This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Freedom To Change One's Religion Is Fundamental Right

4382 words - 18 pages

Support at the Institutional Level and its Implications for Other Rights and Freedoms
In drafting the United Declaration of Human Rights (UDHR), it was decided, after lengthy debates between state representatives, that the article on freedom of religion should include the right to change religions. Thus, Article 18 of the UDHR reads “Everyone has the right to freedom of thought, conscience and religion; this right includes freedom to change his religion or belief, and freedom, either alone or in community with others and in public or private, to manifest his religion or belief in teaching, practice, worship and observance”. As Margaret O. Thomas looks at Western-Christian and Middle-Eastern Muslim concerns over the freedom to change religions, she asks whether or not such a right can be supported by social, governmental and religious institutions (337). In answering this question, Thomas looks at the complexity of the issues surrounding this freedom. Also, she explores the use of the language of “choice” as a substitute to the language of “change” used in the UDHR arguing that the term conveys autonomous and non-coerced decision-making which nurtures the dialogue between Christians and Muslims. Whereas her arguments and solutions remain quite ambiguous, in this paper I intend to answer her question by arguing that this right cannot be freely exercised in instances where religion is a key component of public identity. Furthermore, I will argue that in those instances freedom to change religions can effectively strip an individual of other basic rights and freedoms. As an alternative to Thomas’s dialogue approach, I will claim that the application of Taylor’s management of diversity model at the institutional level could serve as a vehicle to strengthen the support of this specific religious freedom.

Religion as a Key Component of Public Identity
First, human rights documents on freedom of religion are built on Western Christian sensibilities. Therefore, they assert the right to change one’s religion without considering the way local and regional dynamics affect the various issues accompanying such a change in religious identity. In fact, it can be difficult to reconcile human rights with certain creeds which forbid apostasy - the renunciation of a religious faith. In the West, religious status is not an important public concern. Hence, changing from one religion to another comes with few consequences. On the other hand, in the Middle East, where religion is a major component of public identity, such a change is accompanied by complex personal, social and legal issues which fuel conflict (Thomas, 337-338). These conflicts arise from the lack of support of the freedom to change one’s religion or belief by the dominant religion in the Middle East: Islam. As Frederick Mathewson Denny explains, conversion away from Islam is prohibited by Islamic law. The latter claims to be the “religion of unspoiled nature”, in other words one cannot convert...

Find Another Essay On Freedom to Change One's Religion is Fundamental Right

Freedom to Change Essay

1536 words - 6 pages make'em wanna do right Lu…They're getting self-esteem Lu…These girls are trying to be queens Lu…They're trying to graduate from school Lu…They're starting to think that smart is cool Lu (dumb it down) (45-51). The way that language can define someone truly shows the power of language. The system believes that exposing certain classes to intelligent forms of language they may attain ambition and move away from their personal situations. This can

Communication is Fundamental to Social Work

705 words - 3 pages There is expectation to demonstrate core communication skills and the capacity to develop them and ability to engage with people in order to build compassionate and effective relationships (The College of Social Work, 2014). Communication skills are fundamental in social work; every aspect of their role involves communication. In order to communicate effectively, social workers need to be aware of the forms of communication, i.e. non-verbal

The Desire to Change One's Self in Harrison Bergeron

631 words - 3 pages and they would rather change their attitude about themselves to be better instead of changing other people. In addition, they would try to improve themselves in order to overcome their insecurities. Also, being equal than everybody is something that would be boring for some people. Therefore, some people would make an effort to be a better person not just to compete with others but to success and to defeat their insecurities. In conclusion

The Right To Property: An Essential To Freedom

1176 words - 5 pages social need for property ownership and how they should not be denied the ability to fulfill that need. The inadequacy of government to allow for the rights of property ownership, as well as protect those rights, limits the freedom and happiness of those governed. People should have the right to be able to own property because it raises financial security and success, as well as supports individual freedom and happiness. First of all, property

Factual Proposition: Consuming marijuana is detrimental to one's health

1984 words - 8 pages OPPONENT'S BRIEF Factual Proposition: Consuming marijuana is detrimental to one's health. Definition of key terms:1. Consumption= Smoking or eating marijuana.2. Marijuana= Psychoactive mind altering substance, also known as cannabis.3. Detrimental= Serious harm. Primary Inference: Smoking or eating marijuana is likely to create serious health problems for most individual users or society. Overview:Since the

Global Economic Freedom is an issue that we as conscious business people should be aware of. It is not enough just to know the rules and laws that govern the economic system in one's own country

1751 words - 7 pages Global Economic Freedom is an issue that we as conscious business people should be aware of. It is not enough just to know the rules and laws that govern the economic system in one's own country. With the continued expansion in global business it is almost certain that a business dealing with foreign countries will need to have a general idea about the foreign countries economic system and the general rules and laws that govern that economic

Taxation is Oppressive to Freedom

1291 words - 5 pages utility, or society, might object that a conscription army sharply reduces societal happiness. That is someone, who wants to serve in the military and does, sees an increase in utility while someone who is unwilling to serve does not also increasing overall utility. From a libertarian perspective, that is a viewpoint looking to maximize freedom of the individual, the advantages of the volunteer army are clear. By forcing someone to serve against

The Right to Freedom of Expression: R. v. Keegstra

3315 words - 13 pages advance the view that the “right” to freedom of expression is not final and absolute, as expressions of hated do in fact cause real harm to people, and there rights too must be taken into consideration. Fundamental rights should be viewed as a privilege, which includes a responsibility to respect and value the rights of others to provide for a truly liberal democracy. I will refer to the landmark judicial decision in the Canadian Supreme Court case

Marx uses the idea of freedom to justify Communism, yet Nozick uses it to justify pure Capitalism. Which if either, is right?

2573 words - 10 pages this. Yet it can also be said that communist states seem to have done more to change the role of women in family to reduce the burden of childcare and house work. Thus it is believed that despite all that can be said to disapprove communism, it is by all means a more hopeful theory and one which clearly justifies freedom, freedom of the individual through an egalitarian society, free from divisions and therefore free to feel one and equal with everyone, over ruling the selfish nature of capitalism.Marx uses the idea of freedom to justify communism, yet Nozick uses it to justify pure capitalism. Who, if either, is right?

The Right to Bear Arms is a Human Right

760 words - 4 pages Michael Bross 28 May 2014 American Government John Burton Dangerous Freedom or Peaceful Slavery? “A well regulated militia, being necessary to the securing of a free state, the right of the people to keep and bear arms shall not be infringed.” Those are the words of the seconds amendment to the Constitution of the United States. These words were written by the man who laid the foundation of our government today. As a constitutional right our

Mandela: A Life Devoted to Change and Freedom

2375 words - 10 pages freedom. As a result, after Mandela’s retirement, he focused on abolishing poverty and economic injustices. Before the end of his speech, Mandela sums up his speech by calling everyone to action. Mandela asks “all humanity” to “rise up,” because not helping people in poverty is like a “crime against humanity” (9). To remind the audience their power to change the situation of poverty and social inequalities in South Africa, Mandela told his audience

Similar Essays

Healthcare Is A Fundamental Right Essay

1435 words - 6 pages How a person envisions healthcare usually reflects a persons attitude towards “right or privilege”, if they view it from a humanitarian or a financial perspective weighs heavy on how that question is answered. As a Christian who is anti-abortion, the choice of whether healthcare is a “right or a privilege” is straightforward; healthcare is a fundamental right. Babies are human; we do not lose compassion for them just because they grow older. In

Right To Religion Essay

743 words - 3 pages the society’s well being and order. In this case, the right to religion is considered as a legal aspect with connection to religious permissiveness and detachment of the church and state. Additionally, the United Nations Universal Declaration of 1946, which concerns human rights states that, each person in the society has a right to freedom of ideas together with moral sense and religion . Likewise, this right covers the liberty to change

Right To Religion Essay

941 words - 4 pages directly associate itself with any one religion. It shall represent the true meaning of secularism by promoting universal freedom to one’s right to religion. In my view, I strongly feel that any action taken by the state reflects the object of the constitution and in turn the preamble itself. The petitioner’s faith is not being interfered by the State and has no right to convert the State’s policy from secularism to atheism which shall be in direct

Is Freedom A Natural Right? Essay

811 words - 3 pages Freedom. What is freedom? Is it an absolute right? We are born to become free. Freedom is defined from different aspects ,and according to different cultures,freedom varies from culture to another.Some define freedom as a natural right,the human being is born with.Everyone wants to be free and independent from others.Freedom is the right to do what one wants,live where he wants,eat what he wants,learns what he wants,and chooses the religion in