Is Frankenstein a man, whose ambition led to a disaster; or a monster, which created a
life with disregard for the human race? Frankenstein, in my opinion, was the monster not the life
that he had created. Frankenstein never admitted to his family what he had done, never admitted
responsibility for his actions. He might as well have killed Elizabeth, William, Justine, and
Clerval with his own hand. The so called “Monster” only wanted companionship; he did not
want to murder those people. The circumstances forced him to commit murder. Frankenstein
was the instigator of those circumstances.
To me, Frankenstein and the monster are one and the same. While reading this book the
thought that kept occurring to me was that Victor had multiple personality disorder. Although
the book Frankenstein is a work of fiction, does it not suggest that Victor was the one
committing these vile acts? The persona of the monster is just his conscience making it easier
for Victor to dismiss the atrocious acts that he had committed. Shelley’s reference to “My first
thought was to discover what I knew of the murderer and cause instant pursuit to be made. But I
paused when I reflected on the story I had to tell.”(Frankenstein, Mary Shelley), showed that
Victor had the knowledge that he was the reason William was dead. Frankenstein didn’t need to
know about the murderer, because he was the murderer. No Hero in Mary Shelley’s
Frankenstein cites “He is so self-centered that his lack of interaction and love for others after his
experiment has been completed, would barely qualify him as a person, if the difference between
being human and being a person lies in the ability to have relationships with others.” This
statement suggests to me that he created this other personality so that he didn’t have to deal with
his own shortcomings.
The word “Frankenstein” is defined in the dictionary (Encarta Dictionary) as “a creator of
something that causes ruin or destruction, or brings about a personal downfall. Shelley definitely
chooses the name well. Victor certainly created something that caused destruction, not only in
his own life but in others lives as well. Justine took the fall for Victor, dying for his secret.
Elizabeth died because Victor chooses not to create another monster. The monster did not
necessarily want another monster-like companion, he just wanted acceptance. Victor brought
about his own destruction. In Finding Virtue in Frankenstein the author states, “Never learning
self-criticism, Victor believes that the Monster is an ill-fortuned mistake and not a reflection of
his own character or misjudgment.” Victor’s own choices created the war he was in.
Victor’s ability to deal with the real world was almost nonexistent. He had only one
friend, Clerval. His choice for a wife was a person he called “cousin”, but in fact was his
adopted sister. Did Victor create this so-called “monster” to have a friend, the one thing the
monster wished for?...