This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

For Gay Marriage Essay

759 words - 4 pages

In Andrew Sullivan’s article, "For Gay Marriage,” he appears to be so fully committed to democratic values that he seeks to extend equal rights in marriage to homosexuals. And he makes an admirable case for equality and dignity for all people, including homosexuals. Instead of begging the question or avoiding the issue, which is seen in many politic debates, Sullivan tries to persuade conservatives about the emotional, financial, and psychological bond between two people (Sullivan 30). By doing this, Sullivan attempted to argue that heterosexuals and homosexuals are the same. However, his lack of specific evidence and use of the logical fallacy, oversimplification, muddy and weaken his argument. This article, probably meant to show a sympathetic side in the debate about gay marriage, showed the overarching components for any marriage debate. Which, oddly enough, made Sullivan’s claims contradict his argument.
In the article, Sullivan’s argument is that the focal point of a marriage contract is an emotional, financial, and psychological bond between two people. Liberals are of the opinion heterosexuals and homosexuals are exactly the same on this point, as neither is more or less capable of making this connection. Gays and lesbians are also no more prone than heterosexuals in not upholding their fidelity in a union, or divorcing or separating. Liberals want the people to see that heterosexual couples have been failing at making marriage work for decades, perhaps longer. Thus, their logic would lead to the fact that homosexual couples should not have to prove that they can succeed, any person who loves their partner should be given the opportunity to make the sacrifices and commitment it takes to make marriage work.
Although Sullivan's meaning is well taken by sympathetic readers, the fact is that he could overcome much of the ambiguity of his presentation by citing more concrete studies, including long-term studies, which support his key points. For example, when he makes the assertion that "in some ways the marriage issue is exactly parallel to the military" (283), it is unclear exactly what he means. He believes that homosexuals are able to care for, defend us, as well as make sacrifices for our country, and they should be allowed to. “Such a denial is a case of unequal protection...

Find Another Essay On For Gay Marriage

The Fight for Gay Marriage Rights

838 words - 4 pages religious background. Since the founding of the United States, people are Christian in general. Christian are opposition to homosexual phenomenon, they thought it was “ugly”. So it may be hard for many people to accept the gay marriage. (Menzie, 2012) As the development of society, especially after the American counter-culture movement, with the struggle of homosexuals, the relentless religious conservatism began to collapse, people's

Why Gay Marriage Is Wrong for Georgia

1227 words - 5 pages understand their own roles in society does not have a positive impact for our citizens here in Georgia. Overall Georgia needs to ban gay marriage because if it is passed, we the people and citizens of Georgia will pay the severe consequences of many generations and its affects will be everlasting. Either way it is a disturbing concept in our country that we have to deal with and hopefully our local government will have the gumption to make the

What are the reasons for and against gay marriage

2689 words - 11 pages What are the reasons for and against gay marriage Introduction Gay marriage is one of the most controversial issues in the modern world. For the past thousand years, marriage has been recognized as the social union between a man and a woman. In most cultures across the globe, homosexuality was viewed with disdain, and marriages between same-sex couples were forbidden.However, homosexual relationships are slowly gaining acceptance, as

A Critique of "For Gay Marriage," by Andrew Sullivan

523 words - 2 pages In Andrew Sullivan's article, "For Gay Marriage", he is a man on a mission. He appears to be so fully committed to democratic values that he seeks to extend equal rights in marriage to homosexuals. And he makes an admirable case for equality and dignity for all people, including homosexuals. However, he could make an even stronger case by citing more studies and expert opinions.Although Sullivan's meaning is well taken by sympathetic readers

Are Same-Sex Marriages Cool or ‘Gay?’ An Argument for Same-Sex Marriage

2248 words - 9 pages do not have gay marriage legalized. This study also shows that many other types of discrimination have harmful effects on the psyches of homosexuals. Severino, Roger. Or for Poorer? How Same-Sex Marriage Threatens Religious Liberty." Harvard Journal of Law & Public Policy 30.3 (2007): 939-982. Academic Search Complete. EBSCO. Web. 14 May 2010. The author argues that legal same-sex marriage would cause irreparable damage to religious liberty. He argues that, in order to legalize same-sex marriage, we will conflict with our first amendment in freedom of religion.

"Acute American Toxication" by Ethan Herber: The idocy of gay marriage, abortion, and other non-religious things are being blamed for today's problems

1129 words - 5 pages model". Are you people freaking retarded? See, this is what happens when we throw religion into politics; their morals get confused with laws, and something like the "great American gay marriage debate is born"! If you don't allow someone to do something just because they are a certain way, then that is plain old discrimination. 1950's and 60's discrimination. It's black and white, in the book, plain to read, and if we don't allow them to marry we

Gay Marriage

1670 words - 7 pages . The risks of legalizing gay marriage affect all of society. Gay marriage would completely change the definition of marriage, deliberately cause children to be raised without either a mother or a father, and affect everyone, including individuals who do not support gay marriage. Children are the future of the world, so it is imperative they are raised in the best environment possible. The best environment for children is living with a mother and

Gay Marriage

884 words - 4 pages gets to legallydecide matters.Americans are very diverse in their opinions of gay marriage. There are hundreds of thousands ofpeople fighting for the right for gay couples to marry and have the same privileges that traditional couples do.There is also a very large group of people who oppose gay marriage.

Gay Marriage

2191 words - 9 pages The Supreme Court of the United States recently ruled that the Constitution guarantees a right to same-sex marriage. Yet, same-sex marriage continues to be a highly debated issue. If we are discriminating against gay marriage then we are not the true land of the free. I believe men and women should be able to love freely and not be shamed by it. Marriage is a great factor in the United States. To some people it’s what we live for; is to get

Gay Marriage

790 words - 3 pages . Reproduction should not be a determining factor in a traditional marriage because about half of the couples who are already married would in fact be untraditional. Adoption is another critical issue with gay couples. Legalizing gay marriage would impact the adoption world tremendously making it much easier for same sex couples to adopt instead of leaving thousands of children in foster care. Statistics actually show that children who were

Gay Marriage

800 words - 3 pages The topic of gay marriage has overwhelmed the headlines of local papers and lays heavily on the social conciseness of every American for the past few weeks. The president, House of Representatives, and senate have confronted this issue head on. The president states, "Eight years ago congress passed and signed the Defense of Marriage Act, which defines marriage in federal law as a union between one man and one woman". The act passed the house of

Similar Essays

Summary Of For Gay Marriage Essay

1106 words - 4 pages Summary of "For Gay Marriage"In his essay "For Gay Marriage," Andrew Sullivan argues that marriage isn't and has never been, in his view just a "private contract" between two people, and that now marriage is seen as a social and public recognition of such a commitment (404). Sullivan argues that to refuse homosexuals the right to marry is a public offense to their rights and equality as citizens. Sullivan makes the case in his essay that

Gay Marriage Is Good For America

1625 words - 7 pages On June 26, 2015, the US Supreme Court ruled that the US Constitution guarantees the right for same-sex couples to marry. Many conservative groups do NOT agree with this decision. The gay marriage debate has been simmering for as long as I can remember. The four articles I have selected give information from four different perspectives including that of liberals, conservatives, homosexuals, and orthodox Jews. With so many differing

Arguments For And Against Gay Marriage

600 words - 2 pages has to do with their religious views on traditional marriages and false gay stereotypes. Gay marriage is seen as immoral to many people. But shouldn't our first amendment right of freedom of religion also imply to freedom from religion? Church and state are kept separate for a reason, to ensure that law does not reflect or enforce any religion. Although it may not be supported by the Catholic Church, that is not grounds to make it illegal.People

The Need For Gay Marriage Equality

853 words - 4 pages by same sex couples is legal in a lot of other countries but not in America? Gay couples could be providing a good and caring home for lots of lonely children but they can’t because they are being discriminated against with this too. The United States is about freedom and equal rights so saying same-sex marriage is illegal is discrimination. I do not believe that homosexuality is a choice because my uncle is gay and when he was younger he