Free Will And Religion In The Aeneid And Plato Seminar, Bard Essay

979 words - 4 pages

1
Quinn Henegar
John Adams
Seminar
25 November 2017
Free Will and Religion
Fate and free will plays a big role in a lot of religious texts. That’s because, in a way,
religion can strip a person of their free will. In ​The Aeneid ​the Gods determine the humans’ fate.
More specifically, seems to be calling all the shots. With Jupiter determining the humans fate, it
takes away their free will because whenever they attempt to make their own decisions against
his, they are somehow punished. Another text that fate and free will plays a big role in is ​Plato:
The Allegory of the Cave. ​It’s not as literal as it is in ​The Aeneid​, it’s more of a representation in
this text. The Cave represents religion keeping people prisoners in a sense. They only see what's
shown to them.
In ​The Aeneid, ​there is a character named Aeneas and according to Jupiter, Aeneas's fate
is to establish a new Trojan race in Italy. There are other gods who don’t want this to happen,
like Juno. And unlike Aeneas, she is a god so she can tamper with fate without consequences.
She can’t change it because Jupiter is the main god in this story who controls fate. An example
of Juno tampering with fate is shown in the first book when starts a storm in attempt to kill the
Trojans, she states “Thrash your winds to fury, sink their warships, overwhelm them or break
them apart, scatter their crews, drown them all” ( 49) but Neptune stops the storm and puts the
ships back on track. This happens because Aeneas's fate is set and Juno knows this as she says
2
“Defeated, am I? Give up the fight? Powerless now to keep that trojan king from Italy. Ah but of
course- the fates bar my way” (48). She’s stating she knows that she can’t stop Aeneas and his
crew from reaching Italy because of fate. But if fate is determined by Jupiter, then Jupiter is the
one in control and it’s not really fate stopping her at all, It’s just Jupiter.
Aeneas is kept from doing what he wants by the fates, in other words, by the gods
because the gods are the ones that determine and control fate, thus stripping him of his free will.
In book two of ​The Aeneid​, Aeneas and the rest of the Trojans try to settle in Crete instead of
going to Italy like his fate entails. This was Aeneas trying to implement free will, which turns out
badly because the gods don’t want that to happen. They want to be in control. To remind the
humans that they are to do what they are told, they are punished with death and tragedy. “Our
ships were no sooner hauled onto dry land, our young crewman busy with wedding, plowing
fresh soil; while I was drafting laws and assigning homes, when suddenly, no warning out of
some foul...

Find Another Essay On Free Will and Religion in the Aeneid and Plato - Seminar, Bard - Essay

Promoting Morality in the Aeneid and Metamorphoses

1653 words - 7 pages ' societal aims were, both The Aeneid and Metamorphoses are mythological and etiological justifications for humanity's role in the ever-changing world. Works Cited Anderson, William. The Art of the Aeneid. Prentice-Hall In., Englewood Cliffs, N.J. 1969. Austin, R.G. Aeneidos, Liber Primus. Clarendon Press, Oxford. 1984. Bailey, Cyril. Religion in Virgil. Oxford University Press, Great Britain. 1935. Block, Elizabeth. The Effects

Destiny, Fate, Free Will and Free Choice in Oedipus the King - Fate and the Modern World

985 words - 4 pages the will of the gods and initiated a series of events which would eventually lead to the complete fulfillment of the oracle’s prophecy.          Does man have free will or is fate a preordained path which a man is required to follow? An individual schooled in modern western thought might feel this question is simple-minded and not deserving of a thoughtful response.  A common response may be, “I am in control, and fate has noting to do with

The Underworld and Morality in Vergil's Aeneid

1063 words - 4 pages The Underworld and Morality in Vergil's Aeneid Book IV of the Aeneid can stand alone as Vergil's highest literary achievement, but centered in the epic, it provides a base for the entire work. The book describes Aeneas's trip through the underworld, where after passing through the depths of hell, he reaches his father Anchises in the land of Elysium. Elysium is where the "Soul[s] to which Fate owes Another flesh" lie (115). Here Anchises

Spinoza And Free Will

984 words - 4 pages against the establishment of free will and basis for judgement of free will exists or not.           Spinoza, Paul, Augustine, Luther have all grappled with this question of free will for many years. What has been said goes to a religious side. Which has been believed of an omnipotent God who will preordain who would be saved and who would be lost. In the simple but complex question in the book of

Fate and Free Will

1005 words - 5 pages even, would it mean that I am destined to remain a perpetual student because I will never find my calling (like Trofimov from the Cherry Orchard)? I’d rather think that with hard work, I can pick my destiny. It is human nature to want to have control and with a predetermined fate, this isn’t possible. Free will can be more scary than fate in some instances. Unlike fate, free will can easily be taken away. Teenagers in particular have a strong

Determinism and Free Will

883 words - 4 pages Determinism and free will are incompatible. The events in people’s lives are already chosen for us, or determined. The expected behaviors of people are explained by natural laws and by experiences that they were exposed to. But this viewpoint does not explain people’s intuition. Although, there is a chain of physical causes that lead into people’s intuition. The incompatibility of free will and determinism can be best described by the law of

Free Will and Determinism

2017 words - 9 pages usually required in order to say that something was done “on purpose.” Agents can choose either way based on their free will, and if they succeed, despite the probability of failure, they are responsible because they have succeeded at what they were trying to do in the first place. Kane says that indeterminism is consistent with nondeterministic or probabilistic causation, where the outcome is not inevitable, and therefore it is a mistake to say

Free Will And Determinism

679 words - 3 pages Gregg Andrews Phi 130 November 1, 2001 Writing Assignment 2 Free Will And Determinism The problem of free will and determinism has troubled the mind of man since time began. The reason it is a problem is that no one knows the truth. There are two sides to this issue. One side says, "Everything in the universe is governed by causal laws." This view is called hard determinism. The opposite if this view is the libertarian theory. This view believes

Destiny, Fate, Free Will and Free Choice in Oedipus the King - The Fate of Oedipus

1302 words - 5 pages The Fate of Oedipus in Oedipus the King   In "Oedipus the King" there comes a point in the play where Oedipus learns something that plays an important role throughout the play.   He learns from a  oracle that he will eventually kill his own Father and sleep with his own mother.  As one could imagine this is a shock to Oedipus, and he does not believe the oracle.  However, he cannot prevent any of this from

The Workings of Destiny, Fate, Free Will and Free Choice in Oedipus the King

698 words - 3 pages Fate in Oedipus Rex   Sophocles' tragic tale of Oedipus presents the reader with a very bleak view of mankind and the world in general. According to the story, every person is predestined to enact a role scripted by fate, a "mysterious power" that rules even the greatest of Greek gods (Hamilton, 27). In this tale, the source of this fate is not as clear as its function.      The first of many allusions to fate in Oedipus the

The Place of Destiny, Fate, Free Will and Free Choice in Macbeth

3146 words - 13 pages the place of fate in the decline of Macbeth:    "One feels," says W.C. Curry, "that in proportion as the good in him diminishes, his liberty of free choice is determined more and more by evil inclination and that he cannot choose the better course. Hence we speak of destiny or fate, as if it were some external force or moral order, compelling him against his will to certain destruction." Most readers have felt that after the initial crime

Similar Essays

Destiny, Fate, Free Will And Free Choice In Oedipus The King The Paradox Of Free Will

1315 words - 5 pages A Paradox: Oedipus's Free will in the Play Oedipus Rex William Shakespeare once wrote, "Who can control his fate?" (Othello, Act v, Sc.2). A hero and leader must acknowledge above all else his honor, and the pride of his image.  In ancient Greek beliefs, a hero was a man who stood taller than the rest; he was able to better any conflict.  He did this not for himself or for any token award that may be given to him, but for the security of

Essay On Fate And Human Responsibility In The Aeneid

2822 words - 11 pages , the tragedy of 'fatum' is revealed in the deaths of Dido and Turnus, who are mere innocent victims of fate.  Anderson notes: "Everything that Aeneas does seems to have its cruel price; every time he promotes the destined future he also hurts the present condition of someone else" (26). Yet, out of all the characters in the Aeneid, readers will pity Dido the most.  Turnus could fight back against fate, but Dido can't.  In fact, Poschl argues that

This Essay Will Aim To Discuss Durkheim And Marx In The Context Of Sociology Of Religion

1967 words - 8 pages This essay will aim to discuss Durkheim and Marx in the context of sociology of religion. The first part will briefly define religion and then acknowledge Durkheim being a functionalist and Marx and his conflict theory. Finally will then go onto compare and contrast both their ideas on religion.Religion is a way of life and can be a type of government, as it entails rules that are set out and have to be followed.Religion is also a set of beliefs

Relinquishment Of Free Will In The Birthmark And Carnal Knowledge

1202 words - 5 pages , and they justify that choice with emotional devotion. Both stories describe how this voluntary relinquishment of free will results in misfortune and unhappiness. The use of weak characters in major roles allows the authors to illustrate the dangers of putting oneself in such a position. WORKS CITED Boyle, T. Coraghessan. "Carnal Knowledge." The Compact Bedford Introduction to Literature. Ed. Michael Meyer. 5th ed. Boston: Bedford/St. Martin's, 2000. 242-255. Hawthorne, Nathaniel. "The Birthmark." The Compact Bedford Introduction to Literature. Ed. Michael Meyer. 5th ed. Boston: Bedford/St. Martin's, 2000. 277-288.