Forced Ranking In The Workforce Essay

1320 words - 5 pages

This case looks at methods used to evaluate and review employees and the impact these methods have on productivity and morale. It focuses on “forced ranking” as an evaluation tool and gives examples where companies such as GE, Yahoo, and American Airlines are trying to adopt more flexible systems. We conclude from this case, that the evaluation process no matter what name it is given is a difficult task for the employer and the employee alike. It is obviously imperative for the employer to identify and merit better performers to encourage continued levels of performance. Though, at the same time it is a delicate subject when dealing with the bottom tier of the ranking structure. These people may become disgruntled, feel discriminated, and even retaliate to lower marks by means of lower productivity, quality, and increases in absenteeism. What we find from this case about employee performance reviews is as Libby Sartain states, “there’s no magic process.” (Ivancevich, 2011)
In my time as a corpsman in the Navy a ranking model of performance evaluations was utilized for advancement that is similar to that of forced ranking. My last pay grade in the Navy was that of E-5, so what this means is that I was ranked with other E-5 personnel in my specific directorate. As a radiologic technologist I fell under the same directorate as lab techs, surgical techs, pharmacy techs, and then of course each directorate may have your E-5 in administrative roles such as secretarial work, etc. The Naval Medical Center San Diego is a very large hospital with a number of E-5 personnel under each directorate. Take radiology techs alone for example, my last evaluation included 30+ E-5 radiology techs. The ranking system includes performance traits in leadership, teamwork, personal job accomplishment, military bearing, command and organizational involvement, quality of work, and professional knowledge. In each section of the directorate all these personnel have different roles and responsibilities. I happened to work in an advanced field of radiology known as Interventional Radiology where we deal with complex procedures and patients. The fact that so many personnel with such different job scopes were evaluated against one another seemed unjust in my opinion. How could one rank my job skill where we deal with treating brain aneurysms to that of a person that counts pills and places them in a bag? At the same time how could I be ranked in command and organizational involvement against the person who has less job responsibilities and more time to be involved in command committees, groups, activities and such. This has been my experience with ranking performance evaluations and though the military is a different monster than most organizations it left a sour taste in my mouth in regards to performance evaluations of this kind.
Questions
1. What’s your opinion regarding forced ranking performance appraisals? Do they motivate employees? Explain. First let me answer the...

Find Another Essay On Forced Ranking in The Workforce

Sexual Inequality in the Workforce Essay

4909 words - 20 pages Sexual Inequality in the Workforce Women have had equal rights in the United States for quite a few years now but they as a society are not used to women being in roles that men traditionally hold. Female doctors, lawyers, political leaders, judges, law enforcement officers, etc. are still not viewed as the cultural norm. Most women are thrilled when they do see other women in these roles because it continues to be unusual to find them in

Workforce Analytics in the Management Field

568 words - 2 pages The human resources department is in charge of a variety of activities but its most important function is figuring out the staffing needs of their company. In most cases, these needs require the hiring of new employees. Sometimes this process can take a very long time causing the company to lose money. GlaxoSmithKline, a pharmaceutical giant in Philadelphia, was in this position until its HR executives turned to a technology known as workforce

Society Against Women in The Workforce

2510 words - 10 pages chores such as laundry, washing dishes, cleaning house, and taking care of the children while their husband works. During the 1950- 1960s in the South, society including many men and some women believed it was against societal norms for women to work. This created difficulties for women when trying to find jobs, because society believed women did not belong in the workforce, instead they belonged at home raising their families, and because society

Hiring New Employees in The Workforce

585 words - 2 pages Hiring New Employees in The Workforce Hiring new employees is a difficult job for most employers to do. When a person is hired most jobs only know a little about their new employee's personality. They only know what is on the person's resume. Resume's are usually made to make the person seem more intelligent than they really are. Resume's do not tell the employer about the persons work ethics. Personality is to be decided if an

Challenges Facing Singapore's Workforce in the Future

704 words - 3 pages increasingly competitive workforce.However, will this trend continue? Singapore has a clear advantage in multiple sectors, among them the industrial and service sectors. But the competition is closing in, and none of them very far away. Perhaps this is the problem with being on top of a hill, because everywhere you look, it's all downhill. This is among the main challenges faced by Singapore's workforce in the future.Singapore advanced through its

Participation of Women in the Workforce

2280 words - 9 pages Since the late 1970s, the participation of women in the workforce has dramatically changed from women traditionally following their mother’s footsteps to obtaining an independent career of their own. According to Resident Scholar, Christina Hoff Sommers of the Huffington Post, "there are far more women than men in college, and they earn more than fifty-eight percent of [the] college degrees [in the year of 2013]." However, some women in the

Women in the Workforce and there networks

1690 words - 7 pages Women in the Workforce: There NetworksIn the past, men were generally meant to be the bread winners in the family while women were suppose to be the caretakers of the children and home. Financial challenges, combined with better and expected educational opportunities, started the mobilization of women into the work force. Many colleges, universities, and Ivey league schools, once closed to women, opened their doors, making coed education

The Pros and Cons of Women Leaders in The Workforce

2064 words - 8 pages lacking access to power and leadership compared to men (Carli & Eagly 629). Furthermore, according to many researchers, women are still underrepresented in the workforce; facing barriers against stereotypes, gender differences and inequality with men. WOMEN AND STEREOTYPES Gender stereotypes are strongly accepted as societal norms, women who do not act in accordance with feminine stereotypes are seen negatively (Willemsen 386). “In general

From Kitchen to Office - Women in the Workforce (Australian)

1101 words - 4 pages The role of women in the workforce as well as society's attitudes towards them has changed dramatically over time in Australia. Women have been allowed to open the door to the world of work and this is a great improvement from what it used to be. They are generally adopted and accepted into our workforce but much still needs to be done to ensure that this is preserved.Once, women were personified as the mother figure that stayed at home, cooking

A Long Road to Equality: Women in the Workforce

1747 words - 7 pages “For most of history, anonymous was a woman –Virginia Wolf.” For women, the path to equality in the home and workforce has been a long hard fought battle that is still taking place as we speak. With every victory that has taken place, there have also been road blocks at every turn, many shed tears, resistance, and an unwavering belief felt by men, that women truly will never amount to anything other than a housewife. If the women from the start

Forced to Fight: the United State's Envolvement in Vietnam, and the Anti-war Movement

3181 words - 13 pages government. Others in the country learned to be skeptical of official reports and policies. It was a time of changing attitudes toward war and government. Previous wars had been fought with a good versus a bad side and seemingly clear, correct responses to a threat. The Vietnam War was caught up in problems of policies and goals. It forced a reluctant U.S. to really look at itself.

Similar Essays

Women In The Workforce Essay

1774 words - 7 pages based on how they acted around these people. This type of mentality make women feel inferior and feel as though there is no one there willing to listen to them or believe them when they are in need. It is important that this mentality is eliminated so that women can feel content with knowing that if someone in the workforce were to ever harass them people will listen to them and if they are ever forced into prostitution they have ways of getting

Creativity In The Workforce Essay

1399 words - 6 pages Creativity and the Workforce This modern world is a competitive place, and the competitors are supremely varied. From race to size to musculature, no two members of the workforce are exactly the same – and their ability to compete in the market is just as varied. Some will obviously have a distinct advantage, while others may have to struggle mightily just to meet the lowest expectations. Recently, one trait has come to the forefront as the

Mothers In The Workforce Essay

2011 words - 9 pages In a society with the majority of mothers joining or returning to the workforce, there is a growing body of research documenting the demands placed on these women and what can be done to help their transition into this new role. According to the United States’ Department of Labor, in the year 2012, 70.5% of mothers with children under the age of 18 were a part of the workforce; of these women 73.7% were employed full-time, working over 35 hours

Teams In The Workforce Essay

2503 words - 10 pages Teams in the Workforce Introduction The working environment in the United States and in many other countries is undergoing tremendous change. The global marketplace, international trade, and the Internet have brought about a new way of looking at business. Competition has risen to levels never before attained. In order for businesses to succeed in such a competitive market, they must change their organizational structures and the way