This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Freedom Or Security? An Analysis Of The War Measures Act, 1970

929 words - 4 pages

" Just watch me," was uttered by Pierre Trudeau on October, 13, 1970, in response to how far he would go to keep order during the October Crisis. Three days after Trudeau made this statement, he imposed the War Measures Act in an attempt to prevent a nationalist terrorist group, called the Front de liberation du Quebec (FLQ), from continuing with their violent revolutionary crimes. The implementation of the War Measures Act was strongly criticized as it suspends all rights and freedoms; and a debate arose between the need for freedom and the importance of security. Ultimately, the War Measures Act allowed for a secure society by focusing on the safety of Canadian citizens which, consequently, provided freedom for citizens by defending Canada's democracy from authoritarian separatists. The War Measures Act was justified during the October Crisis due to the concern for safety among Canadian citizens, the defense of democracy and the inevitable need for help from the federal government. The FLQ committed violent crimes for their separatist cause, therefore they would not be considered as ordinary criminals, but as nationalist terrorists that Canada must defend themselves against.The War Measures Act was not imposed merely to defend an important principle regarding negotiating with terrorists, but it was used to provide safety for the citizens of Canada. John Turner, Minister of Justice (1970), stated, "We have a series of bombings and violence, and a rising increase in thefts of dynamite..." This quotation exhibits the frequent and violent terrorist attacks that imposed fear in many civilians, and it demonstrates the need for protection from these attacks. Bombings and violence were not the only form of criminal acts the FLQ performed. The kidnappings of James Cross and Pierre Laporte shocked the public and forced thefederal government to take action against these revolutionary terrorists. Two innocent family men were kidnapped, while one was murdered (Pierre Laporte). These formidable attacks allowed the government to assume that the FLQ was an extensive terrorist group, which may seem like a naive assumption, but the federal government was only so naive due to the constant worry and concern for their citizens. It is not right to allow terrorists to continue with their violent crimes while threatening the lives of innocents, which is why the implementation of the War Measures Act was essential in maintaining safety in Canada.While maintaining safety, the federal government must perpetuate democracy as well. The Front de Liberation du Quebec was a revolutionary group who attempted to destroy society by using violence, and later used alleged authoritarianism as a justification for the need to use violence. But authoritarianism is not a democratic act and poses a risk to a democratic society. The War Measures Act maintained democracy and freedom instead of destroying it because...

Find Another Essay On Freedom or Security? An Analysis of the War Measures Act, 1970

Analysis of Music in the 1970's and 1920's

920 words - 4 pages “Music expresses that which cannot be put into words and that which cannot remain silent (Hugo, 2007).”Whether you grew up in the Roaring 20’s or in the Disco 70’s music was a strong source of fun and entertainment. It is an art of sound in time that expresses ideas and emotions in significant forms through the elements of rhythm, melody, harmony, and color. If you ever heard the phrase “Do the Hustle” you would most likely be referring to the

The Controversy Over New Airport Security Measures

2017 words - 8 pages )).EPIC called the full- body scanner program “unlawful, invasive, and ineffective” ,and argued that the department of homeland security “has violated the Administrative Procedures Act, the Privacy Act, the Religious Freedom Restoration Act, and the Fourth Amendment.”(EPIC v. DHS (Suspension of Body Scanner Program)). In another case, an Arkansas man ,Robert Dean, sued the TSA claiming that the new security measures are

An Analysis of the American Recovery and Reinvestement Act 2009

2818 words - 12 pages public opinion have upon the passage of such bills, and more specifically the ARRA of 2009. As previously noted, the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009 or the stimulus is an economic package enacted by the United States Congress in February of 2009 and signed into law by President Barack Obama on February 17, 2009. The bill was set in motion in order to combat the effects of the late-2000s recession. During this time, the United

From a historical point of view, is the Reformation an act of religious reform or an act of political revolution?

854 words - 3 pages and economical revolution commenced. This economical and political revolution began the "Renaissance" which is the time period of development and exploration after the "Middle Ages" or the "Dark Ages".Another reason that the Reformation should be treated as a political revolution was that many princes switched to Lutheranism as an excuse to go against the Pope. Since there were always collisions between Church and State, the princes were eager to

Title V of the Social Security Act

1708 words - 7 pages know about their sex life for the future. Sex education seems, after studies and debates, to be the most effective method in aiding these issues. In the fall of 2016, if democrats are in office then it will result in, passing the bill to amend title V of the Social Security Act to eliminate the abstinence-only education programs. Therefore, the billions of dollars of funding for abstinence- only programs currently could be used to improve sex

An Analysis of Slavery and Freedom

952 words - 4 pages Description: This about the rise of the New World with freedom and slavery. This essay include historical evidence of the contradictory belief's of our past leaders.Hope this helps someone.An Analysis of Slavery and Freedomas the American ParadoxBy Megan SmoakMr. Harris – HIS 131“The rise of liberty and equality in this country [America] was accompanied by the rise of slavery,” (Slavery and Freedom: An American Paradox, page 5

The Homeland Security Act

887 words - 4 pages provides Congress with the power to create laws to successfully execute their powers, known as the Elastic, or Necessary and Proper, Clause. This clause allowed them to create the Homeland Security Act because Congress saw fit at the time to attempt to integrate and coordinate between the bureaucracies. These points convey how the Homeland Security Act was and is still necessary to maintain order even at the cost of freedom. Overall, there are

An Analysis of Security Sector Reforms

1845 words - 8 pages capable of obtaining this reform; whether a country shall attempt the reform during war or post-war; and discovering the challenges and successes of the reform. To start off, each individual has an argument for the best way to go about reforming the security sector within transitional societies. As my own individual, I believe that it is best to build a military force that can uphold the laws and cultural beliefs of the people. Stated in John Moyibi

The War of Freedom of Expression

1935 words - 8 pages : Derek Raymaker, David Kilgour, Victor Ramraj, and Bruce Elman. They argue that there is definitely a moral place for laws regarding hate speech, whether they are criminal or not. There was recently a new development in the Canadian war for freedom of expression. Introduced in April 1982 was a new and important strategic battleground.With the Charter of Rights and Freedoms the war could be won or lost by either side. It was not long before the

An Analysis of the Outbreak of the Iran-Iraq War

796 words - 4 pages Costing up to $1,000,000,000 monthly and possible over $300,000,000,000 in material terms (Swearingen, 1988) over the course of the conflict, the Iran-Iraq War was at face value, an attempt by Iraq to compel Iran to recognize Iraq's territorial rights and to renegotiate the 1975 treaty. Initially, Iraq seemed to have either no clearly formulated strategic goals or had fallen short of them - the first reaction one would have when hearing that

An Analysis of the Outbreak of the Iran-Iraq War

1124 words - 5 pages resources • ANALYSIS: • Iraq wanted to become a regional hegemon but wasn't able to due to a lack of sufficient power. It chose to attack a significant actor such as Iran because of its population size, its army, its industrial base, its territorial size was a significant threat to Iraqi hegemony. Additionally, due to the revolution, Iran was considered to be an international pariah and Iraq attempted to use this to its advantage. It chose not

Similar Essays

Political Fumble: The War Measures Act, The Implications Of The Institution Of The War Measures Act Of 1970 By Former Prime Minister Pierre Trudeau

1302 words - 5 pages French. The declaration of Canada as a bilingual nation was the most prominent aspect and undoubtedly left the largest visible mark on the Canadian landscape. Among Trudeau?s achievement lye political fumbles, among the most apparent is the enactment of the War Measures Act. The War Measures Act is the single most irresponsible action taken by the Canadian government in the past 40 years, Trudeau?s biggest fumble in an otherwise successful political

The Balancing Act Between Freedom & Security

1312 words - 6 pages Introduction The USA Patriot Act came about after 9/11. The Act remains in use today with some slight modifications. On the other hand, FISA has been in use since the mid-1970s. Both Acts are highly controversial and are foreign to the average citizen. National security always requires a balancing act between freedom and security. As the saying goes, freedom is not free. This paper will describe the primary elements and / or components of the

An Analysis Of The War Powers Act

2296 words - 9 pages national security enterprise without discussing the role of the U.S. Supreme Court.” During the 190 years from the signing of the constitution, to the War Powers Act of 1973, the influence of the Supreme Court greatly enhanced the precedent of executive powers. Early American history demonstrates an increasing trend of the executive to use his authority as Commander in Chief. President Jefferson utilized military force without Congressional

The War Measures Act: Was It Necessary?

1295 words - 5 pages emergency power during a war, invasion or rebellion. It allowed the cabinet to do anything necessary for the “security, defence, peace, order and welfare of Canada” (Morton and Granatstein, 1989, p.7).The act severely limits the freedom of Canadians. It was used during World War One (1914), World War Two (1939) and the October Crisis (1970). It also has a negative effect on the esteem of Canada as it can be viewed as a hypocritical democratic