, they have very good reason to feel this way. One such example where the blatant incompetence and callous attitude of Congress

Pro Immigration in the United States

1332 words - 5 pages century when the English established settlements on Plymouth and Jamestown, which were originally the Native Americans. Notice where I?m going with this? No, ok, read on. Most of the Immigrants were European, until the passage of the Immigration Act was abolished in1965. Approximately one million Immigrants enter the US each year, and about 500,000 come in illegally. (Duignan). Lawmakers have attempted to revise immigration policies and crack

Immigration and Nativism in the United States

2141 words - 9 pages Immigration and Nativism in the United States In the United States, the cliché of a nation of immigrants is often invoked. Indeed, very few Americans can trace their ancestry to what is now the United States, and the origins of its immigrants have changed many times in American history. Despite the identity of an immigrant nation, changes in the origins of immigrants have often been met with resistance. What began with white

Illegal Immigration in the United States

930 words - 4 pages Illegal immigration in the US is and has been an ongoing battle for many years. According to legal-dictionary an illegal immigrant is define as an alien (non-citizen) who has entered the united sates without government permission or stayed beyond the termination date of a visa. There are many problems that occur such as overpopulation, raising crime rates and unemployment. Some Americans have issues with illegal immigration and some do not

Immigration to the United States

759 words - 3 pages industry, and was deemed a success for the American agriculture business. The Mexican-American border did not close after the closure of the Bracero program in 1964. Undocumented immigration was still a useful tool for the agricultural business. Until a speech by President Ronald Reagan in 1985, when Regan claimed that the United States had “lost control” of the immigration of Mexican workers into the United States. With these words

Similar Essays

Immigration In The United States Essay

1983 words - 8 pages Immigration is what has made America what it is today. An immigrant is a person who comes to a country to take up permanent residence. Everyone in the United States of America is an immigrant either moving here themselves or being directly related to someone who did. All of us came from different parts of the world even as far back as the Native Americans when they emigrated from Asia to the United States. Immigration is needed to grow America

Immigration In The United States Essay

2115 words - 8 pages believe that the government should open the borders and have open immigration. Increased immigration to the United States would help to contribute to the country's technological advancement, help with labor needs, increase tax revenues, and improve U.S. competitiveness in the world economy (Simon 55). Immigrants improve the job market by increasing the demand for labor. People believe that the only way to raise the nations productivity is to

Immigration In The United States Essay

1104 words - 4 pages of the entire population. With this rapid increase in diversity, many citizens have opposing views on its impact on the United States. In my opinion, an increase in immigration does contain both positive and negatives effects, but in general it provides an overriding positive influence on America’s society (“Population”). In 2007, the White House issued this statement in hopes to influence a Congressional debate: “Immigration has a positive

Immigration In The United States Essay

1338 words - 5 pages Latinos and Asians also came to America as immigrants. Immigration has helped the United States by giving a helping hand and providing a workforce to deal with America’s growing manufacturing economy. In 1880-1930 more than 27 million new immigrants came to America from Italy, Germany, Europe, Russia, England, Canada, Ireland, and Sweden. Apart from all these countries, Mexico is the largest immigration source country. Chinese and Indian immigrants