Finding Truth In Constructivist Psychotherapy Essay

2050 words - 8 pages

Finding Truth in Constructivist Psychotherapy

Science is a construction of the human mind. The theories, approaches, and methods that are used in any scientific field have gradually developed over time to become an objective standard of evaluation. As science continues to evolve, new approaches to obtaining knowledge about the world around us must be considered, and at the same time these new approaches must be evaluated within the present context of what is considered to be science. In doing so, conflict and confusion will arise as new concepts meet the critical evaluation of the old. The appraisal of and criticism of a new approach to psychological therapy is one example of such a situation. By looking at the evaluation of constructivist psychotherapy, one can bring this conflict and confusion into the light of understanding.

Since its dawning at the turn of the century, psychotherapy has faced a myriad of objections in regard to its validity as a scientific practice. With the introduction of psychoanalysis in the late 1800’s, Freud opened the doors to a field that would mature as the next one hundred years progressed. Throughout its evolution, psychotherapy has been evaluated for its capacity to deal with clients on an individual basis and at the same time maintain the objective viewpoint which science requires. In what Robert Neimeyer considers a "postmodern context" of scientific, social and political themes, a new philosophical approach to psychotherapy has developed. This approach, called constructivism, is based on a subjective interpretation of reality and how that interpretation affects human thought processes. In "An Appraisal of Constructivist Psychotherapies", Neimeyer looks at how constructivism has developed in psychotherapy, how it has diverged into various sub-fields, what valuable contributions it brings to the ever-advancing field, and finally what problems lie in this subjective approach.

In the article titled "Constructivism in Psychotherapy: Truth and Consequences," Professor Barbara Held criticizes the constructivist approach for its antirealist claims. She reasons that the subjective nature of constructivist therapy disallows the knower from coming to any conclusions that are founded on an independent, objective reality. Rather, "knowers make, invent, constitute, create, construct, or narrate, in language, their own subjective realities…".1 In her analysis of this alternative method of psychotherapy, Held takes a straightforward, logical approach that leads her to conclude that constructivism is not an acceptable, standardized means of therapy. She walks the reader through the distinctions between realism and antirealism, the consequences of yielding to subjective therapy, and evidence that such therapy does appeal to antirealist doctrine. However, she oversimplifies the true essence of contructivist psychotherapy. By reducing it to the absurd she does not give a full view of the complexity that is involved...

Find Another Essay On Finding Truth in Constructivist Psychotherapy

Langdon Winner's Article: Upon Opening the Black Box and Finding it Empty: Social Constructivism and the Philosophy of Technology

1666 words - 7 pages artefacts in the context of society and explores the dynamics of technological change. According to Pinch and Bijker (1987), social constructivism is “fundamentally a sociological approach towards technology”. This school of research attempts to understand the mechanisms behind different social groups’ interpretations of technological artefacts. In his article titled “Upon Opening the Black Box and Finding It Empty: Social Constructivism and

Encouraging Constructivism in today's classroom Essay

2153 words - 9 pages look at the new information as irrelevant and discard it. The constructivist theory asserts that we are active learners and creators of our own knowledge. Due to the way humans operate and because not everyone things and looks at things the same way constructivism divides learning into two types: accommodation and assimilation. Hence, the focus is now on the individual’s desire and ability to learn, and the teacher or therapist in some instances

The Benefits of Narrative Therapy

2029 words - 8 pages an Australian children’s hospital. It was there that he became disenchanted with conventional models of psychotherapy. This led him to study some of Michael Foucault’s constructivist concepts about how people are marginalized by the meta-narratives of society. Foucault theorized that the “experts” in society created narratives that oppressed people who did not live up to standards of a given society. Eventually these narratives become part

An Overview of Counseling and Psychotherapy

1297 words - 5 pages treatment of people with milder psychological problems or to advice given on vocational and educational matters. Counseling psychologists usually work in schools or industrial firms, advising and assisting people. Today the distinction between psychotherapy and counseling is quite blurred, and many mental health professionals use the terms interchangeably. III. Presentation and Discussion Psychotherapy is an important form of treatment for

Anas Harthieh

2051 words - 9 pages factors in human decision-making. Such positivism seeks to explain social phenomena by simplifying and excluding factors that interrupt the creation of a module to predict or interpret the social (Hey, 2004, pp.52). Constructivist heavily criticizes such epistemology due to the fact that in a positivist model of the social, one can include and exclude factors, which can lead to manipulation and alteration of the facts to come out with a preferred

Assisted Psychotherapy for Treatment

1304 words - 5 pages up was conducted and after 3.8 years, the subjects were still symptom free (Vitelli). Since the first study was conducted, a little over 780 people have received MDMA-assisted psychotherapy and 83% have found lasting freedom (“Powerful Results, Promising Futures”). So how does this happen? How does MDMA assist in PTSD sufferers finding the freedom they long for? MDMA decreases activity in the limbic system of the brain which is involved in

The Sociology of Scientific Knowledge

1200 words - 5 pages socially perpetuated independent variable that dictates which content, and by what means, becomes part of the collective knowledge that composes science and technology. Another constructivist point of view which relates to SSK is the idea of “heterogeneous constructivism,” or the belief that the content which makes up science and technology is intertwined and melded with social structures and practices in the greater community. By this theory

John Lennon’s Beliefs

1362 words - 5 pages simultaneously admits that there are constantly wars going on in the world. As a result, he could be a mixture of all four, Realist, Liberal, Marxist and Constructivist. On December 8th 1980, approximately five years after the end of the Vietnam War, Lennon was assassinated by Mark Chapman 5. It is not for certain that the word assassination could be used on a singer, song writer who also published books. However there is no doubt about the fact that

Management Research Methods

1274 words - 6 pages , 2012). It looks at what creates and influences social realities in the world of management. It describes the view that we take based on the nature of reality that is whether it is subjective or objective. Objectivist ontology refers to the discovery of realities in relation to objectives of a research. The assumption is that social phenomena was present even before social actors came into existence. Constructivist ontology seeks to show the

Constructivist Child Development Theories

2772 words - 11 pages previous hypotheses to be wrong. Some research data suggests additional hypotheses to be examined and provide direction for dealing with practical issues. Constructivist Child Development Theories Introduction The constructivist theories of child development were put forward by theorists such as Lev Vygotsky, Jean Piaget, and Maria Montessori. Even though there is a huge difference in the works of these, nevertheless everyone formulates a

Contemporary Community and Research

858 words - 4 pages constructivist, (meaning is subjectively constructed from an objective reality), and post-modernist (viewing truth as completely subjective) methodologies have been popular mainly in the social sciences (Kayrooz & Trevitt, 2005, pp. 323-324). In this very brief essay I will suggest a definition of contemporary community and explain how research may be conducted on community in terms of that perspective.
 My definition of contemporary community is a

Similar Essays

Finding Truth In Math, Arts, And Ethics

1284 words - 5 pages arts. Overall, the approaches toward finding the truth within mathematics, the arts and ethics vary, but the final truth is intertwined. Works Cited Bernardin, Andrew. "Four Types of Truth." The Evolving Mind. N.p., 15 June 2008. Web. 25 Jan. 2010. . Lamb, Robert. "How are Fibonacci numbers expressed in nature?" HowStuffWorks. Discovery Communications, 24 June 2008. Web. 28 Jan. 2010. . Rowse, Darren. "Rule of Thirds." Digital Photography School. N.p., 2009. Web. 29 Jan. 2010. .

Finding The Truth In The Situation

1044 words - 4 pages Iago is not just the evil vindictive character he is believed to be but rather both of these men are far more interesting than that. They both have the necessary qualities that get them through life and potentially threaten their lives. Through their actions and interactions with the other characters that they really are is shown. Othello seems to have a really rough time finding the truth in people. The reasoning behind this is simply the way

Finding The Truth In Gretchen Moran Laskas’s The Midwife’s Tale

1268 words - 5 pages Finding the Truth in Gretchen Moran Laskas’s The Midwife’s Tale The prologue to Gretchen Moran Laskas’s novel, The Midwife’s Tale, begins with her narrator protagonist, Elizabeth, telling readers, “Mama always said that most of being a good midwife was in knowing the family history. Not just the birthing story of any given woman--although that was a good thing to keep in mind--but the whole history.” Assuming the “whole history” is a thing

How The Environment Plays A Role In Learning?

1521 words - 6 pages significant shifts--epistemological, technological, and cultural--are required. (Swef, 2002) In truth, few designers have acknowledged, much less successfully negotiated, the hurdles associated with transforming a highly traditional community of educational practice.Yet, as constructivist learning environments are repurposed to fit traditional classroom practices, mismatched theoretical foundations, assumptions, or methods may result. Instructional