Flaws With Utilitarianism Essay

636 words - 3 pages

Among the most glaring problems that I see with Utilitarianism is its inclusion of animals under the umbrella that blankets this theory. It seems irrefutable that there exists an inordinate number of cases where the consequence that is against the best interest of an animal is favorable to humans, yet that dictating action is one that has been continually taken and condoned by the general public. This is a fundamental challenge, as the Utilitarian philosophy decrees that the pleasure and pain experienced by all individuals, including animals, has equal worth and must be considered when determining the net benefit of an action’s consequences.
     The most drastic and prevalent of examples that one could provide to illustrate this contradiction would be the practice of using animals to provide food. It cannot be argued that it is in the best interest of a cow, a chicken, or another animal to be slaughtered to serve the dietary needs of mankind. Accordingly, Utilitarian reasoning suggests, in direct opposition to the intuition of humanity, that it is morally impermissible to kill the animals. While a Utilitarian philosopher might provide the counter-argument that such is natural order of the world that there exist a hierarchical food tree. Further they would insist that the greater good is that humans be nourished and provided for by the meat, for our pleasure is superior in quality to that of the beast. This reasoning, however, is flawed in two ways. Initially, the method by which meat finds its way to grocery stores for our purchase and eventual consumption is not one governed by the ways of nature, but rather is one engineered for efficiency by humans. Animals are bread forcibly, then nourished with specific intent of managing fat content, meat flavor, and healthiness, each of which discounts the Utilitarian claim that nature makes our carnivorous methods ethically permissible. Secondly, and perhaps more fundamentally, such a claim is in direct contradiction to the...

Find Another Essay On Flaws with Utilitarianism

Explain the Main difference between Act and Rule Utilitarianism (it can also be used to explain the main difference between Bentham and Mill)

2697 words - 11 pages , "the greatest good for the greatest number." Bentham called this principle the principle of utility. With "utility" here referring to the tendency of an action to produce happiness, not its usefulness. It is the aim of Act Utilitarianism to fulfil to the greatest extent the principle of utility.Act Utilitarianism focuses solely on the consequences of the action. The motives and the reasons why actions are carried out are trivial in determining

Mill's Utilitarianism Essay

1145 words - 5 pages tend to promote happiness, wrong as they tend to produce the reverse of happiness. By happiness is intended pleasure, and the absence of pain; by unhappiness, pain, and the privation of pleasure" (Mill, 1863, Ch. 2, p330). In other words, it results with the greatest amount of happiness for the greatest amount of people that are involved. Mill takes on the claim that utilitarianism is fit for a swine. “…life has no higher end than pleasure

Higher and Lower Pleasures: Their Effects on Millian Utilitarianism

1443 words - 6 pages In this paper, I examine Mill’s distinction between higher and lower pleasures that he presents in his Utilitarianism. Then, I raise objections to Mill’s distinction by focusing on the ambiguity of his definition of pleasures and his concept of the competent judge. I conclude that, with a recalculation of the definition of pleasures, his distinction of higher and lower pleasures can support a broader theory of utilitarianism. 1. Examining

Answers and explains questions pertaining to ethics

977 words - 4 pages , 4. To resolve conflicts of interest in just and orderly way, and 5. To assign praise and blame, reward and punishment, and guilt. These 4 principles are the basis for morality. I feel that Utilitarianism in no way fulfills all of these purposes however; it definitely promotes a few of them. First Utilitarianism has a few flaws, due to the fact that the purpose of utilitarianism is to do what produces the most good, something is right if it

Euthanasia: Kantianism vs Utilitarianism

1618 words - 6 pages stated in my thesis, I believe that Utilitarianism, and Kantianism do not provide an adequate resolution to the issue of euthanasia, because of the significant flaws in their reasoning. With Utilitarianism, the significant flaw in their position lies in the fact that it is built on the false assumption that the consequences of actions can be predicted, when in actuality they cannot. For example, it is possible that the person, who underwent

Criminal Legal System and Ethics

1308 words - 6 pages reclassification of the case is to clarify to the public whether the person holding a public office fits to serve in that capacity given recent plagiarism allegations. Under utilitarianism, a person holding public office must act within the law. This means that any questionable conduct must be investigated with haste to ascertain or expunge the accusations as mere rumours for the office holder to continue serving in that public office. Need for

Peter Oiler and Winn-Dixie Stores

2146 words - 9 pages these methods were very intuitive and simple, however utilitarianism might not work in every cases. There are several flaws that a traditional utilitarianisms hold. There is a misunderstanding when comparing the benefits and costs of the available alternatives. Most often, we only analyze the direct and indirect effect that is produce by the option, however we does not calculate the future effect that might happen when the option was chosen

Utilitarian Logic in Hard Times

1690 words - 7 pages such as love, imagination, and humor. Sissy Jupe, the daughter of a circus man, was taken in by the Gradgrinds to live in their home. She is representative of the circus people with her innocence and free-will, qualities which are lacking in the lives of the people around her. Just by her presence, her goodness rubs off on the people around her, although it is too late for most of them. Even after numerous attempts to force utilitarianism into her

Utilitarianism, Economics and Ethics

1751 words - 7 pages individuals as ethically equal. However, for all its merits, Utilitarianism has many flaws and has proven to be unpractical in the real world. The following compares four areas of similarity between the Areas of Knowledge, Economic and Ethics and the weaknesses that emerge from applying Utilitarianism. The four similarities are the challenge of measuring happiness; the focus on outcomes versus intentions; the promotion of negative happiness

The Differences in John Stuart Mills and Jeremy Bentham's Versions of Utilitarianism

2653 words - 11 pages "stratified" hedonistic utilitarian, since he retains Bentham's emphasis on pleasure or happiness, but "stratifies" the notion of pleasure or happiness based on differences in quality between the various types of pleasure. Both Mill's and Bentham's ideas of utilitarianism contain many interesting concepts, but also several flaws. One major problem is with Bentham's 'hedonic' calculus as it concentrates on the consequences of an action rather

The Right to Die - An ethical argument for the civil right of one to die either by suicide or physician assisted mercy killing

2335 words - 9 pages the intention of keeping this paper short, the positions explored will be based on "Utilitarianism" ethical theory and the "Categorical Imperative" ethical theory as espoused by Immanuel Kant. The paper will then be summed up with a personal point of view using reasonable logic unfettered by extreme applications.Utilitarianism Ethical TheoryThe Utilitarianism view holds that euthanasia is morally justifiable. According to Utilitarianism, ethics

Similar Essays

The Flaws Of Act Utilitarianism Essay

1775 words - 7 pages African non-profit organization writes a letter to all those who donated thanking them for saving the lives of many. The hypothetical story discussed above exposes four major flaws in Mill’s AU theory. With the saving of the starving kids in Africa aside, the seemingly arbitrary numerically assigned sum of the pleasure of the humanitarians alone could possibly satisfy Mill’s condition in that most, if not all of group which experienced both pleasures

Utilitarianism: Founding Fathers, Strengths And Weaknesses Of Act Utilitarianism And Rule Utilitarianism, Other Forms Of Utilitarianism, And Recent Philosophers

1528 words - 6 pages are harmonized with some major flaws. I will discuss the founding fathers of utilitarianism, the strengths and weaknesses of act-utilitarianism and rule-utilitarianism, other forms of utilitarianism, and recent philosophers of this school of thought.This idea of the greatest good for the greatest number was developed by Jeremy Bentham. Although the ides of utilitarianism is often traced back to and credited to Jeremy Bentham, John Stuart Mill

Utilitarianism. Essay

1513 words - 6 pages real-life situations, it becomes apparent that it has its flaws as well as its benefits. It encourages people to think not simply about themselves, but to consider how their actions will affect the well-being of others. Also, it pushes people to reflect on the consequences of their actions. Still, there are some serious drawbacks to utilitarianism. It is rather inflexible with its ideal that whatever best suits the majority is the moral thing to do

Utilitarianism Essay

1442 words - 6 pages ? Then there is the question of scope. How far does someone look in deciding who is involved and who would be affected by the action? Along with these problems, there are many arguments for and against Utilitarianism and whether it provides an adequate basis for making moral decisions. An argument against Utilitarianism is that there is no agreement about what is the 'good' that is to be maximized for all concerned