Freedom Of Press Or Danger To Troops?

965 words - 4 pages

Freedom of Press or Danger to Troops?
The news has been an important source of information for as long as it has been around. News during a time of war is sometimes the only way a family member, friend, or general public have any idea what the soldiers are going through. Having this source of information can help rally support for our troops when they need all the support they can get. As reporters are granted more access to military operations the information they are provided, and have to report on, become a great responsibility and they should make sure to only make public what should be made public. Information is increasingly becoming the most important weapon in any militaries arsenal, so we should be more careful as to how that information is obtained and dispersed.
With respect to the war in Iraq and other military operations abroad I don’t feel the press should be required to be given as much information or granted as much battlefield access as they have been. I am all for the freedom of the press and being informed as to what is happening to our troops, but to many times has information been distributed that could have had a negative impact on the outcome of an operation. One example is when Geraldo Rivera basically drew out in the sand on live television the position of the troops he was tagging along with. “Geraldo Rivera, reporting from Iraq for Fox News last week, drew a map in the sand, on camera, that gave away his unit's location” (Poniewozik 1). As he should have been, Geraldo was punished for that and told to leave Iraq and report from Kuwait. This was not the only example of this kind of reporting mistake made during that war.
Reporters often interview retired generals or other government officials to try and understand as much about the war and how the United States handles war. “At a Pentagon briefing, General Richard Myers blasted retired generals serving as news analysts for criticizing the Pentagon's war plans” (Poniewozik 1). In that example they didn’t give away any secrets, but simply criticizing current war plans could be harmful for the troops moral and the averages citizens trust in the president. “Basing editorial decisions on what's "helpful" for troops and patriots may make for outstanding morale — and probably even better ratings” (Poniewozik 1). Further consideration for what is being said should be given to prevent things like this from happening.
In future conflicts their will have to be greater ground rules and policies laid down for the media. The Iraq war, which was a first of its kind with embedded reporters, had some basic rules laid out. “Although all journalists will have to abide by basic rules for travel with the units, each commander will have the flexibility to restrict access based on need” (Strupp 1). “NBC News, and every other news organization that wanted to be embedded with the military, had to agree to some...

Find Another Essay On Freedom of Press or Danger to Troops?

Freedom of Press in Cuba. Essay

614 words - 3 pages Cuba has very low rank in World Press Freedom index by Reporters Without Borders. World Press Freedom index places Cuba at No. 171 out of 181. Cuba is the world known country because of political issues and government mechanism. Cuba is socialism country so it is very close to communism, what means that the government has the first position and controls everything. Cuba has the most restrictive laws on freedom of speech. Since Cuba became

Should Freedom of the Press be Limited to Protect National Security?

1597 words - 6 pages law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances” (Fiorina). Freedom of the Press, a right stated in the First Amendment, “Protects the right to obtain and publish information or opinions without government censorship or fear of punishment…applies to

Is Freedom of Press really exists in no limit

1185 words - 5 pages public to provide the evidence, such as the videotapes or photos they cap for the incident which have not been verified before uploading. This can make the public feel they have larger degree of sense of freedom of press and of expressions when using online networks as it seem to have less control when compare with reality. They seems can even report the news or the events that do not revealed by the TV news or any other media through the use of

Freedom of the press, globalization, public diplomacy and current events.

2047 words - 8 pages conditions and social values. These concepts include Authoritarian, Western, Communist, Revolutionary and Developmental.The Authoritarian concept holds that the government is always allowed to control the press. Any news reported on the government should make the government look good to the public. News that does have negative reports on the government will result in censorship, shutting down publications or jailing journalists. A key example of the

Freedom of Religion, Speech, Press, Assembly, and Petition

918 words - 4 pages Freedom of Religion, Speech, Press, Assembly, and Petition There are three main reasons why we have or need our Freedom of religion, speech, press, assembly, and petition. First, the 1st Amendment gives us our independence. Second, it also gives us the right to express ourselves. Last but not least, it allows people to express themselves without constraint by the government. The 1st Amendment is a very essential freedom

Is canada in danger of breaking apart or civil war?

903 words - 4 pages Is Canada in danger of breaking apart or Civil War?Canada is in a slight danger of breaking apart, yet it is probable that Canada is not in danger of civil war. The basis for the separation of Yugoslavia's various cultures was due to ethno-nationalism. When compared to Yugoslavia's conditions prior to their break-up, Canada's situation is somewhat similar; although, Yugoslavia and Canada are entirely different countries on a variety of levels

The Possible Danger of Mobile Phones to our Health

2670 words - 11 pages The Possible Danger of Mobile Phones to our Health Ever since the price of mobile phones dropped, resulting in a huge increase in the number of people owning them, the question has always been asked as to whether they are safe and if they pose a danger to our health. The full results of long-term use on such a huge scale has never been able to be tested, as quite simply they have not been around long enough for the

Freedom of religion or belief in russia

2020 words - 9 pages different law based on; customary law, statutes, court presidents, administrative regulations and many more, while Russia chose the constitution. According to The Constitution of Russian Federation (1993), “Everyone shall be guaranteed the right to freedom of conscience, to freedom of religious worship, including the right to profess, individually or jointly with others, any religion, or to profess no religion, to freely choose, possess and

America, Land of the free. Discusses what would happen if it didn't have the freedom of press, and the freedom of speech

807 words - 3 pages America, land of the free. America, a country based in many ways on the freedom of press, and the freedom of speech. But what would happen to this great country, tis of thee, if these precious rights had ceased to exist? America, the land of liberty and home of the brave, would hold a great stock of uninformed and uneducated community, ready to rise up to anarchy at any moment; a crowd of undiverse and ununified people; and a population of souls

The Importance of the Printing Press to the Development of the Reformation

708 words - 3 pages corrupt teachings, Luther used the press to his advantage and his opposition never used the press as well as him, and in a time when this was the main way of communication, I think it was very crucial to the development of ideas and effectively the development of the Reformation. However, there is some controversy amongst 20th century historians about whether or not the printing press caused the Reformation

Has Culture Enhanced or Hindered my Freedom of Choice

798 words - 3 pages How has my culture enhanced or hindered my freedom of choice? First I ask myself “What is culture to me?”. My definition of culture would be common thoughts, beliefs, and behaviors that are carried from one generation to the next. Then I ask “What is freedom of choice?” When I think of the expression “freedom of choice”, I think of an individual going through life making choices as they please. I, being that individual, do make my own

Similar Essays

Freedom Of Speech And Press In Venezuela: In Danger Of Disappearing

1348 words - 5 pages An awful reality, the freedom of speech and press in Venezuela is in danger of disappearing. In Venezuela, if someone has a different opinion of the President of the country, Hugo Chavez, could be penalized. Can the opposition movements, including student force, change this current reality? What can the common citizens do against the government when every day it is capable of setting down more severe restrictions to silence the press? Should the

Pornography On The Internet, Freedom Of Press Or Dangerous Influence?

2084 words - 8 pages freedom or censorship cites the U.S. and bases arguments on the First Amendment. With this precedent setting responsibility, one must look at what is going on in the Supreme Court with regards to the Internet.Peter H. Lewis, a reporter for the New York Times, has been covering the Computer Decency Act since passing of the law. The Computer Decency Act, part of the Telecommunications Act, was passed on February 8, 1996. The main purpose of this

Freedom Of Press Essay

2453 words - 10 pages The Frist Amendment (1791) to the Constitution of the United States (“Congress shall make no law… abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press…”) holds the importance of the freedom of speech and press as one of the most basic rights of US citizens and reporters in the process of upholding a democratic society. Freedom of expression; the ability of people to communicate their feelings and thoughts effectively, without fear of being

Freedom Of The Press Essay

5629 words - 23 pages press.       Thomas Jefferson, on the necessity of a free press (1787) The basis of our government being the opinion of the people, the very first object should be to keep that right; and were it left to me to decide whether we should have a government without newspapers, or newspapers without a government, I should not hesitate a moment to prefer the latter.       * * * * * The origins of freedom of speech and press are nearly alike