This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Freud And Nietzsche An Account For The Role Of Memory In Our Lives

1208 words - 5 pages

One of the main concerns of contemporary philosophy has been the role of the memory in the life of the individual and the group, or more precisely - the lack and excess of memory. Memory is something very unreliable, because it causes the same kind of decay that invades our physical bodies, undermining the identity of every individual and every society. Even though human identity is based on historical memory, neither individuals, nor societies should be limited in categorical way by it and the importance of forgetting should not be diminished. In consideration of memory, psychoanalysis and history as disciplines may be merged to provide one with a more expansive view of this phenomenon, without reducing one to the other. Reading Freud's account of melancholia in relation to Nietzsche's account of historical illness can help enhance the understanding one derives from each individual discourse, in addition to highlighting an important theme in contemporary philosophy.In Freud's essay, "Mourning and Melancholia", he considers the act of mourning, which if carried out incorrectly can result in melancholia, a pathological illness. Freud states, "In mourning, it is the world which has become poor and empty; in melancholia, it is the ego itself." An individual suffering with melancholia often cannot pin point what they have lost, as it is often not a person but an abstract concept. Their fixation on this object is intense often due to the narcissistic basis of the attachment, therefore when they lose this object; they lose something more drastic - themselves and their will to live. Symptoms of melancholia are similar to those of mourning; however melancholia is differentiated by "an extraordinary diminution in self-regard" and the absence of shame. Freud believes that a certain period of mourning is necessary when confronting loss; in fact if this process were not to occur, or if this process were to be interrupted, it could be of great detriment. Mourning should be used to recognize the loss of a particular object and to eventually come to terms with the separation, the experience ultimately making one stronger and urging one forward.Nietzsche believes that history is also something that individuals and groups must use to move forward, however it is largely practiced in a harmful manner. History is necessary for us to be human, yet it must be practiced in the right way to avoid damage to human life and culture. Irving Ball beautifully articulates the point, "the past should be a springboard not a hammock", as the past must always be in service of the present and the future. In his essay, Nietzsche outlines three forms that an excess of history can take.The first is what Nietzsche describes as the "monumental", in which people look to the past for models, which they passively emulate, robbing the present of its self-defining vitality. The veneration of the past turns history to stone, literally and figuratively, and therefore is really a kind of...

Find Another Essay On Freud and Nietzsche - An Account For The Role Of Memory In Our Lives

Buddhism: The Role Desires Play In Our Everyday Lives

1457 words - 6 pages desires are so strong it takes over, and the mind and body has to react to them. There are also instances where the body may ache when trying not to act on desires that we strongly long for. Desires play a very important role in our everyday lives. That yearning or thirst can cause problems in our lives that may not be in our best interest. We often choose to over look signs that are caused by desire and end up hurting someone or even ourselves

Sigumand Freud And Nietzsche: Personalities And The Mind

1646 words - 7 pages ascertained that by binary opposition, Nietzsche, as well as Freud, can thus now reveal to us our split personalities. "Much will have been gained for esthetics once we have succeeded in apprehending directly- rather than merely ascertaining- that art owes its continuous evolution to the Apollonian-Dionysiac duality," proposes Nietzsche, "even as the propagation of the species depends on the duality of the sexes, their constant conflicts and

The Expressions of Art and Its Influence in Our Lives

680 words - 3 pages and identity, yet they all seem to have certain commonalities. For most artists, art is at the core of their lives. Art is an extension of them. They spend the majority of their life thinking about art. They are resilient and understand that success is not an overnight occurrence and that it involves many years of hard work. Over the years I have heard of many artist and composers but I will admit that I had never taken the time to learn

The Impact of Nanotechnology in Our Lives

1548 words - 6 pages The Impact of Nanotechnology in Our Lives"Nanotechnology is science and engineering at the scale of atoms and molecules. It is the manipulation and use of materials and devices so tiny that nothing can be built any smaller." It refers to the use of materials with nanoscale dimensions, ranging from 1-100 nanometers. Nanotechnology impacts our lives today in many ways, such as economically, socially, environmentally, ethically, and

A Role for Hippocampal Neurogenesis in Learning and Memory

2635 words - 11 pages are impaired in this specific test, suggesting a role for the hippocampus (Ennaceur et al., 1997). There is evidence to suggest that a reduction in adult hippocampal neurogenesis impairs spatial memory in the hippocampal dependent object location task. Methylazoxymethanol (MAM) is an antimitotic agent (Johnston and Coyle, 1979) that was used to reduce the number of young granule cells before the object location test was carried out. The mice were

Significance of memory for Paulina in Death and the Maiden

1045 words - 5 pages recreating it from her own memory, but changing the variables; she is changing herself into Doctor Miranda and Doctor Miranda takes the place of Paulina in this altered version of her memory. Now, instead of Doctor Miranda, Paulina is in power. And this is just because of her possession of the gun. Hence, we see how important a factor memory is in Death and the Maiden; most importantly for Paulina. The characteristics and the personality of an entire character as well as the plot of the play is based on just one memory.

Discussion on Noel Carroll's account of the monster and its role in horror films

559 words - 2 pages supernatural.First of all, I am going to discuss about Carroll's account of the monster and its role in horror films. In Carroll's point of view, to provoke fear, one must be threatening; to provoke a sense of disgust, one must be impure. As horror is made up of fear and disgust, one must be both threatening and impure to provoke horror. Therefore, only a monster can do so.To the point of being impure, Carroll elaborate in this way. Being an impure figure, a

The Role of History and Memory in The Fiftieth Gate, Schindler's List, and The Send Off

1114 words - 4 pages , memory, do not detract from Oskar Schindler’s bravery but show how representation is dependent on context. ‘Schindler’s List’ was produced in 1993 when the world felt compassion for the Jews and revelled in stories of heroicness. Heroicness is a theme that is discontinued into Wilfred Owen’s poem ‘The Send-Off’; it is in fact the opposite. ‘The Send-Off’ is represented entirely by memory, and is interpreted from within the cultural context and

Role of Memory in Politics

908 words - 4 pages his recollection of past rulers’ performances to distinguish whether a ruler made an efficient or inefficient strategies. For instance, Machaivelli commended how the Kingdom of Egypt imposed artificial necessity that molded its inhabitants to become finest soldiers who, according to Machiavelli, “…deserved more praise than Alexander the Great and many others whose deeds remain fresh in our memory.” Through memory, Machiavelli was able to evaluate

Account for the breakdown of the family as an institution

1486 words - 6 pages Account for the breakdown of the family as an institution.The family is a set of parents and children or of relations living together or not. It is a race or group of people from a common stock. The family is the oldest institution devised by man. It is a legal social and moral institution because it perpetuates throughout generations. It existed from time immemorial. With time, it is a concept but its structure has changed. There has been a

What is the role of nurses in the community. Give detailed account of a patient cared for?

2551 words - 10 pages many years ago. He has 2 children but is not in contact with them. At present Mr. Clarke lives in a single hotel room, provided by social services after spending long periods of time in Prison and later on the streets. He has a lady friend who visits regularly, they have known each other for over 5 years.Mr. Clarke has a medical history of hypertension, type 2 diabetes mellitus, which was diagnosed 5 years ago and has been administering insulin

Similar Essays

The Role Of Sexuality In Our Lives

1252 words - 5 pages The Role of Sexuality in Our Lives The word “sexuality” has been looked upon as taboo and for centuries many of us grow up being taught how this part of our lives shouldn't be expressed openly. We all experience the feeling as humans, we share this characteristic. Some of us are taught not to express any feeling that has to do with our inner wants when it comes to this topic. It could make us more loving or even at times some incidents

The Role Environment Plays In Our Lives

1656 words - 7 pages I am a firm believer that environment has a profound affect on individuals. The reality of life is that we cannot always control our environments, yet there are times in life where we find ourselves staring down the path to several destinations, the choice of which- in our own hands. As people we must choose to make the very best of the environments that do not foster the best for our lives. Choosing to be strong and derive positivity out of

The Role Sports Plays In Our Lives

3934 words - 16 pages highlight the importance of the sports in our lives. Even on national holidays like Thanksgiving, American families find sports a rich topic to watch, talk about and gather all together around for some time. “Sports are bigger than life," as an old proverb says (Bradlee). It is something that captures the attention of students at schools and colleges, families at homes, and, of course, it brings millions in audience to media, print and television

How Memory Contributes In Our Everyday Lives

788 words - 4 pages Already by the age of two, humans are able to think back and retrieve memories of a specific event. Memorization is an important aspect of our everyday lives as it aids us things such as learning and recognition. Communication with others by either speech or written words is only made possible by recalling words, grammar rules, and how to form sentences. Everything would be new to us every time we saw it without memory. A computer, a chair