This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Freedom Of Speech And Violent Video Games

2134 words - 9 pages

Most people see a violent video game being sold and do not think twice about it. The sale of violent video games in our current system is normal. In 2008, 298.2 million video games were sold in the US, totaling $11.7 billion in revenue. Six of the top ten best-selling video games included violence, with four of the games carrying a "Mature" rating recommended for persons aged 17 and older (Procon). In June 2011, the case of Brown v. Entertainment Merchants Association California attempted to enforce a statute that gives a punishment for selling violent video games to minors (Herard 515). Entertainment Merchants Association took this statute to court saying it violated rights given to the people under the first amendment. Both sides of the case had a well constructed argument. The Supreme Court had a final decision of seven to two. Even though the decision was not very close, both sides need to be looked at to understand how the decision came about.
The time prior to this case, violence due to videogames was being shown by the media more than ever. There was always a news article on the kid who beat up another kid because he learned it in the video game he just got. A game fell into the violent category if its depictions of
violent acts (1) were rendered in a way that "[a] reasonable person. considering the game as a whole, would find appeals to a deviant or morbid interest of minors," (2) were "patently offensive to prevailing standards in the community as to what is suitable forminors," and (3) would cause "the game, on the whole, to lackserious literary, artistic, political, or scientific value for minors" (Herard 516). Brown wanted it to be harder for minors to get these violent videogames, and if the game was sold to a minor there would be a fine of $1000 imposed. They felt this punishment could substantially lower the amount of violence with minors. California enacted the statute not thinking it would be a possible violation of the first amendment; they were only trying to actually take a stand. However the enactment of this statute started a war in the gaming industry.
Entertainment Merchant Association believed the statute in affect was unconstitutional and therefore should be stopped. Their argument was the law took away the basic right of freedom of speech. The video game makers had the right to portray any situation they wanted and sell the game to mature audiences; whether or not the parent of a minor bought the game for their child was entirely up to the parents. Placing a fine on the person that buys for or sells to a minor is taking that person’s right to freely speak. The Court suggests that video games are essentially similar to other First Amendment-protected forms of literature, regardless of the complexity of the technology involved (Herard 525). Even though a violent game is not a piece of literature, it is still a form of expression and should be held under the protected forms of speech.
The argument put up by...

Find Another Essay On Freedom of Speech and Violent Video Games

Effects of Violent Video Games on Young Children and Teenagers

1260 words - 5 pages During different periods of time, people used different types of entertainment. Nowadays, the adults are usually entertaining themselves with media, and children, who are not really impressed by television, usually are font of video games. In would be good, if the games were not violent. Would you like your young or teenage child to play games, where they kill each other, and get points for this? I consider it to be the rhetorical question

Violent Video Games Essay

1634 words - 7 pages The Dangers of Violent Video Games Today, video games have become very popular. The first video game was created in the year 1958; it was a video game of table tennis. One of the most popular video game categories is violent video games. This has become very popular by many teens specifically teen boys. There are many cons about violent video games and one should be aware of them before he or she buys or plays a violent video game

Violent Video Games

1167 words - 5 pages Bang! Bang! Bang! That’s a kill! Bonus points for Headshot. The little kid gets excited for the whole day because of what just happened and during dinner he pulls out a fake gun and starts shooting it. This is exactly why Proponents take their side in this argument by saying that violent video games contribute to Youth Violence. However Detractors argue that there is more to youth violence than just violent video games. Evidence from

Violent Video Games

746 words - 3 pages Are violent video games dangerous for young minds and society? No, because in some ways kids are smart enough not to go out and kill someone or steal a car. One reason is that society is most of the buyer of their kids or minors video games so if they wanted to have the influence that there kids might go out and kill someone. Then why would they buy it? My second reason is that kids like I said are not under the influence of their video

Violent Video Games

1373 words - 5 pages Did you know that the average amount of time an 8-18 American child spends on video games per week is 8 hours? That’s a more than a whole school day! Many kids today are spending more and more time on video games. Not only is it damaging to the brain and body, but it also can cause insanity and dementia. Many of the mass murderers of the past have been found to play violent video games. Teens should not be permitted to play violent video games

violent video games

855 words - 4 pages Many people believe violence in video games result in violent outbreaks and unhealthy behavior in real world. Since the first Nineteen Eighties, violence in video games became a part of a political issue leading advocates to create theories that these styles of games are corrupting society. Studies have been created to seek out if there's a link between violent video games and violent behavior. Are these video games shaping today’s generation of

Violent Video Games

1046 words - 5 pages play violent video games because the games may affect their ability to handle some situations, the intensity of the language and gore could be too much, and the storylines of the games could have a negative influence. Children learn how to respond to different situations from past experiences and observations that may be influenced by something that is constantly seen or surrounding them. Violent video games can be a strong influence in their

Violent Video Games - 2332 words

2332 words - 10 pages Violent video games are undoubtedly a legalized drug to children and teens, numbing their thoughts and reprogramming their minds. Like a drug, it desensitizes them, and makes them more prone to violence. This idea of violent video games was not a phenomenon until the later 20th century, and evolved from racing into enemies, to free-for-all drug abuse and sexual/physical violence that most youth know and play today. These games have a

violent video games

847 words - 4 pages There are claims that violent video games cause violence in kids but there are also people who say they don’t. The people who are in the pro side that are critics of violent video games claim that violent video games start school shootings and violence in youth. The people who are con side who defend violent video games say that violent video games do not cause violence in youth but instead provide a healthy opportunity for children to virtually

Violent Video Games - 1663 words

1663 words - 7 pages Adolescents who frequently play violent video games and movies without the proper education and care can increase the chance of them displaying violent behavior in adulthood. I asked some parents why they let their kids play violent video games. Those parents would say “it doesn’t matter what they play, it’s your job to educate your kids on what’s right from wrong, to distinguish fantasy from reality.” They say “if you restrict your kids from

Violent Video Games Shouldn

877 words - 4 pages Violent Video Games Shouldn't Be BannedWritten by: Nick LilleymanHumanity has had many scapegoats for violent acts during all it's ages, as long as there is something a person doesn't like people will always find a source to blame. Video games have been under a lot of scrutiny over the last few years. Many people believe that they have harmful side effects, and that teenagers should not be allowed to play them. The effects of violence in the

Similar Essays

Video Games And Violent Video Games' Effect

1578 words - 6 pages warn the buy it may be inappropriate for young people. Parents, contribute to the problem because they buy their kids violent video games, usually unknowing it contains violent content. Efforts to ban violent video games have failed in the past, this is because the creators of the video games are protected under the first amendment (freedom of expression) and are allowed to publish whatever they want in the form of any type of media (Marcovitz 76

Violent Video Games And Ethics Essay

709 words - 3 pages Violence in video games and whether or not it influences people to act violently in the real world has been a topic of heated debate as of late. I can see how killing somebody in real life is unethical, but how can playing a game be unethical? I don't kill people in games. Killing means permanently ending someone's life; that doesn't happen in games. When I hit the reset button, everyone is alive again. I don't think violent games promote

Effects Of Violent Video Games Essay

940 words - 4 pages . National Library of Medicine). "It’s clear that the ‘big fears’ bandied about in the press - that violent video games make children significantly more violent in the real world; that children engage in the illegal, immoral, sexist and violent acts they see in some of these games - are not supported by the current research, at least in such a simplistic form. That should make sense to anyone who thinks about it. After all, millions of children and

Censoring Of Violent Video Games Essay

1402 words - 6 pages There has always been controversy as to whether violent video games should be censored. Video games should be censored for the good of society. Video games do harm to teens and society due to making teens accumulate frustrations,makes teens think violence is acceptable in problem solving, and makes them very unhealthy but it also does some good, such as helps teens control their emotions, makes them conscious of what is good from what is bad