Frankenstein: Philosophizing On The Nature Human

1650 words - 7 pages

In her author’s note, Mary Shelley tells of the motivation that lit the spark for what would become one of the most famous novels of all time. Interestingly enough, Frankenstein was the result of a bet between four noted writers of the time: Mary (of course), her husband Percy Shelley, Lord Byron, and John Polidori. They all agreed to write a ghost story, and of the four Mary was the only one to finish. She writes that she wanted a story that would rival all other ghost stories. She said that she wanted to write a story that would, “…speak to the mysterious fears of our nature and awaken thrilling horror…” (Shelley, xxiii). In fact, if one were to take English author M. R. James’ points of what makes a true ghost story, then Frankenstein is a perfect ghost story. There are five points that he makes: 1. it has to have a pretense of truth, 2. No gratuitous bloodshed or sex, 3. No “explanation of the machinery”, 4. setting must be of the writer’s own day, and 5. “A pleasing terror”. It is this last point that James says is “the true aim of the ghost story.” Shelley, before she started writing, was set on making this her main purpose of the novel. The result of her toils is a novel that explores the argument of Nature vs. Nurture through her two main characters, Victor and the Monster, by creating them in the image of the two major arguments of the human condition in the 18th and 19th century.
On one side, there’s Victor. He is very easily described as an ambitious and bright young man, both that can be positive attributes of his character. However, both of these turn out to contribute to his hubris, in that after he discovers the “cause of generation and life” (Shelley, 37) he distances himself from society, locking himself in a “solitary chamber” for over two years. Victor’s character, during and after the creation of the Monster, exemplifies Genevan philosopher Jean-Jacques Rousseau and English philosopher Thomas Hobbes’ views on human nature.
Garrath Williams’ summary of Hobbes’s picture of human nature is that we are “…vulnerable…easily led astray in our attempts to know the world around us…When we act, we may do so selfishly or impulsively or in ignorance…” (Williams). Wasn’t that what Frankenstein was doing while he was creating the Monster? He was not aware of the future consequences that would be the result of his creation. He made no attempt to contact his family and friends, he became so caught up in his work that at some point he had forgotten about them completely.
Once he completes his project and realizes the mistake he has made he is plunged into what Hobbes calls the “natural condition of mankind”. Shelly, however, in keeping truth preserved, does not do away with government as Hobbes describes, but Frankenstein is cast into a state of being that would follow the absence of government: “a state of violence, insecurity, and constant threat.” (Williams)
Now, Shelley also used another philosopher’s idea of the “natural human”...

Find Another Essay On Frankenstein: Philosophizing on the Nature Human

Nature vs. Nurture and the Impacts on Human Intelligence

2276 words - 9 pages education. A higher emphasis is placed on that individual's educational future. This act in itself alters the environmental influence on the individual's intelligence. From the examples used in this paper we can see an argument for environmental influences taking shape as the majority defining factor of an individual's intelligence level. I conclude that while both nature and nurture have varying influences on human development, it is the

Different Viewpoints on Human Nature Essay

739 words - 3 pages Different Viewpoints on Human Nature Throughout history there have been arguments about anything and everything that is disagreeable. People innately have there own and often different opinions. A prominent discussion topic throughout history has been the nature of mankind. Many have written works about human nature but few are discussed in greater detail than Candide, The Prince, and Essay on Man. Voltaire, Niccolo Machiavelli, and

Thrasymachus' Perspective on Human Nature

1340 words - 5 pages Thrasymachus' Perspective on Human Nature Thrasymachus' perspective of human nature is that we all seek to maximize power, profit and possessions. He gives the argument that morality is not an objective truth but rather a creation of the stronger (ruling) party to serve its own advantage. Therefore definitions of "just" and "unjust", "right" and "wrong", "moral" and "immoral" are all dependent upon the decree of the ruling party

On Evil and Human Nature

858 words - 3 pages When prompted about the true nature of the human race, a great majority assumes “survival” instead of “good”. What this assumption leads to is a study of weather the human race is in fact “good” as people would like to think. In fact the one think that has allowed our race to survive is praying on the weaker, so are we morally “evil” by allowing our nature to dominate over us? If so is this nature a true evil? Many philosophers have studies

The Theme of Nature in Frankenstein

2340 words - 9 pages De Lacey’s house. In the essay, “Frankenstein and Mary Shelley’s “wet ungenial summer””, Phillips states, If we do, nature has a habit of reminding us that it is there, just as the monster, a force of nature perverted by human ingenuity, is constantly remaining Victor Frankenstein of his existence. (Phillips 6) The creature always follows Victor, reminding him that he is there. The creature will show up when Victor least expects it and he

Nature Vs. Nurture In the Novel Frankenstein

2205 words - 9 pages , Nicholas. The Nature-nurture Controversy. New York: King's Crown, 1949. Print.) The importance of nurturing a human being is that all circumstances has such an immense impact on what the child will become. In the case of the monster in Frankenstein, his rejection from Victor is the center of the events that take place in the novel. Every event that the monster experienced was negative. As we already know, the more the monster had learned, the more

The Roots of Human Nature

690 words - 3 pages The Roots of Human Nature The roots of human nature are sunk deep into our history and experiences. When in our own lives we are to find the basis of our human nature, we must look to our early years, the formative years. Now take for example if we placed a newborn in the wild or in a high-class, well-mannered, wealthy family. The human nature of the newborn in the wild will be exactly that, wild and chaotic. While on the other hand the

Essay on the Human Spirit in Frankenstein and Picture of Dorian Grey

756 words - 3 pages Similarities of the Human Spirit in Frankenstein and The Picture of Dorian Grey      The human spirit is one of the most beautiful forces in the world, but it is also one of the most vulnerable. In the novels Frankenstein by Mary Shelley and The Picture of Dorian Grey by Oscar Wilde, this idea of the human spirit is portrayed clearly. Both novels have similar aspects about the human spirit, but they also have

The Flaws in Human Nature

1115 words - 4 pages The Flaws in Human Nature The story is known. A boy buys magic beans from a seller, plants the bean, and a giant bean stalk sprouts. The boy climbs it and meets a giant. This giant however is not like the giant in “The Selfish Giant”, by Oscar Wilde. While reading this short story a theme at first glance did not surface. But while dissecting it, readers will see that this is a follow-up of Adam and Eve with many lessons that the reader can

The Duality of Human Nature

1038 words - 5 pages In The Strange Case of Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde, Robert Louis Stevenson expresses the concept of the duality of man. Using gothic literature, he depicts the idea of man’s doubled nature. Stevenson demonstrates through the character Henry Jekyll the duality of human nature and the constant battle of good and evil inside all individuals. In Victorian society, maintaining a good reputation is of utmost importance (Perkins 207). For instance, Dr

The Human Nature of Medea

2040 words - 8 pages The Rhetoric and The Poetics of Aristotle, trans. W. Rhys Roberts andIngram Bwater. New York: 1954.Bates, W.N. Euripides: A Study of Human Nature, New York: 1961.Conacher, D.J. Euripidean Drama, Toronto: 1967.Euripides. Medea, in The Norton Anthology World Masterpieces, trans. Rex Warner.New York: 1992.Kitto. Greek Tragedy, New York: 1952.Norwood, Gilbert. Greek Tragedy, New York: 1960.Conacher, D.J. Euripidean Drama, Toronto: 1967.Snodgrass, Mary Ellen, Cliffs Notes on Greek Classics, Lincoln: 1988.

Similar Essays

Perspectives On Human Nature In ‘Frankenstein’ And ‘Moby Dick’

1415 words - 6 pages Romantic literature, at its very essence, attempts to deal with the subject of human nature (Wang, 2011). Both Mary Shelley’s ‘Frankenstein’ and Herman Melville’s ‘Moby-Dick,’ being Romantic texts, each offer their own perspective on the true essence of humanity. While their perspectives are largely similar due to the era they originated in, with both reasoning that humanity possesses an excessive pride in the desire to exceed its limits that is

Victor Frankenstein Defies Human Nature Essay

1314 words - 5 pages motivation was for his own pride and power. We realize that Victor is actually the monster himself. Victor breaks boundaries on life, violates morality, manipulates human nature, and he changes history. Works Cited Shelley, Mary. Frankenstein. New York: Barnes & Noble Classics, 2003. "The Story." Galileo. Salem Press Encyclopedia of Literature, Sept. 2013. Web. 31 March 2014 Clerval, Walton H. "Literary Intelligence." Romantic Circles. RC

Analysis On Human Nature

1565 words - 7 pages which of these is superior. Finally, I will conclude with my opinion on human nature, and my personal beliefs in the matter. To begin with, what is human nature specifically? Human nature can be described as the general psychological characteristics, feelings, and behavioral traits of humankind, regarded as shared by all humans. Charles Darwin, the father of the evolutionary theory, believed that human nature could be explained trough natural

Essay On Human Nature And The Canterbury Tales

1586 words - 6 pages Human Nature and The Canterbury Tales       When Geoffrey Chaucer undertook the writing of The Canterbury Tales, he had a long road ahead of him. He intended to tell two stories from each of thirty pilgrims on the way to Canterbury, and then two more from each pilgrim on the way back from Canterbury. Of these, he completed only twenty-four. However, in these tales, Chaucer depicts both the pilgrims and their stories with striking realism