Foreign Aid Is Bad Promotes Imperialism Harvard Westlake Research / Debate Thesis

1083 words - 5 pages

I negate the following resolved: Wealthy nations have an obligation to provide developmental assistance to other nations.
My value for today’s debate is utilitarianism. Jeremy Bentham defined Utilitarianism as the doctrine that an action is right insofar as it promotes happiness, and that the greatest happiness of the greatest number should be the guiding principle of conduct. I will prove that developmental assistance is harmful and immoral through offering assistance in the assistant's image.
VC- My value criterion to weigh my value will be maximizing sovereignty
C1- Imperialism
Developmental assistance has proven in history harmful. Western society clearly shows this in the form of imperialism.
SUB A: Countries receiving aid lose their independence and sovereignty through imperialism
Africa has always been abused by imperialism from European nations in the 17th century and still today. Nobel Prize of economics winner Angus Deaton charted over the span of ten years that an influx of foreign aid lowered economic growth. And countries that receive less have a higher economic growth. Foreign aid is mostly brought upon countries with the most natural resources proving that wealthy nations seek the most benefit for themselves. He expressed these opinions most forcefully in a chapter of his recent book The Great Escape: Health, Wealth, and the Origins of Inequality, an excellent book, in which he argues that aid does not work, and that it can accelerate corruption and keep bad leaders in power.
SUB B: Development Assistance Has Unethical Motivations
International Geopolitics Play a Significant Role in Aid Allocation. NJG
Dreher, Axel. Eichenauer, Vera. Gehring, Kai. Langlotz, Sarah. Lohmann, Steffen."Does foreign aid affect growth?” The Center for Economic Policy Research. October 18th 2015. Accessed October 10th, 2017.
Figure 1 gives a hint of the political motives donors might have. The figure shows that countries of particular geostrategic importance – measured by their presence as temporary members of the United Nations Security Council (UNSC) (bolivia, egypt, japan, kazakhstan) – receive substantially more aid than other countries, and get almost twice the aid the same countries receive before they enter the UNSC. This relationship holds in more rigorous settings, highlighting the importance of vote-buying in international organizations as one important motive for giving ‘aid’
SUB C: OBLIGATORY DA CREATES ECONOMIC INSTABILITY
Griffin et al (Magdalen College, Oxford), “Foreign Assistance: Objectives and Consequences”. Economic Development and Cultural Change, Vol. 18, No. 3 (Apr., 1970), pp. 313-327 Published by: The University of Chicago Press Stable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/1152061lk
Even if the primary objective of foreign aid is not to improve the material well-being of the recipient nations, it is still worth examining the effects of capital imports on development. Our thesis is that not all help is helpful; not all aid assists. A...

Find Another Essay On Foreign Aid is Bad - Promotes Imperialism - Harvard Westlake - Research / Debate Thesis

Peer Influence: The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly - This is a research paper on peer influence on middle school students

1387 words - 6 pages believe. "Studies show that, almost always, peer influence is weaker than adults believe" (Black, 2002). Adults tend to underestimate middle school children and their ability to make decisions on their own. When a child commits a wrongdoing, parents automatically want to blame peer influence. Yet research has shown that young adolescents are not necessarily drawn into certain behaviors by peer pressure, rather they decide to be more like their

Animal Rights is the title of this persuasive paper. It includes thesis, topics and clincher,and its about the three main reasons why animal research should not be allowed. 800 words

580 words - 2 pages Animals have been used in medical research for centuries. In a recent count, it was determined that 8815 animals were being used for research at MSU, 8503 of them were rats, mice, hamsters, and gerbils. The strugle against animal research has been one of the most debatable issues of the decade. Even though most researchers need to do experiments on animals in order to achieve medical advances, animal research should not be allowed because it is

Pregnancy and Smoking. This is a Term Paper that I got an (A) on. It's 7 pages long including Bibliography. My research has been wide and thorough enough to support my thesis or purpose

1304 words - 5 pages relationship between sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS) and smoking during pregnancy.II. Ways in Which the Public is Educated About the Issue:The high incidence of smoking during pregnancy presents a serious public health problem; numerous interventions have been developed to counter the current trend. As discussed, smoking during pregnancy is more prevalent among women of lower economic classes and those who are less educated. Accordingly, many

The Pros and Cons of Imperialism

531 words - 2 pages to starvation of native. In document 3, it portrays how the Europeans enforced labor on native people. To conclude, foreign rule is still practiced in the modern world as the means of power. It had many bad and good effects on the native people. Many of those effects you can still notice now such as Moroccans speaking French. From my perspective, imperialism should be practiced to a limited extent such as the aid of a nation that is on the edge of collapsing. Works Cited Prentice Hall Brief Review Global History and geography

Ethical Scenarios In The World of Intelligence

1793 words - 7 pages . Additionally, if Chinese citizens were to die as a result and it was uncovered that the CIA was at fault, it may give China the justification to declare war against the US. This could lead to a number of unnecessary deaths on both sides. Scenario 2, Kidnapping or Killing a Defector: Tommy Westlake is a forty-eight-year-old CIA officer who has spent the majority of his career in the Middle East. In his last overseas assignment, he was the CIA

U.S. Foreign Aid: Its History and Implications

2177 words - 9 pages underdeveloped countries, they have ulterior motives; thus foreign aid is not a totally good thing and it can even be a bad thing. The U.S. promotes development abroad in two ways: with official donations of money through USAID (United States Agency for International Development), the World Bank, the International Monetary Fund (IMF), and the United Nations; and through non-governmental organizations (NGOs) (6). The U.S. gives about 1% of its budget to

colonialism and imperialism

1346 words - 6 pages . Imperialism is imposed when military action is presented to enforce domination over another country. The intention being for imperialism is to increase foreign rule in order to intensify a countries size and economical state. “Our own men and our sons have joined the ranks of the stranger. They have joined his religion and they help to uphold his government” (Achebe 176). In “Things Fall Apart” an accurate illustration of colonialism is given, by which

A Comparison of J. A. Hobson and V. I. Lenin’s Historical Interpretations of Imperialism

848 words - 3 pages Jessica FennellHist 4000September 17, 2014A Comparison of J. A. Hobson and V. I. Lenin's Historical Interpretations of ImperialismAs defined by Merriam-Webster Dictionary, imperialism is a policy or practice by which a country increases its power by gaining control over other areas of the world. J. A. Hobson and V. I. Lenin constructed their own definition and analysis of the matter. Hobson, an English journalist, addressed his capitalist

Aid has made no benefit

2288 words - 10 pages economist, Dambisa Moyo, that this is not always the case. Moyo, is a Zambian-born- Harvard-and-Oxford-educated economist, who in interestingly authored the internationally bestselling book, Dead Aid: Why Aid Is Not Working and How There is Another Way for Africa. She was also a former student of Sachs’ in Harvard, and she remembers quite succinctly how Sachs’ once exclaimed that "the path to long-term development would only be achieved

Imperialism Essay including quotes and various forms of outside information. Got a 97 grade. - Arlington High School APUSH - research paper

1078 words - 5 pages interests and concern that the Filipinos were unfit for self-rule. The ones who were anti-annexation argued that it was morally wrong and not “the American way”. Soon formed was the Anti-Imperialist League, born under the opposition of the annexation of the Philippines, and the debate ensued.            America is a worldwide symbol of freedom, democracy, individuality and independence, and during the time of imperialism, many believed this was

DEBATE QUESTION- GEOGRAPHY

1544 words - 7 pages U S FOREIGN POLICY IMPERILAISM VS BENEVOLENT Imperialism Imperialism is the act of adding more territory to your nation by establishing dominance over the other nations. During the Spanish American war, America received Guam and Puerto Rico. They also received the Philippines for 20 million dollars. America has constantly interfered with other countries by establishing it’s economic, cultural, and military influence over other countries. This

Similar Essays

Foreign Aid Is Used For Illegal Activities

2879 words - 12 pages .”11 Positive vs. Negative Impact of Aid Economists think that aid has either a positive or negative impact on the world. Aid definitely has a positive impact on the trivial things in the world such as humanitarian relief, but there are different views on if foreign aid actually promotes economic growth or not. Aid promotes the economic growth because the main purpose of aid is for it to do so. But aid could negatively impact the world since

Using Animals In Research Is Bad!!

681 words - 3 pages bodies they must go through years of testing. Testing that is unfortunately done on defenseless animals. Each year 50 to 100 million vertebrate animals, such as mice, rats, rabbits, cats and dogs are used in experiments to test products such as medicines, lipstick, household cleaners and pesticides. Along with the vertebrate animals used, primates are also used. It is believed that the animal’s responses to these products can predict the potential

A Research Essay For A Basic Freshman Writing Class. The Thesis Of The Paper Is That Alcohol Is The Worst Drug In The United States.

549 words - 2 pages most dangerous drug to society.Some people say that alcohol should be banned. Despite the overwhelming evidence that alchol is very bad for indivduals and their loved ones, alcohol remains legal in the U.S. During the 1920's the US banned alcohol during a time called Prohibition. This policy is considered to have been a failure because it lead to more organized crime, increased alcoholics and negatively impacted the economy. Alcohol continues to be

This Work Is Basically A Critical Review Of Bergen's Book: Holy War Inc. But It Is Also A Good Source To Aid A Student In His/Her Research Of Us International Policies, Oil, Etc

2263 words - 9 pages , the USS Cole, in Yemen left seventeen American sailors dead."Bergen's concludes his book by maintaining that Osama Bin Laden's Holy War is not a cultural attack against the West, but rather, a condemnation of the United State's Middle Eastern foreign policies: "?the continued American military presence in Arabia, U.S support for Israel, its continued campaign against Iraq and its support for regimes such as Egypt and Saudi Arabia that bin Laden