This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Fluency And Reasoning Essay

1512 words - 7 pages

Introduction
One of the most influential theories of cognition in the last century is that posited by William James (1890) in which he suggested that reasoning in humans is divided into two distinct processing systems. The first is quick, effortless, intuitive and has little demand for cognitive capacity (known as System 1 processes) while the other is slow, effortful, deliberate and requires use of cognitive resources (System 2 processes) (Alter, Oppenheimer, Eyre & Epley, 2007; Morsanyi & Handly, 2011). Evidence suggests that we rely on our System 2 processing only after it has been triggered by certain cues and makes sense within the context of a situation (Reisberg, 2013 p. 414). As such, heuristic based judgments (System 1) are more likely to be used when under time constraints and System 2 judgments are more likely if more attention can be paid to the judgment being made (Reisberg, 2013 p. 414).
However, judgment errors can be made even when one is focused and alert and time constraints can contribute to heuristic based errors people are still able make correct assumptions even when under pressure (Reisberg, 2013 p. 414). So what does it all mean and why should it matter? The following papers discuss a number of important aspects of dual process theory and how it affects how we make decisions. The first by Alter, Oppenheimer, Epley and Eyre (2007) looks at metacogntive difficulty as an activator of analytic reasoning (System 2), the second by Topolinksi and Strack (2010) looks at how fluency effects can be prevented by blocking sources of fluency variation and finally the paper by Morisanyi and Handley (2011) discusses the interplay between System 1 and System 2 processes by looking at how people evaluate syllogisms and judge their validity. Each of these studies provides us with a unique look into our decision making processes with inferences to practical application.

Overcoming Intuition: Metacognitive Difficulty Activates Analytic Reasoning
In this study Alter et al. hypothesized that System 2 processes are activated by “metacognitive experiences of difficulty or disfluency during the process of reasoning” and as such serve as a “red flag” or a cue to draw our attention to, and possibly correct, some of the output produced by the quicker System 1 processes. In this study they completed four experiments.
The first experiment was to test the hypothesis that when we experience cognitive disfluency that will serve as a cue to adopt a systematic (and override the heuristic) approach to reasoning. The participants completed the Cognitive Reflection Test. This test consists of three items in which the initial (gut) reaction is incorrect but can be correctly answered if the participants engage in a deliberate reconsideration of the item. There were two conditions that were presented; The test was either administered in an easy to read font (fluent condition) or a difficult to read font (disfluent condition) and they hypothesized that more...

Find Another Essay On Fluency and Reasoning

Contingencies of Self-Worth by E. J. Horberg and Serena Chen

1634 words - 7 pages when participants reported feeling close to their father and perceived their father as wanting them to do well on the task. Participants completed an anagram task that was described as an important measure of analytic reasoning and were instructed to find as many different solutions to the anagrams as possible. Immediately before they completed this task, participants were subliminally primed either with words representing the concept “father” or

Reading Comprehension Essay

1292 words - 5 pages questioning, reviewing, revising, and rereading to enhance their overall comprehension.” (Douglas Fisher, 2011) One other skill that is crucial to being a skilled reader and comprehending text is the fluency with which a student reads. Teaching fluency skills is a very important aspect of helping a student comprehend what they are reading. If a student is using all of the short term memory decoding words and sentence stucture, there is very

My Educational Philosophy for the ESL Classroom

2120 words - 9 pages about their students’ diverse background in order to fully comprehend the reasoning behind the behavior and how to appropriately address the issue. When examining the ELL domain of speaking, it is crucial to understand the difference between accuracy and fluency. Fluency is the ability to operate a language quickly, it is message-oriented. Accuracy is the ability to conform to the language system itself, it is language-oriented. Current

Speech and Language Disorders

689 words - 3 pages Now, for a main question that crosses most people’s mind. How much money do speech-language pathology make hourly and yearly? As of 2012 the median pay was $69,870 and about $34 an hour. The reasoning upon having a median wage is when they take half of the workers of a profession earned more than that amount and half earned less. The lowest 10% have earned less than $44,000 and the top 10% made more than $105,000 (Bureau of Labor Statistics

Bilingual Education in the School Systems of the United States

1400 words - 6 pages Over half of the world’s population today is bilingual, meaning that it is able to use two languages with equal fluency, and sixty-six percent of children are raised to speak more than one language. At the same time, only 6.3 percent of children in the United States are being raised this way. In an effort to keep up with the times, many school systems throughout the world practice bilingual education, or teaching two languages simultaneously

Learning Disabilities

2038 words - 8 pages he was assessed for special needs services, it was noted that TC’s areas of concern were: Phonemic Awareness, Phonics, Word Identification, Fluency and Reading Comprehension, Math Skills, Basic Math Facts, Computation, Math problem solving and writing (i.e. expressing ideas). It was also stated by his assessor that even in the 1st grade TC had already stated he disliked school. The psychologist also stated in the report his concern for his

Can food influence creative and critical thinking ability?

979 words - 4 pages operate faster while performing in the best possible manner with the least waste of time and effort. Within this group, higher blood glucose had declared faster completion of the spatial memory task. Two more recent studies in adults introduced whether effects of breakfast were specific to memory based tasks or included tasks that would estimate the sustained attention span, reaction time and logical or pertained reasoning. In both studies, mood and

A Career as a Research Psycologist

896 words - 4 pages stated by the Arizona Career Information System, being capable of reasoning and problem solving are some of the most important skills suggested for researchers to be able to take significant notes and so that they can “[u]nderstand new information or materials by studying and working with them.” (“Psychologists”). This would be beneficial to the researcher because it helps him or her comprehend everything better the more they work with their

"The Collar" by George Herbert(1593-1633)

901 words - 4 pages ,/Deserves his load" the poem reads like a very histrionic soliloquy. The second effect of this randomness is to suggest the indiscipline of the rebellious spirit, which is both cause and consequence of the rebellion. The argument is heated and passionate but unconvincing. As it proceeds, the reader has the sense that the reasoning has not been premeditated and pondered, but is impulsive, spoken in heat. It seems like boastful posturing even before the

The link between creativity and bipolar disorder

670 words - 3 pages patients at different stages as compared with a group under the effect of the medication, lithium. Experimentation is reflective of the regular and elated states in bipolar disorder, thus depression is not evaluated. In addition, use of a normal control group will also allow for comparative analysis of creativity in bipolar subjects versus controls. The reasoning for this experiment is to derive a pragmatic overview of the association between

High School Students with Reading Disabilities

769 words - 4 pages ). Learning disabilities in reading are the inability to understand the meaning of words and comprehension of passages (Howrowitz 2). This disability can take many forms, such as dyslexia and can be mild or severe. The evidence and signs of a reading disability include difficulty understanding the vital ideas, word recognition, phrasing, fluency, language processing, and visual reasoning. Diagnosis includes testing, direct observations, and analysis

Similar Essays

Adolescent Learning Disabilities (Ld) Evaluation Essay

6768 words - 27 pages expressed dissatisfaction with his performance. On paper-and-pencil tasks, the examiner observed that Ron had an unusual approach of jumping around on the page instead of proceeding sequentially. For example, on the Math Fluency subtest, Ron was required to complete as many simple math problems as possible within a 3-minute time limit. The typical pattern is to begin at the first item on the first line and to proceed

Small Talk Essay

1219 words - 5 pages leaving aside other skills. WEAKNESSESS AND STRENGTHS OF THE ARTICLE -- - - - First of all, the author's line of reasoning is that using this method, students will improve their fluency, accuracy and complexity. This is based upon the questionable assumption because the topic is chosen only by one student, the leader. We suppose that this topic is not equally motivating for all students. Making small talk means that students should have a wide

Don’t Worry: Be Wise And Happy

595 words - 3 pages , personal opinions are sought from other people, directly basing the conclusion in the article on primary data. Information is logically presented in the article. Starting with a statement that raises curiosity about why one should not worry about aging despite the fact that cognitive ability is likely to decline, describing the benefits of wise reasoning as explained by researchers, stating the differences between wisdom and intelligence, and

Mental Retardation Essay

907 words - 4 pages 1. L. L. Thurston’s theory of intelligence identifies seven recognizable intellectual abilities: spatial ability, memory, perceptual speed, word fluency, numerical ability, reasoning, and verbal meaning. Thurman argued multiple factors go into making up intelligence and although there may be some correlation between mental abilities, each ability is relatively independent of each other. A person having remarkable spatial ability or the ability