Foreign Aid Effectiveness Essay

1082 words - 5 pages

Foreign Aid has always been scrutinized for the fact if it is actually effective for the country receiving the aid. The stated goal of foreign aid is to reduce poverty and promote economic growth in the country. There have been mixed results with the outcomes of the countries receiving the aid.
Foreign aid critics, noble laureates Friedman and Bauer (1950) argue that aid strengthened and enlarged central governments and as a result aid did more damage than good, these critics see aid as being used as a political tool that distorts incentives and increases corruption. Brautigam and Knack (2004) concluded and found evidence that suggested that foreign aid has a negative impact on ...view middle of the document...

It than explores some of the problems with aid and how to improve aid effectiveness.

What is Foreign Aid
Foreign aid comes in three forms financial flows, technical assistance and commodities given by the residents and governments of one country to the residents and government of another. It can either be in the form of grants or subsidized loans.
An official source on foreign aid is the Development Authority Committee (DAC) of the Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD). DAC became part of the OECD on 23 July 1961. It is the largest international organization with 30 member countries, which are most of the major aid donors in the world. The World Bank, IMF and UNDP participate as observers.
According to the DAC, for assistance to be counted as official foreign aid it must meet two criteria’s:
• 1. Assistance has to be designed in a way, in which it promotes welfare and economic growth of a country.
• 2. The aid provided should either be in the form of a grant or subsidized loans.
Foreign Aid has two types Bilateral Aid and Multilateral Aid.
Bilateral Aid is when one country directly gives assistance to another country without having an intermediary. The major agencies for Bilateral Assistance are the US AID, UK department for international development (DFID), Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA), Canadian International Development Agency (CIDA) and Swedish International Development Cooperation Agency (SIDA).
Multilateral Aid pools together resources from many donors, the major multilateral agencies are the World Bank, IMF and African, Asian and Inter-American development banks.

Motivations for aid
The donors have a variety of motivations to provide aid to low-middle income countries of which a few are regarding economic development, Dwight H. Perkins, Steven Radelet, David L. Lindauer, Steven A. Block (2013) explain that:
• Policy and alliances regarding the recipient country are the major motivators for donor countries to consider when discussing foreign aid deals.
• The income level and poverty levels of the recipient country play a major role in deciding the allocation of aid, the lower the income level and higher the poverty level the more aid grants and subsidized loans they receive.
• Country size is also an important factor in the...

Find Another Essay On foreign aid effectiveness

Foreign Aid: Congress Should Shift USAID Funds to the Millennium Challenge Account

833 words - 3 pages Introduction: The Heritage Foundation is conservative think tank that does research and analysis of several policy issues in order to market their findings to policymakers in the Legislative and Executive branch, as well as the media and the academic community. On August 4, 2009, the Heritage Foundation published an analysis of the US foreign aid policy called Foreign Aid: Congress Should Shift USAID Funds to the Millennium Challenge Account

Advantages and Disadvantages of Giving International Aid to Poor Countries

2324 words - 9 pages reduce their balance of trade deficits. It is believed that foreign aid is necessary for poor nations in order to break the cycle of poverty that ties their citizens in low productivity zones and so their economy will not be weak. However, some critics view the extension of aid to poor countries as means of keeping the nations in economic slumber so that they can wake up from only by devising ways of furthering self-sustainability. Because of

Foreign Aid

1598 words - 7 pages analysis and comparison of two opposite points of view. Furthermore, a case study will be used to support the thesis, leading to the presentation of a personal opinion based on ethical theories and evidence. The case study chosen to support the thesis is “The Effectiveness Of Foreign Aid”, conducted by Uliane Appolinario in 2009 at the University Of Geneva, which mostly focuses on Zambia. However, it gives a really good image about what is happening

Does Bilateral Aid Benefit the Country's Economy?

1488 words - 6 pages order to determine the overall effectiveness of foreign aid theoretical approach must be taken before empirical data can be analyzed. To do this, several different works from different fields will be assessed. Jeffery Sachs (2005) The End of Poverty identifies this problem using classic economic development models, primarily the Solow model of economic growth. Easily enough explained, the Solow growth model essentially states that there is a steady

An Analysis of the Hurricane Catrina Relief Effort

3751 words - 15 pages occasion is a necessity. Additional Consequences The rejection of aid by the U.S. government did not only have negative consequences regarding the effectiveness of the relief process, but also negatively impacted our international relations. With poor communication to foreign governments offering incredibly large sums of money to the country, many nations felt disregarded by the U.S. In the future if national disasters occur and we do need

The Effectiveness of Napoleon III's Foreign Policy

1526 words - 6 pages The Effectiveness of Napoleon III's Foreign Policy In general terms, Napoleon's foreign policy was much less successful than his domestic policy was. Generally speaking, the aims of his foreign policy were to present France as the champion of oppressed people throughout Europe, to create new countries, which would be grateful to France, to maintain good relation with Britain and to maintain a balance of power between

The Nation Under the Articles of Confederation

819 words - 3 pages scales throughout the then weak country. Also to aid in judging between effectiveness would be its political organization at the time of the writing of the articles. The Constitution included the two missing branches during the articles, the executive and judicial, differences that contributed to the disaster, one power to create a "check and balance" government and the power to create laws for the country. Another

Helping the World through Humanitarian Aid

975 words - 4 pages out to due to various reasons such as lack of research. However, instead of merely being “good,” the foreign efforts prioritize the process of building relationships with local grassroots as they look for good balance between their roles. As ImageCat and Gem presented effectiveness of their teamwork, I saw hope in collaboration that can be done by different aspects of the society such as businesses, governments, scholars, and NGOs to save more

Health Aid and Global Benefits

2373 words - 10 pages mortality declines among the poorer wealth quintiles”(6). This comes to show that foreign aid does work and it one of the many effective ways to improve poverty levels. The research also shows that countries that have been receiving foreign aid have decrease of child mortality rates and are getting closer to those of the wealthier countries. If health aid was to be eliminated then it will diffidently be a waste effort because the of how much these

American Foreign Policy Position Paper: Trade, Sanctions, Debt, and Investment

5918 words - 24 pages longer either advance U.S. interests abroad or promote economic development" (CI, 2001). Party Mouth feels that these programs have exhausted their effectiveness as well as their popular support and must be immediately eliminated from the United States foreign policy agenda.Foreign aid is mostly intended to provide funds to poor nations for rebuilding and reform, but their more prominent attribute is their cost to the United States. Party Mouth cites

United States Government Welfare

1705 words - 7 pages United States Government Welfare began in the 1930’s during the Great Depression. Franklin D. Roosevelt thought of this system as an aid for low-income families whose men were off to war, or injured while at war. The welfare system proved to be beneficial early on by giving families temporary aid, just enough to help them accommodate their family’s needs. Fast forward almost 90 years, and it has become apparent that this one once helpful system

Similar Essays

Foreign Politics And Economics: Annotated Bibliography

639 words - 3 pages Growth, Vol. 5, No. 1 (Mar., 2000), pp. 33-63. Boone, Peter. “Politics and the Effectiveness of Foreign Aid,” European Economic Review 40 (1996), 289-329. Abbott, George C. “Economic Aid as a Unilateral Transfer of Resources”. Journal of Political Economy, Vol. 78, No. 6 (Nov. - Dec., 1970), pp. 1213-1227. Mikesell, Raymond F. “The Economics of Foreign Aid: Treatises in Modern Economics”. London: Weidenfeld & Nicolson, 1968. World Bank. “Assessing aid

Foreign Aid In Developing Countries Essay

1406 words - 6 pages important to understand the different types of foreign aid in order to evaluate the effectiveness of foreign aid. There are three main types of aid, humanitarian and emergency aid, charity- based aid, and systematic aid (Moyo, 2009, p. 7) Emergency aid is supplied in the occurrence of a natural disaster. In addition, organizations such as World Vision and OxFam distribute charity-based aid. In this paper we will focus on the third type of aid

Foreign Aid And Growth Essay

2173 words - 9 pages I. Aid has no Effect on Growth One of the earliest papers that examined the impact of foreign aid on economic growth was Boone (1995). Boon used a neoclassical model, and his time frame was 4 samples of 5-year average from 1971-1990. He focused on the effect of policy on the effectiveness of aid by comparing three political regime scenarios in developing countries. The first scenario, was egalitarian regime where the government maximize

The Effects Of War And Peace On Foreign Aid In Afghanistan

962 words - 4 pages peaceful Afghanistan with little or no warfare. Works Cited 1. Goodhand Jonathan, Aiding Voilence or Building Peace: The Role of Foreign Aid in Afghanistan, Third World Quarterly,2002, Volume 23 No. 5, pp. 837-359 2. Walden Matt, Aid Effectiveness in Afghanistan, Oxfam International, March 2008, pp. 1-28 3. BruntonKatheryn, Securitization, Democratization and Aid Distribution, March 15th 2013 4. Buckmaster Julia &SuhrkeAstri, Aid, Growth & Peace