This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Framing The Innateness Hypothesis Essay

1597 words - 6 pages

Framing the Innateness Hypothesis

Perhaps the most traditional way of framing the innateness hypothesis would be in terms of an opposition between rationalism and empiricism. This is an opposition that is frequently encountered in philosophical debates over language acquisition, with the one side arguing that language acquisition is a phenomenon associated with the maturation of a language faculty or "organ," while the other side argues that language acquisition is instead a process of generalization from experience. Underlying these two positions are specific hypotheses regarding the resources the child brings to the task of acquiring language. The rationalist postulates the existence of innate ideas and/or principles, while the empiricist does not. Chomsky's position, as he consistently has acknowledged for decades, is rationalist. As he put it not long after Aspects appeared, his is a theory of " psychological a priori principles that bears a striking resemblance to the classical doctrine of innate ideas " (Searle 1977 p. 121). This general description is as valid for the current Government Binding (GB) theory as it was for the various Transformational-Generative (TG) programs of the 1960s and 1970s.

Does anything consequential follow from this opposition? I believe it does. Prima facie, of course, there is a significant difference between the assertion that there are innate ideas and principles and the assertion that there are not, and it is reasonable to expect that a research program based on either position would hypothesize explanatory agents, frame questions, and categorize evidence in a way that would differ significantly from the other.

Of perhaps more importance, however, is the fact that rationalist and empiricist hypotheses are addressed to fairly different explananda. In terms of developmental phenomena, the generative theory's rationalism can be seen as largely concerned with explaining the activation of the a priori principles determining the adult's attained language state, whereas more or less empiricist theories -- connectionist-inspired theories come immediately to mind -- have been concerned with explaining the dynamic stages understood to be manifested in the child's linguistic development. Consequently, the rationalist and empiricist explanatory programs are aimed at different fundamental questions regarding language acquisition. Whereas the generative program asks

How are linguistic parameters set on the basis of the input stimuli?

the empiricist program asks

How are the rules of grammar inductively generalized on the basis of the input stimuli?

The object of explanation aimed at in the first question is the maturation of a hypothesized pregiven language faculty, while the corresponding object of explanation aimed at in the second question is the " bootstrapping " by which language is learned. (It is worth noting that the generative program appears to be less concerned with developmental...

Find Another Essay On Framing the Innateness Hypothesis

Positive and Negative Evidence in Language Learning

1038 words - 4 pages maximally constrained – limited in such a way that it can only be used to describe natural languages. The final important criterion is that grammars should be as simple as possible in the sense that they need to be learnable by young children in a short period of time. Theory of language acquisition is focused on the question of how children acquire grammars of their native languages. The innateness hypothesis introduced by Chomsky, suggests

Infant Language Development Essay

1641 words - 7 pages of the larynx, hence greater variety in the production of sounds. (Stoell-Gammon & Menn (1997) (as cited in Bjolrklund, 2005). There are several theories regarding language development. Work by Chomsky, Piaget and Kuhl are critical. Studies by Chomsky, as examined by Albery, Chandler, Field, Jones, Messer, Moore and Sterling (2009); Deloache, Eisenberg & Siegler (2003) argued for the innateness of language acquisition due to its complexity

Decision Making

1036 words - 5 pages the framing of the question, namely framing effect. That is, individuals would choose different options depending on how the question is been asked. Interestingly, some individuals like to choose risk averse choices (e.g., “choices that involves gain” p. 453) while others risk taking choices (“choices that involve losses” p. 453; Tversky & Kahnman, 1981). One of the reason why participants would differ in their choices under the framing effect

Language Development in Exceptional Circumstances: Auditory Impairment

2145 words - 9 pages ” (Sutton-Spence 1994: 216) This study provides evidence for Chomsky’s theory of innateness in language (Pinker 1995) given that humans possess a ‘blue-print’ for language and that language is not modality specific. Language has a robust quality and can be learned by all humans however, specific language isn’t in the genes of a child. Language develops because of input around them. Children would not learn language

Influence of the Chinese Communist Party Over State-Controlled Media and Internet Media

3756 words - 15 pages theory, is a theory that states that individuals will manipulate the system to achieve what is in their best interests, can also be used in the agenda setting context. The newspapers may be driven by personal gains to make money by printing stories about issues that will sell more copies, such as corruption and scandals rather than stories about land reform or farming. Agenda setting and framing are two very closely related but different and complex

Agenda Setting

881 words - 4 pages Sequoia Bey Introduction to Media Theory Victim and the Media This paper will talk about the murder of Trayvon Martin and his killer George Zimmerman. The news outlets taken into consideration are Fox News and MSNBC. In this essay, I will talk about framing, agenda setting, and who owns each of these news channels. Various websites and the class textbook will support all of this. Agenda-setting hypothesis is to show how the media influences the

EVALUATION OF STRESS MANAGEMENT FOR HIGHER SECONDARY STUDENTS IN SALEM DISTRICT-TAMIL NADU

2621 words - 11 pages status and monthly income. This description shows that respondents included in this survey belong to different backgrounds and this turn increase the scope of the study. Analysis Collected data were arranged in logical of sequential order. To analysis the data percentage analysis has been made simple bar diagrams pie charts, has been used for diagrammatic representation of data. Chi-square was used to test the data, hypothesis were framed to

Quantum Theory

929 words - 4 pages . In his book Elementary Principles in Statistical Mechanics (1902), the American mathematical physicist J. Willard Gibbs conceded the impossibility of framing a theory of molecular action that reconciled thermodynamics, radiation, and electrical phenomena as they were then understood.At the turn of the century physicists did not yet clearly recognize that these and other difficulties in physics were in any way related. The first development that

The Efficient Market Hypothesis

1836 words - 7 pages 1. INTRODUCTION The efficient market, as one of the pillars of neoclassical finance, asserts that financial markets are efficient on information. The efficient market hypothesis suggests that there is no trading system based on currently available information that could be expected to generate excess risk-adjusted returns consistently as this information is already reflected in current prices. However, EMH has been the most controversial

Christianity in Early-Modern Europe

1096 words - 5 pages religious lens to give context to his ideas. The fact that he uses reoccurring religious ideas throughout his work reinforces the notion that religion was immensely important throughout early-modern Europe. In contrast to Hobbes' Leviathan, Locke's On Government would at first seem to contradict the hypothesis that religion had an immense impact on the early-modern European world. Indeed, Locke's work clearly contradicts many of Hobbes' arguments. These

Learnability of a Language

2849 words - 11 pages shifted. Deacon does propose less innate brain complexity, but given the credibility he gives to the learnability argument and his advocacy of biased learning, he is far from being an empiricist. The new question is what kinds of innate knowledge are required for language learning. To take one example, Pinker argues that "the data on language acquisition provide little support for" the hypothesis of maturational changes in language acquisition

Similar Essays

Innateness Of Children’s Language Acquisition Essay

1497 words - 6 pages faculty is the initial root of all linguistic grammatical rules and principles; it is the mental archetype of all languages. To begin with, Chomsky chooses to focus on children’s acquisition of language because children have the least pre-existing knowledge of language compared to adults. Children, in this case, are the primal study in the innateness of language. By looking into children’s interaction in language acquisition, Chomsky reasons his

Nature And Nurture In Language Acquisition

2799 words - 11 pages for this universality can be drawn from studies from Stromswold (1990) with fifteen children that showed that the acquisition of more than twenty English auxiliary verbs occurred in the same order. Studies from Pinker (1989) about the errors made by children while learning language (using parents report) also support the innateness claim. He claims that children can use irregular past in English for weeks and then suddenly start making over

English Syntax Summary Essay

750 words - 3 pages innateness hypothesis, which is defined as : “ The hypothesis that states that the course of language acquisition is is determined by an innate language faculty“. However, there is a critical period in which a language may be acquaired, and it is the first few years of a child. Children who tried to learn a language after this period were unable at succeeding at it, and they have never learned to speak properly. When constructing a

Al Jazeera And The Syrian Revolution

1331 words - 6 pages to label Alawite sect and promote the Sunni political Islam in framing civil war in Syria? RQ1: How does Aljazeera present the Alawite sect? RQ2: How does Aljazeera present the Sunni sect? RQ3: How does Aljazeera present Fundamental groups such as Nusra and Ahrar Al sham? RQ4: How does Aljazeera present political Islam? The Sample: A theoretical sample was drawn from the research questions. This sampling method allows the