Observations On The Writing Profession In The Republic By Plato

1446 words - 6 pages

Questioning of the Writing Profession Plato’s The Republic

For all the time today’s students spend learning to write well, Plato is skeptical of those who spend their lives crafting words. In the tenth chapter of The Republic, Socrates condemns poets as imitators. In the dialogue that bears his name, Phaedrus wonders whether words in the constructed rhythms of speech or poetry will obscure Truth, the philosopher’s ultimate goal. Speech-writing is just the clever use of rhetorical device, poetry is faulty imitation, and both empty voices can deceive us. Eventually, though, Socrates admits that the work of words deserves our effort. Because he is a writer himself, Plato’s criticism of the writing profession rings hollow: "It’s not speaking or writing well that’s shameful; what’s really shameful is to engage in either of them . . . badly," says Socrates (Republic 69A).1 Writing never ceases to be an imitation. Bad writing and speeches always threaten philosophy. Yet Plato’s own work reflects the constant questioning of philosophical dialogue. It passes Socrates’s test for good writing.

When he refers to writing, Socrates means speech writing. Philosophers judge the written against the spoken—what Phaedrus calls the "living, breathing discourse" (276A). For the philosopher, the spoken word is superior to the written one. Composition takes on meaning when an audience hears it; even Homer’s merits as a poet come from the speeches his characters give. Socrates asks: "Have you only heard of the rhetorical treatises of Nestor and Odysseus—those they wrote in their spare time in Troy?" (261B). Good writing is a tool for talk; The Iliad is better heard than read. Socrates has no use for silence. Writing is meant to be read, and read aloud.

Delivery is still a problem. The writer writes for a purpose, and so giving a speech, however eloquent, is recitation. At best, writing "can only serve as a reminder to those who already know" (277E-278A). But philosophers are knowledge seekers whose search depends on the acknowledgment of ignorance. In a letter to Robert Browning, Elizabeth Barrett Browning once wrote that "the fullness must be in proportion to the vacancy"—a vacancy the speechwriter rarely realizes, according to Socrates.2 Most speeches enable the writer and his audience to nod agreement to what they know already: "Those [speeches] that are recited in public without questioning and explanation, in the manner of rhapsodies, are given only in order to produce conviction" (Republic 277E-278A). Writing assumes the knowledge of its audience and reaffirms it. If there is no vacancy, writing cannot fill it.

But by his stringent critique of all written verse and prose, Professor Socrates shows us what he expects of his students’ essays. They should ask questions. They should explain a new point of view, not repeat one that is worn out. As he puts it, writing should help readers "remember from the inside, completely on their own"...

Find Another Essay On Observations on the Writing Profession in The Republic by Plato

Plato---Issues In The Republic Essay

1104 words - 4 pages essence because it keeps the guardians in a pure nature. I don't these laws set forth by Socrates because if you follow them, you get nothing in return. I believe Plato should reconsider some of these laws and amend them.Family Life vs. Civic Life Family life in Book V of the Republic involved women becoming as power as men. However, as far as family life was concerned, you couldn't have a family because every child born was taken by the rulers

Plato and the Republic Essay

2545 words - 10 pages ; bjoch509/works/plato/republic.txt. Accessed on December 28, 2000. Richards, I. A., trans. Plato’s Republic. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1966. Shorey, Paul, trans.. “Plato: Republic, VI-X.” In The Loeb Classical Library. Edited by G. P.           Goold. Cambridge: Harvard University Press, reprint ed., 1994. Stumpf, Samuel E. Philosophy: History and Problems. 5th ed. New York: McGraw-Hill Publishing Co., 1994. Taylor, A. E. Plato: The Man and His Work. London: Butler & Tanner, reprint ed.,1963.

The Republic of Plato

1556 words - 6 pages In Book one of the Republic of Plato, several definitions of justice versus injustice are explored. Cephalus, Polemarchus, Glaucon and Thracymicus all share their opinions and ideas on what actions they believe to be just, while Socrates questions various aspects of the definitions. In book one, Socrates is challenged by Thracymicus, who believes that injustice is advantageous, but eventually convinces him that his definition is invalid

Plato, The Republic

1012 words - 4 pages justice, and must be able and willing to rule and be ruled.Aristotle defines a constitution as '...an arrangement in regard to the offices of the city. By this arrangement the citizen body distributes office, either on the basis of the power of those who participate in it, or on the basis of some sort of general equality (i.e. the equality of the poor, or of the rich, or an equality existing among both rich and poor.) There must therefore be as many

Arguments of Plato in The Republic and Aristotle in Poetics

1195 words - 5 pages scholars including Sigmund Freud, Philip Sydney and Adam Smith, but this essay will focus on the arguments outlined by Plato in The Republic and Aristotle in Poetics, attempting to demonstrate the different features of imitation (mimesis) and what it involves for them both. In Plato’s The Republic, he discusses what imitation (mimesis) signifies to him and why he believed it was not worthy of the credit or appreciation it was so often given. In

The Rhetorical Analysis of Writing in the Accounting Profession

1876 words - 8 pages emphasizing on certain words to catch the reader's eye on key points of her arguments.Concluding StatementsIn order to be a successful accountant one must be knowledgeable of proper writing techniques that go along with the profession such as, APA formatting and rhetorical moves. The rhetorical moves that accountants must know how to effectively include in their writings are logos and ethos. By using logos and ethos, one is capable of ensuring his

Plato, Book IV of The Republic.

1487 words - 6 pages In Book IV of The Republic, Socrates has gone on a bit of a digression. He has done this for the sake of proving his argument as to what constitutes the ideal city. In order to do this, Socrates feels that he and Glaucon must evaluate the individual citizen, specifically the mind and soul of the individual citizen. A city in itself is nothing more than a city, it is the individuals within it who make it just or unjust. If it can be proven that

The Dimensions of Morality in The Prince and The Republic of Plato

1291 words - 5 pages Morality is likely the most debated topic of all time, especially in regards to our moral responsibility for each other. Throughout history many writers and philosophers have taken different angles the concept of morality and have applied it in many ways. This includes: Niccolò Machiavelli with The Prince (we will be looking at The Qualities of the Prince) and Plato with The Republic (we will be looking at the section The Allegory of the Cave

The Educated Imagination, by Northrop Frye, Bird by Bird, by Anne Lamott, and The Republic, by Plato

1357 words - 5 pages postulates literature is actually “evil” to the ideal society. He puts forward this argument by recreating a dialogue which he had, as a pupil, with his teacher Socrates. Through a series of questions and answers known as the Socratic method, Plato describes his perfect republic. In this utopia, there shouldn’t be any literature. Plato feels that literature is excessively emotional, and it causes the readers of society to act on impulse rather than

Plato on the Parthenon

917 words - 4 pages Plato would not equate the profession of the architect with the artist. Plato?s views on art are considered shadows, images, and reflections in the Visible World on his Divided Line diagram. It can be argued each way that The Parthenon is a work of art, which falls into the Visible World, or that it is a form of science and mathematics that can be sought in the Intelligible World. In my opinion it is both. Since architecture is a scientific

The Focus on Cultural Competency in the Social Work Profession

2144 words - 9 pages effective clinician of color. Although it is a demand of the profession, it is also enjoyable to persistently inform yourself of your client’s needs, and of changes in legislation that could affect your practice (Lukas, 1993). Aside from learning from other clinicians, I would further my education on topics such as identity and cultural by participating in trainings, conferences, lectures, workshops, and continued education courses specific to self

Similar Essays

The Republic By Plato Essay

657 words - 3 pages better way to live your life. Only if you are a true justice that is morally educated of the rights and wrongs and trained on how to control the temptations to be unjust.The main theme of The Republic is to define justice and other virtues and to put forward an idea for a Utopian city-state based on his beliefs on justice and virtue to show how these ideals could be implemented. Plato then goes on to say that all humans have a soul divided in three

The Republic By Plato Essay

1481 words - 6 pages Wisdom, courage, moderation and justice are four essential virtues the ideal state must be built upon, as explained by Socrates in Plato’s Republic. Throughout the eight books of Socratic dialogue the ideal state and ideas of justice are debated, on both individual and state levels. The guidelines for a perfect state and how it will come about are thoroughly described. Socrates covers every aspect of political life and how it should work stating

The Republic By Plato Essay

2082 words - 8 pages In Plato’s Republic Book 1, Thrasymachus argues that morality is the advantage of the stronger. To support his view, Thrasymachus first claims that the governments, which are the stronger parties, always pass laws based on their own interest, and then argues that subjects must always obey these laws, therefore morality is the advantage of the stronger. Socrates gives two sets of counter arguments. First, by differentiating apparent

The Republic, Written By Plato Essay

1078 words - 4 pages The Republic written by Plato examines many things. It mainly is about the Good life. Plato seems to believe that the perfect life is led only under perfect conditions which is the perfect society. Within the perfect society there would have to be justice. In the Republic it seems that justice is defined many different ways. In this paper I am going to discuss a few. First I am going to discuss the reason why Glaucon and Adeimantus see justice