This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Food Stamp Cuts: Justified Or Unjustified?

787 words - 4 pages

Recent cuts to the Supplemental Nutrition Aid Program (S.N.A.P.), also known as the U.S. Food Stamp Program, have become extremely controversial. Whether Congress was wrong to reduce funding to the program remains a question. There are two principles that may be used to represent each side of this debate. The difference principle will be used to represent those who believe the program cuts were unjustified and the harm principle will be used to represent those who believe the program cuts were justified.
Those who are against the cuts to the Food Stamp Program can argue that under the difference principle, Congress was wrong to reduce funding. The difference principle, created by John ...view middle of the document...

Because S.N.A.P. is justified by the difference principle, Congress was wrong to cut funding towards the program.
Putting the difference principle aside, Congress’s actions can be justified under the harm principle. The harm principle was created by an English philosopher and writer named John Stuart Mill. The principle states that a government should only intervene to prevent someone from harming another. A harm is defined as an action in which someone causes someone else to lose something of value. Hunger in the U.S., according to the harm principle, is not a harm. Food insecure people are not hungry because others are taking away their food; they are hungry because they cannot afford or do not have access to food. Because hunger is not a harm, the government should not be intervening in the situation. Congress is not justified in using people’s tax dollars to create a Food Stamp Program, however they are justified in cutting the funding to the program. By cutting S.N.A.P. funding Congress is also not inflicting any direct harm to people. Congress is not taking away money that the program’s recipients already had; it is making a cut in the money that the...

Find Another Essay On Food Stamp Cuts: Justified or Unjustified?

Food Stamps Essay

1077 words - 5 pages having something to eat in their home or state of living may be. It also makes you speculate how the government can go months without fixing the problem with the food stamp cuts, and backlogging. People who are still being neglected and poverty is increasingly rising 20% in this state. The issue should not be spaced-out but have also made makes you think having your benefits met from welfare? This is more than local; it’s a big economic problem that

The Poor Feeding the Poor in America

985 words - 4 pages -flavored drinks or soft drinks. On the other hand, a SNAP recipient has no restrictions on her purchase and has no obligation to buy the healthier products (Benefits and Services). According to the USDA’s report, Implications of Restricting the Use of Food Stamp Benefits, it is not feasible to prohibit food stamp recipients from purchasing foods with limited nutritional value with their stamps. Their report states, “No clear standards exist for

Policy Analysis on the food stamps Program

3057 words - 13 pages next four months in the House and Senate, there was a joint committee (Major Actions) . On the 4th of February 2014 the president received the Farm Bill and it was signed by the 7th of the same month (Major Actions). By July 2013,the Senate and House of Representatives wanted to propose cuts to the Federal Food Stamp Programs in the Farm Bill.The Senate Bill would save the government 24 billion dollars, but cut about 4.1 billion dollars from the

Food Stamp Program Reform

1718 words - 7 pages The federal Food Stamp Program is an assisted nutrition program that helps millions of eligible, low-income individuals and families (United States Department of Agriculture). This program gives its recipients extra money each month to try to help them have better food security. The Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program is also the largest program in the federal safety net (United States Department of Agriculture). In Ohio’s Appalachian

Weekly Paper

771 words - 4 pages Jindal Moves to Strip Food Stamps from Abusers: This article provides the argument that the Governor of Louisiana, Governor Jindhal, plans to charge the recipients of food stamp benefits in his county with fraud is justified if they abused the system during a mechanical shut down. Apparently when the food stamp system shut down, it no longer recognized the available balance on benefit cards. As a result, active participants were not only

World Hunger

1413 words - 6 pages economy would be about $75 billion per year in current prices.That's a lot of money, but by coincidence, this is roughly what the world's wealthier country to support farm incomes and food aid programs spend each year. If an international food stamp program were set up to operate at this level, traditional farm programs could be drastically cut back or even eliminated. (Gundersen, p. 13-23)Open Markets, Boost DemandCountries, which agree to receive the

Were the Crusades Just Wars?

1297 words - 5 pages Muslims. Although some of the Christian reasons were right, their attacks on Muslims were mostly unjustified. From the Christian perspective, their attacks on Muslims during the Crusades were justified. The first reason Christians thought that the Crusades were justified was because the Holy Sepulchre was burned. In 1009, El Hakim, the leader of Jerusalem also considered mentally ill, called for the burning of the Holy Sepulchre (Video Guide

Food Stamps: Should They Be Limited?

2458 words - 10 pages . In the past, these applications did not require a drug screening to get benefits, but more and more states are adopting this. There are many drawbacks to SNAP as well such as taking money from working people’s paychecks every week and people abusing the system. Talking about a very opinionated subject, we must remove bias and answer whether or not the Food Stamp system should be limited. I started my exploration process by researching

The Need for Reformation

1419 words - 6 pages fraud, or both." "Fraud, Waste, And Abuse: The Cost Of Mismanagement: AIMD-98-265R." GAO Reports (1998): 1. MAS Ultra - School Edition. Web. 13 Dec. 2013. The system responsible for checking food stamp eligibility is flawed. Billions of dollars are sent annually to deceased or imprisoned people. The statement was made by the USDA. Huston, Warner T. "New York: Welfare Money Used at Strip Clubs, Liquor Stores." Breitbart News Network. N.p., 7 Jan

FDR Had the Right Idea

1093 words - 4 pages and Food Stamp benefits increased. The President also targeted money for infrastructure. FDR’s policies put an end to Bonus Marchers, Food Riots and radical politics that had sprung up with revolutionary zeal in reaction to Herbert Hoover’s meager, snail-paced recovery measures. To that generation of Americans, Franklin Roosevelt saved the country in a way comparable only to Abraham Lincoln. Barack Obama’s policies are still in effect and

Food Stamps: An Important Government Transfer Program

1728 words - 7 pages gives the recipient more privacy, thus reducing the stigma associated with Food Stamp use. Finally, using a card is safer than using paper coupons. If the card is lost or stolen the account is closed and the card is replaced (FNS). Costs to retailers using the EBT system are 25% lower than the costs of using the paper coupons (Senauer). The Food Stamp Program is federally financed. The US government provides total funding for the

Similar Essays

Do You Think That Dangerous Prisoners Legislation Which Allows The Further Detention Of Prisoners Based Upon Their Risk Of Committing Further Crimes Is Justified Or Unjustified?

2259 words - 9 pages The new Dangerous Prisoners (Sexual Offenders) Act (2003) In Queensland permits prisoners to be kept in prison beyond their release date where a court finds that there is a 'high degree of probability' that they represent a 'serious danger to the community'. Other jurisdictions have enacted similar legislation to restrict the release of prisoners assessed to be dangerous. Do you think that dangerousness legislation of this sort is justified or

"The Iraqi Road And Generalissimo George." Persuade Your Audience That The Bush Administration Was Justified Or Unjustified In Declaring War On Iraq

1760 words - 7 pages is not committed to using funds available through the Oil for Food program to improve the health and welfare of the Iraqi people...Iraq's contracting delays, cuts in food, medicine, educational and other humanitarian sector allocations...demonstrate that the Iraqi regime is trying to undermine the effectiveness of the program." According to a UN Special Rapporteur report in 1999, Iraq remains the country with the highest number of disappearances

Justified Or Unjustified: America Builds The First Nuclear Weapon

2036 words - 8 pages world. Harry S. Truman once said in his speech, “The atom bomb was no 'great decision.' It was merely another powerful weapon in the arsenal of righteousness” (“Biography of Harry Truman”). It didn’t matter whether the decision to build and drop the bomb was worthy or not, it was just another weapon for righteousness. Yet the atomic bombs were not only made to be used as a weapon, but also to develop and prove America’s science and technology. In

Food Stamp Program Essay

1234 words - 5 pages Food Stamp program will continue to see cuts in the funding from the federal government, I feel that a policy requesting drug testing for participants receiving benefits should be implemented. Taxpayer and federal funds should not be used to provide food assistance to individuals who are using or abusing illegal drugs. In 2011, it was reported in the National Survey of Drug Use and Health (NSDUH) that about 24% of SNAP recipients between the ages