This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Four Definitions Of Nationalism Essay

1681 words - 7 pages

Nationalism was a debatable issue in 19th century. It had developed differently in Western Europe and Eastern, Central Europe. Western Europe was identified with Civic Nationalism, and nationalism was also seen as an imperialist and economic movement. In Eastern and Central Europe, however, there were many types of nationalism, such as the popular nationalism, that aimed at national liberation and unification. Benedict Anderson has a theoretical definition of nationalism, which aim at correcting previous definitions of nationalism and create a single, universal theory of nationalism. In comparison to Anderson`s definition, Peter Sugar has four different definitions of nationalism that focuses on nationalism in 19th century Europe and tries to prove that the definition of nationalism is different in certain times, places and areas. Based on the primary sources in the section, Sugar`s view of nationalism is more persuasive than the Anderson`s view of nationalism. He has comprehensive approach by his definitions of nationalism; by analyzing different nationalist movements in different parts of Europe he offers complete view of nationalism in 19th century Europe. In comparison to Sugar`s view, Anderson`s definition of nationalism is limited and cannot be applied to any situation involving nationalism.

As an anthropologist, Anderson pursues a theoretical approach and holds a macro level theory of nationalism. By using his grand theory of nations, Anderson defines nation and nationalism as imaginary concepts that are simply created by the people for their own purposes; he believes that definition of nationalism is deficient and never fully evaluated. He formulates a definition of nationalism that can be applied to any society and would work in any cases; he does not analyze nationalism simply by the events and developments in any particular area or time period. He also claims that, nations and nationalism do not exist, and they are simply the products of 19th century. Anderson analyzes the origin and development of nationalism, its popularity, and its impacts on societies in order to justify his definition. Anderson rejects the claim of nationalists that nations are divided by certain boundaries. He believes that there are no such things as the boundaries, and expresses that these boundaries are only imaginations of people. He supports that people in a nation feel connected to each other only because of being a resident of the country. He also accuses the accepted definitions of nationalism and marks that they are limiting the world from improving. He supports that by imagining boundaries mankind will always be separate from each other and never be able to unite together. Therefore, Anderson supports a general definition of nationalism that will unite all societies and improve the world. He also supports that such a strict belief in nationalism can even lead people to die for it, which he finds it...

Find Another Essay On Four Definitions of Nationalism

ethnic nationalism : A case study of pakistan - BA (HONS) - assignment

3516 words - 15 pages definitions and many of them overlap. There is a widespread trend to see nationalism either created by industrialization (argues Ernest Gellner), print capitalism and communication (argues Benedict Anderson) or as a group feeling (argues Antony Smith) that is awakened by the spread of modernity.[endnoteRef:14] [14: “ What is nationalism,, accessed 12th Nov 2014.] The idea of Antony Smith appeared most misplaced

The Origin of Modern Nationalist Movements

1762 words - 7 pages varied agency of the actors involved. Because of this, the study of nationalism has no true definitions; instead, it is filled with loose theories. As Hugh Seton-Watson, author of Nations and States: an Enquiry into the Origins of Nations and the Politics of Nationalism (1977), writes, “I am driven to the conclusion that no ‘scientific definition’ of the nation can be devised; yet the phenomenon has existed and exists.” The Arab Spring represented a

WWI Causes

1701 words - 7 pages were militarism, alliance system, imperialism, and nationalism. Nevertheless, The Most important reasons why the war had started would be alliance and militarism.The Death of Austro-Hungary's "Heir to the Throne" was only part of the reason why the war had begun. After this had happened, Austro-Hungary was infuriated. In addition, they had argued that Serbian's government was implicated with the schemes of the Black Hand Gang. They had shown this

Nationalism in Gitanjali

1243 words - 5 pages Sarkar had divided the Swadeshi(Indian Nationalist Movement) leadership into four categories according to the mode of operation-moderate, extremist, terrorist and constructive.Tagore was an ardent supporter of Indian nationalism and we can attribute constructive mode to Tagore's perspective of nationalism.In Gitanjali Tagore elevated nationalism near to the spiritualism. In poem XXIX the line, "I am ever busy building this wall all around" shows how

Explore the ideas expressed in George Orwell's Essays through analyzing its construction, content and language. Examine how particular features of the text contribute to textual integrity

5277 words - 21 pages encompass a religion, race, ideology or any other abstract idea. Examples of such forms of nationalism given by Orwell include Communism, political Catholicism, Zionism, Anti-Semitism, Trotskyism and Pacifism[1] Orwell additionally argues that the definitions of "nationalism" and "patriotism" are not the same, and that "Patriotism is of its nature defensive… Nationalism, on the other hand, is inseparable from the desire for power."[2]Orwell

Nationalism: The Most Dominate Political Idea in Our Day and Age

1093 words - 4 pages 50 individual states and millions of people but we are all Americans and have a distinct cultural heritage, a heritage of the 'melting pot"; therefore our nationalism is the most important political idea because it tell us and others who we are as a nation state. These four points stand as an example of the importance of nationalism. In conclusion, the nationalism of the 195 individual countries across the world is emulated by the flags of

The Rise of Nationalism After the French Revolution

1485 words - 6 pages notion of nationality was flawed. As stated in “Excerpt from Nationality”, “the greatest adversary of the rights of nationality is the modern theory of nationality” (126). Because there were so many varying definitions of nationalism, it presented a problem for Acton. This confusion presented a boundary for the masses understanding the concept of nationalism, especially after being under various empires for so long previously; people were somewhat

Review of Army of Shadows

1267 words - 5 pages how collaborators were seen from the nationalist leadership to be “traitors.” This has been less considered by historians from both Palestinian and Israeli narratives. Much of Cohen's discussion begins with the rise of nationalism in the early 1920s among Palestinian elites and how this movement was interpreted differently by different groups and ignored altogether by others. In the early days of Palestinian nationalism, Hajj Amin al-Husseini

Chicnano Nationalism: The Freedom to Choose

1801 words - 8 pages working definitions, and the ability to create complications, the freedom to govern one’s own people, and the general freedom to choose, are both manifested at different times throughout the documents. Due to the racist structure of society, La Raza expressed their cultural identity as a point of unity among all Mexican-Americans placing Raza nationalism at the heart of the movement and mobilization. Nationalism, as framed in the plans, works in

The Public Sphere

1161 words - 5 pages The Public Sphere So many definitions are there of the public sphere. One can range from a scale as small as a township to a scale as large as a national government. In the earlier post-revolutionary days of the United States, just what the United States actually was and what it meant were still being defined. Now that the revolution was over, words such as nationalism and patriotism must be

The origins of the First World War

1010 words - 5 pages Balkan nationalism was a major factor in the outbreak of the WWI .It is one of the long-term causes which caused European powers to declare war to each other. Even if the war between Austria and Serbia was expected to be a short one it culminated into a worldwide conflict that lasted four years. The idea of Pan-Slavism was the result of Serbian’s nationalism and Serbia refused to be oppressed by Austria-Hungary. Serbs demanded for rights of self

Similar Essays

What Was The Main Cause Of World War I ? The Four Main Causes Were Imperialism, Militarism, Alliances, And Nationalism. Without These Influences The War Would Have Never Happened

848 words - 3 pages Instead of trying to point to one major cause for the First World War, like many historians attempt to argue, there were many causes that evolved around four major ones. Even Benthmann portrayed his frustration with attempting to isolate a major cause when his reply to the question of what started the war was "Oh, if only I knew". The four main causes were imperialism, militarism, alliances, and nationalism. Without these influences the war

How Does Nationalism Shape China's International Relations?

1601 words - 7 pages a more detailed analysis of China’s nationalism and the impact it has on China’s relations with these countries. These four countries were picked as they have a long history and relationship with China that they sees as important. This essay will argue that although nationalism plays an important part in China’s relations with Japan and the United States, it isn’t the only factor that determines these relationships. The way other states treat

How Does Nationalism Solidify A Country?

1435 words - 6 pages ,” which helps create a person’s identity and political determination. To conclude, a nation not only determined by stability, history, economy but also culture, religion and ethnicity. What is nationalism? Nationalism is the idea of a sense of common identity to a particular geographical area. Before bourgeoisie, feudalism was implemented among countries, such as China, Japan and France. Under this hierarchy, there were different social

Nationalism Essay

1234 words - 5 pages where 800,000 people of the minority Tutsi tribe were massacred in a span of four months by people of the majority Hutu tribe. Such acts of violence can be seen across the world as people follow nationalism not by its original concept but instead make their own views and follow their own ideas and goals. Another example of nationalism being used for destructive purposes would be of the Nazis in WWII. Zimmerin, a political philosopher said that, "The